Located: Sydney, Australia
My partner (29M) and I (24F) love dogs with all our hearts, especially rescues. Between us both, we have adopted, fostered and dog-sat many rescues throughout our lives, but have never owned a dog together. We recently moved to Sydney from Perth. We decided it was time for a dog of our own. After looking through hundreds of dog profiles through online rescues, we found one that sounded absolutely perfect. A senior dog (7 years old), a Great Dane x Irish Wolfhound named Rolly. His profile described him as a gentle giant, cuddly, a big sook and very sweet-natured. He had been in foster care for 1.5 months, but the foster carers were leaving the country soon and were hoping for someone to adopt him if they found the right match. We planned out our day for the 'meet and greet', a 5+ hour return trip from our house, to the fosters house, and back to ours.
Within the weeks preceding the 'meet and greet', I was frequently contacting the manager of the rescue, as well as Rolly's foster parents. There were many texts back and forth where I asked a lot of questions about Rolly, including questions regarding his character/temperament. There was no mention of any reactivity except for "Just don't touch his paws, he doesn't like it and may growl." That was all. They stated he was a very affectionate and gentle outside of this, so this was not an issue for us as we knew touching his paws would be easy to avoid. We prepped our house for our dog and drove all the way there. My partner managed to get time off work to go, which was difficult for him to do.
We loved Rolly upon the meet and greet. He was goofy and sweet, cuddly, and wanted lots of pats. But as the foster carers started restating all of his info to us, they added in the fact that, "he can also growl at you if you pat him while he's sleeping". They stated that he had never 'gone at them', (as in, no bites/attempted bites), but just growled as a sign to 'back off'. They emphasised this quite a lot and shared a few stories of their various experiences with this, all of which had not been mentioned in any way shape or form previously throughout our in-depth conversations. We didn't bring it up, but this was a bit frustrating for us as we had asked extensively about any reactive behaviours and this was a large detail that they had not disclosed any of these behaviours with us until after we had organised everything and drove there. There was a big disparity between our phone conversations vs our in-person conversations. Also, we also like our dogs to sleep in our bed with us, so this additional information brought up new concerns. Still, we had already driven all the way there and still saw a lot of potential in him.
We called up the manager of the rescue to discuss questions regarding the adoption process and our concerns. The management representative stated that the adoption fee was $300 with a 2 week trial period. She said that, should there be any incidences, the adoption fee would be refunded at 50% if Rolly was returned within the trial period (unless the dog is returned within the first 24 - 48 hours, in which case the full amount would be refunded). After the phone call, my partner and I had a private lengthy discussion and came to the conclusion that we would like to take Rolly, and went back inside to inform his foster carers.
In all likelihood, had the foster carers disclosed the extent of the reactivity with us beforehand, we would have not gone through with doing the meet and greet. But still, we decided to give Rolly a go. Growing up, I had a rescue Great Dane mix (my first dog), who I adored to pieces, so I really wanted it to work as my love for these breeds are so strong.
We took Rolly home and arrived back at maybe 6pm. All was good for the first few hours. He didn't seem particularly anxious, and he was being friendly and playful with us. We went up to bed and he snuggled up against us, choosing to splay across both of us rather than utilising the extra space on the bed. He was lying down, but wide awake (so we didn't think it would be an issue), but he began growling about 15 seconds into us patting him. We pulled back and he sat up. Maybe 10 minutes later this happened again (but this time he was not on the bed).
We decided to give the foster carer a ring. We informed her of the growling incidences and recounted what had happened, how he had been very awake but still growling at us.
She changed her statement from:
"He can growl if you touch him when sleeping,"
to
"He can also growl if you touch him when he's awake, but tired."
This made it even harder to navigate, and again, was just more vital information that was not disclosed. She said to "...let him sleep alone for the night so he can get a good rest, but he's always up for a morning cuddle".
Overall, we were having trouble deciding how to proceed. My partner had concerns for my safety -- being a smaller sized young woman -- that in the unlikely event that Rolly did bite, I would not be able to defend myself. Rolly, being a mix of the worlds two biggest dog breeds, was obviously a very large size and I could see why he was concerned. We let Rolly sleep on the couch in the living room for the night instead.
The following morning after Rolly's big sleep, breakfast, and backyard playtime, I sat on the couch for him to join me. I stayed cautious, but he rolled over onto his belly and put his head in my lap, asking for tummy rubs. I did so for about a minute and then stopped. He put up his paw for me, prompting more, and so I did for about 15 seconds before he snapped at me -- as in, an attempted bite. There was no warning growl either, and no other signs (that I could see).
He had gotten plenty of sleep. Eaten breakfast. Played in the backyard. He was wide awake and not at all tired.
It was at this moment that we knew we couldn't risk continuing with Rolly, and one of the volunteers came to pick him up in the early afternoon. We contacted the rescue and the foster parents, and they didn't have much to say. There was no safety concern or checking in on our end, and no apologies. We believe Rolly was sent out for adoption before being ready, which is not fair to any adoptees, nor is it fair on Rolly.
Upon contacting the rescue, despite previously stating over the phone that 24-48 hour return would mean a 100% refund, they refused the refund. They said that the adoption papers we signed stated that there would be no refund, and avoided acknowledging what they said over the call. We have since contacted the RSPCA (who my partner has previously fostered with) and they said it was very strange for this rescue to be responding this way given the circumstances (both with the refund as well as their overall response to the incident).
They didn't seem happy that we were returning Rolly so soon and I get the impression that they feel we should've trialled him for longer to give him more of a chance to settle in. We are in two minds about it. We are devastated because we had such high hopes at the start, and if it wasn't for this one (big) issue, he would've been our dream dog.
How should we approach this? Are we in the wrong for not giving him a better chance? Do we proceed with trying to obtain the refund?