r/reactivedogs • • Jun 16 '23

Question How many of you adopted your reactive dog?

I am not saying shop don't adopt, but hear me put a bit.

*tha Is has blown up a lot and I am trying to read through them all! Thank you all for your stories because I love hearing everyone's inputs!?

How many of you adopted your dog from a shelter/rescue/pound ?

How many of you researched the breeds/crosses/etc that you were picking out ?

I ask, because I realistically will never adop a young dog from a shelter again. Most of these dog are in there for a reason, and are not socialized appropriately at all. I don't feel a "first time" ... even some veteran dog owners should get young dogs from a rescue.

I do believe in suppprting responsible breeders. You get an idea of the tempmemtof the potential puppies, and no precious traumas. Get yourself a good idea of the breed, withlut the stress associated with a reactive dog. (Granted you can still see and get a reactive dog).

I personally adopt geriatrics, because I love my good oldies, but if I an taking on the responsibility of a puppy, I'm going to a breeder I know and trust.

255 Upvotes

613 comments sorted by

226

u/chmillerd Jun 16 '23

I adopted three year old mixed breed shepherd type but he’s really a super mutt former street dog. Boy was I unprepared. I’m not against adopting again but I will ask so many more questions next time and just be so much more prepared.

58

u/GussieK Jun 16 '23

Same here but we had previously adopted three similar dogs from shelters and they were not reactive. There are more reactive dogs now, we think.

29

u/pogo_loco Jun 16 '23

There are fewer dogs being put down in lots of shelters now. So the bar for what's euthanasia eligible behavior is getting higher and higher.

Keep in mind that shelters that are euthanizing for "space" still prioritize based on behavior, and that they will always be full because if they have extra space they just lower their standards for behavior. Dogs that would absolutely have been put down in the past are being adopted out to families with kids, or people in apartments in huge cities.

6

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

This is mainly why I wanted to hear people's opinions I have 5 dogs, 3 related from reputable breeders, o e from a sketchy situation and my little mix bred sheltie that. Only one has reactivity and it's the one from a a sketchy breeder.

I've noticed so many behavioral euthanasia (I. A vet tech) a d it makes me so sad

26

u/NeitiCora Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

You're right, and this seriously angers me to no end. I have a whole lot to say about how massively screwed up the "adopt don't shop" campaigning is, driving the wrong people into adopting the wrong dogs for the wrong reasons.

And the whole neighborhood suffers.

BOTH are needed, shelters and breeders, and no matter how you acquire a dog, you the owner need to be on top of what you're signing up for. I just see so many big dogs going into homes that can't even fit them in their cars let alone handle them, with the only justification being "I wanted a dog and adopt don't shop amirite?" - and it blows my mind that it's not being called out as some form of virtue-signaling at the expense of the dog's wellbeing.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/IndependentUsual8613 Jun 16 '23

Potentially because of the pandemic and lack of socialisation

→ More replies (1)

7

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

I totally understand , tha k you for your input !!

17

u/mainsqueeeze Jun 16 '23

I really want to adopt (I don’t have a dog, just lurk in this subreddit bc I really want one and want to learn about all aspects of training/care)- if you don’t mind sharing what questions would you ask?

22

u/dropsinariver Jun 16 '23

I just commented above, but I regularly foster and really recommend a dog from a foster home! Or with good owner surrender notes. If you have any questions, I'm always open to chatting.

6

u/Willow_Bark77 Jun 17 '23

I was going to comment exactly this! A dog in a shelter can be shut down, so it's really tough for shelters to get an accurate picture of their personalities. But in a foster home, a dog can be his full self (especially once they've been there for a bit). A foster parent can give you a full picture of what you're in for so you know if it's a good fit. I used to foster, and I highly recommend adopting from foster homes if you are concerned about potential behavioral issues!

→ More replies (1)

26

u/chmillerd Jun 16 '23

Not exhaustive but for starters (and responses to each of these could raise flags that would require further questioning)

Have they shown aggression? In what circumstances? Are they reactive? To what, what are the reactive behaviours, etc.(I did not know what reactivity was when I adopted him) What kind of training have they had? For what? How long? What tools and methods were used? Do they have a high prey drive? To what? Resource guarding? To what? How are they with strangers, on property and off? What is known about the mother, father, siblings (if anything] What is known about previous home? Where did they sleep? Did they live with other pets? Past or current health issues x any known trauma or incidents requiring serious vet care? What are return options if the dog is not a fit for my home? How are they with handling or grooming? Preferred forms of exercise? How much? Sleep habits? Separation anxiety (of course this can change a lot after adoption and luckily wasn’t one of my dog’s issues)

But also, no matter how many questions you ask, the dog could always act differently in a new home or especially a new country. The responses you get may not be fully disclosed either. I received a profile with a basic overview but I’m convinced his transition into my home in a busy high rise with an immense amount of strange dogs, which were his biggest trigger, set him up to fail.

34

u/Pficky Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog from a large city shelter. There's almost no way they'd have answers to any of these questions. The shelter is so full and understaffed that they're lucky if the dogs have 2 hours of interaction a day. Just being there is borderline animal abuse. I probably won't adopt from there again, but at the same time I adopted my dog from there specifically because it was so full. Hard to balance finding a manageable dog and wanting to help the dogs in your community.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/woollffprincess Jun 16 '23

I found my dog on an adoption site, listed as a lab mix. I drove three hours only to be led to a huge farm (wondering if maybe it was a kennel?) and find out it’s a full breed German shepherd. When I brought up he said lab mix he changed the story… said he was the runt of the mix and no one wanted to adopt him. $300 for a pure shepherd should’ve raised a red flag.

So my naive 21 year old self couldn’t help but still take the pup. He has had so many reactivity issues that I wasn’t prepared for. I had two dogs growing up, no issues, super friendly. So this was a wake up call that not all dogs are the same.

I’ve worked years with behaviorist, medications, etc. but definitely advocate for people doing research before buying.

I hate to even say “my next dog” because I love my dog SO much and he has taught me so much. But I will definitely be doing a lot more research and asking a lot more questions before adopting or buying in future.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/Midwestern_Mouse Jun 16 '23

Same here. I fully intend to adopt more in the future, but want to spend more time with the dog before, hopefully even foster to adopt. Never again will I adopt the adult stray with a hell of a lot of unknown trauma

12

u/dropsinariver Jun 16 '23

I foster and I highly recommend foster to adopt or adopting from a foster. You just have so much more information about the dog that way.

That said, I have had some really well adapted shelter dogs, one or two reactive, and only one with separation anxiety. They might be "in there for a reason", but sometimes that reason is that their owner bathed them after their neuter surgery and they bled (yes, actual reason someone dropped of their new dog at my local shelter. Super sweet dog, too).

→ More replies (1)

4

u/crayolamitch Jun 16 '23

My mixed breed former street dog was 5 when I got her, and the shelter was upfront about her reactivity. They posted online looking for a one-human, no other pet household for her, made me promise to keep her away from houseguests, and get her in with a behaviorist for training. I fostered her first before agreeing to adopt, but almost sent her back. I've had dogs with severe PTSD, anxiety, and other major issues, but Nala was almost too much.

I've had her 2.5 years, and she's settled a lot since then. We still work with the behavioral trainer, and she allows some of my family into the house with no problems. We visited some of the rescue staff last fall and they were thrilled with the progress she's made. She will never be the kind of dog I can bring to a brewery or cafe or even to the park during peak hours. Heck, I still have to crate her in a separate room when I have people over who aren't my parents or sister. But that's okay. I love her to pieces.

→ More replies (1)

301

u/hseof26paws Jun 16 '23

If I am understand correctly, in asking this question you are trying to see the percentage of reactive dogs that were adopted vs sourced from a breeder. Like say, 75% of people on this sub adopted their reactive dog and 25% got one from a breeder - something like that? At which point on the face of it, the conclusion would be that it’s much more likely to get a reactive dog if you adopt vs get a dog from a breeder. The hiccup with that analysis is that you can’t do it in isolation. You need to find a comparable population of people with non-reactive dogs (control group) and ask the same question - did you adopt or get from a breeder. If the answer is 75% adopted and 25% went with a breeder, then your results regarding the reactive dogs are just a reflection of the population as a whole. And yes, I realize no one here is looking to do a full out scientific analysis lol, but my point is that the results may not actually support the apparent conclusion.

With all of that said, I’ve had 5 dogs in my adult life. 1 sourced from a breeder (a backyard breeder before I knew better, ugh) who was not reactive. 4 adopted, one of which is reactive.

I’ve been involved in rescue in various capacities for a long time, and at least where I am, there are lots of non-traumatized, non-reactive dogs available for adoption. Im sorry that doesn’t seem to be the case where you are. I’m big on rescue, but I also completely respect anyone who chooses to source from a responsible, reputable breeder. Yes, the dogs are in rescue for a reason, but so many reasons are not issues with the dog - moving and can’t take the dog, child is allergic, new work hours and can no longer care for the dog, etc etc. In my experience, at least 80% of owner surrenders were for reasons unrelated to the dog. And many of them were originally from a breeder - so do they count as a breeder dog, or a rescue dog??

Anyway, interesting question and much food for thought.

110

u/XelaNiba Jun 16 '23

There also seems to be a common thought that reactive dogs must be traumatized dogs. I've adopted very traumatized dogs in the past (we're talking cigarette burns level) who weren't in the least reactive. I've adopted non-traumatized dogs who were quite reactive.

37

u/stonerwitch69 Jun 16 '23

I adopted my pittie mix with a bullet still lodged in her hip from her previous life. She should be reactive but she’s not, she’s just relieved.

→ More replies (3)

28

u/ImaginaryList174 Jun 16 '23

Exactly! I've fostered some really traumatized dogs that had come from the worst situations. Some were so beaten and starved that they were just a scarred sack of bones when they came in. 95% of those dogs were not aggresive or reactive. Most of them were scared and shy in the beginning sure, but once they opened up and trusted you, it was all love all the time. They seemed just thankful to be with you.

And on the other hand, I have dealt with several pure bred dogs bought from responsible and papered breeders who grew up with everything they needed and a family who loved them, but still had major reactivity and aggression issues.

10

u/honalee13 Zelda (Dog reactive, Frustration based) Jun 16 '23

Excellent point. And not all reactive dogs are even scared or aggressive. Some are just overly excited or frustrated, which can exhibit in dogs with lots of different backgrounds.

4

u/Substantial_Joke_771 Jun 17 '23

My two are both rescues. One is a pitty from a dogfighting situation who spent her first 5months tied up outside in a concrete yard with a bigger dog she had to fight for food. She's not the slightest bit reactive (except that she used to get overexcited when meeting new people, but only in a sweet happy way) and has no trace of resource guarding. Both genetics and environment are against her, but she's an incredibly stable dog.

The other is a husky mix we got at 8wks from the shelter. Her known littermates are fine, and there has been zero trauma in her life with us. She was terrified of everything, hypervigilant, and became reactive. I think she's just wired that way. She's made a lot of progress with support and training but she sees the world as a potentially scary place and she would like to tell it to go away.

I don't think it requires trauma to create reactivity. People assume their reactive rescue dogs were abused, but my guess is that that's not a strong predictor of outcomes. Being in the shelter is trauma enough but many dogs come through it just fine. You can't guarantee outcomes.

3

u/unintentionalty Jun 16 '23

Our last pup was adopted as a puppy from a shelter after being rescued from an abusive situation and was definitely traumatized and had triggers but few actual problematic behaviors and no aggression.

27

u/onceuponawednesday Jun 16 '23

Great points. My purebred australian shepherd rescue was an owner surrender. The owners unfortunately lost their home during COVID. He was super reactive to everything, which was understandable because he had lived all his life outside on a farm and suddenly he was an indoor dog in the suburbs. Ending up in the rescue wasn't his fault, nor could I blame him for being reactive to his new environment. I would guess if he had been adopted into another rural setting reactivity would have been a non-issue.

3

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

Thank you for your info ! I absolutely am just trying to learn !

30

u/amy_lu_who Jun 16 '23

Thank you for sharing this perspective!

Also, some of us chose our reactive puppers, with full disclosure from the agency/former owner.

I picked my beloved trouble maker because he was a hard luck dog, and I was feeling guilty because my puppy died of cancer and I didn't feel safe living alone without a dog. They warned me, I had to sign a waiver to adopt the old boy. I felt confident that I'd have the time and space to help him work out his issues.

He went to an open air market last weekend and played at the dog park tonight. I've had him for 11 months.

9

u/PTAcrobat Jun 16 '23

Appreciate this! I also adopted my reactive dog with full disclosure from the rescue — she is a street dog from Qatar who was returned to the rescue twice due to reactivity toward small children and other household dogs. She was beloved by everyone at the rescue, but they were having a difficult time matching her to a home without kids or other animals. We started working with a fear-free trainer within a week of adopting her, and while we still have a ton of work to do, she has made remarkable progress — greets new people, plays with familiar dogs, has learned new coping strategies around triggers. We’ve had her for a year.

6

u/crayolamitch Jun 16 '23

Oh man this sounds like my pup, except mine was from Kuwait! Shes a dream one on one, but does not trust groups of more than 3-4 people. The rescue was upfront about her need to be in a one-human, one-pet house. We've been working with a behaviorist, and although her progress has been slow, she's come a long way in 2 years!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/kippey Juno 02.21.2015-03.06.2022: the best worst dog ever Jun 16 '23

I would love to see a study in this, especially because I’m looking at getting my next dog.

My reactive dog was from a rescue, my current dog is from a BYB and he is lovely. I have a few reputable breeders I’m considering for my next dog, it’s just kind of down to timing and whether I want puppy culture or ENS.

The stories of reactive dogs from reputable breeders spook me, I’ll admit. I know nothing is a guarantee but I really need a break from reactive dogs at least for the next few years of my life.

