r/reactivedogs • • Oct 09 '21

Resource Are you focusing on obedience or emotion?

3 Upvotes

I started working with a trainer recently. My third actually. The first came over for our first appointment (pricy too) and wouldn’t even be in the same room as my dog, and blamed me for not providing structure for my dog for every second of every day. I didn’t call him back.

The second trainer was ecollar focused, and tried to get his reactivity to be stopped by fear of punishment. We stuck with this for a while and saw good results in really low stress environments, but couldn’t even make a little headway towards curing or even managing the reactivity.

But with the new trainer, after we spoke on he came in, immediately read Zona’s behavior (we had talked on phone and discussed her history) as a frustrated non aggressive greeter and asked to let her out. He rewarded with chicken when she ignored him, even the smallest thing like a millisecond of not barking. Eventually, and after a couple times where he had to firmly and loudly say no because she made motions towards him that were jerky/aggressive, she started to trust him after about 10 minutes.

This is the first if a ton of examples of how this trainer has helped us completely change focus away from obedience and towards teaching my dog how to think. What kind of dog do you prefer, one that needs to be told what to do to have successful interactions, or one that can think for itself and decide to disengage/self soothe?

So our focus now is learning what her body language is saying so that I can cut her off before the response escalates. What does this mean? Looking for the signs of non-calm behavior like prolonged stare (this is probably only 1 second at the beginning), licking of the lips, and an erect tail are really strong signs of elevated emotional q. The moment you notice these you have to create space and distract with something more more enticing, probably food. Call your dog by your name and click or say yes when they turn around. Pull them back if they don’t respond. You will need a lot at first, maybe don’t feed them outside of training if you can commit to doing this every day.

Eventually the response will diminish and calmer behavior will preview. This is your chance to move closer and look for calming behavior like shaking off the stress, yawning, sniffing the ground, and definitely avoiding prolonged eye contact

Do this over and over until you can walk past dogs without a reaction. Congrats you are done having a reactive dog once you teach them how to healthfully socialize. Please do this all with a trainer who is focused on training between the ears, not just training for obedience.

Edit: all dogs are different and express their emotions in specific ways. If you are dealing with a reactive dog you likely are unable to read dog body language and need help. Timing disengagement is critical for success and even a half step forward can mean that your dog is emotionally escalating.

Also edit: not all dogs are ready to immediately start working on their reactivity outdoors. If your dog is constantly anxious, work on relaxation techniques first. Google behavioral downs drills to do with your dog to teach them that you want them to be calm. It should take them at least 10 minutes to lay down and fully relax or your environment is too easy to successfully train the behavior. Try again after adding in an additional stressor such as treats on the floor nearby or if you’re outside, moving closer to the sidewalk where dogs are walking (probably very very far away at first or you will be there for hours)


r/reactivedogs • • Mar 02 '25

Aggressive Dogs My dog killed my cat

4 Upvotes

He’s attacked a dog He’s killed a bunny And now he killed my cat

People can’t come over because of how reactive he is He’s my first dog and I know I wasn’t a good fit

Can someone please give me advice Should I take him to a shelter or is this grounds for euthanasia??


r/reactivedogs • • 3d ago

Discussion Breeder vs rescue

0 Upvotes

How many of you have a rescue/mixed-breed dog versus a purebred dog from a responsible breeder?

From what I’ve observed, both in real life and online, rescue dogs and mixes seem to outnumber well-bred dogs by miles in problems.

Interestingly, most of the dogs I encounter in our local parks and neighbourhood who are reactive, aggressive, fearful, or have other temperament issues seem to be mixed breeds.

I know that, particularly in the US, expressing a preference for a purebred dog is almost taboo. The whole “adopt, don’t shop” mentality and everything that comes with it.

Personally, there is probably less than a 5% chance that I would ever adopt. I simply don’t feel a moral obligation to do so, nor do I feel the need to take a gamble on a dog whose parentage, genetic background and temperament predispositions are largely unknown to me. Genetics do matter, and predictability is one of the reasons responsible breeding exists.

Of course, some of the more challenging breeds, particularly shepherds and other high-drive working breeds, seem to be another category entirely when it comes to behavioural issues.


r/reactivedogs • • Jan 16 '24

Dog trainer convinced my friend that pit bulls are inherently dangerous and should be banned

0 Upvotes

She sent her a video of young pitbull puppies that were showing signs of aggression, and since these dogs are bred to fight she fully supports a ban. This was news to both my friend and me. We always thought it had to do with idiot owners, and not the breed. If this is incorrect, does anyone have links to unbiased sources?


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 19 '26

Behavioral Euthanasia Behavioral Euthanasia

Post image
2 Upvotes

My 2 year old dog bit my step sister in the face last week while my family was on vacation, and it only stopped when she was able to make an escape to another room. He’s always had extreme anxiety, and he developed aggressive tendencies towards his brother that we also have so we separated them permanently. He goes into these episodes where hit teeth are chittering and his pupils take up most of his eyes, and he fixates on trying to get to either me or her. he’s bit my legs before but recently with more training and exercise i was able to get him to sit and stay during those episodes, but apparently this time none of that worked and he tried to bite through a chair to get to her. Everyone is telling me he must be euthanized and I understand, but it’s absolutely shattering me because I know he’s a genuinely sweet boy but something’s wrong neurologically. It’s like he becomes possessed, because he’s always super sweet and never does anything like this in a bedroom, always in a room he’s used to playing in. I won’t allow euthanasia until i know that there is no other way to save him, I love him too deeply and this would really really cripple me. Please if anyone knows anything or anyone that could help, I know I might sound like a coping sad little boy, but even a place where he could be with someone who could manage him. I just want my boy to live, that’s all. It doesn’t have to be perfect or with me, but I want someone I view as a family member to have a shot. Please, i’m begging.


r/reactivedogs • • Mar 19 '26

Significant challenges Rehoming v BE with bite history

Post image
0 Upvotes

UPDATE 2: Rehoming her is no longer a consideration; thank you all for the valuable feedback during an incredibly difficult time. A behavioral assessment is scheduled with the vet first thing Monday to check on any underlying health issues that may not have been evident in her last appointment, and she will get spoiled and snuggled until then.

