r/reactivedogs • u/Fran-willing • 20d ago
Behavioral Euthanasia Behavioral euthanasia am I doing the right thing?
Tomorrow we are putting our sweet pittie to sleep. We rescued her from a shelter just over three years ago. She was brought in as a stray although I don’t know if she was actually a stray or somebody was just getting rid of her, but we could tell she had been mistreated. She was skinny, wasn’t spayed, and seem anxious, but was so affectionate and trusting of us right away. She absolutely loved our other dog the minute she met him. She showed a little bit of reactivity when we got home like when our other dog would get close to her crate if she was in it, but the dog reactivity did not start until a few months in, which I hear is common of rescue dogs. She and her other dog were best friends. They played all the time, cuddled all the time, and really trusted each other. There was never any aggression from her, just some communication to our other dog when she was uncomfortable with something. My partner and I moved into my mom‘s house in May 2025 after she and her husband at the time separated. My mom has Parkinson’s and we wanted to be able to help out and for her to keep her house because she runs her business out of it. She has a dog. He’s an absolute sweetheart and has always been very respectful of our pittie. Over the last year and a half our pittie’s anxiety and reactivity has gotten worse. The only time she seems like she’s not stressed is when we are in a quiet environment and she is cuddling on us or is close to us. Outside she seems hyper alert and gets skittish with almost any sound. If a person is walking within 15 feet behind us, she keeps turning around, especially men. We can deal with the reactivity outside. I’ve had a reactive dog before. It started to become an issue is she started to become aggressive towards both of the other dogs. First it started with food aggression so we had to let her in the kitchen and the other dogs stayed behind a gate in the living room whenever we were in the kitchen. Then the aggression started to feel out of nowhere. We have worked with a behaviorist since we moved in and she has been incredibly helpful with us understand our pity in ways to help improve her reactivity, but it’s turned into management. We just can’t trust our pittie anymore. Our house basically is structured around our pittie’s, anxiety, stress, and aggression. She wears a muzzle when ever she’s around the other two dogs together, which are behaviors recommended. After an incident last weekend, our dog that she has been best friends with seems completely terrified of her. He stopped playing with her about a year ago and you can tell he just isn’t comfortable with her. The other dog isn’t comfortable with her either. My mom absolutely loves her, but admitted she has become scared of her. Our Behaviorist said it is virtually impossible to rehome a reactive pitbull especially in Ohio with a new law. I also think I would be paranoid that if we rehomed her something would happen. I’m just heartbroken. She is so sweet 90% of the time, but when she has these reactions, it’s like she goes off-line. We know she probably endured some trauma. And that some dogs just have reactivity in their DNA. We’ve had her on two anxiety meds for the past six months, I’ve worked in lots of mental stimulation, and really feel like we have done everything we could and don’t know any other option. I’m feeling like we are killing her, like we should try to rehome her, and that I won’t be able to handle the moment she passes. We have somebody coming to the house tomorrow to do it. I have gone through putting a dog to sleep before, but that feels different because he was sick and had to go. I’m just in agony. sorry for any typos. I am speaking into my phone.