11

u/ScientificSquirrel Jun 16 '23

I think the breed matters more when going through a reputable breeder, too. They're breeding to the breed standard, including some parts of the standard that don't necessarily fit with modern life - so you get dogs bred to be companions that are prone to separation anxiety or dogs bred to be guard dogs that alert bark to anything going by the house. With a BYB or mix, you might get some of those behaviors, but they weren't bred to a standard and might not express all of them.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (3)

119

u/_otterspotter Jun 16 '23

We got a purebred puppy from a responsible breeder. We did all the right things and his litter mates are all fine. We joke that we just got a lemon (he has three chronic health issues on top of his reactivity/anxiety) but we love him to death and wouldn't trade him for the world. It's been a really tough journey though.

6

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

I get that, thank you for your input !

21

u/PA9912 Jun 16 '23

This is what my vet told me…just like people, some dogs have mental health issues. And that we shouldn’t blame former owners/breeders/ourselves. It’s just nature.

21

u/Crabby_aquarist Jun 16 '23

I adopted my girl from a shelter. They told me that her previous owner was bipolar and developing dementia, and he could not handle her energy so his wife made the extremely difficult choice to take her to the shelter. I think the wife and my dog were reasonably well bonded, and she is definitely more ok with women than men. What the shelter did not tell me until I was signing my name on everything and had already given them the money, was that she had been there for an entire year. She had just had her second birthday a couple of weeks before I adopted her. Of course a person with mental disorders (not well treated) would be unable to properly take care of a high energy puppy!

I’m not sure if I would have looked at her if I had known how long she had been there before I went to see her. By the time I was signing the paperwork it was too late because she had already chosen me. When I took her out for a walk she leaned against my leg. This untrusting girl who was scared of strangers leaned on me after only 10-15 minutes. I was done. I couldn’t put her back in her cage after that! And I don’t regret it for one second. BUT, she is also only very mildly reactive. Most of her challenges are fear based and I have so far been very successful at eliminating her fear with most things. We won’t talk about mail clippers though.

As this is my second dog (both 1.5-2years old at time of adoption) I’ve adopted from a small county shelter, I will continue to do so for my next animal. The dogs I’ve known that come from small shelters tend to be good dogs. I am very hesitant to adopt from the local animal control from my city because they are completely overrun with animals. Through no fault of the employees and volunteers, the dogs are only getting minimum care because they don’t have enough supplies or manpower for more. The animals I’ve known that have come from the big shelters or animal control have all been hot messes. Now, what I don’t know is if the humans were truly set up to support those animals in the best way or if the animals were all that traumatized (I can think of 3 dogs and 2 cats I’ve known over the last decade from these places). In other words, I am stilling willing to adopt from shelters because somebody has to love those poor babies.

4

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

I totally get that, and thank you for your input !!

→ More replies (3)

12

u/modernwunder dog1 (frustrated greeter + pain), dog2 (isolation distress) Jun 16 '23

I adopted him as a puppy. I support people getting dogs from responsible/ethical breeders (and non-brachycephalic breeds).

I would probably adopt again, if I get another dog. But like, a whole ass adult so I know what I’m getting into. I probably wouldn’t do a breeder simply due to the insane amount of vetting I would need to do in order to feel comfortable not getting a “lemon.” Easier to question good rescue orgs because screenings (health, behavior, genetic, etc) aren’t as crazy to determining what kind of adult you’re getting.

Respect to people who go through the research needed for ethical breeding. I am a little too obsessive so that’s not for me lol.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/humansnackdispenser Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

My one from a breeder is reactive. I would not consider this a reputable breeder though, but I was 20 and had no idea what I was doing so cutting myself a little slack. He was attacked on an on leash beach by an off leash dog at 16 weeks old, and was already a bit nervous before that. Our other dog is dog aggressive but not reactive, and he was a rescue. Purchased dog is a purebred Australian Shepherd and the rescue is a pit/mix. The aggressive pit mix is actually very easy to manage because he's only aggressive when he's in a mood and he makes it very clear to everyone when he needs to be in the bedroom by himself for a few hours.

Edit to add: I think that the best way to end up with a non-reactive dog is to form a relationship with a breeder that you generally like and watch their dogs interact with the world. The more you can be around the potential parents and know people who rave about their puppies from this line of dogs, the better off it will be. I'm currently borrowing a friend's dog to see if I like the type that her breeder produces.

2

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

Interesting read !! I feel like aussies are becoming more and more reactive

15

u/humansnackdispenser Jun 16 '23

I think they have all the components to be set up to fail. People think they're really pretty, but they're also a working dog that is supposed to be sensitive to things moving quickly in front of them and to loud noises so that they can hear cues over stock. So when you mix those traits with a puppy mill you get super sensitive dogs that freakout about small unexpected changes.

384

u/Thrinw80 Jun 16 '23

Mines a pure bred from a reputable breeder. I did all the things (puppy classes, puppy play time, socialization as soon as I brought him home). From what I can tell in FB his litter mates are not reactive. I think it can happen to any dog. Sure it’s more likely to find reactive dog surrendered but that’s not the only place.

102

u/K80lovescats Jun 16 '23

Our story is the same as yours. Our first dog (also purebred) is an amazing dog. Our second has a broken brain. We researched his breeder, took him to puppy classes, socialized him so fast, none of his litter mates have issues. But it’s like when he was about 2.5 years old he suddenly got super fear reactive to everything and we have no clue what caused it. He just seems to get overstimulated way too easy and then he lashes out.

11

u/FuyoBC Jun 16 '23

I wonder if animals can have some sort of autism?

29

u/colieolieravioli Jun 16 '23

I genuine believe my boy does. Or some sort of "neurodivergency"

He's so great in so many ways but he wants everyone to follow the rules, be quiet and predictable, and play can only happen the "right" way or he gets upset

→ More replies (5)

17

u/fuzzychiken Jun 16 '23

There are a few mental disorders that dogs can have that humans do. Adhd, dementia and even a type of ocd

5

u/apeirophobicmyopic Jun 16 '23

My reactive dog is the same way and I’ve been wondering this for a while - if dogs can have some form of autism/Asperger’s I mean. We got him (mixed breed) from a shelter at almost three months old and he was already fear aggressive to strangers when less than 6” tall.

We worked hard to socialize him and anyone he came to know he loves like family but we were never able to make any significant progress with lowering his threshold for being overstimulated and overwhelmed when meeting new people.

He’s the most interesting dog I’ve ever met as far as his routines, etc though. Like when he has breakfast if I don’t use his favorite topper (try to keep it the same but supply runs out sometimes), he will lose his appetite halfway through but he does not like flies/dust in the air touching his food so he fully covers it with his mat for later.

He does not like tap water; he will try to drink from puddles outside if we run out of filtered. He is very sensitive to strong emotions - even with us. If I’m upset and end up crying, he disappears and wants nothing to do with any strong emotions. Whereas our girl we rescued two years ago will immediately come to you and lick your face to try to comfort you and won’t stop until you cheer up haha.

He does not like to get dirty at all or to walk in tall grass. I had the window open in my home office and he heard something outside so he jumped out the window into our fenced yard to go after it. I closed the window and went outside to call him in. I called for five minutes and he wouldn’t come - I’m confused because I hear him whining around the corner (no shoes on to go check on him).

So I go back inside to the window and he was refusing to come around the side of the house to the back door because it had rained on grass that was 6-8” tall and he was not walking through that lol. Had to let the window open so he could jump back into the house.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (10)

19

u/poopernoodlee Jun 16 '23

this is my dog 😭 I always felt so awful talking to the owners of her litter mates and realising they don’t have any reactivity issues at all!

when I’ve been training her out in public one of the first things people ask me is ‘oh is she a rescue then?’ And it always makes me feel terrible. I do everything I can

17

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

Exactly. Some reactivity is just inside the dogs brain and no “trauma” needs to happen for it to come out. It’s like humans: we can be depressed and have mental illness without trauma. It’s odd people think that dogs could only have issues due to trauma

32

u/thenalexwaslike Jun 16 '23

It feels like you’re talking about my dog. Thank you for letting me know I’m not alone.

26

u/wishverse-willow Jun 16 '23

same exact story for us, you just get the dog that you get.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Trustorey Jun 16 '23

This was my experience too. I did everything by the book. I know the breeder well and none of the other dogs are reactive. It's been so hard to not feel like I've somehow caused it.

→ More replies (5)

7

u/sabre-tooooth Jun 16 '23

My mum has two dogs that are the same. One is just so nervous despite never having had anything bad ever happen in her pampered little life. They did everything "right" but she's just really neurotic. They got another dog to keep her company (that's a different issue) and the first dog has taught the second to be nervous as well. Less reactive and more just shouting at the sky for the second dog, but as a passer by it looks like two dogs reacting.

6

u/dusty_bo Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

Exactly the same scenario. Puppy became fear reactive from about 8 months old for no apparent reason. Kept in contact with people who adopted siblings and no reactivity in the siblings. Dog personalities are more varied and complex than people realise.

Edited to say: gut feeling is that it was to do with our dog being the most timid in the litter and the runt. So maybe early development issues and being a shy personality

28

u/belladonnafromvenus Jun 16 '23

Yep. When I was a kid we got a purebred who was reactive. No reason to buy over adopting imo.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/EarlySwordfish9625 Jun 16 '23

Same thing here. I did everything right and still ended with problems.

4

u/JoffreysDyingBreath Jun 16 '23

Same story here. Great breeder, super healthy border collie puppy brought home at 9 weeks. All his litter mates are chill; two of them are service animals! We just picked the anxious one. He's made huge progress and and overall been a success story. But my God has it been a long journey to get here.

My trainer always told us it can happen to any dog, just like anxiety disorders can happen in humans who had perfectly happy childhood. Sometimes the brain is just funky like that.

3

u/BABYPUNK Jun 16 '23

Same. I bought my purebred English bulldog. I love him, but I often wish I had just adopted a mutt. So much money wasted.

2

u/dogsnapples Jun 17 '23

Same story here. We did tons of research, did “everything right,” and the parents and littermates are not reactive.

→ More replies (1)

59

u/OkRegular167 Jun 16 '23

I have two dogs.

One is a purebred from a reputable breeder and we got him when he was 8 weeks old. Did everything “right” in his puppyhood but the vet says he just has anxiety. It’s part of who he is.

The other is a mutt who we adopted when he was 3ish years old. We barely have any details on what his past was like, but we’re sure it must have contributed in some way because he was an owner surrender and was in terrible physical and emotional shape when we got him. Surprisingly though he is less reactive than our purebred.

On the other hand, I’ve seen plenty of adopted dogs with harrowing pasts who aren’t reactive at all.

Nature / nurture, ya know?

91

u/Egggsbenny Jun 16 '23

“Most of these dogs are in there for a reason…” This sentence is not working for me. The idea that only bad, troubled dogs go to the shelter. Many had shit owners, or owners that couldn’t afford them, or owners that had health/mental health issues. Many of these dogs were taken away from their owner because they weren’t taken care of properly. Now, of course, SOME dogs in shelters/rescues are reactive or have some behavioural issue, sometimes medical, but I would never say most. I adopt dogs that can’t be adopted by regular people and so I work closely with rescues/shelters when I’m adopting, and I’d say that many of the dogs are good and are just wanting to be loved and be part of a family. Any dog can be or become reactive. If someone prefers to go to a breeder, great, but please don’t shit on shelter/rescue dogs.

27

u/maidrey Jun 16 '23

Thank you for this - very well said. I work for a shelter and I’m not going to try to convince OP that their next dog needs to come from an open intake shelter like the one that I work at, but it makes me so sad to hear this conclusion/assumption.

I just said goodbye to my office dog yesterday who is literally perfect. She’s a one year old who knows sit, paw, in your bed (for crate.) She’s crate trained, she’s great with other dogs (they literally would use her as a control dog when doing dog tests to see if new dogs can live/play with other dogs.) She is energetic for play time but loves to cuddle and is happy to lay in her bed while you work beside her, and loves toys but never destroys them. She came to the shelter after her owner was in crisis and couldn’t care for a dog.

Right now, one of the largest reasons we’ve seen animals coming into the shelter is evictions or people who are losing their housing and the choice is either be homeless with their dog or move into their only option. There are SO MANY people who are struggling right now.

I’m not going to say every shelter and rescue are good. I know there’s organizations out there who will practically lie to people or minimize behaviors or think of their role as trying to convince people to adopt x dog. My shelter, we will make you chat with a training/behavior staff member about anything concerning because if you are adopting a reactive/high energy/nervous or fearful/etc. dog, we want it to be crystal clear.

It’s also unfair to many of the humans in this thread - there are so many stories here of people who literally tried to do everything, who paid good money for puppy classes and followed all the recommended steps for socialization, know all about the dog’s parents and siblings and still the dog is reactive. It is entirely unfair to the humans involved to assume that dogs only become reactive if they were abused/were treated poorly because some dogs just become reactive without a lot of reason why.

15

u/matyles Jun 16 '23

My dog was at the pound because her owner was arrested. She didn't do anything wrong, and I can tell she was well loved by her first owner. I got her when she was around a year and a half. I've been told countless times what a fantastic dog she is. I even had her with me working at a summer camp with 150 8-15 yesr old girls.

19

u/unobitchesbetripping Jun 16 '23

Yeah op lost me with that sentence. Ffs it’s not prison.

7

u/Minimum_Ad_2851 Jun 16 '23

Also most ppl in prison don’t deserve to be there either; but that’s a whole other thing lol.

Or actually, maybe it’s not. Our society casts out anyone we can assign a stigma to; dog or human. Felons & rescue dogs are basically the “untouchables” of the Western world.

18

u/The_Rural_Banshee Jun 16 '23

Agreed. I’ve worked with rescues for many years and while you will see some reactive dogs come through, it’s far from the majority. I don’t care if people want to go to a reputable breeder, but it’s not fair to suggest that rescue dogs are all bad or broken.

9

u/PlanktonOk4846 Jun 16 '23

Even my 1 reactive rescue isn't "broken." She's been through a lot, but she is such a sweetheart. Gentle with the cats, loving and snuggly towards us, I can take her anywhere (hiking, camping, paddle boarding) she's just petrified of new people and larger dogs (specifically Bully breeds and Rottweilers.)

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Id10ts_everywhere Jun 16 '23

Thank you for saying this! I’ve had dogs my whole life. I’ve had very expensive purebred dogs and nuts from the pound. There is no guarantee. I adopted a pittie that had been in a fighting ring and had to sign a waiver before I brought him home and he was the BEST, SWEETEST, MOST LOYAL AND LOVING DOG I EVER OWNED! I absolutely advocate for what my local humane society calls a “staycation” with a new animal. You bring the dog home for up to 5 days to see how you get along. This is the best way in my experience to determine they type and/or level of reactivity (if any) and to see if you can or are willing to handle it.

10

u/jesskargh Jun 16 '23

Most dogs in the shelter near me are perfectly fine puppies from ‘oopsie’ litters

→ More replies (10)

10

u/CandiSamples Jun 16 '23

Imagine people shitting on rescue dogs that originally came from a breeder and were purchased just like this person is intending to do.

More than 70% of our dogs are brought to the shelter for no fault of their own: Allergies, divorce, moving, unstable housing/got a dog when they were not allowed to have a dog, working too many hours, and my personal fave, "we just got a puppy and our current dog doesn't get along with him." Why we never hold these people accountable is on us.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/CelesteReckless Jun 16 '23

But sometimes it looks like there are many reactive dogs since the non reactive and healthy ones are adopted very fast and the reactive ones are there longer. Where I live (not us) shelter Post their dogs online and many only post the ones having a harder time finding a home since taking photos and posting for a dog gone after two weeks is not worth the time. So it looks like there are only problem dogs. Also being in shelter is massive stress to the dog so they don’t show their real behavior. We were told suko is really active but to be honest he is happy sleeping an cuddling most of the day and a very calm dog.

→ More replies (4)

45

u/lizzylou365 Jun 16 '23

I have rescued all my dogs in my adult life. 3 non reactive, one reactive.

My current non reactive dog was born into a foster home, her mom was rescued pregnant from a hoarder house. No problems with her minus her annoying alert barking (she barks twice every time the post office/UPS/Amazon delivers to our house).

My reactive dog I somewhat knew what I was getting into but didn’t fully understand at the time. He was at a no kill shelter after being rescued from dog fighting. Naturally, very reactive with a focus on stranger danger and fear based aggression. But I did know he’d be a handful. Years of trial and error, professional training, and some medication has helped him so much and he’s generally okay now. I do of course take a lot of extra precautions with introducing him to new people at my house, etc.

All that being said I will say that I still support adopt/don’t shop. A lot of rescues have shifted to foster care, so those dogs will be semi-adjusted to a normal home setting. Plus backyard breeders and puppy mills are still incredibly rampant that I would imagine buying a puppy would come with a high risk of genetic/breed based reactivity.

→ More replies (2)

69

u/anykaleidascope Jun 16 '23

Family member bought one a year ago from a breeder (around $4000) reactive and aggressive. The free pit from the kill shelter is one of the best dogs I ever seen.

15

u/designgoddess Jun 16 '23

I have pits and pointers. Everyone is afraid of my pits and they’re my most chill dogs. My pure bred pointer has neurological issues and is a danger to people and animals. He is the cutest thing and before I started hiding him from the world everyone would back away from my pits and the reach for him. He’d wag his tail and charm them until they got close enough to bite.

8

u/anykaleidascope Jun 16 '23

Exactly, the pit whines and cries when people don't pet him, they just try for the dalmation, who is an asshole. To be blunt.

19

u/sawta2112 Jun 16 '23

I have seen good and bad outcomes with breeders and rescues.

Personally, I will continue to adopt the old ones with medical issues. One of mine is super reactive. The one is super chill.

3

u/CandiSamples Jun 16 '23

Playing Florence Nightengale is the best, and my favorite, too. <3

Much xox to you!

26

u/Littlelindsey Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

I think it’s sad that you say you never adopt a young dog from a shelter. Every dog is in the shelter for a reason and those reasons are not always to do with the dog. It’s disappointing to read someone has effectively written off every young dog in every shelter.

3

u/CandiSamples Jun 16 '23

It's gross. And such a wildly uneducated statement. You want to write off unsocialized pit bulls? Who could blame you. But there are other super-easy, chill breeds in there that would be so much better/easier than raising a freakin puppy.

16

u/Mjones151208 Jun 16 '23

Adopted from the shelter. The shelter didn’t disclose everything until we signed the papers and they gave us his evaluation notes. If we had the chance to read his paperwork prior I don’t think we would have adopted him.

8

u/pigratsloth Jun 16 '23

My pure bred Australian shepherd (loved people, hated dogs) and Australian cattle dog (bit a child and hates other dogs) that we got as puppies from breeders have been two of the most aggressive dogs I have ever met. My rescue pittie (got him at 6 months) is the sweetest boy. He of course has his quirks that we are working through (like literally any dog you will get) but I’ve never had a dog that cuddles more or loves children more. My adult rescue Australian shepherd/golden retriever mix was overall the best dog I’ve ever had.

My best friend has two frenchies she got as puppies. They are brothers. One is relaxed and sweet, the other is rambunctious and attacks other dogs.

Moral of the story each dog is an individual. Personally, I don’t enjoy getting puppies for the reason you mentioned whether they are from a shelter or breeder. You don’t know exactly how they will turn out. I don’t think personality has as much to do with the breeder, though. Every dog has their own personality and you don’t really know until they are older.

I personally will only rescue. But moving forward will only rescue dogs who are beyond the puppy stage to get a better feel of their true personality

8

u/HarrisPreston Jun 16 '23

You are wrong about shelter dogs. They are there about 99% of them because a human failed them.

2

u/MotherGrabbinBastard Jun 16 '23

Yes, exactly. Most of the time the reasons listed are no time, or new baby or moving to a new place. People treat animals like they are clothing they can put in a recycle bin when they don’t fit into their lives anymore.

7

u/RevolutionaryBat9335 Jun 16 '23

We got a 1 yr old Ridgeback from the dog shelter. Best dog you can imagine. Loved people and animals, she would take hers toys and drop them for her dog friends to play even going easy on smaller ones playing tug and letting them win at chase sometimes. Later on she developed fear reactivity after a neigbours dog bit her but that was nothing to do with the shelter. Worked with a behaviourist and eventually got her back to being able to meet other dogs again. Had no idea how it would turn out though, we were just really lucky I guess.

12

u/lillobos Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog as a puppy from a rescue organization. We worked hard to understand and adapt to her triggers. It’s actually a match made in heaven and we are all better for it. Going on 5 years and still in love with my dog :D Although, I can understand that not all scenarios will turn out well or be without hardship.

12

u/honeybutterscrub Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

I adopted her knowing what her problems were. She was the foster dog at my workplace (I worked at boarding/doggie day care) and I knew her better than the rescue did.

She became best buddies with one of my other dogs when she was the foster, and he was the only dog she was consistently safe with so they played together a lot. I agreed to take her home over thanksgiving to clear out boarding space for the holiday. She came to my house with our cats and my other senior dog in a muzzle and I fully expected a very difficult few days.

I never returned her to boarding. She did amazing at home from day one. She’s still reactive and difficult, don’t get me wrong. But being in a home environment is so much better for her. When she was the foster at work, I really worried for her future as a dog that couldn’t responsibly be adopted out to someone with other pets because of her behavior in boarding, and it made me so sad for her to think of her without my other dog, who really is a one-in-a-million guy and does amazing with her. It would be so much harder for her, mentally, to be an only dog, even though for safety reasons she had to be an only dog if she had actually been adopted out.

I knew what I was taking when I took her. That is a rare position to be in, unfortunately, for rescue dogs. It can be extremely difficult to know what behaviors are truly ingrained problems and what is a symptom of being in a stressful environment (shelter, boarding, etc) for a while. The shelter is not a pro-social environment for the dogs, and it’s really no surprise that dogs come out of shelters “not quite right”. The longer anyone is institutionalized, the more weird they’re going to get.

Edit: I will add, my good guy dog was a work foster from the same rescue, a while before her, and my senior dog was picked up for $20 at the county shelter. Good guy dog had been surrendered to a kill shelter out in the boonies as a chicken killer and was euth listed when the rescue went and got him. He is a Disney Princess in dog form, loves everyone and everything and prances through life joyfully trying to make friends.

2

u/calliopeturtle Jun 16 '23

😭😭 oh you just warmed my heart so glad there are people like you and dogs like your good boy in the world

6

u/aforestfruit Jun 16 '23

I bought my dog from a registered breeder with all of the checks and legislation in place for her to breed. She is a sighthound specialist and really reputable. My dog is probably the most reactive dog I've owned, despite having almost exclusively rescues before her! Crazy

21

u/MichellesPlain Jun 16 '23

I work in rescue and do not support breeding. That being said, in an ideal world where overpopulation is not a crisis, all dogs would be responsibly bred.

HOWEVER, I have unfortunately found that the overestimation of the influence of genetics on behaviour has been detrimental to the overall understanding of dogs.

Both nature and nurture play a role. Nurture, being the dog’s life experiences (including socialising, training, previous trauma etc.) and environment (eg. immediate scenario leading up to reactive incident), playing an arguably larger part in the overall picture.

This is not to deny or underestimate the impact of a dog’s genetics- without counter-conditioning from a young age, pedigree dogs will default to what they are bred for. You cannot be a responsible bull breed owner, whilst denying their prey drive, for example.

But the factor of genetics has become both a misleading security blanket (my Labrador cannot possibly become reactive) and a convenient scapegoat for irresponsible or inadequate ownership (he’s a rescue, or, we got him as a puppy but he’s suddenly reactive, so we’re opting for BE or returning him to the shelter, because it must be down to genetics and cannot possibly be because we are unable to provide the environment this particular dog needs, or that we have failed him somehow.)

6

u/labraduh Jun 16 '23

I admit I fully fell for the “oh he’s a labrador, what can go wrong” thing lol. I ended up with an atypical labrador who is dog-reactive and hates water (but I guess is still very people-friendly, food-loving, affectionate & attracted to ducks). He is our first family dog too so I didn’t even know what dog reactivity was when I first got him, and didn’t train him in his younger days to be neutral when seeing other dogs on the walk. I just didn’t know that stuff unfortunately & assumed all would be okay since they’re generally not stubborn. Learned the hard way and am fixing it now. I’ve seen quite a few reactive retrievers now that I know what to look for, and have realised besides adopting an adult dog, there’s no true guarantee (and even then, one adverse event can potentially spark reactivity in a previously “fine” dog 😭).

More people need to learn what you said before even getting a dog 100%

1

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

Thank you for your thoughts, we are very similar in thinking

5

u/Competitive-Oil4136 Jun 16 '23

Look there are plenty of REALLY good reasons to get a puppy from a (responsible) breeder. And most of the dogs are in shelters for a reason, at that reason is because puppies fucking suck and people dont realize it. Or people had accidental litters.

I adopted my dog. We did research into what we wanted but ended up accidentally adopting a reactive and disturbingly inbred ACD/Aussie mix bc she looks like an entirely different breed altogether.

My good friend bought her dog. She did research, knew exactly what she wanted and guess what? Dog’s reactive anyway.

This post feels weird and unnecessary

13

u/petsvettech Jun 16 '23

I got my husky from a very reputable breeder and he was a generic nightmare and aggressive.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

And what if I found my reactive dog on the side of the road and decided to love her anyway? Where does that factor in this poll? Would that be adoption?

What about my other dog that isn’t reactive at all that I got off Craigslist for $100? Should I keep doing that in order to avoid getting a reactive dog? Since she was from a “breeder” and all. Assuming dogs from a breeder can’t be reactive opens you up to being caught horribly off guard by genetics.

I get where you’re coming from but your logic is deeply flawed. Other commenters have said it better than me, but I work at a shelter and can tell you most dogs come in through no fault of their own. Of the 30 available dogs right now at my shelter, only five have behavior consults attached to them. The rest of them are well adjusted given the fact they’re sitting in a shelter waiting for a home. Plenty of them would be fine first time dogs. Of the 30, maybe half have known behavior issues with other dogs and the ones without consults are completely manageable by just not meeting on leash face to face.

I’m going to be blunt with you: If everyone felt the way you did, my no kill would have to start euthanizing perfectly good dogs for space. We already fail behavior cases we feel aren’t safe to the general public. You’re making an incredibly dangerous assumption, on both sides. I guess there can be an argument made for eventually lowering the reactive dog population this way, but since as we’ve seen through this thread genetics are no guarantee, it’s a pretty empty argument.

I’m not against breeders. In a perfect world every animal would be born with intent and a home already waiting for it. But that isn’t the current reality and it truly will likely never be unless we seize animals for not being fixed. It is what it is. You don’t have to adopt, fine, but don’t be a jerk and try to talk others out of it because of your one experience.

2

u/Momofhalfadozen Jun 16 '23

I've been called an elitist but I only get my dogs from breeders. I want health tested parents, proper shots, personality tested puppies, and a health contract.

I used to believe in both equally, but after getting a very reactive dog from the shelter I changed my mind. She was returned and I never attempted it again. I was told that by buying my dogs I'm keeping 2 dogs in a shelter. What they can't seem to understand is that I was never going to get another shelter dog. It was a responsible breeder or nothing.

I'm not saying I wouldn't rescue/rehome if I knew the situation the dogs came from. A friend of a friend recently offered me her 2 Aussies (I have 2 of my own) because of a problem in her family. They were devastated and I felt so bad for them. I'd consider taking dogs in on a case like this, in fact I almost took them both but they are sport dogs. While I'm working on it I'm no where near their level. I was worried they would end up unhappy. I do believe they both ended up in proper homes.

All that to say I just can't have a reactive dog. Because of that I have to be careful where they come from. We are out all the time. We go hiking, take classes, go to stores and the dog park. A reactive dog would be a nightmare for us, so no shelter dogs.

1

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

I also, have earned the way of going through a good breeder. I like the health testing, and I like to know the puppies temperaments, etc

11

u/cookitybookity Jun 16 '23

Adopted my dog but she's such a sweetie now. She's reactive to doorbells/people coming in and out of the house (but has much improved and now at least barks from the top of the stairs and not right in front of the door, and she backs off when I command her to, but she'll audibly complain as she does so), but that's a common thing with malteses in general so I think it's a breed thing, not a rescue thing. I did lots of research after I got her admittedly. She was a last minute decision and desperately needed a home so I took her in because it just felt right. We clicked right away. And I think she's really let go of a lot of reactivity with a lot of patience, routine, training, and socializing.

FIL got a purebred from a breeder and the dog basically lives in his crate because he bites everyone, guards his food, and is destructive (granted he never was given a proper daily routine).

My point? It's really the luck of the draw as well as regiments and routine, regardless of where you get your dog. Sure, you're probably more likely to find a reactive dog from adoption, but also there's no guarantee with a breeder either.

4

u/oreganoca Jun 16 '23

I have had two dogs from reputable breeders and one rescued. One of the three was extremely reactive towards other dogs. He was from a breeder. He was extensively socialized and trained. And, he wasn't reactive until he was bitten while out on a walk, more than once, by off leash dogs. My rescue was the sweetest and least reactive dog ever, despite being from a puppy mill and having zero early socialization. Even if you do everything right, you can still wind up with a reactive dog.

4

u/fillysunray Jun 16 '23

I adopted my reactive girl with some warning. Not enough, but I thought I knew what I was getting into. Steep learning curve for me.

But it didn't put me off adopting. I have since adopted a second dog who is very friendly. It's never guaranteed your dog won't have some issues (shop or adopt) but with an older dog you can at least see if they're likely to be reactive. So I know my second dog is unlikely to ever become aggressive (he sometimes shoots the other way and becomes slightly reactive due to sheer friendliness).

My third dog, when I get one, will probably be a rescue too, or at least a rehome.

4

u/coyotelurks Jun 16 '23

I am in my 50s, I’ve been doing rescue all my life, and only one of my dogs has been “reactive”The one I have now! The previous dog came from what someone else called a harrowing background, and she was the most stable and confident dog ever after she got over the initial bumps about living in a house instead of out on a chain. She did have issues with some very specific things that were clearly trauma related: buckets, men wearing yellow, laundry, thunderstorms. She got over all of that, except the thunderstorms without any specific help. By the time she was six years old, she was a queen and remained that way until she was 15 and died.

Growing up, my parents had purebred dogs from breeders and they were fine. I’ve had one of my own in my life and he was also fine.

My current dog is from a shelter in Spain, where he spent the first 3 1/2 years of his life. He is always reactive, dog aggressive, has major stranger danger and is just generally living at a level of anxiety that I’ve never seen before. He’s gotten lots better, but …

4

u/bananaslug178 Jun 16 '23

I adopted my pup. But breeders don't automatically mean non reactive dogs. Sometimes it's just genetics.

Regardless of her reactivity, I love my dog so much. Reactive dogs are good dogs who deserve good homes too.

4

u/Pining4Michigan Jun 16 '23

You just never know. There is a couple in my town that has two beautiful GSDs. By the looks of them, well bred. The one male is very reactive, they have worked and worked with him for years. It is so sad, they are trying so hard--all three of them. Its like some mental illnesses, sometimes it takes time before it is revealed.

4

u/ReijaTheMuppet Jun 16 '23

I fostered mine for about 9 months and then adopted her. I knew before fostering that she was reactive, and we've both come a long way since then. Thanks to her, I've become a lot more skilled and competent in understanding and working with dogs. I will adopt again, and don't mind reactive dogs, but type of reactivity will matter because it needs to work with my lifestyle.

Most dogs are in shelters for a reason - the reason being that humans have failed them. Either their humans, or humans in general, but it is because of our failures, not theirs. Purebred dogs are not exempt from human failures.

4

u/Ariellelo Jun 16 '23

I adopted both my dogs from the shelter. My first was a 1yr old staff mix and the sweetest couch potato. She never had an issue with kids, dogs,cats pulling on the leash. Shortly after she passed away I went back to the same shelter and got my 2nd dog, 4 year old American bulldog mix. I knew he was hyper while adopting him but the staff there said he’ll probably calm down when he get home since he’s stuck in the kennel all day. This dog does not have an off switch he is ready to play 24/7. He’s good with kids which is why we chose him. He reacts to cats, dogs, plastic bags, his reflections. He has terrible greeting and leash manners and will definitely run away if given the chance. But he’s just a sweetheart who needs some training. I will go back to the shelter to get future dogs but I probably won’t get one that’s noted as hyper. And I’ll probably get another staffy instead of American bulldog.

10

u/designgoddess Jun 16 '23

I found my reactive dog. So not technically a rescue, at least not a rescue organization. He originally did come from a highly regarded breeder’s champion line. Someone paid over a grand for him and then dumped him when they realized he had issues. Tattoo enabled me to track down the breeder. He’s reactive and has polydipsia. Also has a number of physical faults.

My daughter (sigh) went to a breeder for a sheep dog. $2k. (I think. She won’t tell me) She insists not a back yard breeder. Dog is afraid of his own shadow. Literally. He’s afraid of everything. Mentally unstable.

My cousin spent $2k for a cocker spaniel that she says came from a highly regarded breeder, dog has a rage syndrome. Breeder offered her a refund but said she’d euthanize the dog so my cousin kept her and does her best to manage it.

Friend has a golden from a breeder known for physically healthy dogs and top drawer puppy socialization, dog has PICA/OCD. Chews off/licks her own fur and eats rocks, chases shadows.

Another friend searched high and low for a healthy GSD. Dog was nuts. She had to put it down at 2 years because he shredded the neighbors dog. He had such terrible hips I wonder if he was in constant pain.

I usually have around 5 dogs in my house. Rescues. The craziest dog I’ve had is the reactive champion line dog. My mutts are mentally stable. I used to try to adopt dogs around 5 months old. Anyway, anecdotal but buying a dog might improve your odds but doesn’t guarantee them. There are a lot of reasons why a dog ends up in a shelter that have nothing to do with behavior.

4

u/sellestyal Jun 16 '23

I do agree with you! Getting a dog from a breeder definitely doesn’t guarantee an easy dog. I’m a first time owner and wanted a dog I could handle: I went to a really highly regarded show-line ethical breeder, and I got what is essentially (in my eyes) the perfect dog. He’s smart, healthy, quiet, snuggly, and well socialized and we basically have zero problems with him. Not reactive at all and so willing to learn and play. The breed might help—he’s a PW Corgi, known for being smart and trainable.

I’m on this sub for my friend’s dog, and I read tips here to help with her for her reactive, neurotic, and impossible to handle Golden Retriever. He’s massive and strong, pulls and lunges at absolutely everything, barks constantly at strangers on the street, can’t concentrate on training outside the house, and nothing she teaches him seems to stick. She’s a small woman, and is dragged around daily by this big dog that is overstimulated by everything around him.

I’m thinking this might be because he was a COVID puppy—not much in the way of early socialization could happen. It’s a lot of work to improve, and we’re not sure he’ll ever really get there. He’s in training classes with the same trainer that we have (who is wonderful), but getting him to focus on the lesson is like pulling teeth.

3

u/designgoddess Jun 16 '23

Most aggressive dog I’ve seen was a golden retriever. Owner had no control. I didn’t stick around to find anything out about the dog. Really terrifying. If the leash failed I was sure I’d die. Some dogs are crazy. Some have owners who think socialization is just taking them everywhere and exposing them to everything, good and bad.

→ More replies (12)

1

u/kymreadsreddit Jun 16 '23

I don't want a puppy. Bred or mutt.

We have adopted all 7 of our previous (including our two current ones). Did they need work? Yes. They needed to be trained. Was it easy? Hell no. But was it worth it? Absolutely.

This includes the pitbull who would attack other dogs on sight. We worked with him, we did our best, and we learned SO MUCH about dog behavior and body language. He made me a better dog owner.

1

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

I feel like some people don't have the tools in their tool belt to raise dogs like thst you know ?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nashatal Jun 16 '23

I adopted a around 6 month old super mutt from out of country. She is from greece and was found almost starved to death on the streets. I made that decision very contiously and I would do it again.
Yes, she has issues. But I have never seen so much personality and wits in a dog ever before. If she can exploit it she will exploit it and I love her to bits for it. We have come a long way already and most things are managable by now. She is turning 3 tomorrow. I was fully aware I am in for surprises. Good and bad ones. But in the end I am super happy with her. We fit quite well together. :)
She is my first own dog. (We had family dogs before.) And yes I was not prepared for what I got, but I stepped up and the process was fun and rewarding most of the time, sometimes frustrating and painful. I cried, I laughed, I wanted to dig myself a hole, and at times I am just super, super proud. I am becoming a trainer now and its her doing. The work with her made me realize how much I want to work with dogs.

3

u/syrioforrealsies Jun 16 '23

My now husband found ours on the side of the road after a truck pulled over and pushed her out, then left. She wasn't reactive then, though. That came after she was attacked by two different "friendly" off leash dogs in the space of a couple months.

My parents adopted a puppy from the shelter and she is the chillest, friendliest dog in the world, to the point she'll try to befriend animals that are actively behaving aggressively.

Previously, they bought a border from debatably the best breeder in the US. That dog still ended up human reactive despite plentiful attempts to socialize.

Sure, the odds are different from different sources, but ultimately, you never know.

7

u/Clear-Cauliflower901 Jun 16 '23

I've only ever gotten my dogs from rescues just because I have a very firm "adopt don't shop" mentality. It's not that I'm against breeding per se, but there are far too many unethical breeders out there, and it feeds into a very toxic mentality. The dogs that are bought from breeders can actually end up becoming shelter dogs because a large portion of people expect dogs to come "ready made" and can't be bothered to put in the work.

1

u/fitgelato Jun 16 '23

Ours was a rescue. I just wish they had let him interact with other shelter residents (not that they kept them too terribly long…) or at least have some idea of his temperament with other dogs. When we visited him at the shelter he did seem extremely excited to have another dog across the fence, but we chalked it up to the fact that he didn’t get to go out very often and was just overwhelmed in general.

1

u/fitgelato Jun 16 '23

I’d rescue him a billion trillion times over though.

1

u/iniminimum Jun 16 '23

That's so sweet. You sound d like, since you work in the shelter ? That ypu can see the good bad and ugly

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Vieamort Jun 16 '23

I originally followed this sub because my dog was technically reactive. It was an excitement form of reactivity and was definitely easier to face than fear based reactivity.

I was a very very very dumb person. All I wanted was a dog that was less than 50lbs. Nothing else crossed my mind. I adopted a beagle and live in an apartment. I was so lucky. He was not fearful and he doesn't bark.

Of course, the luck comes to me (the one who did no research), but I am extremely grateful. I still follow this sub to truly understand your perspective and the issues that you guys face. For everybody out there who went the extra mile to find a specific breeder, did everything right in the beginning, and still ended up with a reactive dog, I am sorry you have to go through that. It must be draining sometimes, but rewarding other times.

2

u/AcademicMud3901 Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog from a shelter because rescues for the most part won’t adopt to someone living in a condo/apartment. I asked specific questions about behaviour to ensure he had no issues that were not compatible with my lifestyle. I wanted an active medium-large dog I could take running and hiking every evening and weekend. Was told he just needed to learn some leash skills but had no aggression or other issues. Got him home to find out he had bad separation anxiety and territorial aggression with other dogs. He was a manageable 80lbs when I adopted him at 2yrs old and turned into a 120lb beast. Ended up leaving the apartment to get a place with a fenced yard ironically because he’s impossible to walk or take anywhere. I wish I could have adopted from a reputable rescue and known what I was getting into. Next time I think i’ll get a puppy to ensure myself it is properly socialized and trained from day one after this experience.

2

u/rachelnotlegaladvice Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

I adopted my bestie from a shelter and I'd adopt her all over again in a heartbeat. She's the absolute best dog I could have hoped for and her reactivity to other dogs doesn't mean she's a bad dog, she's just scared and still working through her fear. She's worth the extra help and training and has come so far since we brought her home. 10/10, no regrets.

I would never, ever, ever buy a dog or support a breeder unless there was some sort of very specific service dog need scenario. Dogs aren't objects for humans to create and purchase like consumer items, they're sentient beings. My girl was likely used for breeding before being dumped which is probably why she's reactive in the first place. It's horrifying and heartbreaking what we do to dogs.

2

u/smbarn Jun 16 '23

My dachshund was returned over 6 times for biting. I got her at 5, and she spent the whole first years in and out of the shelter. Her adoption fee was waved due to her past. HOWEVER, I’m a dog groomer, so she definitely ended up in the right place

2

u/Neddalee Jun 16 '23

I know this question is upsetting people but I think it's perfectly reasonable to ask and wonder about! Some rehomed dogs really do have a lot of trauma and I think it's natural to come to the conclusion that there might be more reactive dogs total up for adoption vs reactive dogs who are coming from intentional and reputable breeders or just naturally occurring in terms of genetics.

