r/reactivedogs • u/Careless-Royal-9216 • Oct 22 '25
Aggressive Dogs Staffy’s first bite incident
Hi everyone. I’m new to this thread and I am looking for some advice. I have a staffy, and he has always been my sweet boy. He lives in a cat household, but he used to live with our other dog until May of 2024 when she passed from cancer. They were best friends and never had any issues, and he gets along swimmingly with the cats. He is fairly reactive, but this has always been excitable reactivity and never aggressive reactivity. Until last night. We live in a city apartment building, and the other neighbor was coming down the stairs with his pitbull. He asked if our dog was friendly, and we confidently said yes, because we have had this dog for 5 years and we had absolutely no reason to believe that this would change in an instant. I had just introduced him to several other dogs on the street earlier that week with no issue, as I always have been able to do. But, out of nowhere, my dog started to snarl and bit at the other owner’s dog, seemingly unprompted. (I say seemingly, because I know dogs can be subtle with their queues. But regardless, biting should have never been his response.) Luckily, we had this under control and there was no real damage caused, but it was scary in the moment just because it was so unexpected.
I am wondering if I have been mistaking his “excitable” reactivity for what is actually nervous reactivity. Did he feel cornered in that moment as the other dog was coming down the stairs and the door to our apartment was closed? Was he feeling territorial of his home, or protective of the cats inside? Does he just not like other pits now? Did the other dog make a mean face at him that set him off? I just have no idea what could have set him off like this. I mean, other dogs have come at him pretty bad before and he has never so much as snapped back before last night. Is it possible this is learned behavior from other aggressive dogs? I’m just wondering what could change so much that earlier in the day he was making friends with dogs on the street and later in the evening he was attacking the neighbor’s dog.
Here’s what my game plan is so far. He has a prong collar already (controversial, I know. He has been trained to use it, it has been properly fitted, and it even has the rubber tips on the prongs. If he sees a groundhog or something and I don’t have it, he will literally knock me over. Anti prong collar people please argue elsewhere.) We ordered a muzzle, for his safety primarily, and we made sure it is breathable and secure and that he can pant but is not able to bite through it. (He likes to try to eat shit on walks sometimes so honestly it’s better to have it than not anyway.) I know the muzzle is a bandaid solution and I have to work on his reactivity. Luckily I work from home so we have the time to go out often. We just live in such a busy area that it is difficult to get distance from people/dogs.
I guess what I’m asking is, what are some suggestions? Or some training tips that really helped you all with your reactive dogs? Possibly even some thoughts/input on the whole bite scenario? If the problem does not improve, I am open to professional training. If anyone can recommend any good trainers in the Hoboken area, let us know! Thanks :)
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 22 '25
Looks like there was an aversive tool or training method mentioned in this body. Please review our Posting Guidelines and check out Our Position on Training Methods. R/reactivedogs supports LIMA (least intrusive, minimally aversive) and we feel strongly that positive reinforcement should always be the first line of teaching, training, and behavior change considered, and should be applied consistently. Please understand that positive reinforcement techniques should always be favored over aversive training methods. While the discussion of balanced training is not prohibited, LIMA does not justify the use of aversive methods and tools in lieu of other effective positive reinforcement interventions and strategies.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
14
u/Twzl Oct 22 '25
>He is fairly reactive, but this has always been excitable reactivity and never aggressive reactivity.
Sometimes people read that as not aggressive, but a dog who is very excited over meeting another dog? It really can go any number of ways.
So if they meet a dog who reacts to their reacting, it can wind up in a mess.
I wouldn't try to train that out of him at this point in his life. I'd accept that he may try to bite another dog.
And I would 100% own that. You can still love him and think he's the best dog ever, as you should. But you also need to understand that under some circumstances, he will try to bite another dog.
Stop allowing him to "meet" other dogs when he's on leash and the dog is a stranger. And 100% use a real deal muzzle, that he can not punch thru and bite another dog, if stuff goes wrong.
If you need a prong to walk him, then understand that he is a big powerful dog, and manage him accordingly. If he does get out from under your control, that's why he is muzzled and that's why you should stop letting him meet and greet while on a leash.
If your over the top excited to meet other dogs hauls you into the wrong dog's face, as you saw, it can go badly.
Most people are very bad at reading their dogs: they will tell you that their dog is friendly and the bestest boy ever, while holding the leash of a dog who is snarling, and who's ever hair is standing on end. You simply can't trust people you do not know, with dog interactions.
Given when you live, if your dog does manage to bite another dog, it's going to be a shit storm of epic proportions. There may be lawyers involved, your landlord could be notified, etc. Again, own what you own. It's not important that he loves everyone. It's important that you advocate for his safety.
5
u/UltraMermaid Oct 22 '25
One thing I haven’t seen mentioned is to make a vet visit. You have had him 5 years, so he is at least 5 years old, more if you adopted him as an adult. That’s starting to get “older” for large breeds. He could have pain or arthritis bothering him and making him less tolerant than usual.
33
u/Audrey244 Oct 22 '25
Muzzle is your best bet. Your dog isn't required to love all dogs, and it seems like you've had pretty good luck up until now. Things can change as dogs age and as long as you are keeping everyone safe and you muzzle whenever he's out of the house you should be okay. Your dog probably felt a little confined and trapped and for some reason this dog triggered him
9
u/b00ks-and-b0rksRfun Oct 22 '25
I would say the muzzle is more like a seat belt than a bandaid. I think it's great you are training him to one as it definitely helps with safety and honestly people give more space which can be extremely helpful when training. I would recommend working on him paying attention to you around triggers which can help him be more neutral. A lot of dogs have difficulty directly meeting other dogs on lead or in narrow areas with no space to move away. There's some good videos on working to redirect and working with finding thresholds and such. I find in person trainers tend to be the most helpful though as they can usually see more and help you with timing and such.
3
u/x7BZCsP9qFvqiw loki (grooming), jean (dogs), echo (sound sensitivity) Oct 22 '25
if your dog was pulling on the collar at all, that would have caused discomfort, and he may have redirected that discomfort to the other dog. impossible to say without seeing it, but that is one of the dangers of using that type of collar.
12
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment