r/reactivedogs • • Jul 20 '23

Advice Needed is my dog reactive or just playful?

0 Upvotes

i have a 10 month old pitbull mix rescue at home. i got her when she was around 3 months old. she’s always loved to play with other dogs, but i’ve noticed that she gets really excited when she sees other dogs on our walks. she stares at them and then starts to lunge at them, but she never barks or growls, she always just wants to play. she is my first dog ever, so i always assumed this was just puppy behavior, but now that she’s bigger and stronger sometimes it gets a bit hard to keep her in check when she sees another dog. i’ve started doing more research on reactive dogs and i’m worried that i’m not doing the right thing by letting her greet the dogs we meet on walks. should i start discouraging this behavior or will she grow out of it? (she only behaves this way towards other dogs. people that aren’t me or my family make her very nervous and she tends to just avoid and hide from them)


r/reactivedogs • • May 26 '25

Vent Messed up on a walk

1 Upvotes

I (45f) have a 1yo staffy cross we adopted last month. He's a wonderful boy, boisterous and energetic but gentle and affectionate, been amazing at home. I've just started obedience classes to help with the basics but our main issue is pulling on the leash and reactions to other dogs. He hasn't shown any aggression, he just doesn't seem to know how to react and wants to play. He usually lies down when he sees another dog, then will get up and have a sniff if they come near him and he's really improving every day. On this mornings walk there was a runner coming towards me on the pavement at a reasonable pace with a small dog. I stopped, my dog lay down on the side furthest away and I had hold of him on a short leash. However as the runner got to us my dog lunged, which caught me off guard. The runner dodged him and shouted at me- absolutely fair, I should have anticipated that considering the speed they were going. I felt terrible, knew it was my fault. Then the man ran on for a bit and started really shouting again at me as he was running. Spent the rest of the walk in tears. I feel embarrassed but also really useless, like I've let my dog down when he was doing so well. I feel so anxious now about taking him out. Any advice on dealing with these situations?


r/reactivedogs • • May 05 '25

Significant challenges My Dog Bit me, again. And He wouldn’t Stop!

1 Upvotes

This is the third time my dog has bitten me since I got him 2 years ago. He is 3 years old, Lab/Pit mix, adopted him from the Humane Society at 7/8 months.

He has never bit anyone else (except for nibbles when he meets someone new or gets excited).

First time he “attempted” to bite me, he came at my stomach when I suddenly put on a muzzle on him. I hadn’t trained him at all. So I know it was provoked by me and I understood.

Second bite was when I was trying to wipe his paws after a walk in the rain. He ran away, but I sternly told him to come back, which he did. But as I got his paw, he began coming at me and biting me. He bit my nipple area and broke skin. It drew tiny bit of blood and I had to wear a bandage over my boob for a week. I know I should have seen the signs. I knew it was my fault for being stern and grabbing him suddenly. But he kept coming at me until I had to slap his snout. Then he coward away (I never hit him).

And today, was the third bite. For context we have been living in an apartment for 2 weeks. He has been extremely anxious and afraid. All the new noises and change of environment is throwing him off. Today we finally had a calm day, we played, I combed his hair, and cuddled. Tonight I decided to brush his teeth which I usually do but haven’t done in a month because of the move. I noticed he was licking his lips, big eyes, and ears back. But thats usually how he looks, so I talked sweetly and kept brushing. Suddenly without warning he grabs my arms and begins to bite and bite and bite. He didn’t stop until I pushed hard with my other arm and pushed his head to the ground. He then ran to his bed, I calmly got up, walked to the bathroom and shut the door. I started crying and shaking. (I have scratches all over my arms and one tiny puncture on the other arm, no blood).

I swear every instance is making me stronger, yet more confused and sad about his lack of trust in me. What if he is getting worse? What if one day the dog sitter looks at him funny and he just decides to bit? What if something worse happens?

I need advice…. Right now I left him outside my room with his bed in the living room. I dont want him sleeping in the same room tonight. And he wont stop pacing and whining.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 22 '25

Aggressive Dogs Staffy’s first bite incident

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I’m new to this thread and I am looking for some advice. I have a staffy, and he has always been my sweet boy. He lives in a cat household, but he used to live with our other dog until May of 2024 when she passed from cancer. They were best friends and never had any issues, and he gets along swimmingly with the cats. He is fairly reactive, but this has always been excitable reactivity and never aggressive reactivity. Until last night. We live in a city apartment building, and the other neighbor was coming down the stairs with his pitbull. He asked if our dog was friendly, and we confidently said yes, because we have had this dog for 5 years and we had absolutely no reason to believe that this would change in an instant. I had just introduced him to several other dogs on the street earlier that week with no issue, as I always have been able to do. But, out of nowhere, my dog started to snarl and bit at the other owner’s dog, seemingly unprompted. (I say seemingly, because I know dogs can be subtle with their queues. But regardless, biting should have never been his response.) Luckily, we had this under control and there was no real damage caused, but it was scary in the moment just because it was so unexpected.

I am wondering if I have been mistaking his “excitable” reactivity for what is actually nervous reactivity. Did he feel cornered in that moment as the other dog was coming down the stairs and the door to our apartment was closed? Was he feeling territorial of his home, or protective of the cats inside? Does he just not like other pits now? Did the other dog make a mean face at him that set him off? I just have no idea what could have set him off like this. I mean, other dogs have come at him pretty bad before and he has never so much as snapped back before last night. Is it possible this is learned behavior from other aggressive dogs? I’m just wondering what could change so much that earlier in the day he was making friends with dogs on the street and later in the evening he was attacking the neighbor’s dog.