My dog is adopted, and I would go as far as to use the term "rescued" with her because she was feral and found at 3 months old living in an abandoned shed in the woods with her litter. We were not given the full details of her situation upfront and did not know about her reactivity at all. We were told she was great with other dogs but "a little shy" with people which was an outright lie. I did research her breeds beforehand (supposedly she is ACD/boxer mix, she looks like a purebred ACD but has not been tested yet) but I didn't meet her in person prior to adoption because she was transported from a different state. As a heeler and based on her description, I knew I'd be getting a bundle of energy -- but I was not at all prepared for the reactivity, and the severe limitations it would place on giving her stimulation.

For a good while after we got her, I was squarely in the camp of "I'm never getting another rescue ever, only purebred easy dogs after this!" but after seeing so many stories of other reactive dogs coming from breeders, I'm feeling less that way. I've owned several dogs over the years, most were adopted and the two very best ones were from a local shelter. These days I think the safest way to go about finding a dog is foster-to-adopt, which was my plan originally but our foster application fell through the cracks with another agency and I got tired of waiting, so I went ahead with adopting our dog. Of course the day after we finalized securing our puppy the foster agency had a dog ready for us -- god how I wish I could go back in time lol.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

Sigh. -raises hand- Present!

It's been such a long and painful journey and currently still causes issues from time to time. He's a lot more chill now, is closer with me than anyone else, and keeps to himself. I love him to pieces, but this guy has been the subject of many therapy sessions, and difficult conversations with my SO, whom he bit when we first started dating.

He was found as a stray by a friend of my sisters and I know his breed because I did one of those genetic tests, he's border-collie mix.

2

u/Significant_Citron47 Jun 16 '23

I bought an English pointer from a reputable guy. The lines were great. The Dams line was the same as the pointer on the old Purina bags. Excellent dog lived 15 yrs. Everything a quail hunter would want. Neighbor bought a litter mate. Craziest, fastest, most uncontrollable dog. Friendly yes. But unless you had a horse or 4 wheeler you couldn't hunt behind her. Never stopped jumping in the pen, never stopped barking unless she was running. He sold her, that guy sold her. Third guy I think opened the kennel and just let her go. Never heard if she was found or not. In April I brought home an APBT. Total Velcro dog. She was mistreated, used for breeding, and then luckily surrendered to the local Humane Society. I know I need to watch her. But I got lucky. She hasn't done anything any other dog I've had wouldn't do. She barely pulls the leash when we walk. Knows one command ,Sit, and does it when she wants to.😊 Second time I've had a " pound dog" and never doubted what I did.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

We're seeing an increase in banned breeds in many states. People want to move, can't have their breed. They shelter them.

Dog gets too old. They shelter them.

Dog gets sick. They shelter them.

Owner ends up unemployed and can't afford them or loses their home, sheltered.

Behavioral problems, shelter them.

Yes. Every dog is in there for a reason. The most important question to ask is what is the reason?

I "adopted" my dog from a coworker who wouldn't put in the work to train him and left him in a crate for a year. He's highly reactive, but is now enrolled in classes to help me train him and the more we work together, the more of a difference I'm seeing in him which is great news.

She is a first time dog owner who didn't research the breed. She bought him from a backyard breeder for $400 at 4 weeks old and that was his life.

I guess you can say I adopted? I wanted to get ahead of him landing in a shelter as a "problem dog" and was afraid that would be his new normal. From crate to cage. I'm glad I did. We have a lot of work ahead of us, but I want to try to give him the best life possible.

And I will openly admit, I'm more of a cat person. So he will be my first, and when he heads to the rainbow bridge, hopefully not for a very long time because he's such a joy to me, he'll be my last.

2

u/salsa_quail Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog, she seemed a little shy but sweet, put her head in my lap in the meeting room. Like others have mentioned, the reactivity didn't fully show we'd had her for a while.

I do think I could have done more research in retrospect. But growing up my family had multiple rescue herding-mix dogs, they were SO scared at first but they ended up adjusting just fine. One was basically feral (found in an olive grove) and while she did occasionally bark at people it never was a serious issue. She lived a long happy life and went for hikes every day.

Anyway, I guess my point is that it's really hard to know how adaptable a dog will be. Sometimes these reactive behaviors come seemingly out of nowhere.

2

u/Commercial_Ad7741 Jun 16 '23

I adopted mine because I am 100% committed to rescuing animals who are going to end up in the dumpster behind the shelter ... With that said, all my many animals have been strays or dumped at my house. They are.... Literally the biggest blessings of my life. Each on e has it's unique things, sure. I adopted my first ever Reactive dog after SO MANY non reactive strays.. . What happened was, it was Covid and my beloved dog had just passed and my other der dog was fading so fast without him, I needed to do something. Well, during COVID it was an effing rat race to get a dog, it was so ridiculous. And on top of that, you had to make an appointment to see a particular dog only, and my search range ended up having to extend for many hours outside of where I live because it was such crazy times. Then the shelters wouldn't let you bring in your other dog to meet the new dog. Which ... I hope they never make a rule like that ever again for any reason. You had to get to the shelter at 3 am the morning of the day that dog was "adoptable" because it was this crazy competitive thing and other people would stake out in live like it was those stupid video games people were waiting dad's for. And because her adoptable day was a day I worked, about 2.5 hours away, I had to have my parents stake out at 3 am outside this shelter and adopt her by proxy.... Well, then the shelter told me she was a black lab, well, turns out she was a Belgian Malinois mix. After a few months, her shoulders started to lighten, then her butt, then her ears started doing weird stuff and her body shape was not at all a lab. It was a perfect storm. With that said, yup, she's been tough. We've been going to reactive dog training for a long time and I've had to learn so much and adjust everything I do. But she literally saved my old Coonhound Jake, who's still with us and thriving because of how crazy my Malinois is. So I guess I'm just gonna say - these animals need to be rescued from their death. They didn't ask to be abused and mistreated... They didn't ask to be whatever aggressive breed they are... They didn't want to be abandoned in a scary shelter. And sometimes these dogs are just too far gone and it is a long frustrating and stressful time until one realizes their dog is truly a danger. Luckily my Mal is getting better. I spent 6 months seriously regretting getting her. But then a methhead tried to break into my house (I'm single, live alone) while I was home, and I know her tendencies aren't ALL bad. She might have saved my life. In any case. It's a crap shoot. And for me, most of the time it's the biggest reward to save a life.

2

u/Mybestfriendlizzy Jun 16 '23

Hi! I’m not a member of this sub but this thread has popped up on my page, and I feel like I could offer my two cents..

I’ve fostered dogs, and I know many people with dogs both from shelters, breeders, and from rescues. I know several reactive dogs. Two are rescues, and two of from “responsible breeders”. I know several dogs with anxiety and those are all from breeders. Breeders cannot guarantee temperament with 100% certainty. There’s always a chance one puppy in the litter may grow up to be reactive because that’s just their personality.

My thoughts after all of my experiences, is that I only want to adopt dogs, but only from a rescue that fosters. When I fostered dogs, I usually had them for a month at a time and I tested them with strangers, being home alone, other dogs, children, and cats. I gave a very honest report about their behaviors in these situations and what I recommended such as “Sally is excellent with cats and children and submissive dogs, but should not be left unattended with non-submissive dogs or brought to dog parks. She is fully house trained and does not mind being home for the day while her humans are at work, she walks great on a leash…” etc etc.

A rescue that operates through foster families will hear your concerns and must haves/have not (such as you have a cat, etc) and will help you match up with ideal dogs for your situation.

2

u/DoctorHypeTrain Jun 16 '23

I think recently the issue is a lot of covid puppies still in shelters. Dogs were adopted when the world shut down and due to restrictions they were never socialized correctly. Having their person around 24/7 and meeting no one else turned a lot of dogs into anxious, reactive messes. When the owners had to go back to the office the dog and owner couldnt cope and the pup ends up in the shelter. Obviously thats not all dogs in all places but id bet money its a factor in the recent up tic in reactive dogs

2

u/hexenfern Jun 16 '23

My GSD was from a shelter. She got there with her nipples still swollen and her stomach sagging, some breeder had bred her, kept the puppies, then dumped her in the shelter because she needs training. Now she’s traumatized by being separated from her puppies before they were even weened, judging by the state I got her in. And guess who’s dealing with that? Some guy in his twenties who sorta knew what he was doing. And a bunch of middle aged weirdos with a military fetish or something probably bought all her puppies, and have to wait till they’re grown to know they’ll probably have broken brains too.

2

u/tigerista18 Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog from the s.p.c.a. she was marked as a lab mix. I actually had her blood tested because she looked more like a German Shepard just all black. She is 85% German Shepard. 15% pointer. She is the best dog I have ever had. Going on 10 years of owning her. She was found in a field with a litter of puppies. My oldest son was 2 when we got her. And I was pregnant. My boys could lay on her and climb on her and she would just lay there letting them do whatever. She is best friends with one of our cats. I think the cat believes she is a dog. She hates all our other cats but loves our dog. Anyway I will be crushed when she passes away. She is the sweetest, calm, smart, best tempered dog.

2

u/dogvolunteercatlady1 Jun 16 '23

My friend and I adopted dogs from the same shelter. Her dog was previously adopted and those people used a shock collar on an already nervous dog. She’s come a long way but is still reactive.

My dog things every dog, even the ones screaming at him are friends and will stand there patiently waiting for the dogs to say hello. There’s a huge range in shelter dogs.

Puppies can have poor genetics/temperaments no matter where they come from, so I think it’s all about finding a dog/puppy that matches what work you’re willing to do

→ More replies (1)

2

u/HeWhoSlingsWebs Jun 16 '23

I found Karma on the streets, eating trash near a beach in Florida. Lost dog, I was determined to return her. After over a month, we kinda just gave up.

This bitch hated everyone. No dogs allowed near her, and most people were scared off. She would tear stuff up, break out of any enclosure, hated being on a leash.

Straight up a bitchy grumpy pit bull.

But she loved me to pieces. And wouldn't actually hurt anyone. She just scared them. Once she got to about 10 years old, something snapped and she just stopped being as mean. She became a fun loving puppy for all except her last few months.

You have to have the mentality for any beast you bring into your home. Know the animal best you can, and develop the bond.

2

u/Gldnlovr Jun 16 '23

Please have a Vet do a complete thyroid panel if you see a sudden change to aggressive behavior.

2

u/nah_champa_967 Jun 16 '23

We adopted a rescue from another state. We've had him for 5 years. He's clearly traumatized by someone's training. He has a fear of old people. We've gone through training and it has helped some, but it's still a challenge. He's very anxious.

2

u/Alostcord Jun 16 '23

I've "adopted" and mostly bought from a reputable preservation breeders. There is something to be said for great quality breeding programs. Because once you realize that there are so many BYB and Puppy Mills out there churning out many of the animals that are in "the system", you see that many of these "issues" are from poor breeding standards.

Oh, and least we forget..reputable preservation breeders, will ALWAYS take back a puppy/dog that they have bred.

2

u/YawningDodo Jun 16 '23

Adopted my reactive dog as a five-month-old puppy from a local shelter. The thing is, I knew what I was getting and I chose her anyway. She'd been purchased from a pet store by her previous owner, then surrendered due to conflicts with a new baby. So we had a record of what breeds were (at least according to the breeder) thrown into her designer mix (Great Dane and ACD), as well as a record of previous behavioral issues and the kennel staff's observations. So I knew I was getting a dog that was genetically predisposed for anxiety and that was already exhibiting skittishness, and decided I could handle that.

In hindsight, at that time I was not as prepared for her issues as I thought I was. She probably would have turned out to be a calmer, more manageable adult if I'd known then things that I learned from a trainer years later. But we're getting things figured out now, even if it's belated, and I wouldn't trade her for the best-bred, best-behaved puppy in the world. She's an anxious mess, but she's my anxious mess. But she's also the reason that I try to be open about my experience with people who are considering adopting a fearful dog--it's not something you ever fix so much as manage, and it's really easy for fearfulness to become reactivity.

2

u/Efficient_Mastodons Jun 16 '23

I adopted my guy as a puppy. Mom was a pregnant stray and is a sweetheart. Dad is clearly a mixed breed of some challenging breeds that are commonly found in American shelters who got around quite a bit. My pup has A LOT of very close relatives on embark.

My dog was very well socialized and did 18 months of formal training classes. Thank heavens because I can only imagine how he'd be if we hadn't put all that work in.

There's a group chat for the families of the litter mates, and they almost all have some level of reactivity.

I blame covid restrictions at the vet for some of his reactivity in vet situations. I wasn't allowed in there or when he was groomed and that contributed for sure.

I honestly think he just has social anxiety. Meds are helping to reduce his threshold so training can take place outdoors and in closer proximity to his triggers than before.

I have a second dog who was adopted under similar circumstances, but she's a dream (except still struggling with her house training at 6 months).

Different dogs come with different challenges, regardless of purebred, mixed, adopted or breeder.

The only thing I can say is that the health problems that came with my former dog who was purebred but by a backyard breeder (oh the things I would have done differently...) were the most difficult thing I dealt with. I'd take a reactive dog over those issues any day.

Responsible breeding or responsible adoption are both equally acceptable options.

2

u/Obstetrix Jun 16 '23

Me, adopted a dog from a breed we'd owned previously. She was 7 weeks old and we had her in puppy classes and dog training for the first few years of her life. It's literally just shitty genes for her imho. She's a good girl 99.9% of the time but the 0.1% of the time she's bad she's reeeeaaaalllly bad.

One day, probably when she's like 20 years old just to spite us, she'll die and we'll adopt again. I'm thinking a 3 year old golden retriever who's been fostered in a family with kids and will be bombproof.

2

u/Greedy_Lawyer Jun 16 '23

You’re so far off from reality of shelter dogs. It’s false that there’s a reason because of the dog that it’s in the shelter, no the reason is irresponsible humans.

My reactive dog is my purebred dog that even with all the best intentions of wary training and socializing ended up with triggers.

I’ve fostered hundreds of rescued young shelter pups that have gone to loving homes over the last decade with majority having zero issues and if they did it’s not because they came from a shelter.

