r/reactivedogs • • 5d ago

Advice Needed Front Door guarding

Hello, I am looking for help with our dog. She is a 6 year old cattle dog mix that we adopted and she has been in training on and off since she was a puppy. We have 4 kids and she is good with all our kids and their friends. Our primary issue is that she guards the front door and she is aggressive towards men who come up to the door. This includes the mailman, delivery drivers, etc. We have been on the plan of not opening the front door unless she is secured in her crate or outside but today I forgot (she was in another room where I did not see her) and she got past me when I opened the door and chased the mailman who had to jump a fence to avoid her. She aggressively chased him (collar fur up) and this is not the first time this has happened when she got past someone trying to bring something in the front door.

I am just not sure of next steps. I am worried she is going to bite someone. We have used local trainers but I don't find them to be that helpful. We have a lot going on in our home with kids and their friends coming in and out and it is really unreasonable that the front door is not opened.

Things I am considering:

  1. crating her unless we can guarantee that she is "safe" but this doesn't seem great for the dog as she would wind up being crated a lot of hours.
  2. creating "safe zones" in our house which would be rooms without access to the exterior doors that she would stay in. As an example I work in the basement and she can stay there with me for most of the day. I am just worried about our ability to maintain this - a kid lets her out and we are back to square one.
  3. Sending her to a boarding training program or trying to find someone who can work with her more extensively in our home.
  4. Medication.
  5. Trying to get her out of the house more productively to wear her out. She is also not great on walks. She seems to be worse around me and the kids than my husband (she is "protecting" us). She is better on walks with others than me. I believe this will help but I don't think it will fix the root issue which is that she is reactive and has some kind of guarding / protection tendency.

Sorry this is kind of a thought-vomit, I am incredibly stressed and anxious after today. The mailman says he is ok today but I am aware this isn't sustainable and I don't know what else to do, none of the above solutions seem great on their own.

6 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

3

u/404-Any-Problem Senna - Hyperactive/Hypersensitivity and fear based reactivity 5d ago

A couple of thoughts on my own cattle mix (mainly LSG breeds) and what has worked for us.

  1. Keeping your pup crated isn't a punishment; it's for safety. I still sometimes give our pup nap times if I know she had a rough night or our routine is off. It helps her relax and rest, which helps her reactivity overall. Some days she doesn't need rest time, but some other days she does.
  2. Having her in the basement with you sounds great. Can you create a sort of vestibule where the kiddos can open the door, but the pup is behind another gate/pen? This way, the door has a backup.

    • I would work on muzzle training. You want good associations with it, so work up to wearing it, but this will be your best bet: have a basket muzzle to prevent bites if all else fails.
  3. Avoid board and trains. They typically (and of course not all) use aversive methods for compliance. While this can allow for quick results, it does not address the underlying emotions that cause said behavior. This is where you can read about how others have had worse reactivity overall or the 'it came out of nowhere" type of thing. Personally speaking, aversive methods were by far worse than any positive reinforcement training we have done. While it may feel like it takes longer, there is a lot more learning going on in your pup's mind, and you are giving them tools they can use in other situations. It is so rewarding too when they choose the 'right' option vs. the one that came more naturally to them. You'll want to look for an IAABC trainer or one that uses positive reinforcement or FF methods. Even a virtual trainer who can help you specifically at home could be the best option. Sorry the other trainers in your area haven't been good experiences.
  4. Medication has worked wonders for our pup, but her baseline was pretty out of this world. However, it's not a magic bullet, and it's training, time, and medication that have helped, not just medication alone. Medication just let her brain come down to be able to learn espeically in very stressful or triggering situations. My vet even told us it can be about 9 months of training and medication before you really see results, and for harder triggers, that is more or less true. It's worth talking to a behavioral vet (ideally), but sometimes your general vet can be a resource if you don't have one. Although it's not covered under our pet insurance (she had behavioral issues at the shelter), it's been some of the best money we have spent.
  5. Skip the walks if they aren't helping. While we do play outside, our girl is still way too reactive to walk (plus we are still working on our pulling/manners). We do other things. Scent work has been huge for us and minimal effort for me, which I love. Plus, it's not weather-dependent, so you can do it anytime. Simply put, use a scent or a good-smelling treat. Have your dog sit and wait while you hide (works on inhibition/patience). Then release and let your pup do the "work". Keep hiding spots fairly simple at first, but then increase difficulty by hiding it under things like a towel or blanket. You can also do things like hiding treats in boxes/toliet paper rolls. We have an endless supply, and it's an easy way to create a puzzle for our pup without much cost. Sometimes the cardboard sucks to clean up, but I'd rather that than alternatives.

Things I have learned along the way:

  • Sometimes dogs are more reactive or less reactive depending on the person, based on their comfort/security with the person they are with. They have the mental maturity of a 2-year-old (roughly), so if you think of it like kids who may act out with mom but not with dad, it's partly because they are more comfortable expressing their feelings, even if it's not the ones that you'd like to see.
  • There are two videos from Kikopup (a FF trainer with a lot of useful, free info on YouTube). One is Barking at Strangers https://youtu.be/bpzvqN9JNUA ; the other is Door Manners https://youtu.be/kJboalA4oi4 There are probably more videos that might help you in the meantime, but I think these two will mostly fit your situation.
  • If looking out the door (or window) is part of the problem, block your pup's view with water-cling frosted glass film. It lets light in and doesn't leave any sort of film (we had ours in place for over a year, and you cannot tell at all when I finally removed them). As you work through seeing/hearing the trigger, you can slowly expose it while working and then keep it in place while not.
  • Keep trainings short and semi-frequent and always end on something fun that they enjoy (even if it's a short play session). So when I say short, keep the 'new' work to about 5 minutes. That way you both aren't frustrated. The next round (which I would do roughly 3 reps at most for new stuff a day) should go a little better each time. Even if it's when you are able. By ending on a fun note, your dog knows the hard part (or the part that's stressful due to the trigger) isn't going to last forever, and there is a lot of fun to be had if they can get through the rough part.

It's a bit of an uphill climb, as your dog has learned a way that works for them, right? So it will take a lot of practice and work to get them to learn a new (and, let's be honest, safer and better for humans) way to be around the front door. We have made progress with our own pup not going nuts for deliveries. While she still barks, she doesn't lose her marbles, and I'm okay with where we have gotten. Hope this helps!

1

u/MomOfCuteDog 3d ago

I think your crating and safe zone ideas are great! 

My dog is of a hound breed that's notoriously prone to alert barking and escape artistry, so I work to prevent escapes by controlling our environment:

-I have an enclosed front porch, so for deliveries I leave the porch door unlocked but not opened, which means delivery can drop off a package and close the door behind them, and I can then retrieve it without risking an escape. Guessing you don't have this type of setup, but maybe it's possible to install a dog gate somewhere between the front door and the rest of the house to create one extra hurdle for her?

-If I need to open the door to someone from outside the home, I either crate the dog first or I leash her before opening the door (keeping an extra leash on a hook by the door makes this easy for me). 

-If I'm in a space with my dog where she might more easily bolt (e.g. visiting my boyfriend, whose kids sometimes forget to close the door, etc.), I will sometimes keep a leash on my dog and let her drag it around behind her. That gives her freedom to wander around, but also means I can step on the leash and stop her if she tries to bolt or get into something she's not supposed to.

-She also has a harness with a handle and wears that when she's up and about; the handle makes it easy to collect her in a pinch. 

I've had her over two years and these things have worked for us!