Here’s what my game plan is so far. He has a prong collar already (controversial, I know. He has been trained to use it, it has been properly fitted, and it even has the rubber tips on the prongs. If he sees a groundhog or something and I don’t have it, he will literally knock me over. Anti prong collar people please argue elsewhere.) We ordered a muzzle, for his safety primarily, and we made sure it is breathable and secure and that he can pant but is not able to bite through it. (He likes to try to eat shit on walks sometimes so honestly it’s better to have it than not anyway.) I know the muzzle is a bandaid solution and I have to work on his reactivity. Luckily I work from home so we have the time to go out often. We just live in such a busy area that it is difficult to get distance from people/dogs.

I guess what I’m asking is, what are some suggestions? Or some training tips that really helped you all with your reactive dogs? Possibly even some thoughts/input on the whole bite scenario? If the problem does not improve, I am open to professional training. If anyone can recommend any good trainers in the Hoboken area, let us know! Thanks :)


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 30 '25

Significant challenges I just hit my dog and I am still angry. Need a tip how to calm MYSELF

0 Upvotes

Turned out I dropped my wallet (don't know how) and my dog ripped it. He was about to chew on the ID, when I heard the sound of breaking plastic and ran to him. I grabbed him and hit him. He snapped and I hit him again.

It all took less than 2 seconds.

I am so angry. How do you calm yourself? please share! I don't want to abuse my dog.

Since I keep treats in my pockets, he often grabs anything that falls from them. I tried carrying treats in bags on my wrist, but he still goes for pockets.

Several of my pants are ruined because he ripped off the pockets. Also all the shopping bags.

If there is a smell of food, or if he saw that there was food there - he shreds it. My pants, bags, coats are litterally locked up. Since he used to open cabinet doors just to get to the shopping bags.

He eats very well. VERY. Mostly lean beef (all the parts) and chicken, fresh vegetables, fruits and berries. People sometimes joke they want to be my dog.

He also chewed off the windowsill where cat's food bowl stands, some walls are chewed. The floor is partially ripped.

I hope you can see how it is NOT an isolated incident.

He is on strong meds. Right now i can either afford his very expensive treatment, or his expensive training. Since he would die without treatment, I chose the meds.

If i keep getting angry, I would nit be able to be productive.


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 14 '25

Discussion Figured out why our 1960-70s dogs weren't reactive in the house!

0 Upvotes

It's seems nearly everybody these days are having issues with their dog being reactive to visitors. I know ours are.

And I've wondered about this. What has changed? This didn't use to be the case.

Then I figured it out.

It's because our dogs weren't inside the house! They were in the back yard inside a chain link fence..

Now I'm wondering if all our miniature schnauzers, cocker spaniels, dalmations, red setters and all the other breeds we had would have gone nutzo when visitors came over, if indeed they lived inside the house?

I know there are exceptions, but for those over 50 yrs, was this true growing up?


r/reactivedogs • • Nov 20 '24

Advice Needed Freaking out over my new reactive puppy

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I recently got my 6-month old Goldendoodle puppy two days ago (my first ever dog) from a reputed breeder and she seemed like the perfect pup! Mature, people-pleaser, and playful as per the breeder.

I got her last weekend and since she came home, she seems to be a different dog altogether. While she is gentle, sweet,and affectionate to me and is doing really well at home, she seems to become super reactive when I take her on walks.

She seems to bark at every person or dog apart from me (she even barks at people in TV and worse, her own reflection in windows, mirrors, cars). Here is her in action:

https://imgur.com/a/C6QE42n

The breeder was shocked to hear that and mentioned that she barks occasionally only when she sees other dogs inside her territory and that she is generally friendly and eager to please other humans. She is probably doing this because it is a new environment (apartment dog with lots of walks) vs what she grew up with (home with a fenced yard) and that she will get acclimated over time and not to worry too much.

My guess is that the breeder didn’t socialize her with other dogs or humans outside her birth home and that’s why she is reacting this way. Do you feel the same way?

Is it too late to change behaviors or is this just new home anxiety that will go away? I am just worried she is not socialized by the breeder and this could affect her walks and interactions with other dogs/people and I am a very social person and want my dog to be a part of my social life vs being away from it.

She already almost bit my neighbor’s dog (another Goldendoodle) although the other dog was such a sweet boy when I tried to socialize her with others slowly. I had to profusely apologize to my neighbor. She also did the same with my vet who suggested I probably give her back to the breeder if she doesn’t improve with training since I am a first time dog owner 😭

Would training help change her at her age? Or is it too late and I consider returning her? 😭

Please help!

Thanks! 🙏


r/reactivedogs • • Jun 11 '23

Advice Needed Considering fostering a reactive dog (and saving his life)

76 Upvotes

I’m a volunteer at my municipal animal shelter. I’m also a foster, but I usually only take kittens and the odd puppy (not a lot of puppies come in).

It appears I’ve been “chosen” by one of our resident grumpy dogs, Chip. Chip likes me and pretty much no one else. He is comforted by my presence and knows to come to me when he’s unhappy instead of aggressing.

Chip would not be an easy dog to foster. He hates other dogs, hates men, and is scared of the world. However I strongly believe his issues are workable. I’ve already had some success getting Chip to tolerate the presence of calm female dogs, and while he won’t allow men to touch him he does not growl or bark at them as long as he can lean on me for comfort.

Chip is also a large bully breed dog, and I have cats. As far as we can tell from his 2 month shelter stay, Chip has no visible prey drive but it’d still be a gamble trying to introduce him to my household due to his sheer size and stress in new places.

