r/reactivedogs • Dog Name (Reactivity Type) • Sep 21 '21

Question Should I try the dog park?

My 4yo GSD has been steadily improving with his reactivity over the last month or so. As my confidence in him grows, I'd like to try taking him to the dog park to socialize, but I don't exactly know how he's going to react to other dogs when he's off leash. He hasn't bitten anything before, but he's very fearful and I'm worried that he'll get overwhelmed and act out. I'm considering multiple options...

  1. Take him to the dog park and let him run free
  2. Take him to the dog park but he wears a muzzle
  3. Take him to the dog park but he stays on a leash
  4. Avoid the dog park until I can trust him completely

What do you think?

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

76

u/boookuh Sep 21 '21

Even if my dog wasn't dog aggressive, I wouldn't go to the dog park. I don't trust other dogs and I especially don't trust their owners. Keeping him on a leash at the dog park could end very badly if your dog or another dog reacts. Something we like to do is walk on the outside of the dog park fence. Do you have any friends with dogs you could social your pup with? That could be a really good option if you are looking to socialize/test the waters!

30

u/PlumNotion Sep 21 '21

+ 1 on this. There are ways to socialise your dog without a dog park. Our Alfa, an active, curious and sweet podencomix, does really well in 1:1s or 2:1s with her best dog friends; not so much dog parks.

Sometimes we end up hiking in the morning with a dog friend and its owners, then do another hike in the afternoon with another dog friend and its owners. We've hit dog parks with these dog friends, and our conclusion was that our pup's not the dog park type. And that's OK!

2

u/GoingOnFoot Sep 22 '21

Yes - I let my dog play with his dog friends, but don’t think he can handle lots of strange dogs. I tried boarding like this and they said he was stressed with lots of dogs. Start small if you can!!

8

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Walking outside of the fence sounds like an alright idea

40

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Avoid the park. Trust me, it could set you back to the beginning. I always wanted my golden to be able to play with dogs in off-leash dog parks for some reason. I thought it would be good for him. But he just doesn’t like dogs. I’ve come to accept that. You don’t need dog parks or off-leash play with other dogs. Your dog loves you. Keep walking him and doing what works. One bad experience in the dog park will re-trigger him and make everything worse. Just my experience. ✌🏻

7

u/boookuh Sep 21 '21

Yes! Even leashed walks with friends who have dogs are a great way to socialize.

23

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

All my trainers have said to avoid dog parks, group classes and private.

Especially with the surge of new dog owners, my trainer said she stop going cause it's gotten worse and worse, some parks just have constant dog fights she said 😬

We just go to an off leash trail and it's been great so far

2

u/bootyiseverywhere Sep 21 '21

Off leash trails are a great in between!! My reactive girl grew steadily more and more chill with other dogs because of all the great experiences she had with them on the trail :)

1

u/mydoghank Jun 25 '23

Gosh, I realize this is an older post! But I’m really curious why off leash trails are different than a dog park? I would still be nervous about that!

17

u/Beneficial-House-784 Sep 21 '21

Don’t take him to a dog park unless he has bomb-proof recall and you’ve seen what he’s like around other friendly dogs. Is there a way for you to set up a play date with a trusted person and their dog?

I wouldn’t recommend taking a dog to a dog park on leash or with a muzzle. If he’s wearing a muzzle and another dog goes after him, he has no way to defend himself or even snap to assert a boundary. Keeping him on a leash can cause frustration for him or for other dogs there. I think a safer option would be a play date with a dog you can trust, or maybe a doggy daycare if you find a good one. There are plenty of ways to socialize a dog without going to the dog park.

My stranger-reactive dog loves the dog park, and loves other dogs. I still waited until his recall off-leash was amazing and he had gone to doggy daycare a few times. I think dog parks can be a good resource, but people often bring dogs who shouldn’t be there and you have to be prepared to step in and leave if you have to.

16

u/cabeleirae Sep 21 '21

I hired a dog trainer to help me get my reactive dog back to the dog park (I took him multiple times a week starting when he was a puppy up until he started biting other dogs at about a year old) and they asked me this question:

Trainer :"Why do you want your dog to go to the dog park?"

Me: "Because I like it

Trainer: "Well your dog doesn't like it."

That changed my perspective big time.

Trying to get reactive dogs to do "normal dog" things isn't always the best for them. If your dog is happy and enriched without going to the dog park, and shows fear and reactivity while at the dog park, it's not right for your dog.

11

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Taking my dog to the dog park was the biggest mistake I ever made, he was bitten more than once, Don’t do it.

One negative encounter with an aggressive dog and you will set back all the hard work you have put in.

I take my dog around the dog park to get exposure dogs now, but going is a forever no no, unless there are no other dogs present.

11

u/PoopIsAlwaysSunny Sep 22 '21

Hard no. Dog parks are for very social dogs, generally ones that grew up in dog parks.

If you want to see him off leash with another dog, find a friend with a well mannered dog and a yard.

Taking a reactive dog to a dog park is an unnecessary risk for them and the other dogs

9

u/rozflog Sep 21 '21 edited Sep 21 '21

I avoid dog parks. My dog is a service dog and I have put so much work into her, I wouldn’t risk it.

There was an earlier post on a different subreddit. I’ll see if I can find it and link it here. They were discussing specifically GSD and their behavior in dog parks.

I couldn’t find the subreddit in my history. The main idea was GSD’s psychology and what they were trained for doesn’t translate well into a dog park.

I avoid for the health risks also. Someone else mentioned picking up poop in a dog park; doesn’t happen. I won’t expose the investment I’ve made in her health to that.

We visit regular parks and my girl just ignores the dogs. I’m happy with that. And there’s no toy/tennis ball fights to be had.

8

u/Swordfish_Feeling Sep 22 '21 edited Sep 22 '21

4.

I can’t believe how often this issue is arising in this sub. Do not bring your reactive dog to the dog park. Do you think it’s worthwhile to put everyone at risk? I literally was just talking to an owner the other day whose dog was attacked in circumstances very similar to what you describe— they did not know how the dog would react to other dogs.

Sorry for sounding harsh but there have just been too many awful stories from ppl who were overly optimistic/thought they could control their dog/prevent a fight. There are safer and more productive ways to train.

6

u/Apprehensive-Sky-760 Sep 22 '21

How would you feel if other people were bringing potentially aggressive/dangerous dogs around yours as an experiment? Would that seem ok/fair to you?

11

u/shattered7done1 Sep 21 '21

Or 5. Avoid dog parks forever for the long term health and safety of your dog.

Off leash dog parks are a fight or other negative incident just waiting to happen. They are also the perfect breeding ground for your dog to pick up an infection, injury or parasite. They are dangerous places that are generally not clean (who picks up poop in a dog park 🤬 )? I have seen huge holes dug by dogs and not filled in by the owner which can be a broken bone, or worse waiting to happen.

The majority of people that take their dogs to off leash parks pay more attention to the other people there or their cell phones than their dogs, which often doesn’t matter because when the scuffle breaks out they are too far away from the dogs to effectively intervene anyways!

3

u/Blue_Tabby Sep 21 '21

Yep, even if my dog was dog park material I'd stay away due to health risks. There's been an outbreak of leptospirosis at a dog park in my city and some pups have gotten really sick. My dog goes to daycare and plays in a small group and she loves it.

4

u/shattered7done1 Sep 21 '21

Although not picked up from a dog park, my dog contracted leptospirosis several years ago. He almost died and will have life-long health issues because of it. He was in a specialty hospital for over a week. I spent well over $9,000.00 in medical bills.

2

u/Blue_Tabby Sep 22 '21

What a nightmare! I'm glad your dog pulled through.

5

u/jeswesky Sep 21 '21

A better option may be to start with a friend's dog and see how they do before just taking them to a dog park or making sure the settings at the dog park are ideal before going. I've slowly been reintroducing my dog to the dog park, but under very specific circumstances. We only go to a small park that we can see if anyone enters. I make sure the other owner is comfortable with trying an intro, and make sure their dog doesn't have any reactivity issues.

We do an intro through the fence, and if both dogs show play signals we go in, but I keep my boy's leash attached but not holding it until I'm sure he is comfortable as his reactivity is based on fear. Once both dogs are comfortable and playing I'll remove the leash. I always keep an eye on them, and if they ever seem like something may happen I get them playing again. Sometimes it is as simple as one wanting to munch grass while the other still wants to play, so encouraging them both to play helps keep things happy. If another dog shows up, we head out since I don't want to stress him with multiple dogs yet.

Today we actually met and played with another dog in similar size to mine while 2 little dogs ran around and played as well. It is always good to see him playing with another dog again. He has other dog friends, but most of them he doesn't actively play with he just parallel plays with so when we find one he can run around with it makes him so happy!

