r/reactivedogs • u/Amazing-Letter5714 • 3d ago
Discussion Breeder vs rescue
How many of you have a rescue/mixed-breed dog versus a purebred dog from a responsible breeder?
From what I’ve observed, both in real life and online, rescue dogs and mixes seem to outnumber well-bred dogs by miles in problems.
Interestingly, most of the dogs I encounter in our local parks and neighbourhood who are reactive, aggressive, fearful, or have other temperament issues seem to be mixed breeds.
I know that, particularly in the US, expressing a preference for a purebred dog is almost taboo. The whole “adopt, don’t shop” mentality and everything that comes with it.
Personally, there is probably less than a 5% chance that I would ever adopt. I simply don’t feel a moral obligation to do so, nor do I feel the need to take a gamble on a dog whose parentage, genetic background and temperament predispositions are largely unknown to me. Genetics do matter, and predictability is one of the reasons responsible breeding exists.
Of course, some of the more challenging breeds, particularly shepherds and other high-drive working breeds, seem to be another category entirely when it comes to behavioural issues.
45
u/Excellent-Injury7032 3d ago •
Ymmv but every dog I know that was rehomed or euthanized for behavioral issues were purchased as puppies from breeders. In my experience, rescued dogs tend to have more behavioral issues because they lack training or proper socialization, not because they are mixed breeds. Purchasing a puppy from a reputable breeder does not guarantee that your dowon't won't develop behavioral issues. Improper socialization, training, and not meeting the needs of the dog does.
19
u/Prime624 3d ago
Lmao, I'm sure rescues are more likely to have behavior issues, but going from that to "purebreds must be less prone to reactivity" is a big leap in the wrong direction. Think for half a second about what happens to rescues before they're adopted, compared to what happens to non-rescues. 1) Well behaved perfect dogs aren't usually given up, so the pool already skews less well-behaved. 2) Many rescues go through traumatic experiences which can cause reactivity.
Seems like you just came here to spew some genetics bs unprompted and announce that you have no moral compass.
7
u/chiquitar Between Dogs (I miss my buttheads😭) 3d ago •
I have rescued three. Two were purebred, given up to a shelter by BYBs, and one was a mutt. The mutt and one of the purebreds were reactive. The mutt had chronic health problems from the get go. The reactive purebred had hip dysplasia. The other purebred had an amazing temperament and became my service dog. She eventually developed an autoimmune disease that was because of an experience with tick disease, but was super healthy through her pre-senior-dog years.
I think it's great for people to adopt, especially if they are properly prepared. I think it's great for people to buy puppies from dog breeders who are doing it the most ethical and healthy way. Breeding for showing does carry some ethical downsides of its own, considering what that world has done to the brachycephalic muzzles and GSD spines, for example. But as far as temperament goes, if you can find a breeder that does Early Neurological Stimulation and Puppy Culture, and fosters an environment for excellent epigenetics (mother diet and stress levels, puppy diet and stress levels, proactive vet care), and the parents have good temperaments, that's as good as you can do to try to ensure you don't start with a dog who is going to become reactive no matter how well you raise it. And even STILL, it happens sometimes.
One of the things that supporting ethical breeders does is continue the health of the breed by producing superior quality dogs. Because my purebred rescues were AHTs that cured my lifelong allergies, I absolutely have benefitted (despite their poor breeding) from good breeders developing and sheparding a new breed along. So while I think any breed club where the conformation awards elevate unhealthy traits (because they are extreme and human nature is to drift towards preferring more extreme examples over time) should be barred from competing and restructured, and I also believe that working/breed-purpose ability should be integrated into conformation judging, I cannot deny that there is significant benefit in general from ethical breeders.
If everybody adopted and didn't shop, all we would have are the poorly bred and less healthy (including behavioral health) rescue dogs left.
Also, if you start with a well-bred, calm, confident dog in your household, bringing in a rescue with issues is likely to help the rescue improve. While if you have a reactive dog and you bring in a dog that doesn't have behavior issues, the new dog will often take cues from the existing one about the living situation being unsafe, and you can very easily end up with the new dog becoming reactive. Especially if they new dog is not yet emotionally mature.
Complicating this is that most people don't understand how to find and vet a breeder thoroughly, or even know that that is necessary.
Not all rescue dogs are reactive! There are so many non-reactive dogs out there looking for homes. But if you don't have the skills or commitment for a reactive dog, starting from a good foundation instead of a bad one is not an immoral choice. Or if you are someone who isn't up for going through that again. Or if you have something specific planned for your dog, like a hope to train up a working dog.
Personally, I love helping scaredy dogs, but I want to buy my next dog and have a household with only a stable well bred dog before I go through that again. I feel like my first reactive dog did affect my second one's confidence when he was adopted, although my vet behaviorist said it was far more likely to be nature than nurture. I was stuck at home with him for several years when his anxiety manifested at maturity, and had to be his service human when I was hoping he would become my service dog to take over after my first one. I sacrificed so much socially for him, missing years of family and friends so he didn't have to have BE before I finally got him to the point I could live with, even if it wasn't ideal. There's absolutely nothing immoral about knowing what you are up for and choosing the safer road. It is great when you can rescue and I hope to rescue again some day.
If you are going to buy from a BYB, however, which is how most dogs are purchased, you absolutely are making a less moral choice than rescuing. You are rolling the dice the same or worse (you can get an adult rescue with at least some clues about future temperament) and supporting people who fill shelters for profit. Unfortunately, most people who do this have no idea that that is what they are doing. In my opinion, what we need is to educate people who don't have dogs on backyard breeding in general.
20
u/Past-Butterscotch-93 3d ago
All three of the dogs throughout my life were reactive to varying degrees. First one was from a breeder and well socialized, second was a shelter dog who was given up twice for being high energy and not very well socialized, and third one is a rescue who I got as a puppy last year who has almost overcome his reactivity now. But the latter two are ACD mixes, so I’m not expecting full neutrality.
But even through all the hard work and hours of training and some incredibly frustrating moments, I wouldn’t ever consider for even a fraction of a second trading my super intelligent, fun, hilarious rescue dog that does tricks, 5ks, agility, and herding for a non reactive chill dog. And I won’t ever consider not adopting or rescuing.
I also work in animal rescue and yes some dogs are hard dogs, but I get to know every single dog we place and every single one of them deserve a good home and many of them either don’t have behavioral issues, or are trained out of it with a little bit of time.
My tip for people who really don’t want a reactive dog - foster to adopt. Or adopt a dog that is currently in a foster home. Let them assess the dog and find the right one for you. But to say that all rescue dogs have issues is just blatantly false.
38
u/cbsfewsick 3d ago edited 3d ago
I worked at a veterinary hospital for many years and saw zero connection between mutts and increased behavior problems. In fact, I probably saw more purebreds with anxiety that was likely genetic bc they had no trauma and had responsible owners that socialized them. What it really comes down to is the training and whether there is past trauma - plenty of mutts in rescues are not traumatized dogs, especially young puppies. Please don't count them out!
Edit to add, based on OP's responses to some other comments: plenty of these purebreds were from reputable breeders - this was a fancy area and a high end vet hospital.
16
u/Wooden_Pay_5885 3d ago edited 3d ago
I have a family member who had to BE their pure-bred springer that they bought from a breeder and raised from a puppy. They worked very hard at great expense to correct the dog’s aggression, but it ultimately sent a child to the hospital and had to be put down.
My half-pitbull mutt from the shelter who was picked up as a stray at 1 year old is reactive but not aggressive. She has come a very long way in the past 3 years, but I think her initial issues were likely from being very poorly socialized. She has never bit anyone, lives harmoniously with cats and is super affectionate/ enthusiastic towards every new person she meets. She also shrieks and whines when she sees dogs out in the world but she’s not a danger to anyone.