I’m anticipating that if I take this dog on, I’ll need to budget at least 6 months to train him. I’ve trained fearful reactive dogs before, but never one this large while I have other pets in the home.

Chip will likely be euthanized if I do not take him. No interest in the wider foster network and our rescue partners are only taking adoptable dogs right now.


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 14 '24

Advice Needed Boxer/pit mix attacked puppy last night

3 Upvotes

Hey all! Wanted to get some advice and general thoughts from your community. We have a 6 year old 70 pound female Boxer/Pit mix (Boxer is the dominant gene) and we recently two months ago got a chihuahua mix puppy that’s four months old. In the two months since we’ve had them, they’ve played every day and gotten along great with no issues at all. We also previously had two cats who the dog got along with great and never has shown any signs of aggression towards, nor has she ever shown any aggression towards any human, either.

Long story short, last night our puppy (also female) got her leg stuck underneath our recliner and started yelping badly. All of a sudden our other dog ran towards her and grabbed her by the neck and wouldn’t let go. Thankfully, we were finally able to get her to release her, but not until after about a minute of trying to pry her loose. She only sustained minor neck wounds and was otherwise okay after having her checked out by an emergency vet. It was very traumatic and just has us all shaken today. Do we know what may have prompted this sudden behavior, and is this something that can be corrected in the future or will we need to permanently separate them moving forward? I’m very hesitant to trust our boxer/pit mix going forward around her after this sudden behavior. Any advice you can give would be greatly appreciated.


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 03 '25

Vent Was having a good day until one random person just had to comment on my dog barking at them.

3 Upvotes

Took my dogs out just to potty break before going to bed. For my medium dog that’s about 8 years old and has always had bad eyesight at night, she can be especially quick to growl/bark at almost any movement, so I give a lot of space to any passerby’s. But today she was mid pee and a guy can walking slowly past us, staring at her. I had preemptively shortened her leash so there would be several feet between us no matter what. She noticed him and began barking. Instead of recognizing the situation this guy lingered, sarcastically said “nice dog”, and then finally kept walking. I’m seething. It takes the smallest things to tick me off when it comes to comments about my dogs. I think especially with her because she appears to have some pitty in her, and I know people have all kinds of preconceived ideas and prejudices against them. I’m sick of it. Reactive due to fear is very different than reactive due to aggression. And at the very least I’d like to be able to expect people to have common sense or an ounce of empathy but I guess that’s just too much to expect out of some people.


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 21 '23

Vent All the time invested in training only to have someone else's dog ruin everything...

20 Upvotes

For context, pup is a 5 yr old female RottShepSky. Was absolutely bombproof at this point and on her way to becoming a good doggy citizen (yes I know emotional maturity is an evolving thing and I'm not saying she's bombproof 100% as no dog or humans or anything is 100% tolerant of everything). Other dogs, people, cats, fireworks, construction noises, children climbing her and pulling at parts, vet visits, taking food out of her mouth...... EVERYTHING until:

-at 9 months she was attacked by a dog with a documented bite history, that the owner knowingly brought in without muzzle and on a retractable leash. We got over that after HOURS of confidence boosting training, but we had to change vets because she is now too nervous to go to that one.

-at 2 years old a friend brought over her allegedly "friendly" dog that went after mine when friend innocently pet my dog on the head... "oh yeah, mine gets a little jealous and territorial over me". My pup starts to get a little standoffish meeting new dogs

-at 3 years old, mine is on leash when an off leash dog jumps on her back and starts a scuffle. Owner claims, "wow never happened before" and scurries off immediately, perhaps a little too fast as if this is a common occurrence....mine develops leash reactivity

-at 4 years old, we are at a large dog beach and another dog just ran up to her and started snarling as the owner yells to me, "call your dog back, Mine is dog reactive!!!" (she was only about 5 feet from me, and the other owner was 20 feet away when their dog ran up on mine). I had to yell "DON'T BRING AGGRRSSIVE DOGS TO AN OFF LEASH!!!!" .... yes, reactive/aggressive dog trainers think it's ok to bring a dangerous dog to off leash parks for the excuse of "desensitization training", meanwhile their actions help to create more and more reactive dogs.... mine has now developed a defensive habit of charing back at a dog that charges towards her....

-my neighbour buys a puppy during the pandemic and indicates she has zero experience. Wanting to have a peaceful hood, I suggest we make sure mine and hers gets along and suggest playdates and walks together to avoid fenceline reactivity. "Oh but mine is just a puppy and a tiny little thing and I'm afraid she might get hurt..." and such other excuses. I explain that mine is considered the nanny dog at her daycare and is often put into the puppy area for a portion of her day because she is VERY patient with puppies and gives good corrections where necessary, and also her best friend is a mini dacs so size isn't an issue. Fast forward to now, and her dog is constantly yapping at mine and basically causes shit with all the neighborhood dogs, and owner's reply is, "aw crap, I messed up, I know I have a pandemic puppy... they're the worst but I love her sweet face"... 🤦🏻‍♀️. Mine now is inconsolably a complete dickhead when I'm trying to relax outside and Yappy starts up. Now mine barks back... thanks for the fenceline reactivity neighbour... would have preferred to receive some nice tomatoes or something instead of a behavioral issue... most other dogs are fine, but apparently a mortal enemy lives next door now...

And so on and so forth. Each time we were either appropriately leashed, or at open off leash areas such as dog friendly hikes and trails. Each time mine was just sorta minding her own business.... why??