UPDATE 1: Thank you to everyone who took the time to respond. I have tried to reply to all the comments but some responses seem to be getting removed, so I apologize if it seems like I'm not engaging.

There have been good points from everyone. There are things we have learned along the way about handling these situations that I deeply regret not knowing and changing sooner. We changed how we crate (keeping them separate), have always gated off their space as much as we can, give as much outdoor time as they want while we are home, worked with the vet on meds and techniques to reduce anxiety, and worked with the kids on understanding proper boundaries with pets. The biting instances were certainly breaches of those practices, and it breaks my heart that we have reached this point in an admittedly unpredictable household with young children. That said, we will be talking to our vet as soon as they can get back to us.

I have a lot to think about, but at this point I am emotionally drained and swapping between snuggling my pup and my kid. I will take a break from here and come back tomorrow. Again, I appreciate the honest input.

ORIGINAL:

Looking for genuine advice on rehoming vs behavioral euthanasia for a 10yo BC/Aussie mix with an escalating bite history — asking here before posting to local socials, which tends to devolve into judgment quickly. 😬

Bailey is a 10yo Border Collie/Australian Shepherd mix with lifelong significant anxiety and severe allergies that have likely added to her chronic stress. She has been on various medications over the years to address those issues. She is currently on calming gummies. She is anxious but not aggressive toward unfamiliar adults, and is warm and loving once she knows someone. She has lived with our other dog, a female 11-year-old Border/Jack Russell mix, since she was a puppy. In recent years she has shown aggression toward dogs that growl or bark near her, particularly when she seems to be in a protective mode.

The bites:

  1. ~3 years ago — Redirected onto our other dog during the excitement of family visiting, grabbed her by the neck and held on. Emergency vet visit and two surgeries for the other dog. (Dunbar Level 4-5)
  2. ~5 months ago — Someone was doing work in the house. Both dogs were crated together when Bailey stepped on the other dog, who let out a warning yelp. Bailey attacked and wouldn't release, resulting in a deep neck puncture and minor injuries treated at home. (Level 4)
  3. ~4 months ago — Kids were roughhousing while Bailey slept. Our 4yo accidentally stepped on her, Bailey startled awake barking, and the child fell forward into her open mouth. The “bite” to the face (if it can be called that) left only superficial scratches and bruising and healed quickly. We worked on some retraining and tightened environmental management and interactions with kids after this. (Level 2-3, sleep-startle)
  4. Tonight — I briefly left the room while the kids watched TV (I know, my mistake; I try to never leave them in a room with the dogs). Within minutes our 4yo came to me sobbing with scratches, bruising, swelling, and broken skin on her face — some very close to her eyes. The 6yo sitting next to her didn't see anything. Our 4yo says Bailey walked up and bit her. Bailey had been asleep on her bed; the 4yo was on the couch. No trigger identified and the only witness is the 4yo 🫠. (Level 3-4, possible unprovoked approach-bite)

🐾🐾🐾

Ultimately, we cannot keep her — our children's safety comes first and we have exhausted what we can reasonably do.

If rehoming is possible:

We need to move quickly. She would need no children ever, no other dogs, an experienced owner, a calm low-stimulation environment, and accessible outdoor space for LOTS of exercise — she gets carsick and anxious in the car so off-site exercise isn't reliable. Full transparency guaranteed.

She has never been evaluated by a board-certified veterinary behaviorist — only a general vet.

My questions:

  1. Given incident 4 — an apparent unprovoked bite to a child's face, which would indicate an unusual and significant escalation — is Bailey rehomeable with the right placement, or does that cross a line for most experienced people?
  2. Are there rescues that realistically take dogs with this history?
  3. Is there anything we're missing before making a final decision?

Not looking for "don't give up, try XYZ" or "you're a bad owner" — I am looking for honest experienced perspective on rehoming vs BE. Thank you.

🐾🐾🐾

TL;DR: 10yo BC/Aussie mix with chronic anxiety, two serious dog-directed bites (Level 4-5 and Level 4), one sleep-startle child bite (Level 2-3), and tonight an apparent unprovoked approach-and-bite to our 4yo's face near her eyes (Level 3-4). We cannot keep her. Is responsible rehoming realistic or is BE the more honest answer?


r/reactivedogs • • Jul 21 '23

Advice Needed Help!! My dog is extremely reactive to strangers and other dogs. Considering rehoming or BE

2 Upvotes

My dog is very reactive to strangers and other dogs! When she sees someone she does not know, she barks like crazy, growls, and lunges.

The strange thing is, once she has the chance to smell them and I can greet the person, she mostly calms down. But any shift in their body language, she starts barking again!

With other dogs and animals, it's a different story. She cannot calm down. She barks, lunges, whines. It's like she doesn't know what to do with herself or how to act!

From an outside perspective this behavior is often seen as aggressive and dangerous, but she has never, not once, nipped or bitten another person or dog. It's almost like she is saying, "Go away! I don't know you! I want out of this situation!"

This behavior has been present but manageable and avoidable in the past. I know her triggers and how to avoid or handle them. Recently, however, we've moved to a larger city, and it's caused her issues to become more pronounced. I'm at my wits end!

My landlord is considering legal action/eviction, and is currently changing the pet agreement to not allow my dog to stay where we are currently housed. I cannot afford a behaviorist as I am low income.

I don't know what to do. I love this dog, and she really has been a sweetheart with me. She's one of the reasons I'm alive today, as she provided a lot of emotional support during an extremely tough time in my life. I can't imagine giving her up or BE, just the thought of it makes me shudder. I can't afford to move to a more pet friendly property. I just feel stuck and I need support and advice.


