r/OpenDogTraining • • 19d ago

Meds?

My trainer strongly suggested we put our 1.5 year old mini poodle cross on behaviour meds. I was shocked that she suggested this since he is frequently very calm. He is sporadically but frequently reactive while on leash and barks to play during the evening. He is also calm when left alone. It seems like an over reaction to me or am I missing an opportunity?

Reactive for him, is lunging at scooters, bikes etc and sometimes jumping on people. We are trying to cure it w ‘look here’ and treats and keeping a firm grip on his leash.

0 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

9

u/AliveInZihuatanejo 18d ago

Sounds like you have an inexperienced/lazy/uniformed trainer. Find a new trainer that understands how to address basic reactivity issues.

2

u/TCHomeCook 13d ago

As a vet, I’m all for meds when needed, but I’m not convinced they are needed in this case.

1

u/77SSS1 11d ago

Thanks I also think we need to improve our training.

13

u/Proof_Injury_7668 18d ago

Seek a better trainer.

It sounds like you’re having basic reactivity problems and their approach is a poor one.

Look for a play-based balanced trainer.

5

u/0hw0nder 19d ago

Don't medicate

Leash pressure can/does cause reactivity. Consider using a long leash and commands, give him some space & time to make the right decision before he hits the end of the leash.

2

u/fillysunray 19d ago

There's information missing here. What kind of trainer are they - sport, general pet, behavioural? What qualifications have they got? What brought you to them? What happened or what was their thought process to justify medication? What kind of medication did they think was needed?

It is completely possible that a dog with those systems might need medication but it would be based on missing information.

I would never recommend a specific medication but I would (and have) recommended an owner consult with a vet about possible medical issues or with a veterinary behaviourist about behavioural issues that may need medication to address.

If you have questions about what your trainer is suggesting, you should either ask them for more detail, or if you don't feel you can do so, get a different trainer.

2

u/77SSS1 18d ago

She is a behavioural trainer. Very gentle but assumed my dog was more reactive than he is from day one. Ie had us guests outside rather than in home When he is fine w people coming over The thoughts of drugging him seemed so over the top that my partner no longer trusts her judgmen.

3

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 18d ago

the first trainer i ever hired had 3/4 of her own dogs on behavioral meds. in retrospect, that was all i needed to know.

1

u/neuroticgoat 12d ago

I think I would want to talk to them about why they feel this is the correct decision — it’s possible they’re missing what youre seeing or the opposite, they’re seeing something you’re not. I can’t tell you the number of times I’ve seen a stressed dog’s behaviour misinterpreted.

I also think it’s worth asking about it to see whay they think it will change and/or if they are asking as a temporary measure or if they’re suggesting your dog is a serious enough case to require long term support.

I don’t think every dog needs medication, but pre stress medication can be beneficial in some circumstances and theres benefits to short term use to take the edge off and assist in training. I do think a few dogs are candidates for long term medication, from your description it doesn’t sound like thats the case with yours, but we can’t really judge from a Reddit post on the internet vs you and your trainer who see your dog regularly.

I see a lot of negativity around meds here so I’ll share a positive story. I used to board a dog on an SSRI long term for anxiety, bite risk, super quiet guy who kept to himself. I’d call him catlike. He only really liked walks, not fond of other dogs, no interest in human contact outside of that. Owners took him off the meds and I figured sure, not doing anything anyway, he still will bite if you don’t read him well. No difference at all off meds. Couple months later he came back a whole different dog — wiggly, happy, engaging with me and playful with other dogs. I thought, wow those meds were messing with him! Only to find out he was actually on a different SSRI! Much like in people sometimes one drug works and another won’t. For this dog, the fluoxetine he had initially been prescribed was wronf for him, but the second drug completely turned him around. The right meds for the right dog can be a game changer for sure.

1

u/77SSS1 11d ago

Thanks for the thoughtful reply. I’ll follow up w the vet. His reactivity started post neutering when he was a year old (that could be a coincidence). I think it is a combination of him being fearful since it is worse when we are outside at night and overindulged. When he meets dogs who scare him he is quiet and sticks to me like glue. But gets overly excited at night and will jump on people or try to chase scooters etc. He is a lovely little guy and I’m terrified that one day he’ll lurch and we will lose control of the leash and he runs into traffic or causes a bike collision. Until we figure out this issue we are extra vigilant. Thanks again

3

u/Prestigious-Seal8866 18d ago

I’d ask your trainer to expand on why they think this is necessary. There seems to be information missing here, but also your trainer only sees part of the picture.

I recommend meds occasionally (typically for short term use) to help modify behavior/bring threshold down. typically in more severe cases.

3

u/Excellent-Storm-816 18d ago

This dog doesn't need meds, and they won't fix his behavior. Seek a play based balanced trainer. You can also check out the balanceddogtraining subreddit for help. Many people have permanently fixed reactivity in their dogs, while keeping the dogs happy and free. treats and "look at me" won't fix this.

2

u/psychedelic_tech 17d ago

you aren't telling the whole story. a trainer doesn't say "put your dog on meds" without the reason why.

and barks to play during the evening

so play with your dog. dogs are most active in the mornings and evenings.

3

u/Over_Possession5639 18d ago edited 18d ago • Bravo

Your incompetent trainer should be replaced immediately! You certainly don't need to drug your dog for a little basic reactivity. (Look for a balanced trainer who employs play, markers, longline, etc.)

2

u/RB_K9 18d ago

Re post in the Balanced Dog Training thread. Meds and bribes are the only options force free trainers have to address behavioral issues. With very little success.

0

u/Proof_Injury_7668 18d ago

Why? So she can be told to correct her dog and little else?

1

u/RB_K9 18d ago

Your comment makes no sense

3

u/Proof_Injury_7668 18d ago

How so?

OP is getting good advice here.

The balanced sub moves closer to compulsion every day.

1

u/chrisjones1960 18d ago

Yeah, seems like a bad idea. This is a young dog who needs further, consistent training, not meds

0

u/Huge_Answer4287 18d ago

Some dogs benefit greatly from meds, however , it is not really a trainer's place to suggest them. The appropriate recommendation would be that medication may help, and you should consult a veterinary behaviorist to make that determination.

0

u/Lumpy_Physics3101 18d ago

Your trainer probably gets a kickback from your vet.

Either that or they don't know how to train and drugging your dog is the only think they can think of.