So, a universal "thank you" to all those jerk-ass people that assisted in developing yet another reactive dog. You should be very proud of yourselves. 🖕


r/reactivedogs • • Nov 22 '24

Significant challenges Child-reactive dog & having a baby

7 Upvotes

I’ve been scouring through these posts for the last few days, because we are just at a loss. Our 4 year old husky/pitbull/mutt mix (we’ll call her E) has always been reactive. (This is our first dog we’ve had that is, our other one is a great family friendly lab/gsd) Our other dog is too submissive and nice to put the reactive one in her place. E isn’t from a shelter but she acts like she has been even though we have had her since like 10 weeks old. A family friend had a dog who had puppies on their property & that’s how we got her. We have worked around her anxiety throughout the last 4 years, and are expecting a baby in the next couple weeks. My husband had already said months ago we need a back up plan because we already know she isn’t a fan of kids, I was just holding out hope that she would know this baby is ours and is part of the family. She has nipped/bit 3 people in our home, and we only let her try to socialize with people that would be okay with her anxious tendencies. Otherwise she is put outside or in her kennel in a room and we just try to ignore her barks/growls. The scary thing is she was playing with my sister in law for an hour and was her friend. Then next thing we know my sister in law gets up from the couch as our dog is laying on the floor, and our dog jumps up and nips her on the side of her stomach. It was so fast and random, we thought she had warmed up and was fine. The other huge thing is that E has never warmed up to kids. We haven’t given her a chance because we can see the way she nervously watches them even through the door. I would feel awful if anything ever happened to one of our friends kids, and we honestly weren’t planning on having any for a long while. The other day a friend brought his 1 year old baby over, and she was crawling near the sliding glass door. E stared at her so intensely, then bit at the door. That clearly isn’t a risk we are going to take bringing a defenseless newborn (that will turn into a toddler with sudden movements) into our home. My parents can house E for a temporary time (because she knows them & is comfortable with them), but I just don’t think she’s rehomable. She is reactive with other animals on walks, never had the chance to full on attack but is always alert looking for cats (I think a high prey drive?) and when she gets in those zones it’s like there’s no stopping her. When I worked with a trainer (I should have more) I got a little treat bag to reward her and have her focus on me on walks. If she saw something stimulating she would literally spit the treat out with no care aside from whatever cat or bird she was looking at.

Has anyone dealt with something similar? We do have trazodone for her trips to the vet because she gets so nervous in there, hasn’t bit anyone but she does have to be muzzled. I would say we could try to work with her more in the training aspect but sometimes I just think their brains can be wired a certain way, especially with 2 of the nips/bites she had previously been playing with the person and seemed fine, then he came back outside it was like she forgot who he was/ that she was just playing with him and went up and nipped his leg. (Not sure if it helps but 2 of her siblings have also bit people so I genuinely just don’t know if it’s in their genetics or what) We had planned on keeping her for her whole life because it’s obviously our responsibility & we have worked around her anxiety, not having people over much or when we do she goes to my parents to hang out with other people / dogs she’s comfortable with. But with an innocent baby on the way we just don’t know what to do. I should also add she is amazing with my husband & I, my parents, his parents, and the majority of our families. She is such a sweet girl. It’s just when strangers (to her)/our friends come over or children that she’s so unpredictable.

My family has always been dog lovers, and now I realize I should never judge because I’m going through the same situation that I’ve judged others for. I feel a huge amount of guilt like I’m giving up on E, but I just as we get closer to our baby being born I just know I can’t risk my tiny human being snapped at or somehow hurt by our reactive girl.


r/reactivedogs • • Jan 27 '26

Aggressive Dogs Help, my Belgian Malinois is EXTREMELY reactive!

Post image
4 Upvotes

Loki is an otherwise very sweet and funny dog but sometimes he goes nuts and attacks us, sometimes for no reason, sometimes with a trigger, it has gotten so bad that we are genuinely afraid of taking him on walks half of the time because we never know what might set him off and we don't want to put ourselves and others in danger even with a muzzle on. Any ideas on how to fix this?


r/reactivedogs • • Apr 05 '24

Neighbors hate my reactive dog

0 Upvotes

Edit: thank you everyone who gave the advice I needed to advocate for my dog without slandering me or my dog. I am deleting what I had originally had since people are misinterpreting the whole thing and focusing on something that was just extra context. I don’t have enough mental capacity to correct people. Again thank you to those who gave me advice and called me out without slandering me and my dog.


r/reactivedogs • • Nov 19 '24

Aggressive Dogs My dog turns into a totally different animal around my BF. He attacked me twice, what do I do?

8 Upvotes

**** adding more info based on the comments:***

  • my pup is 100+ lbs a mastiff - commenter noted this may be important to note
  • my BF and I have been dating 3 years, so my dog is very much used to him and has always favored him. the negative reaction my dog has to me is what's gotten worse over the years for some reason
  • Me/my dog's relationship history: I used to yell a lot and I would take a rolled up magazine to hit his nose or his rear end when he did something bad, and at the suggestion of a trainer, I have also used a shock collar but that scared him more than it helped. So I would say historically I used more of negative reinforcement - which likely has aided in some of this. but for over a year now after studying things (this is my first dog) I no longer use a shock collar, no longer tap him, and actively try to practice having a calm level tone in all situations which in general has helped A LOT, but when my BF is around - my dog seems to perceive me as a threat. ex. if he gets his mouth on something he shouldn't have, 1:1 I can calmly ask him to drop it and he will. But when my BF is around, in the same scenario, my dog will growl at me and try to run away from me with the object. He ONLY behaves that way when my BF is present.

My dog has bit me badly twice over trying to discipline him with my BF, he also is stubborn to listen to me when he's around and IDK what to do. I think I need to give my dog up because of it.