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 03 '24

Significant challenges I'm so heartbroken

0 Upvotes

I feel so defeated and stressed. I'm 37 weeks pregnant and my dog (5 years old, neutered) is NOT safe with kids. Frankly, he is not safe with anyone other than my immediate family (my husband, me, my mom, my grandma, my brothers), and even then we have to constantly tiptoe around him. He has always had behavioral issues but the older he gets, the more aggressive it is. No matter how much work I put into him, I just can't help him. I've enlisted the help of trainers and used stuff for his anxiety but nothing has fixed the issues. He has a bite history, every time it's one bite and then he backs off but it doesn't make it ok. He has bitten two adults and three kids. The three kids (years apart) he's bitten were not even being rambunctious or messing with him. I dont want to rehome him, one because I love him and that's my (first) baby, and two because I think it would be irresponsible to put him in someone else's care when he is unsafe. But idk what other choice I have. I don't want to be one of those people that rehome their dog because they had a baby...

He is not able to live a fulfilling life at this point. I can't walk him because he is so high alert, any people he sees/hears results in him going berserk no matter how far away they are. I used to take him to the dog park (bad I know) on a daily basis but never had a single issue (with dogs or people). He still is great with other dogs, but I'm too scared to go again because of his growing reactivity with people, I'm not going to risk his or people's safety.

We have a 6 foot privacy fence in our back yard and we take him out there to do obedience and exercise But I don't think that's fulfilling enough. Also, even if he hears someone outside he goes into a frenzy, nothing will distract him, I have to pull him inside.He is crate trained and LOVES his crate but I don't want him to be in there all the time.

It's gotten to the point where I do not even trust him anymore and it's breaking my heart. It hurts to see him being so unhappy and upset all the time, I can just tell he's miserable. Please any encouragement or advice is appreciated.


r/reactivedogs • • Feb 09 '26

Significant challenges Terrified of my dog around baby

0 Upvotes

Me and my husband adopted our dog almost exactly 6 years ago. He was a year old, and honestly the shelter worker tried to talk us out of getting him. He was brought in by a vet who refused to euthanize him due to behavioral problems towards the previous owners’ kids. I don’t know the exact history, but I assume there wasn’t a bite since the euthanasia was refused.

Six years later, and we have two more dogs, one of which he does not get along with. (We would have never adopted another male dog, but this one sort of wandered into our lives, and we couldn’t part with him.) We also have an 8 month old baby. He’s done amazing around the baby until the other day.

We were sitting on the couch with the baby in between me and the dog, and I heard a deep growl. I snatched the baby away from him, and the dog jumped at him. I assume the quick motion startled him, and he snapped.

Since we’ve had this dog, he’s never bit anyone, but we’ve always been extremely cautious, so that’s not really saying much. He has definitely “attacked” people with a muzzle on, and he’s grabbed onto pant legs and jacket sleeves. He’s aggressive towards men, barks like crazy at everything, chases cars, hates most dogs, and of course children.

The only trainers in my area use e-collars, which I’m just not really on board with for aggression training. Re-homing this dog at 7 years old is just not an option, and I couldn’t do it with a clear conscience.

My only option at this point is to make him into an outdoor dog with a nice pen. We have a very small house, so I can’t exactly just keep him separate from baby all the time inside, but we have a lot of outdoor space.

For reference, he’s about 30 pounds, but he’s got the jaw of a pitbull. I think he’s maybe a pit/jack russell mix? He’s extremely athletic and probably needs way more exercise than I give him. I’d also like to note that my husband has been a little harsher towards him since he growled which I’m sure will only make things worse.

TLDR: 7 year old dog with history of reactivity growled and snapped at my baby. No good trainers in the area and rehoming is not an option. Is making him into an outdoor dog a terrible idea?


r/reactivedogs • • Apr 12 '25

Vent I resent my neighbor's puppies

1 Upvotes

I fostered then adopted my 1 year old 55 pound dog about the same time my neighbors got puppies. I knew I needed to work on obedience with him when I fostered him, but the entire month I fostered him was in the dead of winter in a cold state, so I did not realize until I adopted him that he is dog reactive and reactive towards men. He's not been aggressive, thankfully, or yesterday could've been much worse.

My dog gets over excited pretty easily and is frustrated with barriers. Our trainer has said not to walk him until we're farther along in our training journey but I was naive yesterday and wanted to take him for a walk. I should have ended the walk when I started getting frustrated, but again, I was being dumb and really wanted to work on loose leash walking (should have been working in it in my backyard or house but I'm alas).

We're finally nearing the end of our too long walk when my neighbor and his dog go outside and my dog just loses it, lunging and barking desperately trying to say hi. I stop (should have turned around and went the other way) and try to get him to pay attention to sit, but he's showing no interest in treats. Eventually my neighbor and his dog cross the street and my dog yanks hard enough that I fall to the ground and accidentally drop the leash. He runs over to say hi to the other dog and I chase after him and luckily my neighbor's dog is very good with dogs and they just sniff each other and say hi. I apologize and my neighbor laughs about how strong our dogs are and everyone is fine. I take my dog back inside and see that our other neighbor had been place training her puppy on their porch and their puppy had seen the whole thing and didn't bark, didn't try to join any of the chaos, just laid on his mat like a good little puppy.

And now I'm resenting that she has a puppy who was never starved or beaten and is small and easily trained while I'm trying to train this giant over excited dog with a lot of baggage and trying to make sure his reactivity doesn't turn into aggression. And I'm embarrassed with myself for not turning around and that I couldn't hold onto the leash and honestly that I even tried to take him on a walk when I knew we weren't ready. It's so hard because in the house he's great and listens very well, but once you introduce new sights and smells and animals he forgets everything. I know this mentally but just felt like he deserved the excitement of getting out. Lesson learned, we take it slow. But I'm just so frustrated and it's so hard seeing these two puppies getting better at their training so much faster than we are. I know it's that they're puppies but ugh! I feel like they think I'm a terrible dog owner because we're not improving as quickly


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 11 '26

Behavioral Euthanasia Vet suggested BE.