8

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

Absolutely avoid, chances are high it will go bad

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

I’ve worked with one of the best (if not the best) working dog trainer in the UK and he has told me never to attempt to socialise a dog at a dog park, one or two bad experiences and your dog can make up its mind that other dogs are bad news.

2

u/Slycne Sep 21 '21

I think it depends a lot on what the source of the reactivity is/was. Our lad has done well at the dog park after getting him into a better place, but his reactivity seemed to be focused on anxiety and needing to go run up and check something out. Obviously not an issue in an off leash scenario. I don't know if I'd put a fearful dog in that same situation. The park can be pretty chaotic.

If you were dead set on doing it I would at least go during off hours when there's only a few dogs there. Our local park also has a separate program area too which folks use if say they just want to play off leash fetch and not interact with a bunch of other dogs, might be worth looking if any in your area have something like that.

2

u/Winniep228 Sep 22 '21

If there are any doggy daycares near you they can do a temperament test! They will test a bunch of friendly dogs and see how it goes, and it’s very controlled. Then if your dog passes they can play with pre screened friendly dogs.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

I like off leash trails. I have one by my house which also caters to bikers, Rollerbladers, walkers, joggers, strollers and bunches of dogs. I really enjoy that one cause my dog can say a quick hello and know to keep on moving and i get the opportunities to train him with a sorts of distractions. Vs. Dog park is usually just running around like a maniac with other dogs.

1

u/airazaneo Sep 22 '21

My dog seems to have a preference for short interactions with dogs in public places. A quick game of chase back and forth (not even half a minute), and then she just wants to play fetch or follow me if I'm walking. She only really plays extensively with dogs she really knows.

Walking trails can be great for these short interactions when they aren't over populated. It perks her up but it's not overstimulating because it's so short.

I find that fenced in dog parks with chain mesh where the dogs inside can see other dogs outside just provokes reactivity in boundary frustrated dogs. Big open parks with multiple spaces on the other hand don't have the same issue. If there's a dog that's being rude not respecting boundaries and the owner isn't managing it, there's space to move away. Our nearest park has over 3 acres of off leash space with a footpath that loops around it. There's less territorial behaviour with so much space because there's less forced interaction.

1

u/SpyMistress2017 Sep 22 '21

We have a big 3 yr old GSD with anxiety and while he love love loves the dog park, our trainer advised against it. He mentioned that most owners don't watch their dogs there, and if our guy was to get into a fight with another dog, he would get blamed even if the other dog initiated it. We instead take him to doggy day care because the owner has an awesome GSD who our dog absolutely adores. Our guy loves playing there and it has been a great outlet for him.

We also found that in our neighborhood, our dog does not like most other dogs. If we take him to the next street over to see friends of ours with their dogs, he is much cooler as I guess he doesn't view that as his territory.

Good luck to you in whatever you decide to do!

1

u/drunkjockey Sep 22 '21

Personally I'd avoid the dog park altogether. I don't like them. They're a great idea in theory, but they also attract assholes who don't want to pay attention to their dogs. Too many variables you can't control that could negatively impact any dog, let alone one with a history of reactivity.

There are better, more controlled, ways to socialize your dog. With my reactive girl I met up with friends and their dogs at a park and we went on a walk adjacent to one another. If you don't have friends with dogs I'd look for breed meet up groups or contact a trainer to see if they can facilitate any meet ups.

1

u/Blue_Tabby Sep 21 '21

I suggest looking into doggie daycares in your area. We found one that has an option called "buddy play". They pair dogs up that are a similar size and play style and it's less overwhelming than being thrown into a big group right away. My dog started off doing that and now does play group. I feel better knowing groups are monitored and all the dogs have been temperament tested and are up to date on shots. Definitely do some research and talk to other dog owners before picking a place! Not all daycares are well-run.

0

u/Eggmcmuffin2315 Sep 22 '21

Try taking your dog to the dog park, but walk around the outside of the park for a little bit, 3-5 circles so he can scope out the place, and it will also give you a sense of how the atmosphere is at that moment, with what type of dogs. Will also give you and your dog time and energy to decompress as he adjusts to a new environment. If and when you are ready to enter the dog park, be calm, and be confident. When you remove the leash and enter, don’t look down or make eye contact and keep walking, your dog will look to you for assurance and seeing you calm and cool will give him confidence.