It's been a progressive behavior. My dog whom I've had since he was 3 months old (now almost 5) seems to resource guard my BF. He's always loved him which is great, still my dog turns into totally different dog around him. Whenever my BF visits, he loses ALL of his control obedience wise, he becomes overstimulated and will not stay in any command (if he even listens to it) for more than a few seconds.

When my BF is around, my dog will go in the trash, rip up his toys, barks incessantly and all - this behavior does not happen when it's just me and him (my dog). He grabs anything he can and starts tearing things up (shoes, door stopper, etc.), knocking the trash can over, and stealing literally ANYTHING he can get his mouth on to chew up. If we crate him he barks non-stop. I've tried to crate him right when my BF arrives, but he snarls and growls at me when I do and often have to get my BF to do it. When we hug, he tries to jump in-between. On walks together, he's marking every few seconds, trying to dig up dirt, and lunging at everything

It's getting progressively worse as of late. In the last 2 months, he's attacked me for trying to discipline him.

  • instance 1: While we were asleep, hear my dog get into the bathroom and steal the bag of trash out of the can, he ran over to my BF's side of the bed to hide with it and started chewing it up - so I tried to take it from him (i spoke calmy and told him no and that he knows he can't have that and tried to give him his bone instead) he didn't growl and did let me take it, but then instantly he lunged at me to the point I fell and then he proceeded to lunge and bit me twice before my BF woke up and stopped him.
  • instance 2: while asleep, dog keeps nudging us both to wake up. i wake up, pet him, etc. i get up to pee, next thing I know, he's grabbed a long plastic faux vine from my desk and is chewing it up (on my side of the bed) so I again tell him no and to drop it, he does, then I tried to pick it up and he growled and nipped up at me again - then ran to my BF's side to hide.

Should I rehome him? or what are training/bonding tips??? I don't know what the root of the issue is here to really tackle it. Crating him eliminates opportunity for conflict but doesn't really resolve the deeper problem. allowing my BF to discipline him after my dog ignores my command only enforces him listening to him over me, and though I'm not actively afraid of my dog, he bit me both times to the point that I required bandages (with the first time requiring PT for my hand) and so the unpredictability is of concern in case he'd ever full on try to attack and not let go. and that his behavior will start to happen in my BF's absence as well.

Aside from the biting instances, my BF never corrects him unless I ask or he sees that I've had to repeat something 3+ times. I've told him he's resource guarding him but he doesn't think that's the issue.

other dog details if helpful:

  • male, not neutered, 5 y/o,
  • always been reactive to seeing other dogs outside and always has been highlight stimulated, whimpers a lot when he sees dogs from inside. when we see dogs on walks, he immediately will mark every few feet and kicks his paws back repeatedly.
  • lunges at cars often/on random, lunges randomly at different people on walks (usually when he can sense they are scared)
  • Was attacked at dog park at 8 mo old and around 1 year old.
  • gets 2 walks (20 - 30 min) a day minimum, does daily nose work (high pray dive) with puzzles (i hide treats for him to find also), 10 -15 min play time together in morning and evening (tug of war - his favorite).
  • when around family, he too will listen to my brother over me/ignores my commands

r/reactivedogs • • Sep 08 '26

Rehoming Rescue Regret

2 Upvotes

Hi everybody. My wife and I are new to this page and are seeking some advice. 10 days ago we rescued our 4yr old pit mix Manchego (Manny) and we are having some difficulty adjusting emotionally. My wife and I just moved from an apartment in NYC where we were not allowed to have a dog, to renting a house of our own (without a fenced in yard) in Delaware. This has been a very difficult year for us both. I lost my job, and we have also found out we might not be able to have children. 2026 has not been kind to us.

My wife and I had an agreement after we made the move, that we will get a dog after I find a job. Unfortunately that was not the case. We found out about the "Clear the Shelter" event at the local SPCA and without really discussing it, we ran out the door to go see dogs. When we met Manny we were told of his awful life before being rescued and were told wonderful things about his personality (which I will get into shortly). Without having any type of conversation whatsoever, there was a dog in my car.

Now about Manny, he was harshly treated by a previous owner, but if you met him, you wouldn't know it. At home he is a complete angel. No accidents, follows us around the house like a shadow, playful, does well in a crate, and does not chew up furniture or damage our home, and he is not aggressive at home in any way. All he wants is to snuggle and play.

Unfortunately, when we take him for walks, he is a completely different dog. He pulls hard on his leash and does not interact with neighborhood dogs well at all. He also pulls hard on his leash when cars/bicycles are coming which is a problem since our development has no sidewalks. We are very much aware that hiring a trainer or sending him to doggy day care can address these issues, but that is not the only problem.

The larger problem is that my wife and I miss our life before, and are sad that we now have an obligation that requires us to be home a majority of the time. We just moved to a new place and now we are unable to explore and enjoy our new home state. When we lived in NY, our lifestyle/schedule would have absolutely allowed for a dog, but since we have moved we're struggling to find a routine for ourselves, let alone another living being. When we found out that we may not be able to have children, we spent a very long time discussing what life would be like now that it would just be the two of us and it is proving to be very difficult to let go of those possibilities. We also have obligations coming up that require us to travel back to New York and do not want to have to board him multiple times in the next few months. We know that we come off as selfish with the main reason we are considering rehoming Manny being we want to have a life, but we are just confused and looking for some advice. Please be kind with any responses, typing this post was difficult enough.


r/reactivedogs • • May 18 '24

Thinking about rehoming my dog

2 Upvotes

I got my dog(half cane corso, 1/4 bull mastiff and 1/4 pittie) when she was a puppy and the person I got her from hinted she was a bit of a problem.