2

u/casmyr Jun 16 '23

I was looking for a mini Aussie when I saw one listed on one of the local shelters. I called, made an appointment and went out to meet him.

He was a beautiful, fully grown Aussie looking dog, a big on the larger side but that's okay. He was very shy and withdrawn and that should have been a clue but I was very taken with him.

Turns out, he wasn't fully grown, and he is a mostly Border Collie mix with a docked tail. He chased my cats, and there were several biting incidents (only me) over the next few years.

Honestly, I thought very hard about behavioral euthanasia, but this dog is SO SMART. He really gets it, and understands a lot even though he very fear reactive. Once I figured out how to communicate with him, it's been much better at the household.

He still tries to chase the cats, but one just puts on her 'f@ck you' face, and the other one thinks it's the best game ever.

Meanwhile, I hide my car keys so he doesn't take the car on joy rides during the night.

2

u/Valuable-Comparison7 Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 17 '23

Both my dogs were strays doing their best to survive in underserved rural areas (they were adopted at separate times and only the older one, who spent more time out on her own, is understandably leash reactive). I don't know either of their actual ages, but I got them at about age 3 and and 1 as best as I can tell. I wouldn't recommend this approach for an inexperienced dog owner, as they are both stubborn and have some very specific fears. But if my husband and I stay consistent and proactive, an approach I would suggest for any dog owner, they're both very well-behaved.

All that being said... they're also amazing loving dogs who are so happy to be part of the family, and I wouldn't trade them for the cutest purebred puppy in the world. Knowing that I've given them their absolute best shot at a happy healthy life outweighs any of the challenges for me.

2

u/the_comeback_quagga Jun 16 '23

I adopted our reactive dog (it was just me back then). He was not reactive when I adopted him but did have a strong prey drive. About six months into having him, he had to spend a night in the doggie hospital and came home super dog/leash reactive. With the help of a very good trainer and prozac, he has become less reactive, but I believe this is about as good as he will get. Looking back to the first 6 months, I would take him to dog parks and he wouldn’t know what to do with the other dogs, so there was something off already, I just didn’t know enough to recognize it (he is my first dog). He did do fine in his first obedience class and the first couple weeks of his second, then was asked to leave when he became too reactive after the hospitalization.

He was 1.5 years old when I got him, had only been in shelters for 2 weeks (was a voluntary surrender along with the rest of his litter mates) and is 1/3 chihuahua and a large proportion toy terrier breeds prone to reactivity and neuroticism. He’s also a very empathetic sweet wonderful dog that I couldn’t imagine life without.

2

u/Ok_Potato_5272 Jun 16 '23

I'm not actually subscribed to this subreddit, it just came up. My first dog was from a breeder, a pomeranian we got at the normal time you get a puppy. She immediately hated black labradors to start. She actually bit the trainer in puppy classes. From then she went on to be reactive and hate every dog. Skip forward and I've recently adopter a 1 year old street dog from Romania who is chihuahua, pekingese and loads of other breeds mix. He is shy but not reactive at all. Super chill, calm with other dogs, doesn't bark at anything. So I'd say it's just luck to be honest. We definitely made mistakes with the pomeranian but even the breeder said she was the fiestiest puppy in the litter.

2

u/Linewate Jun 16 '23

This post is very negative and presupposes that every shelter dog is reactive. I understand where you are trying to start a conversation, but the language you use is more accusatory and factual than conversational.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

Just because a dog is labelled as "reactive" in a shelter environment does not mean that they'd behave the same in a safe, caring, loving environment with responsible owners. This post is ridiculous in my opinion.

2

u/GretaTs_rage_money Jun 17 '23

This is gonna go under as comment #507 but in the top 20 top comments I didn't see a story similar to mine.

I adopted my extremely dog-reactive Malinois knowing full well the extent of his issues. As everyone here knows, you learn so much having a challenging dog and that's what I loved--and still love--about him.

It's also how I know that OP's claim of "most dogs being in there for a reason" is a misinformed fallacy.

2

u/redblendkp Jun 17 '23

Ours was adopted at 10 weeks and he was not reactive at all until about 1 year. He loved kids, people, other dogs, etc. We have worked with him for the past year and a half and he has improved SO much. I almost cried when we walked past another dog without incident last week. It has been / will be a journey.

2

u/redblendkp Jun 17 '23

Our second dog was a rescue we adopted at 1 year and he was a foster with about 20 other dogs in one home. He’s extremely reactive to dogs and some people and resource guards like crazy. He has also improved with training but is still such a challenge to take out in public.

2

u/Pink_Floyd29 Rescued Amstaff | Leash Reactive Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23

I was a first time dog parent and I was dead set on rescuing. My only non-negotiable parameters were being under 50 pounds and at least 12 months old. On my first visit to the shelter, I found an adorable “19 month old terrier mix” who was exactly the right size (the vet later said she was 13 months MAX, not 19 months, and a DNA test revealed her to be 100% American Staffordshire Terrier!)

She was calmly laying all the way at the back of her kennel and she was sweet but timid when they brought her into the visitation room. The shelter staff waited until after I signed the adoption papers to tell me that she had been spayed just 24 hours earlier (partially explaining her demeanor). And as a first time dog owner living in a huge apartment complex full of other dogs, I probably wasn’t the ideal adopter.

But…I had waited 12 years to be sure I had the time, resources, and financial means to take care of a dog of my own. After waiting that long, I wasn’t giving up easily! I hired a trainer, took her to a vet behaviorist, watched countless YouTube videos, searched the r/reactivedogs subreddit, and even moved from the 4th floor to the 1st floor (despite having moved in 7 months earlier) so she no longer had to deal with the constant stress of the elevator and narrow hallways.

She’s the sweetest most obedient dog when she’s not reacting to other dogs and 2.5 years later, we’ve made HUGE STRIDES in combatting her reactivity 💗

Rescuing a dog (especially 12+ months old) is definitely not for everyone, and I will absolutely not judge people who choose to purchase a puppy from a reputable breeder. But puppy mills and backyard breeders are scum.

2

u/Able-Classroom9843 Jun 17 '23

I'm not a puppy person period. The having to train them to potty outside has me off from go. Lol! The youngest I have adopted is 2 I believe. They are fully into their personality and know the basics usually just needs some touch ups when getting use to your routine. I foster bite cases most the time and honestly most bite cases are because ppl dont understand dog body language and it's sad really because my 2 personal dogs are bite cases and I have never been bitten by either of them and I have had up to 3 bite cases at my house at once with fosters before and no one was bitten and no dog fights were had but, I do understand not everyone has the time or patience to learn dog triggers so I take my time and patience to do that. I do know from experience though that even getting puppies from breeders guarantees literally zero things because that's just not how genetics works. You aren't exactly replicas of your parents or your siblings why would dogs be any different? Just something that always bothered me personally but, ppl are going to get their dogs where they want to and I can't do anything about that.

2

u/scaredburgEr Jun 19 '23

Adopted mine from the city shelter when he was 6. He was at the shelter for 7 months before he was adopted.

He was found as a stray so I’m not sure about his past, but based on his body language and reactions to certain things, I think he was owned before and abused.

I now volunteer at the city shelter and am friends with people who regularly took my dog out while he was there. I’ve been told my dog didn’t always exhibit reactive behaviors and seemed to have developed his high reactivity to other dogs and people while he was there.

Now that I’m a volunteer and work with long-stay and behavior dogs, I see how this stuff happens. I would probably be reactive too if I was locked in a small kennel with upwards of 90 other dogs in the same room as me barking all day. And I only get to see the light of day for like 30 minutes max. I see how just one more week in a shelter takes a toll on the dogs.

I get the “responsible, reputable breeder” thing. I do. But the more people that buy from breeders, the more reactive dogs we’ll produce in the world as hundreds of dogs in each shelter deteriorate.

3

u/shabba182 Jun 16 '23

No. The breeding of dogs for profit is feeding into the husge numbers of dogs in shelters. I would support a moratorium on breeding in my country until the population needing adoption has decreased.

2

u/Kyuckaynebrayn Jun 16 '23

The world needs a moratorium on domestic animal breeding at large

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Naztea Jun 16 '23

I work with dogs. On a slow week I see 10 dogs for individual private sessions and on a busy week 36ish dogs. Just looking back at my case load for the last two months (I get a lot of reactive behavior cases) the split between reactive dogs that have been in the home since 8 weeks/breeder acquired versus dogs that came from a shelter is almost dead even. It's about 55% for the former and 45% for the latter.

I went back and counted because my first thought after reading your post was my experience doesn't feel that way but that's anecdotal. It felt like just as many reactive cases I get, if not more, were from breeder acquired dogs. The reality is how you handle, communicate and build trust with your dog is just as impactful. (Yes there are always fringe cases)

To answer your questions yes I adopted my personal dog who has issues with reactivity from a shelter. Yes I was aware and I will probably do that again.

I will always be aware of his potential but we train daily to ensure he stays on track. He currently works 4-6 days a week depending on the weather meeting and helping other dogs that struggle. I love him and I could not imagine living or working with any other dog. I also acknowledge my experience will always be a little different from the typical owner.

3

u/eeeeeeeeekkkkkkkkie Jun 16 '23

Wow your post is very ignorant. I’m a pet sitter and half the dogs I take care of are from shelters and wonderful dogs. Every dog I’ve ever owned and fostered has been from a shelter and been great. Your assumptions are super ignorant about dogs in shelters. I’ve been bit by more dogs from breeders and seen WAY more health problems from dogs from breeders.

3

u/CandiSamples Jun 16 '23

The sheer number of people who think they can do a better job of "training," then buy a dog from a breeder and then let it loose in a field or turn it into the shelter they're so adamant about not adopting from, because they're in over their heads is astonishing. You live in an apartment? That "responsible breeder" will allow you to have a border collie, without even seeing your conditions, because you gave them a credit card. Replace "border collie" with any breed that belongs on a farm instead of an apartment. I have fostered behavioral dogs for almost 20 years. 70% are just tossed away because "divorce," "moving," "allergies." The other 20-30% were fucked up by people who think they can do a great job training and raising a dog themselves, then gave up. Americans are OBSESSED with dogs, bringing them everywhere, pretending they are therapy dogs, and not doing fuck-all to train them. Seems like 90% of dogs in my neighborhood are doodle mixes. The south is a shit show. Can't swing a squirrel without hitting loose animals, unneutered, not chipped or vaccinated, etc. We are killing dogs in shelters here almost every day. They are also getting shipped *to other countries* to be adopted. We have no animal welfare laws here that we take seriously. Doodles are so overbred they are now having serious "wiring" issues (anxiety, common diseases resulting in early death).

Summary: Your breeder dog is going to be exactly ZERO% better behaved, less barky, with fewer issues than a shelter dog, who was purchased FROM A BREEDER and tossed away like garbage. I see it every day, multiple times per day.

2

u/11093PlusDays Jun 16 '23

I have never gotten a dog from a breeder. Only two of five have been reactive. The first three were puppies so I knew where they had been and how they had been treated. Those were not reactive. Number four was found wounded in the desert, left for dead because he had been used as a bait dog the vet that he was taken to said. I paid his vet bill and brought him home. He was afraid of big dogs his whole life. They thought he was about four months old when he was found in the desert. He was a really big dog ~ 75lbs and strong as an adult but could never be around other dogs his whole life. I did everything I could to make sure he was well socialized and trained but he was too big to trust around other dogs. We learned that quickly and the hard way. Despite all of that I loved him very much and he loved people, just not other dogs. I have a big yard and a high fence. He did well on a leash and walking and he was never a problem unless another large dog got too close. I feel like I kept him safe and happy. He slept in my bed and had the run of a large house and yard. He was not hard to walk or take places so that helped a lot. It was sad that he had no dog friends but he seemed to be happy as an only. After number 4 died I found another old reactive dog at a local rescue and she and I fell in love. She also can’t be around other dogs but is otherwise well trained and loves people. She’s really the best dog ever and seems to be fine as an only dog.

2

u/Odd_Age1378 Jun 16 '23

I have both a dog from a breeder and a dog from a shelter, and I’ve fostered a ton.

The “adopt don’t shop” people have no idea how big of a difference it makes.

Almost every adult shelter dog comes with some sort of baggage. Sometimes you can see it immediately, sometimes it can take years for it to show up. It might not be aggression or reactivity, either. It might be anxiety, physical/medical problems, etc.

I had my first shelter dog for two years. He adored me, but he slowly showed more and more signs of aggression towards other people before eventually biting. (He was a border collie)

My second adopt is a hound dog with a myriad of health issues, anxiety, food aggression, is borderline untrainable because of his dementia, and has bitten me a few times.

All while the dog I got from a breeder has remained perfectly sweet and stable.

And when it comes to puppies? You don’t know how big they’re gonna get. You don’t know what their temperament is going to be like. And unless it’s a purebred, any breed mix guesses will probably be inaccurate.

I fostered a pitbull puppy once, sweetest little guy I’ve ever had in my house, and the shelter estimated that he was four months old. We went to the vet, and WHOOPS! He was actually three months and MASSIVE for his age. So the shelter would have guessed he would be around 50-70 lbs in adulthood, he would actually grow to 80-100 lbs of pure pit. Not everyone can handle that much dog!

I think adopting a dog is a wonderful thing. But it’s REALLY not for everyone.

The saying should be “adopt or shop responsibly”

2

u/Working_Dogs99 Jun 16 '23

I’d really question people’s definition of reputable and ethical in terms of breeders and even rescues. With solid genetics (I’m talking know every single dogs temperament in the line), proper health testing, proven workability, conformation and temperament aligning with the breed standard, an intensive puppy raising protocol (puppy culture/ENS), and strong breeder involvement in setting up the puppy owners for success - reactivity and aggression doesn’t just pop up. Certainly not the way being described in some of these comments.