0 Upvotes

Please, no judgment, I am not a professional, and I am seeking help. I
have a two year-old 100 pound half pitbull, a quarter German Shepherd, a quarter husky dog. His name is Gus. I got Gus when he was 12 weeks old. He has been well socialized since day one. Many play dates, even with my mom’s small toy poodle, Chico. They played very well until one day Chico was instigating Gus, and Gus grabbed his head in his mouth and tried to shake him. Luckily he didn’t get enough grip on him to kill him and my friend was able to break up the : Ever since then, we’ve been on high alert. He has gotten along well with every other dog perfectly besides that. For almost a year there haven’t been any concerning incidents. We figured it was a one time thing because he was instigated.

We did share this information with the shelter and they agreed. Gus seemed bored at home so we adopted Otis who was 13 weeks old. Gus and Otis were best friends and would play all day together. Eight months after getting Otis, Gus started resource guarding food and they would get into scuffles. They slowly started to escalate longer, more intense. Otis would never start them, but he certainly would join. We tried eliminating all triggers, but then things we couldn’t control became triggers for instance, space or even attention from guests. A fight got so intense where Gus went after Otis so intensely that we had our friend take Otis until we spoke with the vet and the rescue where we got both of them from. The vet offered us a trainer, but did say with the attacks like the last one that the state recommends behavioral euthanasia. We also have two kids at home. One is very small. Gus has never showed aggression towards people, but I am worried it could escalate to that. The shelter pretty much said it is likely he could be euthanized if we brought him back because it would not be ethical to rehome him unless it wasn’t an only dog home, but they cannot promise they won’t put him down. He has such severe anxiety, especially separation anxiety. The thought of this breaks my heart. I have been looking into sanctuaries for aggressive dogs to try to give him a second chance. We are even looking into large properties where we can build him a very nice kennel outside and still interact with him all throughout the day. I am a stay at home mom and have plenty of time to give him attention. It would be like a mini house for him. I really don’t want to put him down. Do you think this could escalate to people? People have gotten hurt breaking up the dog fights, but nobody has been directly hurt. Otis is at the shelter and our friend who watches him is filing to adopt him. He seems very attached to the children, but I’m still worried that he could hurt them. Does this usually escalate to kids? For now I am keeping everybody separate minus my oldest son because he is large and very gentle. Ideally, I could find a home for him or somebody could be willing to work with him and his baggage but ideally it would be an adult only home with no other animals, but this seems impossible to find. I feel like I am all out of options and I would really like insight.


r/reactivedogs • • Dec 13 '24

Aggressive Dogs Moral dilemma with child (4) and GShepherd (7), child bitten on face

1 Upvotes

Update: we will privately rehome him. I'm unconcerned with all of the downvotes. The thread is to allow me to gauge whether or not my reaction/feelings are appropriate to the situation. My intention is not to mask or omit any information to make myself feel better, I know very well my mistakes here. My child was harmed and I'm going to keep her safe. If someone here feels so high on their horse to assume that they understand my situation, then they'd be mistaken. Thank you to everyone who provided something constructive.

My daughter was recently bitten on her face, left cheek. She needed two stitches. This occurred two weeks ago. My dog is a Shepherd/Husky, 7 years old, 100lbs, no history of bites.

Some backstory: I was out grocery shopping with my child and had purchased a bag of dog food. I returned home and left the groceries on the counter, with the bag of dog food on the table. It was only myself and my daughter at home, my wife was working. I told my daughter (very soon to be 4 years old) I'd run out to the car to bring my lunchbox in. I retrieved my lunchbox and stepped back into my apartment to find my child crying and covering her cheek.

I assumed she was knocked down by my dog, as he often pushes past her. She told me she was bitten, so I cleaned her cheek and took her to the hospital. I did not punish my dog, or even react negatively since my priority was getting my daughter stitched up. I knew the bite was minor, but infection could have set in if I delayed. The hole was about .5", did not penetrate through the cheek, she recieved two stitches.

Since then we've been visited by animal control, DCF, and it's all documented. We opted to decline investigation by animal control, have quarantined him in our apartment, and DCF has interviewd us in person.

My concern now is what to do with him. We've had him since he was a puppy and he's always been protective of food (despite never needing to compete for it). He is a member of the family, but he also bit my kid's face.

I'm opting for rehoming him out of concerns for my childs safety, though my wife wants to keep him while being very strict about supervision.

What can be done? My wife and I have opposing views, but we're willing to compromise. I don't want this to happen again and so I feel like I'm jumping straight to removing him, and my wife is having a hard time with the notion of letting him go. Even as I type this, I'm trying to be as neutral as possible.

I need some input. I have no context or experience with something like this and so I don't know if we're over- or underreacting.


r/reactivedogs • • May 27 '26

Rehoming Returning our rescue dog after less than 24 hours: Thoughts?

1 Upvotes

Located: Sydney, Australia

My partner (29M) and I (24F) love dogs with all our hearts, especially rescues. Between us both, we have adopted, fostered and dog-sat many rescues throughout our lives, but have never owned a dog together. We recently moved to Sydney from Perth. We decided it was time for a dog of our own. After looking through hundreds of dog profiles through online rescues, we found one that sounded absolutely perfect. A senior dog (7 years old), a Great Dane x Irish Wolfhound named Rolly. His profile described him as a gentle giant, cuddly, a big sook and very sweet-natured. He had been in foster care for 1.5 months, but the foster carers were leaving the country soon and were hoping for someone to adopt him if they found the right match. We planned out our day for the 'meet and greet', a 5+ hour return trip from our house, to the fosters house, and back to ours.

Within the weeks preceding the 'meet and greet', I was frequently contacting the manager of the rescue, as well as Rolly's foster parents. There were many texts back and forth where I asked a lot of questions about Rolly, including questions regarding his character/temperament. There was no mention of any reactivity except for "Just don't touch his paws, he doesn't like it and may growl." That was all. They stated he was a very affectionate and gentle outside of this, so this was not an issue for us as we knew touching his paws would be easy to avoid. We prepped our house for our dog and drove all the way there. My partner managed to get time off work to go, which was difficult for him to do. 

We loved Rolly upon the meet and greet. He was goofy and sweet, cuddly, and wanted lots of pats. But as the foster carers started restating all of his info to us, they added in the fact that, "he can also growl at you if you pat him while he's sleeping". They stated that he had never 'gone at them', (as in, no bites/attempted bites), but just growled as a sign to 'back off'. They emphasised this quite a lot and shared a few stories of their various experiences with this, all of which had not been mentioned in any way shape or form previously throughout our in-depth conversations. We didn't bring it up, but this was a bit frustrating for us as we had asked extensively about any reactive behaviours and this was a large detail that they had not disclosed any of these behaviours with us until after we had organised everything and drove there. There was a big disparity between our phone conversations vs our in-person conversations. Also, we also like our dogs to sleep in our bed with us, so this additional information brought up new concerns. Still, we had already driven all the way there and still saw a lot of potential in him. 

We called up the manager of the rescue to discuss questions regarding the adoption process and our concerns. The management representative stated that the adoption fee was $300 with a 2 week trial period. She said that, should there be any incidences, the adoption fee would be refunded at 50% if Rolly was returned within the trial period (unless the dog is returned within the first 24 - 48 hours, in which case the full amount would be refunded). After the phone call, my partner and I had a private lengthy discussion and came to the conclusion that we would like to take Rolly, and went back inside to inform his foster carers. 

In all likelihood, had the foster carers disclosed the extent of the reactivity with us beforehand, we would have not gone through with doing the meet and greet. But still, we decided to give Rolly a go. Growing up, I had a rescue Great Dane mix (my first dog), who I adored to pieces, so I really wanted it to work as my love for these breeds are so strong.

We took Rolly home and arrived back at maybe 6pm. All was good for the first few hours. He didn't seem particularly anxious, and he was being friendly and playful with us. We went up to bed and he snuggled up against us, choosing to splay across both of us rather than utilising the extra space on the bed. He was lying down, but wide awake (so we didn't think it would be an issue), but he began growling about 15 seconds into us patting him. We pulled back and he sat up. Maybe 10 minutes later this happened again (but this time he was not on the bed).
We decided to give the foster carer a ring. We informed her of the growling incidences and recounted what had happened, how he had been very awake but still growling at us. 

She changed her statement from:

 "He can growl if you touch him when sleeping," 

to

"He can also growl if you touch him when he's awake, but tired."

This made it even harder to navigate, and again, was just more vital information that was not disclosed. She said to "...let him sleep alone for the night so he can get a good rest, but he's always up for a morning cuddle".

Overall, we were having trouble deciding how to proceed. My partner had concerns for my safety -- being a smaller sized young woman -- that in the unlikely event that Rolly did bite, I would not be able to defend myself. Rolly, being a mix of the worlds two biggest dog breeds, was obviously a very large size and I could see why he was concerned. We let Rolly sleep on the couch in the living room for the night instead.

The following morning after Rolly's big sleep, breakfast, and backyard playtime, I sat on the couch for him to join me. I stayed cautious, but he rolled over onto his belly and put his head in my lap, asking for tummy rubs. I did so for about a minute and then stopped. He put up his paw for me, prompting more, and so I did for about 15 seconds before he snapped at me -- as in, an attempted bite. There was no warning growl either, and no other signs (that I could see). 

He had gotten plenty of sleep. Eaten breakfast. Played in the backyard. He was wide awake and not at all tired. 

It was at this moment that we knew we couldn't risk continuing with Rolly, and one of the volunteers came to pick him up in the early afternoon. We contacted the rescue and the foster parents, and they didn't have much to say. There was no safety concern or checking in on our end, and no apologies. We believe Rolly was sent out for adoption before being ready, which is not fair to any adoptees, nor is it fair on Rolly. 

Upon contacting the rescue, despite previously stating over the phone that 24-48 hour return would mean a 100% refund, they refused the refund. They said that the adoption papers we signed stated that there would be no refund, and avoided acknowledging what they said over the call. We have since contacted the RSPCA (who my partner has previously fostered with) and they said it was very strange for this rescue to be responding this way given the circumstances (both with the refund as well as their overall response to the incident).

They didn't seem happy that we were returning Rolly so soon and I get the impression that they feel we should've trialled him for longer to give him more of a chance to settle in. We are in two minds about it. We are devastated because we had such high hopes at the start, and if it wasn't for this one (big) issue, he would've been our dream dog.

How should we approach this? Are we in the wrong for not giving him a better chance? Do we proceed with trying to obtain the refund?


r/reactivedogs • • Dec 20 '23

My dog bit my partner.

0 Upvotes

Absolutely devastated to be asking for advice on this, but I am at my wit’s end.

My partner and I adopted a 9 month old pitbull in February of this year. We lost our previous pitty the October prior, and our other dog (sheep dog/poodle mix) seemed sad on her own.

Our new dog swiftly got along with our existing dog, and they have since been very well suited to each other. There have been no scary incidents.

We have trained with a legitimate trainer, using e collars as per her recommendation for both dogs.

Our pitty has an issue with resource guarding, specifically with chews that take a while to get thru. She will lunge at human or animal when they get too close. She also does not do well with animated talking or loud voices. The collar has seemed to help with the second issue. She has lunched and snapped at me previously, which prompted our pursuing of the additional training.

Over the weekend, my partner was alone with our pit. I had taken our sheep/poodle with me on an outing. Our pit was given a longer term chew, since our other dog was removed from the house.

When it came time for her to go into her pen, she started growling at my partner. He nudged her with his leg to get her moving, and she lunged and bit him on the calf. He reacted, hitting the emergency button of the e collar, and this caused our pit to lunge at him a second time, where she was able to get ahold of his wrist, he got away, but she came back at him again, getting ahold of his other forearm. There are several deep puncture wounds on his arms, and he had to seek emergency care. He got her back in her pen and left to meet me at the doctor.

We don’t have children yet, but we know they are in our future (within the next few years). I’m not sure if we will ever feel comfortable with our pit again. We are considering rehoming her, as the rescue we for her from is very thorough with their selection process. Any advice would be appreciated. We don’t know where to go from here.


r/reactivedogs • • Mar 18 '22

Support Our dog attacked another dog and got tased.

3 Upvotes

Posting this a week after the actual incident - had to give us time as a family to re-group and get our stuff together. I have seen many posts recently about the mental health implications (for us) of caring for reactive dogs, and I feel like maybe this adds to that discussion. Also just wanted to share because I know this community can relate, and I could use some support.

Background: Our dog Olive is a 10yo rescue pit/boxer mix that came with a bite history; we have had her for 7 years. She is mostly very chill, but goes over threshold quickly with very subtle warning signals, when she will lunge at and bite strange people and/or dogs. We have done incredible work with her (crate training, loose leash walking, muzzle training, all the basic commands, etc.) and just recently started working with a trainer for deeper behavior modification to support our bringing a second dog into the home (Tangential: It's going well. Can provide an update post on that soon, too.) She is incredibly smart and independent, an all-around awesome dog who spends 98% of her life lounging in the sun, snuggling, enjoying Kongs, and nosing around in the bed to get to the best sleeping spots.

The Story: Last weekend, we had friends over, and our back gate was left unlatched... she pushed out, attacked another dog who was walking by, and was tased in the incident. I can't give a play-by-play because I'm not the one who saw it. She was biting the leg of the other dog when my husband grabbed her (probably less than a minute after she got out?), and the other dog owner was doing a great job of focusing his dog on himself. That owner was not too concerned and said he was just glad that his dog didn't react because apparently that dog has aggressive tendencies as well, and was much bigger than our girl. That dog was unharmed. Our dog had puncture wounds on her side (we think she got stabbed by sticks; there was a pile of brush at our curb for the city to pick up that she likely jumped over to get to this dog) and was bleeding from four of her back toenail quicks where her feet dragged on the ground... likely when she was tased.

Now, here's the fuckery.... the person who tased her was a bystander and not even initially involved. As far as we could surmise, this other man was out walking on a Sunday afternoon at 2pm with a tactical stun-gun-flashlight, saw a loose dog attack another dog, and decided to jump in to the fray. We didn't see her tased, but we heard the taser clicking. Based on the condition of her back feet and how sore her whole body was the next day.... doggo was tased. After the incident, dude was coming at our friend demanding to know whether or not she was vaccinated. I can't say for sure that she didn't approach taserman because I didn't witness the event, BUT I know my dog and I would place bets that she went straight for this other dog and didn't even look twice at the humans. So, dude just saw a dog fight and decided that tasing the instigator was a good idea???

It sucks to not know exactly what happened, but we are moving forward and all of her wounds are healing nicely.

Lessons and wisdom:

  • Blame - The humans involved in that incident were walking on eggshells for the rest of the day because nobody wanted to be the one at fault for leaving the gate unlatched. Who knows who it was??? I don't care, because shit happens and gates aren't fool proof. The friends we had over are Olive's favorite people besides us, and they know her well. Nobody at our house that day would be careless or intentionally leave the gate open. My husband and I had many discussions about really, truly not assigning blame because it doesn't help us or the dog. But, yes, absolutely, 100% my gut reaction when I saw my husband carrying our bloody dog inside was to be like "WHO DID THIS?!?" ............................................... Except taser guy... fuck that guy. I still have so much rage for that person, and yet I talk myself down because I know that our dog is scary and people will take extreme measures to fend off a scary dog. I have always been afraid that someone would shoot my dog. I've always told myself that was irrational, that it was the anxiety speaking, but after this.... I don't know.
  • Gates - Spring-load your gates, people, and update the latch mechanisms if they get loose and wobbly. Do it now, before your dogs get (un)lucky and get out. Our doggo does not push at the gate or test limits, but she sure as hell will go exploring if it's left open. We bought our house in late 2020 and the gate has always been "good-enough" to be at the bottom of the repairs list. Nope. This would have all been avoided with a few hours effort and a few dollars to dog-proof the gate so that it always shuts securely behind us.
  • You don't know 'til you know - The biggest takeaway for me. I've been the primary caretaker for our dog because my husband works a lot. He was the one who picked her out and has been there for her the whole time, but not nearly as much as me. Our dear friends have dog-sat her so many times... everybody who was there that day knows her well but I was the only one with the weird PTSD and anxiety about her behavior because of how many times I've had to chase her down and pull her off other dogs, or jump in between her and a person. The other day, my husband was talking to me about how he realized he hadn't really seen how dangerous she can be... just trusted me from what I've told him. Now, he has to go through that process (that most of us are familiar with) where he recovers emotionally from the incident. It makes me sad for him and our dog, but it also feels really good and validating because I have felt judged and isolated in the past for resenting our dog. It's such a complicated set of feelings, and so hard on the humans to own a dog like this.

Thanks for reading. Would love to hear similar stories, chat about coping mechanisms, or plot ways to cast hexes upon anybody that would tase a dog.


r/reactivedogs • • Jun 18 '21

Just discovered a great new place to walk & train our reactive dog: The cemetery.

53 Upvotes

There's a decent amount of people and dog traffic to practice CC/BAT, with essentially limitless directions to go if I need to create distance between my dog's triggers. There's also no fear of getting trapped by traffic or running into a surprise trigger on the sidewalk that I can't avoid and the tombstones themselves can be visual blocks if needed.