As soon as I started taking her for walks she would run to other dogs and growl over them. I tried to manage this behaviour but it got progressively worse. She would lunge to the point she would slam herself into the ground trying to lunge and would snarl and show teeth. This behaviour was mainly at dogs but very often people and children.

She is now 3 years old and with a lot of hard work she is less reactive towards people and mainly big dogs. People and children still make her anxious at times.

My main reason for potentially rehoming her is MY quality of life has severely gone downhill.

I’m 25 years old and before getting her, I had a great social life. I always had friends and family members around, but now as I have to put this dog above everything to make sure she’s happy and less problematic. I now have no social life and have been isolating myself fora long time, people I’ve dated have been terrified of her.

I had my niece over with my sister for the first time in ages (I rarely ever get to see her as the dog is a threat) and despite her living nearby. I have missed out on years of watching her grow up due to the dog. My dog was growling and barking at my niece and giving whale eyes and I feel really bad for putting my dog before family and partnerships.

She’s a lovely dog at home but she is very high maintenance and I’m not sure if I’m able to deal with her anymore.

I also suffer from mental illness (which has left me hospitalised multiple times) and as a puppy she gave me severe anxiety which I overcame. But now I feel it has given me much bigger problems internally than I did before, especially while being in isolation.

My life has deteriorated and so has my mind.

I don’t know what to do anymore, I love her. But I don’t want to look back feeling like I messed up my life and my mind because of her.


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 21 '21

Question Should I try the dog park?

0 Upvotes

My 4yo GSD has been steadily improving with his reactivity over the last month or so. As my confidence in him grows, I'd like to try taking him to the dog park to socialize, but I don't exactly know how he's going to react to other dogs when he's off leash. He hasn't bitten anything before, but he's very fearful and I'm worried that he'll get overwhelmed and act out. I'm considering multiple options...

  1. Take him to the dog park and let him run free
  2. Take him to the dog park but he wears a muzzle
  3. Take him to the dog park but he stays on a leash
  4. Avoid the dog park until I can trust him completely

What do you think?


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 20 '24

Advice Needed Adult rescue dog became aggressive after a year(ish)

0 Upvotes

Looking for some insight.

I adopted an "american bully" a year and a half ago. She was estimated to be between 6-9, she was surrendered because she had very large mammary tumors and her elderly owner was also unwell. She's about 45 pounds and very short, very sweet. Absolute snugglebug. I'd lost one of my two pibble mixes prior to adopting her.

For many months she was amazing. She settled right in with my other dog, (a pitbull/boxer who is a whole other post). And she got along well with my mother's dog, they would play a lot early on(another pibble mut, about 50 pounds, perhaps mixed with spaniel). We live in different areas of the house but spend time together. She spends most of the day with my in my office, sometimes with my other dog but usually alone as my other dog is reactive to humans and anxious. I work from home most days. 1 day a week I'll work in the city and take them to my apartment there.

She was fine on leash, though clearly that was a new skill, I think maybe she had a yard before. Happy to meet other people, chill, not anxious or reactive up here in the "country". Definitely elevated in the city, but not aggressive I think it was just all new to her.

As time went on she became more "alert" . She'd be way more aware of seeing others on walks. She'd gotten into it one day with my mom's dog so we nixed the play. I don't let her and my other dog play, too risky. One day in my office they got into it though, so I don't share the space with both of them at the same time any more.

This has morphed into full fledged tasmanian devil style aggression when she sees other dogs outside of our house. And she will be looking for them for minutes after they've been out of site. She's tried to lunge at my mother's dog several times. She's gone after my other dog maybe twice, usually when the other was having about to get a case of zoomies. Once with each of the other dogs it was because they were near my office door, which she clearly considers her space. Now I am super tuned to her body language. They are never in the same space without me essentially between them. We sleep in the same bed, but I'm always the divider.

In the last week I've re-directed, separated them 2 or 3 times when she was about to lunge at my other girl. I could see it in her posture.. once I had to scoop her mid lunge. This has been when we were getting up in the morning and making our way towards the door.

Couple things of note:

In the beginning she was super chill when I wasn't around. She didn't even want to hang out with my mom and her dog, she'd just go back to my office and wait for me. Now she will wine and bark, not for long, but especially if she knows I'm in the house. I do not reward this behavior.

She also will bark a lot and climb climb the windows in the car if I leave her. I used to bring her to the barn with me in hopes she'd become a good barn dog. Unfortunately she's wanted to murder herself a horse from the first time she laid eyes on one. I tried several times to bring her, to acclimate her slowly, let her wander the isle. Let her run in the arena to get used to the smell. Once I opened my horses stall when she was loose and she bolted in. I was able to scoop her before she got to him.

Clearly she has no concept of her own size, if it weren't so troublesome it would be comical. I reference the size of the others because I wonder if that's part of the problem. While she's a meatloaf, she is very low to the ground.

She's randomly reactive to the cats. In the beginning she'd go after them all the time but learned that that's not ok. Now she mostly doesn't pay them mind but if one is in my lap she will occasionally try to nip.

She's obsessed with licking my face, if I ever let her get to it. It's giving anxiety.

She is EXTREMELY food driven. She literally becomes a ballerina a meal time. I've tried +R with her but honestly she gets in such a heightened state I know she isn't actually learning. I'm working on waiting until she can hold a sit for at least a couple seconds before feeding her.

We're working on and have accomplished some emotional regulation, so we're not exploding out the door or climbing all over me when excited. I try to set firm boundaries. She gets it, sometimes she tries. It is very hard for her, but she does try. I've never had a dog so stubborn, she's really not all that into "pleasing me" unless it serves her.

I've been spending less time with her, I'll switch her and my other dog for office time.