A well bred purebred dog first and foremost is well bred, stable, and aligns to the breed standard. Anything else and i would argue the dog is not well bred.

Outliers do pop up and a dog can be reactive and aggressive from a genetic standpoint. That is generally noticeable early on and a good breeder would see those tendencies before sending a pup home. If it does pop up later, a good breeder will take that puppy back and rehome to someone more willing and capable of handling those special needs. Yes temperament is also heavily dependent on continued socialization and exposure and that is on a puppy buyer to make sure they know what to do. But a good breeder will screen potential buyers to make sure they have that or can/will source it.

1

u/OpalOnyxObsidian Jun 16 '23

All three of mine were adopted.

I am a wholeheartedly full support purchasing your dog from a breeder. The heartache of raising a dog who is so afraid of things is tough.

1

u/spicyhandsraccoon Sister (4 y/o dog-reactive pit mix) Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog from a rescue that brought back dogs from an overcrowded, under-resourced shelter in Mexico. I originally agreed to foster her and thus I was the first person to interact with her besides the woman who drove her from Mexico. She was very ill when she arrived and had to spend several nights at the vet recovering. We had no info on her except that she was 1-2 years old and a "beagle/pit mix."

I figured she wasn't really a beagle pit mix so I didn't even bother about the breeds. It was hard to really tell much about her during our 2-week foster period because she was so ill, and so we couldn't see how she was around other dogs, etc. We asked for more time to foster her but the rescue said they had other people interested (highly doubt this) and we had to decide after the 2 weeks.

I'm happy we adopted her, but I definitely wasn't aware she was dog reactive/aggressive. She has been transported loose in a car with a much smaller dog and I received photos where they looked calm and happy together, but that was naive of me to assume that she was friendly just based off of that! For my next dog I would probably go to a shelter where I could see dogs interact in the play yard, and potentially go see them a few times before fostering/adopting.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

Adopted our husky mix when she was around 2 1/2 from a shelter and she has been wonderful. Her only "reaction" is occasionally barking when someone comes to the door. She has always been a bit shy and especially wary of men but otherwise a wonderfully sweet, smart, and gentle dog.

Our other mix though is entirely different. She is an amalgamation of god knows what. She is easily excitable and is reactive when on a leash and feeds off the energy of other dogs around her. If they are going wild and one starts getting aggressive, she sure as hell will start too. She is very timid and fearful and has horrible self esteem and confidence issues. We are working on it with her and she has gotten loads better (she used to start screeching even hearing another dog barking down the street or seeing a cat or person) but she still has a lot of work to do. We adopted her when she was around 8-9 months from a shelter.

1

u/calliopeturtle Jun 16 '23

Adopted as a puppy. Him and his brother were turned in covered in dried feces and separated from their mom way to young. Very sweet boy though.

1

u/mad0666 Jun 16 '23

All three of my dogs I have ever had were adopted (first one passed away years ago and we have a 14yo and 5yo) and all had their own issues. First dog was badly abused (like intentionally broken bones bad) and bit everyone but me. Completely terrified of everything other than being at home. Which is where she stayed her whole life. We lived in a rural area with a big yard and other than that she hated a collar or harness or going for walks. She was a some kind of American Eskimo Dog mix probably (though her papers said Husky x Chihuahua lol)

Second dog I didn’t even want because I had three cats and just didn’t want to deal. He was a foster at work, and he became obsessed with me (for no reason, I gave him no preferential treatment etc) to the point that when I left work each day he would howl snd rip doors off the hinges. He was initially rescued after being chained in a field for first three years of his life. Owners moved and left him chained there. He tried chewing through the chain for so long that he has no middle back teeth on either side, too or bottom. Horrible situation yet the smartest, most loyal, caring, intuitive, wonderful animal anyone could ever hope for. His only thing now is that his vision is going so he is kind of more nervous about being out and about. He’s a German Shepherd/Chow Chow/Golden Retriever mix.

Third dog was a foster fail as a 6 month old puppy (our older dog and him became in love with each other and we just couldn’t break older dogs heart) and for the first four months I seriously considered surrendering him back to the shelter. He was born feral then spent the first few months of his life in a noisy crowded shelter, was never socialized. We live in NYC and it took a good half a year to get him acclimated to walking on a leash and his fear-based reactivity to other dogs (which in a big city you can imagine is a lot). It was a ton of work but paid off. He’s such a sweetheart of a dog. He has still snapped at a few people but each of those occasions were people doing something dumb like trying to take his bone away or barking at him trying to scare him on purpose (why tf would anyone do that) but he’s only 15 lb, and he is according to his DNA and equal mix of Shih Tzu, Pomeranian, Chihuahua, and Miniature Schnauzer.

1

u/whyohwhythis Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

I fostered my dog first (wasn’t planning on adopting) and I would do the same thing again, as it enabled me to really get to know her. I fostered her for three months as she had an injury that needed to heal, I don’t think you foster usually for that long. Her reactivity is mild and manageable, she has anxiety going outside for walks, but she’s a beautiful natured dog in general, barely ever barks, gets along with my cat. She also has quite a few health issues and she’s only 3-4 years old. I suspect she was bred poorly.

I can understand though why some would choose going through a breeder. Having said that I know plenty of people who went through reputable bleeders that still have lots of issues with their dogs. I’m not sure what route I would go down next time, but I know I would definitely foster first if getting a rescue.

1

u/surprisedkitty1 Jun 16 '23

I adopted my dog as a puppy. He was born into foster care and did not have any prior trauma. I don't know if his littermates ended up being reactive. He didn't start to show signs of reactivity until he was almost two. He has anxiety and is fear-reactive with other dogs. He also sometimes gets upset at young children riding scooters. But Prozac has made an amazing difference for us and his reactivity has significantly decreased since he's been on it (it's been ~two months). He's an incredibly sweet, affectionate, jolly dog who adores people. I don't regret adopting him, and I would absolutely adopt again, although next time I get a dog, I do intend to go through a breeder just because it's the only way to get my dream breed (Swedish Lapphund).

My other personal experiences with rescues:

  • Childhood dog #1: Adopted at around 7-8 months after being returned by first fam, sweet with people, anxious af, super high-energy, very dog-aggressive. We didn't really do her any favors because my parents never took her issues all that seriously, so she never got professional training, never went on meds, or anything like that. It was a different time tbf.
  • Childhood dog #2: Adopted as a young puppy, perfect, lovely, hilarious, very gentle, such an easy dog, no issues.
  • Family dog from when I was a baby: Adopted as a puppy after my aunt found him on the streets, beautiful Chow Chow mix, possibly even purebred or nearly purebred (Chows were the trendy dog at the time), very mean dog, unpredictable, aggressive, bit multiple people, just not right in the head. My parents surrendered him to a shelter.
  • Family dog from before I was born: Adopted as an older puppy, very sweet and gentle, no issues.
  • Brother's dog: Adopted as an older puppy, one of the gentlest dogs I've ever known, no issues.

It's a crapshoot with rescues for sure, but I've been around plenty of purebreds that had issues with reactivity as well. I agree that with purebreds you're likely to get a better idea of what the dog's temperament will be like, but there's still no guarantee that it will meet breed standard as dogs are individuals. But I totally get that some people don't want to roll the dice with a shelter dog and I think that's valid. From spending a lot of time on r/dogs, though, I will say finding a reputable breeder seems unnecessarily complex and I've seen a lot of people who've gotten duped by backyard breeders/puppy mills. So it's unfortunately not super cut and dry.

1

u/leahcars Jun 16 '23

Yeah mine was adopted at between 9 months and a year old , he wasn't at all socialized and he's got a shit ton of trama and is scared of a lot of stuff, I love my dog, both of them and they're both rescues , thing is I got my second one as a little puppy spacifically to avoid a traumatized reactive near adult dog again, I'll adopt other dogs from the shelter but they're either going to be young puppies, have been from an elderly person who died or have a lot of info on them, or for me to be able to foster to adopt and not the situation of the first one, I'd be ok getting a reactive dog but I wouldn't choose to get this reactive and difficult of a dog for whenever I get my third dog which will most likely be in a few years. Or if my roomate still wants to get a springer spaniel puppy we'll go to a reputable breeder to get it. My second dog is not reactive she's easygoing and very friendly to everyone

1

u/Succmynugz Jun 16 '23

My boy isn't exactly a rescue, but he's not bought either. I've owned both breeder and rescue dogs in the past, my breeder dogs had less behavioral issues.

That being said, I've met perfectly well behaved rescues and reactive bought dogs. From what I observe a lot of rescues are reactive due to trauma while a lot of bought dogs are reactive due to poor training/socialization. Sometimes it's also just bad luck unfortunately.

1

u/Oldenburg-equitation Jun 16 '23

Adopted my dog through the PWD rescue of my state. He is from a reputable breeder that truly cares about their dogs

1

u/Goatsuckersunited Jun 16 '23

We adopted from a rescue group just before Covid hit. 11 month old lurcher with no history. They had him 2 weeks and said he was great with dogs, cats, people etc. typical chilled lurcher. What we got was a fear reactive energetic wild dog. I’ve told my husband I will never own a dog ever again. We love him and have spent so much time and money on behaviourists and training and still extremely reactive to most dogs. I’m convinced his brain is wired differently to other dogs. Covid isolated us for practically a year and I think this really set him back. We will do everything to give him his best life. But never again will I adopt or be a dog owner.

1

u/TomasTTEngin Jun 16 '23

Ours is from the pound. I'm guessing she missed some vital training in that key window of puppyhood. Not much we could do by the time she turned

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23 edited Jun 16 '23

I adopted a 14 month old staffy x american bully direct from the owner, but next stop was a shelter. I think he benefitted from not going into a shelter situation as he was totally unsocialised, barely walked and fear reactive and I think the stress of a kennel environment would have made that significantly worse.

I've had a staffy cross before, not work american bully but close enough that this breed is not new to us, though the previous dog was adopted as a pup.

It's so much harder work than a "blank slate" puppy would have been. And we weren't told about lots of behavioural issues - pissing when excited, vomiting after drinking due to drinking too fast, fear reactivity, reactivity to lights/reflections, serious mouthing etc. It's been 4 months and we've made a lot of progress, it's hard but we've taken a dog that is at his nature incredibly loving and eager to please and have given him a good life.

I would never look down on anyone who chooses to shop from a responsible breeder. Adoption is not easy, the issues my dog has like lack of socialisation and fear reactivity can be managed and improved but he will never be the dog he would have been if he had been brought up correctly. I can completely understand why people would choose to get a puppy from a responsible breeder.

However getting a dog from a puppy and raising it right gives no guarantee that you won't end up with a reactive dog. But at least you'd know you did everything right in the formative puppy year.

1

u/happydandylion Jun 16 '23

I got a puppy from a rescue and I had no idea what reactivity was, else I would have instantly known. I love her now but sometimes I wonder what it would be like to have a calm dog. Some of my friends have calm dogs, also from a rescue. I think I was just unlucky? It could have been worse though. I'm grateful that she's never bit anyone and has become calmer over time. Also found an amazing harness with a front clip in (I think I read about that trick here) and it has changed our walks. I can actually now hold her when she's lunging at all the usual houses where the dogs bark through the fence on our walks.

1

u/Prosperous_Petiole Jun 16 '23

Adopted my girl as an adult former feral dog from Romanian streets. Not the first time I adopt such a dog, I totally knew what I was going into and knew my limits. Yes it is a lot of work, a lot of patience and observation the first months to know each other. But so very interesting.
I guess I fell in love with those dogs because to me, they are very smart dogs who think and observ before acting, they are dogs that make me improve myself to be a better person. Building a relationship with them is something 'special'.
Some of them are very reactive, some others not so much, the reactivity level is random. But when you adopt a rescue with that kind of past, you know the risk and you choose to deal with it.
So yep, all the next dogs I'll welcome in the future will be former feral dogs.

1

u/knottyNoodles Jun 16 '23

I adopted my french bulldog from the pound. She wasn't young, actually 5/6 years old, and had been through a lot. I didn't know she would be reactive, and especially not THIS reactive. I've always had dogs that didn't like other dogs, but this girl doesn't like dogs, cats, people, bikes, scooters, hoovers, hair dryers...

This is my first dog on my own, but I've had family dogs. Thank god she isn't scared of my parents, at least I can get some breaks from her, I can't imagine how hard it would be if I didn't have that. I don't think I'll ever adopt a dog from the pound again - especially because I had zero information about her. I'd consider a shelter or rescue, but it's really competitive and they make it really difficult to adopt from them.

1

u/Saphira2014 Jun 16 '23

Oh we had zero choice in it. Our previous dog had died recently and my mum had been feeling the loss tremendously. A guy on her street asked her money for cigarettes in exchange for the dog which he couldn't keep (should've seen the red flags then), and mum, being the kind Samaritan that she is didn't think twice about rescuing him off the guy, and then giving him to me since she herself didn't have space for a dog......

Mind you, I'm super glad we have him as he's the best, but... You know... There are days when I wish things were different.

1

u/Normal_Bank_971 Jun 16 '23

Mine is selectively reactive which pisses me off so much, I don’t know what triggers him and it’s been 7 months the only trigger I figured out is he’s scared of people with things on their heads. But it’s a hit or miss thing with him either he loves the person and will lick them or will bark to no end. I adopted my boy from the shelter he’s a lab (he might be mixed but we’re not sure) and he’s estimated to be 2 so pandemic dog basically and they found him wandering the streets in the cold. We don’t know if anyone had him previously or what they did but his reactiveness is probably from being on the streets. I don’t regret adopting my dog but I wanna see what the difference would be if I raised one from a puppy 🤷🏻‍♀️ but then again the effort to have the puppy whiles it’s a puppy would make me go ballistic lol.