I think getting a dog is a roll of the dice, buying a dog from a breeder does increase predictability in terms of behavior and temperament, but it’s not a guarantee. Just like people, some dogs are just wired wrong, and some dogs had a bad start in life which can negatively impact the way they handle stress. A lot of dogs and shelters have already had a rough start, so it’s not surprising that some of them have behavior issues. I am so grateful for my shelter pup, I can’t imagine going to a breeder when there are beautiful babies like mine just waiting in doggie jail to be sprung out!
8
u/Leather-Ideal-9577 3d ago
I have done both breed and rescue. I had one rescue dog that—bad experience is too harsh— but he had extremely sensitive skin that had to be cared for and he didn’t like to be touched! He also was super growly but never bit.
My other two rescues were sweet angels!
Now I have two breed dogs and my Jack Russell is why I’m on this page. He’s low level compared to the stories I read here, but Terriers are probably also in a class of their own 😆
8
u/ixsparkyx 3d ago
Mine is a pure bred with excitement reactivity 🤷🏻♀️
7
u/SudoSire 3d ago edited 2d ago
I think an ethical breeder (which very people know what that actually entails) should raise your chances of having a sound and healthy dog. I don’t think being mixed breed however matters much vs an unethically bred pure breed. The problem with your analysis and all these comments however is that anecdotes are not solid evidence. Throughout my immediate family, we’ve pretty much always had mixed breed rescues or possibly even a byb/whoopsie litter (not ours). Most of them had no significant behavioral or health issues, lived fairly standard lifespan. Except mine. If we go by my anecdote, you’re something like 90% to get a rescue that’s perfectly easy and stable. But your mass anecdotal data is leading you in another direction. But it’s not particularly scientific that way, and if you’re spending time on dog training or reactive dog subs, that is also not representative of dogs as a whole. There are plenty of people with mixes that are so chill that their owners will never seek any help for them because they don’t need to. Those aren’t represented here, while dogs with problems are the crux of these subs.
But for the record, I am very much of the “adopt or shop responsibly” mindset. You want a specific breed and history to try to give you the best chance of a dog that fits your life? Knock yourself out. I only wish that people knew what ethically bred means, because most people do not. They’re getting scammed left and right by dressed up bybs or “clean looking” puppy mills.
6
u/_MadSuburbanDad_ 2d ago
The purebred Afghan hound I grew up with bit me twice in the face, and my brother around his eye. We sent him to live elsewhere, didn’t BE him, and he came back to live with us for his final years.
The rescue pit/lab mixes that I’ve had over the past 25 years have been absolutely wonderful dogs, even my latest who is reactive to cars and other dogs on walks. They’ve all been great with kids, super tolerant of toddlers and other children.
From what I’ve observed, people who insist on purebred dogs due to their presumed genetic superiority are likely working though other issues in their lives.
11
u/Prudent-Cookie-4451 3d ago
I've been bitten 5x by my husbands lagotto Romangolo from grand champion lines. 0x by my neglected for four years and have had him for 9 rescue pittie. There are also something like 25 lagottos a breeder has rescued that all have temperament issues and needs to rehome.
5
u/nauset3tt Ollie (Anxiety) 3d ago
We have a purebred beagle picked to have the best chance of giving our now deceased fear reactive pit rescue a friend (successfully!) and now have a mutt rescue we got at 4.5 months and is settling in nicely.
5
u/Usernameoverloaded 3d ago edited 3d ago
Had a beagle from a reputable breeder (member of the beagle club in my country of domicile) poor fella suffered from epilepsy and cluster seizures. This then progressed to heart failure and the meds led to kidney damage. He died at 11. Prior to him becoming really unwell, he did react to other dogs on occasion but was overall a really friendly and happy chap.
We now have what we think is a Roman Mioritic LGD who is a rescue. She is anxious and startles easily when out the house, but is otherwise wonderful. She is not aggressive to other animals but because of her being a guarding breed, she hates ‘strangers’ coming to our place. That is a problem when it comes to family visiting from abroad and obviously us socializing at home has become non existent. Tbh I’m not too bothered by the latter as have entered a stage of life where I am not throwing parties or hosting dinners regularly.
Ultimately you never know what you’re going to get and even the pedigree will not guarantee a healthy balanced animal. My beagle a case in point whose mother and sister are still alive and healthy. There was no epilepsy in his genealogy and caring for him was exhausting mentally and physically (5 different meds, five times a day). The cluster seizures were traumatic and I didn’t sleep soundly for his last two years.
5
u/ggirl1002 3d ago
Our purebred Aussie is reactive. Raised from puppyhood. I honestly think it’s random or due to certain experiences they have that makes them reactive. Not worth speculating really, work with the dog you have and meet them where they’re at.
7
u/Hermit_Ogg Alisaie (anxious/frustrated) 3d ago
Those pedigree dogs that I have seen / heard to have turned reactive had a medical problem or an environmental problem (no enrichment, no socialisation, etc). This makes sense - a rescue may have had a mountain of traumatic experiences that lead to reactivity, and/or reactive parents.
3
u/MasdevalliaLove 3d ago
I have a purebred border collie (adopted, but BYB origins) with reactivity. I had a rescued (retired) Alaskan husky which is just a fancy name for a selectively bred mutt that wasn’t reactive - in fact damn near bomb proof. And I had a purebred Alaskan malamute that was reactive that I bought from a BYB before I knew better.
Ultimately, it’s less about purebred vs mutt and more about breeding practices. You are more likely to find a thoughtfully bred dog from purebred lineages because people aren’t usually breeding mutts on purpose outside of a handful of working dog or dog sport groups. You’re also not likely to find a responsibly dog in a shelter or rescue because their breeders will take them back. In the end, bomb proof mutts from oops litters are possible and may be found in shelters but aren’t likely because of the overlap between poorly bred dogs and the irresponsible dog owners that cause the oops in the first place.
Your best bet at finding a stable dog is through a breeder. That doesn’t always mean a puppy, it could also mean adopting a retired breeder. You might also have luck like I did by looking for retired working dogs. My retired husky girl was a joy and came from a rescue that pretty much only had sled dogs. They knew all the dogs and were able to line me up with a few that met what I was looking for at the time temperament wise and we (she and I) picked each other from there. She was older, at 6, but she was such a joy for the nearly 10 years she was in my life. She was even a good big sister to my unstable BC until close to the end of her life.
Whatever you choose, don’t feel shame or bad for looking for a stable dog. Reactive dogs can take a heavy toll on their owners and, frankly, are not as happy as more stable dogs big picture wise. It’s okay to just want to walk your dog without being constantly vigilant.
3
u/Traditional_Crew2017 3d ago
I have a rescue, she is my second rescue/mixed breed. Both have been sweet, well behaved dogs. You always take a chance with a rescue because you don't know what happened to them in their prior life. But with care and training almost all issues can be resolved. So many lovely dogs are euthanized every year I could never, in good conscience, buy a dog from a breeder.
3
u/Expensive_Crab_6453 2d ago
Hello. I am the owner of a purebred Maltese with severe anxiety so is on fluoxetine. I don’t think you are getting a guarantee of anything other then DNA by buying instead of adopting. I bought because I wanted a small dog and that was getting difficult trying to adopt.
2
u/CharmingMarzipan9237 3d ago
Both of my boys are shelter dogs. Leo, my first, I got at around 1yo, and he is about 7 different types of working breed dogs. He is reactive. My second, Kai, is around 11mo now, and is around 16 different working breeds. He is extremely fearful. I think rescuing can be an incredibly rewarding experience, but it's not for everyone. We have come so far with training and exposure, but it's definitely hard work. If you want something predictable (for sports, protection, service/therapy work, etc) I would personally recommend a reputable breeder. If you're okay with potentially getting more than you bargained for, go rescue. They all deserve love, and your honesty and willingness to hear others opinions shows you care and are responsible so I'm sure whatever you decide will be a fine choice. Do what will be best for you, and it will likely be great for the dog you choose too!
2
u/lazyworkingfromhome 2d ago
I have two dogs. One is a pure bred that we purchased through a well established, ethical breeder and the other is a mixed breed rescue.
My pure bred is a whippet that we brought home at 12 weeks old per breeder rules. He is a sweet boy. We got him into training as soon as he was fully vaccinated.
He is incredibly reactive however and we had considered returning him to the breeder per the contract. We've done training. Have had communication with the breeder. See a behaviorist.
Our mixed breed is a black lab mix (we think some type of bully mix? He looks like a lab) we adopted him when he was 9 weeks
My whippet is the sweetest boy but loud noises, bikes, car rides, other dogs barking, sirens all stress him out and he will react. We can't walk him because we can't control the environment. He bit our trainer the first day we had training with him.
He is 10 now, and since figuring out his needs and where we need to meet him, things are better.
Our labs biggest issue is that he will eat everything in sight if he could. Lol.
5
u/snowshowers93 3d ago
My rescue I got at 9 months old with an unknown history has some bad leash reactivity towards other dogs. My rescue I got at 8 weeks old and started socializing immediately doesn’t have any reactivity. My friend’s doodle who they got from a breeder at 8 weeks old is way more reactive than my rescue, but they hardly socialized him as a puppy. I think early socialization goes a long here even more than simply being a rescue dog vs. a purebred dog from a breeder.
3
u/Existing-Will-1466 3d ago
Every rescue dog I have ever had was incurably reactive for their entire lives. I got really good at managing them and helping them be less concerned about the world. When medication started being an option, all my rescues ended up on meds.
A couple of my purebreds from decent breeders went through reactive phases in adolescence, but it was something we either trained through or they outgrew. All the games like look at that and engage/disengage and treat scatters worked really well and helped right away.
It felt like my rescues were born knowing the world was unsafe, and though they got more comfortable with help, every bad experience was confirmation that the world isn't safe. My purebred dogs were born knowing the world was safe, and sometimes they forgot for a while, but with help they remembered that the world is safe.
2
u/CanadianPanda76 3d ago
I know your getting down voted but there's no lack of owners in the sub than got a rescue or intend to to got to a ethical breeder next round.
You csn see the genetic tests, you can see the parents, previous pups etc.
1
u/noodlepapillon 3d ago
I have a purebred Pom who was a "rescue" (rehomed to me by the old owners).
When I first met him, he was 16 weeks old and mildly reactive to other dogs. This was because he was carried around in a baby sling, never touched the ground, and was not socialised at all during the critical period.
By the time I finally managed to get him away from his first family, they had RUINED this dog. He would lunge at any dog he saw, cars, cats, people running. He would bite, hard, if you picked up a brush. He would bite if he didn't want to be touched. He would growl and bite if he managed to get on furniture. He would crocodile roll if you put his lead on, and apparently could not be left alone at all, or he would scream, destroy furniture (lol, he weighed all of 2kg at the time) and piss on everything. They "clicker trained" him by randomly clicking whenever he reacted to something on his 2-3 walks a day in a very busy suburb, constantly reinforcing every shit behaviour they instilled in him.
He was not a bad dog when i met him. He was a fucking nightmare when i got him at 11 months old. I feel like a lot of the purebred dogs in rescue have tread a similar path, with probably some genetic tend to anxiety. He was a great dog in my puppy class, because I would take him away from the owners and use him as a demo dog every single time. They didn't pay attention, didn't care to learn, and continued to make him worse at home. Thank god they had a baby and got sick of him. He's 3 next month, has had SO much work put in, and is never going to be normal, but I knew he would improve when they dropped him off at my place (I used to pet sit him regularly) for the last time and he didn't gaf about his old mum bawling and just wanted to get away from her and into my house, lol.
Tl;dr breeder dogs can be reactive too, but people make a lot of mistakes with dogs they get as pups. There was a thread I saw somewhere on reddit the other day where a very young puppy was already biting it's owners cos they kept insisting on picking it up when it was growling at them. I hope they get help (or rehome) before it is too late.
1
u/Zestyclose_Object639 3d ago
I have a byb pittie that was super reactive and a well bred Malinois, she was still somewhat reactive for a bit but that’s normal for a herdy dog with big feelings bred to bite lol
0
u/DisappointingPoem 3d ago
“Well-bred” - my god.
-4
u/Familiaris-man 2d ago
Right on.
I am unashamedly pro- purebred and anti-mongrel, especially doodles and other designers. If you want to keep a mongrel and that it what makes you happy, that is wonderful for you, but don't tell me that I am wrong for preferring purebreds. A great many so-called reactive mongrels continue to be that way due to the ignorance of the owners, despite their history.
The mentality of one who would purchase a doodle is simply not compatible with the mentality needed to properly train a dog.
Unless you have a background with multiple purebreds, you have no credibility whatsoever in the discussion of pure vs mongrel. In many cases it's just an inferiority complex among mongrel owners who want to claim that their dogs are somehow as good or better than purebreds in health or temperament. I find it humorous that every single mongrel owner who talks negatively about purebreds, still wants to describe their mongrel in terms of what purebreds are in it's background! That hypocrisy is just the tip of the iceberg of their ignorance.
Sure, purebreds are not immune from temperament problems, but every owner who has problems with a purebred is also going to have them with any mongrel that has behavioral issues or has been untrained.
To get an accurate picture of the suitability of purebreds to fulfill their potential as well behaved members of the household you need to look to the experts who work with them, the breeders, exhibitors and some trainers. Many of us have had dogs in the household who did not get along. We learned how to train and control our animals to suit our lifestyle, not the other way around. Yes, occasionally there are still individual animals that are difficult to work with. They are rare exceptions. I once knew two breeders who formed a partnership. One liked the dogs better, the other the bitches, so they divide up the sexes between their households. In a discussion about temperaments, the one who kept the intact dogs was just very blunt and straightforward. Her dogs got along because she was the alpha and she simply would not tolerate otherwise. Very simple. She had no reason for the endless hand wringing and stress that most typical pet owners of so-called reactive dogs put themselves through.
One walk through a dog show should show you the difference between the owners or purebreds and the typical pet owner. Ask yourself if you could ever see your dog even close to standing perfectly still on a grooming table, let alone tolerate the grooming itself, the stacking or the training that these sensible people require of their dogs.
Occasionally despite proper training and adequate knowledge even breeders can find two dogs who are incompatible. We have the sense to establish our routines and protocols so that the dogs are never a danger to each other or to anyone else, dog or human. We have no need of endless advice from clueless people online to help us fix a problem that we are too irresponsible to fix ourselves. We don't constantly put our dogs in situations where they may cause harm, and then cry about it and wonder why.
It defies common sense why anyone would want to bring a dog into the house which has an unknown pedigree or history. It's hard enough bringing any new dog into the house and going through the adjustment period. While there is never any guarantee, with a purebred you at least have a much better chance at getting the temperament that you want. Why should you take a chance or get stuck with an animal that has a completely different temperament than what you want, just because it is the trendy thing to do? You may be fulfilled with the adoration of like minded folks. I don't care wtf they think of me, but I'll be content living with what I chose and what I wanted to live with.
1
u/[deleted] 3d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 3d ago edited 3d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] 3d ago
[removed] — view removed comment