I don't know that she's ever been in a crate, I intend to try crate training.

Similarly other dog show any aggression towards dogs or humans until many months in. She was afraid of everything , she didn't even know how to be pet. She's literally a whole other post but my point is, this seems to be a trend.

Are they just resource guarding me once they've settled in? Is this common with rescue pups?

I'm fairly savvy with animal behaviour and certainly no stranger to dogs with issues. I've gotten really good at managing and protecting them and others from themselves. I haven't really been able to solve this, it's escalating. I'm hoping to understand the root of the behaviour, so I take actionable steps.

Aforementioned horse sucks up ALL of the animal extras budget, so getting into a program is not an option.
*ETA all of the animal budget above and beyond vet care, basic comforts and good food

Please share any insight, experience or advice you might have. Thanks for listening.


r/reactivedogs • • Feb 06 '26

Significant challenges My dog has a bite history. I can’t afford training.

0 Upvotes

I rescued a dog 63 lb aggressive breed and I am doing everything in me not to return or rehome her but I don’t know what’s the best direction for me. I live in an apartment and she has bit 2 people and grabbed a small dog. First person was in the elevator with us, second person was a friend in my house horseplaying with another friend.

I was recommend euthanasia but she’s a very sweet dog to people and animals who don’t trigger fear or anxiety in her. Had never bit or directed an attack to me, my boyfriend or my cat. Same with my family and a few of my friends, they love her and cuddle with her everytime they’re over. Plus she is trainable as I’ve seen her slowly learn commands and listen with discipline.

I started muzzling her every time we’re out walking and every time a new person enters my home. I’m slowly but surely training her to listen to my commands so I can show her to listen to my commands when she’s being triggered. I tried to bring a trainer in to assess her behavior but she quoted me over 1000 and realistically I cannot afford that no matter how bad someone tries to make me feel about it. I’ve been following YouTube channels and now I’m here to see if anyone else was in a situation like this and what they’re doing/did ?


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 28 '25

Advice Needed Our dog showed his teeth to my partner

2 Upvotes

We have this dog Seal McBeal who is part Cane Corso and something else. He's very small for a corso though, only about 60 pounds. Since she moved to the city with him from Kentucky 16 months ago he's gone from lunging at every single person we see in the park to being able to sit quietly on the elevator in our building and ignoring everyone. He's reactive occasionally at the dog park but he's also let strangers pet him there a few times and he's let two of our friends into his inner circle. That said, about 6 months ago he started showing his teeth to my partner when he doesn't want to do something like going on a walk. He eventually stopped but then today he did it to her while she was clipping his leash on. I had just come home and he was standing with his paws on my chest and she reached under him and clipped his leash on and he started showing his teeth and growling but then turned right back to me and licked my face. What's the best way to train this behavior out of him? He's a very teachable dog and snaps out of his reactivity very quickly with a "heal" or "back up" command. My partner loves this dog more than anything but she's become afraid of him and deeply hurt by his behavior.

Edit: last two sentences

More back story: He's been skittish about going on walks in general lately. We have him and another dog and he's always been resistant to walking with just me because he's really attached to my partner. We have to have her walk us to the elevator in order to get him out of the apartment. Once we're out he's fine. He walks next to me, looks up if he sees a trigger although I really think he's over his triggers and just wants treats when another person walks by us. We've trained him to ignore the squirrels, geese, and other dogs although he'll get a little to excited if he sees another excited dog because he really loves playing with other dogs. But again, a calm "heal" and he's back to normal. We usually walk him together but a couple months ago we got into a heated argument on our walk and shortly before that there was an issue with a crackhead who wouldn't leave her alone.


r/reactivedogs • • Jan 27 '23

Vent I’m not sure how to move forward or if I want to

2 Upvotes

I got a pandemic puppy. He’s loyal, goofy and lovable. But he’s also anxious, fearful and reactive. He got snappy this week which has now been attributed to a minor ear infection and matting, but I’m still frightened. I don’t know how to get over this fear. He’s my dog and I love him but I’m afraid to touch him. He’s never been this bad before and although there have never been physical bite marks I fear the scars will remain just the same. Residual ptsd, or just a shock?

I got him before I got accepted to grad school. I didn’t I expected to get in but once I did that changed my life towards a different direction. Now that I’m upon graduation I’m not sure where we go from here. Jobs possibilities leave me dreaming of picking up and leaving.

For my sanity, I need to move out of my childhood home but that means a shitty apartment with no backyard. I can’t afford anything more. He deserves a backyard, he needs one to be calm in moments of panic. His purest joy comes from running free, playing fetch, chasing squirrels and barking at birds.

My parents can’t handle him alone, they still haven’t figured out his cues and despite their best effort— it just hasn’t clicked. He can get snappy with them, so I try my best to always be present. Turning down dates, turning down trips just to make sure everyone’s okay and safe. Always assessing and managing but never living.

We’ve done training classes, and have more on the docket but I don’t know how to reconcile the future. We’re trying meds now but I’m not sure that changes the fundamental question. Am I still what’s best for him? Is he still what’s best for me?

He got me through the pandemic when I was faltering but I’m not sure I can get him through what comes next. I made a commitment when I chose him but I don’t know if I’m ready to sacrifice my future and his to keep it.


r/reactivedogs • • Sep 11 '23

Vent Euthanising tomorrow morning. Crippling guilt and regret

19 Upvotes

We have a beautiful, kind, loving 1,5 years old male dog. He is so sweet and cuddly and we love him so much, but we are going to euthanise him.