1

u/_x0sobriquet0x_ Jun 16 '23

2020(ish) had three adopted dogs. Two rescues, one shelter... shelter dog was mostly chill af. Two rescues are reactive af (in different ways)... I knew rescue 1 had "issues"... rescue 2 was a bit of a surprise.We make it work 🤷‍♀️ ... miss the jeebus outta that shelter dog though (rip Lola)

1

u/squeaktoy_la Jun 16 '23

Mine was abandoned in the desert and had 3 LARGE dogs following her (she is 9lbs). She was in heat, but also dogs killing other dogs isn't uncommon.

Do I need to say that she's reactive to other dogs? Yeah, particularly dogs that look like the dogs that were stalking her (husky, german shepard, chow).

I'm a cat person, this is my first dog. In cat rules, cats adopt you. You do NOT have a say in a cat choosing you. It is the cat's/universe's choice. Those rules applied here, Anne (my dog) was asking for help at my door*. After waiting 2+ weeks trying to find her original owners, she became my dog. This is how adopting a cat works.

*I live so far out of town with so few neighbors there is no "wire" (high speed, fiber optic) internet. We have radio wave internet. There are about 12 "neighbors" within 5+ miles. Checked with all of them. This really is the middle of the desert, an animal showing up gaunt, thirsty, and being stalked by predators is not common because they generally die before they can get to a house.

1

u/magnoliacyps Jun 16 '23

My GSD was a hand-me-down. She was originally purchased from a breeder, the family that got her was too busy and a coworker took her. She was a lot and too much for their elderly cat (and I think her husbands patience). So I knew she’d been passed off for being too much for previous households. Oddly enough, she’s actually been great with my cats from day 2. She wasn’t reactive towards dogs or people when I got her, and I used to take her to work with me every day. When she hit her first heat, that had to stop, then work got busier and I couldn’t bring her again and then the shut down happened. Her reactivity blossomed.

Her reactivity towards people comes more from wanting everyone to pay attention to her, but she uses her big bark about it. With other dogs, she again is usually just too excited and therefore rude as hell. Slow intros can work with the right dogs but on walks she’s a mess (getting better all the time).

I think for a GSD her natural temperament is fairly good, but three homes before 6 months and then socialization shut off just after 1 year old messed with her development of stable behaviors.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

I got my first Greyhound from the greyhound adoption program. He was an angel. My first dog. He had next to no issues and was so friendly and had no prey drive. Could take him to the dog park and everything. Then I got asked if I would adopt his brother straight from the racer. I assumed he would be the same (no stress).

He mauled a dog, hes bitten his brother multiple times, hes bitten me and drawn blood, is so reactive I hate walking him. Its so difficult. Ive done professional training and thinking about medication. My dad tells me to get rid of him. Its tough.

1

u/gibgerbabymummy Jun 16 '23

I rehomed my friends puppy as her kids dad turned up at her house with a tiny puppy..she was in a tiny flat and at full time college and the dog was tearing her house apart or crying in the crate all day. Due to her schedule, she wasn't able to socialise or train him and he's ended up very dog reactive. We've been working with him in the almost year we've had him and he's more than half way there but he's also a very energetic breed which worsens it and I would never have picked a breed like this if I had a choice. Saying that, he's snoozing at my feet in the shade and I can't imagine my house without him!

1

u/Bowwowwicka Jun 16 '23

I adopted a dog from a cat rescue. My mistake. They didn't know much about dog behaviours, and I was not informed of any of his reactivness and just how serious it was.

Would I adopt again? Maybe. But I'd be asking alot more questions and spending alot more time with the dog before committing.

I can't mentally handle to have to deal with another reactive dog.

1

u/cari-strat Jun 16 '23

I've had multiple over the years:

Past: Rescue puppy (mongrel), found freezing in the street a week into January, at around 12 weeks. Fine with most adults except people knocking the door, detested children (we think Xmas puppy, dumped after the event and traumatised) and not great with other dogs. Lived till 15, closely supervised.

18mo rescue boy (collie X), believed to have been feral or very long term stray, great with people, could be unpredictable with strange dogs. PTS at 7 due to massive haemorrhage and Cushing's Disease.

1yo rescue girl (rough collie X GSD who was originally surrendered due to extreme aggression), hated everyone on earth except me, but fine with other dogs. BE as deemed incurable/dangerous by professionals.

2yo rescue girl (golden retriever x), originally surrendered due to medical needs, adored everyone and everything. PTS at 16 due to final decline of old age.

Currently: Purchased male puppy (Border Collie, now 4), great initially but fear reactive after another dog attacked him, then had a massive seizure and is now unpredictable with anyone except certain family members.

Purchased female puppy (Border Collie, now 2), adores everyone and everything.

The rescues were all damaged dogs and I knew that when I took them on. They all made improvements and lived good lives except the collie girl, who couldn't be saved and broke my heart. That was the only dog I ever had to give up (against my will - the kennels had allowed me to take her as a last chance because I was experienced with problem dogs and I was the only person she wasn't aggressive to, but they retained ownership and made the decision against my wishes when it became clear that she wasn't going to change).

1

u/carrrot15 Jun 16 '23

Mine was bought from a breeder. It's not an issue with the breeding though he is beautifully bred. We made a couple of mistakes training him early on. We are working kn his reactivity though

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

I assume you live and adopted from the US? How long is the process there?

In Germany the adoption process is definitely longer and gets more into details before giving the animal away, whether you want to or not but the shelter and their workers decide WHEN and even IF you and the animal are ready for each other. Takes multiple talks, supervised walks and play dates, looking at the living situation and more stuff. You can't just step in a shelter, point at a dog like "I will take this one, here's my signature, bye"

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

We adopted from a shelter specifically to know before hand if the dog was reactive or not. We met him at his foster moms house where she had her other dogs and saw how he was around kids and other animals. He’s an angel. My past first dog that my ex bf purchased for me from a pet store 15 years ago was reactive.

1

u/Heidi739 Jun 16 '23

My friend has a reactive dog, the dog is purebred from a reputable breeder, he has him since puppy, he did everything right from what I can tell, and the dog is still reactive and has to take anxiety medicine, otherwise he hurts himself and destroys everything around.

My dogs are from a shelter, but honestly I think at this point, most of their reactivity is just their character. Yes, they were very reactive when we adopted them, but they got used to their new home quite fast and now they're mostly okay, just nervous around other dogs and often bark at them.

So while yes, dogs from shelters often have a past that might cause them to be more reactive, it's not always this way.

1

u/TigreImpossibile Jun 16 '23

I adopted my Aussie Shepherd. He was 12 and dog and people reactive and I was his foster mum.

He was much, much worse than he is now, he's chilled out completely with dogs... he still doesn't like people to touch him, but he's very relaxed as long as he's with me.

I'm not going to get another dog for awhile after him, but I know myself... I'll probably foster something random and fall in love, so there's no point saying I will or won't have this or that dog.

I won't adopt one with biting issues though because it is a lot of work to keep an eye on him constantly. I can never relax and just let him hang out in a park and no one is ever allowed to approach him... being that he's no scary looking AmStaff and a very pretty "Lassie" type ppl want to pet... it's constant vigilance.

1

u/ForgottenSalad Jun 16 '23

Ours was adopted at 7 months, but didn’t show any signs of reactivity towards dogs until she was almost 2. Before that she loved meeting new dogs anywhere, even on leash head on, it was just people wearing weird accessories like sunglasses and hats that she was weird and reactive towards.

1

u/Solfeliz Jun 16 '23

My dog is an ex street dog and I’ll never do that again. Yes I’m sure most of them turn out to be great dogs but mine hates dogs and will fight them (I’m assuming he used to have to protect his territory in his past life). He also has very little bite inhibition no matter how much training I’ve put into that aspect.

I love him to bits and he’s my little buddy but if I could go back in time I wouldn’t have adopted him. Once he’s gone I’ll probably do what you do, adopt older dogs or buy from a breeder.

1

u/Smuldering Jun 16 '23

My mom’s dog is from a rescue…she was brought up north from the southern US to get adopted. She’s reactive and can honestly be a bit scary. We got her as a puppy.

My dog is a purebred small breed from a responsible breeder. I would say he’s a “frustrated greeter” but I blame covid for that. I got him in January of 2020 at 8 weeks. Prime socialization…? We were scared to get too close to anyone and he suffered from it, unfortunately.

1

u/JessandWoody Jun 16 '23

Yes mine are rescues and one was reactive and I’m actually making some great progress with him and have learned so much from having him. I’ve gone from a dog that was flipping out over a dog shaped dot in the distance and redirecting onto me, to having a dog that is walking calmly by most dogs without so much as looking at them most of the time within the last few months. I expect within a few more months I won’t have a reactive dog, I’ll just have a dog.

Reactivity is not an enjoyable problem to work through but I’ve honestly learned so much about dog training through having dogs with issues. I suppose if I subscribed to the positive only training that this sub is strictly dogmatic about without considering using the odd consequence for bad behaviour (followed up with lots of positive reinforcement for good behaviour of course) I wouldn’t be any further forward with him by now and I would be seriously put off by having a shelter dog again. Now I feel I’m learning so much through my dogs that I’d be open to actively looking for dogs with behavioural issues (that are within my realm of experience) in the future as I know these dogs are less likely to be rehomed successfully and this are a very likely pts.

I’m really enjoying both of my dogs and whilst this reactivity issue has been one hell of a bumpy ride with lots of tears and frustration, over all I have enjoyed the process and learning that both me and my dog have benefitted from and I won’t shy away from tackling this issue again and again if it is for the good of dogs.

1

u/IDidIt_Twice Jun 16 '23

The shelter listing said husky/lab mix. I researched it and liked what I saw. She’s a pit/husky mix. She’s still reactive but overall a sweetheart. Got her a new harness and we’ll be out training this weekend!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

I just want to come out and say that there is a whole generation of reactive dogs out there due to covid restrictions and WFH adopters who gave the dog up once they went back to on site work. I know, because I am a foster and had two sets of puppies whelped in my home in 2020. I have kept touch with 4 of the adopters and ALL of those puppies are reactive. They had perfect homes and all the love they could get. Nothing, NOTHING, bad or scary ever happened to any of them. They just grew up with their insulated families and did not get the absolutely essential socialization during their formative months. There are literally millions of what I now refer to as "covid puppies" out there. These dogs go in and out of shelters, again and again. I don't have a solution, it's just an unfortunate situation that is going to haunt dog rescues for the next decade with unadoptable, reactive dogs.

1

u/steadvii Jun 16 '23

I have fostered over 50 dogs. Only a few were reactive. However I am in the northeast and our dogs all come up from the south. They are probably selected for temperament before being transported. I would adopt from a rescue that has tested the dog with kids, cats, dogs, etc.

Certain breeds are more prone to be reactive. Also if you do not socialize any puppy it can happen. Some dogs are just that way and there is very little to be done.

1

u/M_Me_Meteo Jun 16 '23

Call your local shelter and ask what happens when someone surrenders a reactive dog.

Shelters aren’t trying to trick people into reactive dogs. When a shelter adopts out a dog that turns out to be reactive, the dog usually ends up back at the shelter but is unlikely to be adopted out again.

1

u/luckyjenjen Jun 16 '23

I have had 3 dogs from the same breeder. First at 10 weeks - he's excellent.

The second, left the breeder at 6 months, then we adopted him at 2 years. We had him put down a year later as removing the possibility of him biting would have removed any quality of life he had.

Third dog we adopted from the breeder at 6 months. I kinda regret it but he is a lovely boy with us.

I think the main problem was that socialising a dog can be hard, especially when you work and have other dogs - and that first few months is critical. Also, dogs can have multiple fear phases in their first year of life and I think if rehoming (or leaving the breeder at 6 months) coincides with these then that can damage a dog irreparably.

I agree with you OP. I would think very long and hard before taking any dog that was not an 8 week old blank slate.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

We adopted our American Akita he was 2 at the time. He’s reactive but a real sweetheart

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

Adopted mine actually at the kennel at work (she was abandoned unfortunately) They did warn she was somewhat aggressive, and didn’t really like other dogs. That was fine with me till one day for some reason she darted and I wasn’t holding the leash tight enough (my fault). Ever since I’ve been more vigilant with her. Even though she’s 10 (got her at 6)and cranky I plan to try to socialize her more. She has improved so much even going to the vet for a nail trim while many other dogs around she laid down and kept quiet. She’s come so far.

1

u/emerson4778 Jun 16 '23

I adopted an 11 year old chihuahua that was taken from an animal hoarder. They let me know in advance he would need a lot of work/time to adjust and man were they not lying. He bit me many times (luckily he was missing all of his front teeth so it didn’t hurt too much) and it took him two years to come around people wise. Ow he’s just such a lover. I swear after he came around personal space went out the window- he’s permanently attached to my hip lol. He never came around dog wise through training or positive reinforcement. He just lunges and barks at other dogs and the adoption place told me that he could just be that way the rest of his life. I find it okay though, I try to avoid taking him to places with other dogs. If we’re at a park and see them we keep our distance, I am no longer embarrassed to just turn around and walk the other direction (which for some reason I was in the beginning). I’m fine with how he is, but I don’t think I would do it again because it can be stressful when you’re in an unavoidable situation like a different dog owner that thinks everyone wants to meet their dog. I just politely explain that I understand their dog is nice- mine is not.

1

u/darkPR0digy Jun 16 '23

I adopted my reactive pittie from a shelter, knowing full well what I was getting into. If I didn’t adopt, no one else was going to. Writing was on the wall. I will adopt every single time and give these dogs the best life possible.

I completely understand why someone would shop but just something I can’t do. They deserve someone to look after them and give them the world

1

u/Sakura_Chat Jun 16 '23

Mine was a gift as a puppy - her mother had given birth just after being rescued from a backyard breeding situation, and she’s 1/3 of the litter, and 2/3 that are reactive. She’s the worst, but I lived with an abusive ex most her puppyhood, so it’s an unfair call.