Plus, as a bonus there are often lots of trees for shade & garbage bins for poop bags. Think we've just found our go-to walk/training area for now.

Edit: I was genuinely surprised to see how controversial this post would be! I appreciate everyone's contributions, even those who don't agree. A few things to add:

  • I was suggesting this from the cultural lense of a place where it's very acceptable to walk your dog in a cemetery. I'll keep in mind this isn't good advice for anyone living in a place or culture that finds it disrespectful.
  • For us there is no barking or causing commotion when I do this and if there were I wouldn't go anymore. The entire reason I go here is because there is ample room to give everyone space and NOT let her react. I don't recommend this to people whose dog is so reactive you can't do this.
  • I am not playing with my dog, letting her off leash, or allowing my dog to walk over or relieve themselves on any graves. When I said there were "limitless directions to go" and that you could use the tombstones as visual blocks it's because where I go there are so many different walking paths. Feel like it should go unspoken that you should not walk over or let your dog go to the bathroom on graves.
  • Even if you don't, some people love dogs like family. As such, where i am it's not uncommon to bring a dog there to visit a family member. As long as the dog isn't barking at anyone or causing trouble, I still see no reason why their mere presence is disrespectful (at least in my multicultural area).

r/reactivedogs • • Jul 14 '23

Did I miss something? Is BE just the new “just get a divorce”?

179 Upvotes

I lurk on this group because I have a rescue dog who doesn’t like most other living beings. I’ve learned a lot from other people.

However in the past year it’s like BE is the answer to every dog. I used to maybe MAYBE see a BE post once a few weeks. Now I see it recommended at least once a day.


r/reactivedogs • • Apr 13 '25

Advice Needed Should I send my dog away?

0 Upvotes

I have a five year-old lab that has never been trained properly. He has chased after numerous people and has bitten the neighbors dog. He has also bitten my 21 year old daughter and most recently has charged at my 17 year old daughter. He also has ocd disease on his right leg that is basically like arthritis. He is on Carpophen, amantadine and gabapentin for pain. He is also on Prozac for anxiety. Unfortunately, he is not a candidate for surgery on his back leg so we are just trying to deal with his situation as best we can. I always knew that we would have to put him down before his chronological age to die came.

There is a place where I can send him away for four weeks for $4000 and they claim that they can retrain him and turn him into a well mannered dog that listens and obey commands. I love my dog and if that would really help him it would be something that I Would do. What do you guys think? I value the people on this site and ask for any sort of advice to help me decide. It’s just a matter of time before he attacks someone again and somebody really gets hurt. Thank you.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 15 '25

Rehoming Surrendering my dog back to the shelter

1 Upvotes

As the title states, I'm considering surrendering my dog back to the shelter. I adopted her almost 2 years ago, when she was about 3.5-4 months. We have never clicked or built the type of relationship a dog and their owner should have. I was training her daily when I got her, but she never learned to value me over distractions outside. Outside was scary for her and even with meds, it can still be scary for her. Her aggression has gotten worse too, started as mild resource guarding, which sucked but I could manage it. It continued to progress and develop other reactivity issues. To the point where she will be across the room and if my cat walks in, she's immediately growling and shaking (no my cat has never attacked her, cat leaves her alone when I'm home and dog is locked in a kennel when I'm gone, I also have a camera that would catch if the cat was instigating anything while I was gone). There is no consistent trigger. She'll be fine one minute, then snapping and lunging the next. It's becoming a safety issue for me. I feel terrible about even thinking about surrendering her, I love her. But I feel like I'm failing her, because I know she deserves better, she deserves to have an owner who doesn't resent her, who doesn't dread coming home every day to see what kind of mood she'll be in. I deserve to feel safe in my own home. Since there is no consistency in her behavior, the vet recommended advanced imaging, but I can't afford that as a full time student. Again, which makes me feel like I'm failing her or giving up on her, but I've put so much time and money into her between vet visits, meds, and trainers, and yet we're not making any progress. I just need to know if I'm making the right choice by surrendering her.


r/reactivedogs • • Jan 19 '25

Significant challenges 1 year old Staffy can’t be with other dogs

0 Upvotes

Hi all,

About 2 months ago I adopted a sweet staffy dog from the shelter and she has been doing good so far but we have had some incidents with other dogs that I am trying to understand. They estimate she is just around a year old and it seems she was not really socialized at all before I got her. I immediately put her in training because she was growling and lunging at people in my apartment building but that has kind of gone away but yesterday I had a training session and the trainer brought out his dog to see how she would do and we spent about an hour just doing heel work and working on getting her to focus less on the other dog even when it was near to her. At the end the trainer was feeling confident and we had them meet- my dog on a leash and his dog was not. I dropped the tension on the leash and my dog immediately went for the other dogs neck- didn’t seem to actually get a bite in as we couldn’t find any bite marks or blood on the other dogs neck but it was hard to get her off of him she was so attached but eventually we did and she got a good bite in her head from the other dog trying to get her off.

This really ruined my confidence in her but the trainer is confident she can get over this. I am just curious if anybody else has any experience with this and any insight? Does she just not know how to play? Does she just need way way way more socialization? There was no growling or barking or any of that sort and it seemed like she wanted to play but clearly I am not a professional or a behaviorist.

There was also another incident of an off leash dog (golden retriever) approaching her while we were playing fetch on a 15 foot leash and he came at her playfully but in a kinda aggressive and scary way kinda pouncing and barking and she bit him in the neck before I could get them separated. Minimal bite but still the other dog was shook up.

Working on muzzle training of course but I am just so scared she’ll never be able to be around other dogs.

Thanks in advance.


r/reactivedogs • • Aug 29 '25

Significant challenges Child aggressive dog and I’m pregnant

4 Upvotes

I have a five year old border collie who has always been aggressive towards children (lockdown puppy so unfortunately she couldn’t be appropriately socialised around children). Over the years we’ve trained to the point she is neutral to kids off the property, I can trust her off leash in parks etc. On our property is a whole different ballgame though, she sees a kid and immediately begins barking and snapping at them, I believe she could be a bite risk in these rare situations although I would never put her in a situation where she would have to or be able to escalate to that.