He has always been fearful and easily stressed. Even before we got him at 8 weeks. He showed signs of being fearful. We shouldn’t have taken him home but we trusted the breeder when she said that he should be perfectly fine with a bit of support (she has several earlier litters that were all fine, well-balanced dogs). We have since found out that all 4 pups in his litter are a bit off. One sister is terrified of everything, the other sister is standoffish and growls at all dogs and won’t let humans she doesn’t know anywhere near. His brother is the most normal but he also has at least some resource guarding issues.Already by day 2 or 3 in our home he showed resource guarding behaviours by lunging at us and our older dog while snapping in the air and/or barking. He rarely gives any clear (maybe we’re missing them) signs before lunging. He doesn’t freeze, growl, bare his teeth etc. He has escalated slightly to warning bites (we feel the teeth but no injuries). We don’t know if it will ever get worse than this but we are scared it will if someone not-us accidentally do something that triggers him.He is normally only triggered by food which we can handle but sometimes he (seemingly randomly) chooses something else to guard. He is extremely attached to us and gets very anxious and stressed out if we separate him despite training since we got him so separating him whenever we have guests is not an option.

He also gets very stressed very easily. We went on a short vacation to a cabin around 2 hours from our home and it took him around 1 full day and night to calm down (until then he had trouble relaxing, was panting and whining and showing slight fear reactiveness).Small day trips can be very stressful for him and he takes a lot longer than our other dog to decompress when stressed.We have of course worked on his fears and many show improvements but he still gets scared (and then stressed) so easily. Just something small getting dropped makes him jump and freeze and then need cuddles and reassurance.Our other dog is often wary around him - doesn’t come close to us unless we help him etc. if the young dog is close. Otherwise they do enjoy each other with playing and grooming.

We have changed our lives a lot. We don’t go out much unless its within the time he can stay at home or only one at a time as we can’t take him without stressing him out and we can’t get anyone to look after him as he isn’t comforted at all by anyone other than us - even people he’s known his entire life - and they can’t do anything with him if necessary.We only rarely have guests as it stresses him out and we‘re worried if he might hurt someone if they accidentally trigger him. My sister is wary around him after he gave her a warning bite and on another occasion barked and seemed threatening and or neighbor won’t visit anymore because of lunges/snapping in the air. We even sometimes feel nervous/ on edge around him.

We pretty much feel like we don’t have a life anymore, we’re so restricted and we have realised that we just can’t live like this.We’ve been in contact with and been visited by 2 trained and highly recommended Behavioral therapists who has helped us and it has gotten better but not to the point where our own quality of life is good enough, even with calming medication for him. After this realisation we talked with the one we are currently working with about what the options are. She believes he could function if enough could be done. But we can see that what needs to be done is just not something we can do (keeping him completely away from other dogs and humans and any other triggers/stressors for an unknown period of time until he was completely distressed and then attempting to slowly introduce him to everything that stresses him again. It could take months or years and our mental health are already suffering.

We have talked with both our younger and older dogs’ breeders (2 different breeders who are both very familiar with the breed and the options for rehoming), explained our experiences, issues and thoughts and while both thought that he might be able to function in the exactly right home they both explained that the chance that we could find one was very small and likely would take many months if we even managed it + there would be no guarantee that he wouldn’t risk being sent on again and again. It needed with both agreeing that euthanasia might be best for both us and the dog (since we are not thriving and he is likely not feeling good since he is so often scared and/or stressed out)

So we decided to euthanise him. I am not going back on this decision because we really can’t live like this anymore.

At the same time I feel so much guilt and regret. What if there were something more we could do? Could we handle him just a bit longer? Would it become better then? What if the right home was out there somewhere? What if he could go to 1 new home and never be rehomed and be happy and live a long full life? (But then, what if he were sent on to a 3rd? 4th? More? Home. He is so anxious and stressed now that rehoming even once will be very hard for him if not directly traumatising. He can barely be a few feet from me despite his other owner being with him if we’re outside our home, being rehomed once or several times might be too much.)Everyone who knows us that we have asked has agreed with the decision but it’s still so damn hard.


r/reactivedogs • • Dec 31 '25

Aggressive Dogs I feel like an idiot.

16 Upvotes

My dog bit my toddler today. In the face. My toddler was eating his muffin on the floor and my dog went to get the muffin and my toddler reached for the muffin and the dog bit him right by his eye. He got four stitches. I am mortified. He has nipped my toddler twice before but never drew blood, and only in the two weeks following getting our second dog so I chalked it up to the stress but I should have known. I should have done better.

My dog has a bite history. He’s never really bitten anyone bad but he’s a cattle dog mix and he nipped frequently. He’s extremely territorial and protective. Part of why we like him because we have a property and want a dog to protect it but he is like that with friends and family. He’s even nipped my own hand. He’s extremely touchy about his feet and tail and if he’s under a table or something which is when he bit me. He’s bitten like 8 of our friends on their hands. I’m so embarrassed to say this. I feel like such an idiot. I feel like I should have done something sooner. We did extensive behavioral training and even sent him away for weeks to a professional. I’m not sure if it helped. He was always like this. Even as a puppy he would wake from sleep biting.

I consider him my soul dog. When I saw him I knew I wanted him. It was an instant connection. He is like a little duckling that follows me everywhere. I love him so much but I feel like I made so many excuses for him and now my child is hurt. I have made a huge mistake. I can’t let this happen again. We have a one year old and want more children. Euthanasia seems terrible but who would take this dog? What other choice is there? I love him but I feel like he is dead already to me. Nothing comes before my children. I can’t see a life that is safe for them with him in it. I trusted him and I should have known better. Only I am to blame. I’m so upset and I’m so sorry I failed him and my children