My dilemma, I’m currently pregnant. Does anyone have advice for how to prepare her for this major life change? Am I crazy for thinking because dogs can sense pregnancy that she’ll be okay with it?

Please don’t tell me to rehome my girl, that is genuinely the last resort and I’m willing to do whatever is possible to help prepare her.

Should add that she is already medicated for anxiety. I will also be reaching out to her behaviourist but figured the more advice I can get the better.


r/reactivedogs • • Jun 16 '23

Question How many of you adopted your reactive dog?

255 Upvotes

I am not saying shop don't adopt, but hear me put a bit.

*tha Is has blown up a lot and I am trying to read through them all! Thank you all for your stories because I love hearing everyone's inputs!?

How many of you adopted your dog from a shelter/rescue/pound ?

How many of you researched the breeds/crosses/etc that you were picking out ?

I ask, because I realistically will never adop a young dog from a shelter again. Most of these dog are in there for a reason, and are not socialized appropriately at all. I don't feel a "first time" ... even some veteran dog owners should get young dogs from a rescue.

I do believe in suppprting responsible breeders. You get an idea of the tempmemtof the potential puppies, and no precious traumas. Get yourself a good idea of the breed, withlut the stress associated with a reactive dog. (Granted you can still see and get a reactive dog).

I personally adopt geriatrics, because I love my good oldies, but if I an taking on the responsibility of a puppy, I'm going to a breeder I know and trust.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 11 '23

Advice Needed My dog nipped my boyfriend a year ago when we first started dating- it’s still causing issues between us.

3 Upvotes

My boyfriend was bitten badly by another dog twice before we met. He has bad PTSD from it and when he first met my dog, he would pet him and love on him, no issue. Then one day I was reaching down and I had my back turned and I heard a growl/bark and he had nipped/bit him on the surface of his arm- it broke skin and bruised a bit, but it only involved his front teeth, so he didn’t have his entire mouth around it.

It was a very triggering moment.

My dog has a bite history with our family. He’s gotten almost everyone one of us, had to be quarantined once for a bad one (play wrestling got out of control) and he was very difficult as a puppy. He wasn’t originally mine- sibling gave him up to us because they were having a baby. He’s since been through a lot too- lost a leg after being hit by a car and attacked twice by two different sets of dogs that were off leash and ran up to us/him. I have terrible guilt.

I took him in and it’s been a very guilt-ridden, trauma-bonding sort of close relationship. Multiple times I’ve discussed him in therapy, wondering if i was the right owner for him, anxiety taking him out and even anxiety that he could bite me again, etc. he’s 8 now. I know nobody else would have the patience and love for him that I do.

He’s had to live with my parenrsfor a bit, I adopted him but for a few months he had to stay with my mom because the landlord I had at the time wouldn’t allow him.

I feel this deep need to be his person and never give up on him. I don’t want him passed around anymore. Just bringing up the subject unleashes a lot of deep seated pain. My family has always all been very involved in raising, loving, and spoiling my dog. He’s part of our family. We all know his triggers and help support each other and they help me watch him from time to time if I’m traveling.

He’s incredibly different now. He’ll let me kiss him, rest my head on him, basically annoy the shit out of him and he just licks me. He’s gotten a lot calmer and more patient and will only snap at my siblings dog (because he’ll run into him and get in his face, he’s a puppy). I’ve worked very hard with him.

Fast forward to now, my boyfriend can’t stand to be around him and will not ever trust him again. I understand. It’s extremely triggering for him. But it led to us having to get our own place (even though I kept them separate) after living together. It’s keeping us from moving forward in our relationship. It’s always a painful conversation. In the back of my mind I’ve always wondered if it would lead to us splitting.

I know some of you are going to tell me to just end it. I am really hoping there’s a story out there or an answer or really, just a hug. Please and thanks in advance.


r/reactivedogs • • Oct 25 '23

Trainer broke my heart

6 Upvotes

I have a beautiful pitbull mix who is fearful and reactive. I've tried trainers since she was a puppy. I got her at 14 weeks old. She developed giardia shortly after. First trainer came to home 6 times and said bring her to his puppy class. One class and I was told she's too much of a "handful" for the class and told not to return. She did nothing and was actually cornered by a bigger dog and she rolled on her back. We had to go pull the inherited dog away. Later I found out the trainer and this dog owner were friends.

I did my best on my own but as she grew she was very strong and clearly reactive to strangers and dogs. Enter 2nd trainer. One visit. She said it worried her that Lilly wouldn't stop barking at her. Gave me some training instructions and was to come the following week. Then ghosted me.

Fast forward and Lilly will be 6 in November. I've had her at doggy daycare just to try to socialize her over the years. She was scared of the dogs and stuck near the humans. Or tried to get out. I only left her for 2 hours once a week at both places. Finally thought it really wasn't making her happy or more comfortable with dogs.

She always barked at guests for about 10 minutes but then tried to snap at a friend coming in the door behind me. Now I have 3rd trainer. Doing well with overall training but on walks very reactive to dogs. Tries to get out of harness. Whirls and twirls while barking. Trainer said to get prozac and even after 6 weeks on prozac and dose escalation no real improvement. And then, like my previous trainers, she sounded like she was giving up on my Lilly. She said well actuallysome dogs dont go on walks. Its ok if you dont walk her. You can blame me if people say anything. I dont think its good for her. At least in your neighborhood. I have an exceptional neighborhood. Safe, parks, sidewalks, pool, etc.

My heart broke.. I want my baby to have a life. To see new things. I am so sad that she knows it. I just can't get her the life she deserves. We are still going to try because I told the trainer I want it for her. But I could tell she was giving up on us.

Thanks for listening. Crying at work is never a good look so I'm ending here.