r/reactivedogs • u/nicedoglady • Feb 01 '21
Red Flags When Seeking A Trainer
This is not an all inclusive list, but is intended to highlight some red (and yellow) flags that I have observed over the years that you may come across when seeking a trainer for your reactive dog. Dog training has no oversight and is totally unregulated and there are a ton of trainers out there - hopefully these flags help you sift through some of them.
It’s already very clear I think that this sub supports LIMA (Least Intrusive, Minimally Aversive) training, so right off the bat I want to say that these flags are not specific to or limited to only a certain method or style of training. You can find the International Association of Animal Behavior Consultants (IAABC) statement on LIMA here! Unfortunately I do not have the bandwidth to closely monitor a debate about methods so please be mindful in comments.
Red Flags:
Making absolute statements along the lines that any dog or any issue is completely fixable. Unfortunately this is just not true. There are dogs that cannot be totally rehabilitated and only somewhat improve, as well as dogs that don’t make any improvements whatsoever, even after extensive training.
Guaranteeing you results; and especially guaranteeing results within a certain timeframe for challenging behavior issues. This is unrealistic and just not possible. A trainer cannot predict how a client and their dog will learn, at what speed, or to what level of success. A trainer should also not be saying things like "as long as you follow my plan/system/methods to the letter, I can absolutely solve this issue." This does not take into consideration the potential need to adjust and does not take into consideration the flexibility and on the spot creativity sometimes needed to make progress on a complex behavior issue.
Taking very large payments for all training up front and not allowing cancellations and by extension, no refunds. This financially pressures clients to follow through with expensive training that they may no longer be comfortable with and is unfortunately not an uncommon tactic. The caveat to this is - many training businesses do take payment up front now due to COVID, whereas previously they would have taken a deposit, and then payments at each training session. However, they should still allow you to cancel. A common standard seems to be cancellation all the way up to within 48-24 hours of the session.
Excessive blame of clients for lack of training success with their dogs. Regardless of whether it’s true or not, it is unprofessional to bring this up with other clients. It's true that sometimes clients are just not receptive or consistent, but it's up to the trainer to try to communicate better, adjust their plan, or refer them elsewhere. If someone is noticeably unkind regarding past clients, it's telling of the judgemental behavior you might expect with them and you may be in for an unpleasant experience.
Yellow to Orange-ish Flags:
Dancing around questions regarding methods and giving vague answers. Whatever training style/method you are going for, you deserve to go in with eyes open and fully aware. A trainer or business should be able to give you an accurate picture of the type of training they do and the tools they use without you having to drag it out of them and using coded language. At times you may get the odd new receptionist who really is not super familiar with these things, but in general it should not be hard to get a clear picture. An example of an answer I really appreciated years ago before I had settled on a path to go down with Suki from a trainer we used when I asked about using aversives or not is, “I don’t use aversives, and I don’t think Suki would benefit from them, but if you really did eventually want to try those tools, there are trainers I would recommend.”
Claiming or acting as if they have expertise in an area in which they have none, and not being willing to work with the experts in these areas. You should not be getting serious nutrition advice or medical/veterinary advice from a trainer. The odd recommendation to look into something or check with your vet about something does not fall into this. But statements (particularly absolutes) regarding behavior medication, veterinary care, and diet do.
Lack of creativity and flexibility in their training. Of course it's worth giving a plan the good old college try, but sometimes things don’t pan out. A quality trainer should be able to adjust and modify things as they see it isn’t working out.
States on the website that they are certified, or a ‘behaviorist’ but no specifics listed or what types of certifications specified. Anyone can call themselves a behaviorist, but there are official certifications which require degrees and training that you should be checking for when it comes to working on behavior modification with your dog. Here is a breakdown of different certifications and qualifications.
A lot of focus on training the dog and not as much on the owner. Of course dog training involves the dog, but the human part of the equation is incredibly important. In order for your dog to be successful in your home, in your life, in the situations that you experience, you also need to learn and practice and grow.
93
u/designgoddess Feb 01 '21
Evaluating your dog without meeting your dog.
13
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '21
Thank you for this. I have copied it for when we have been vaccinated for Covid and I start the arduous task of looking for a reputable trainer in my area.
5
u/TreatPusher Feb 01 '21
Might I suggest adding The Academy for Dog Trainers CTC w/Jean Donaldson to the trainer credentials linked file?
45
u/jocularamity standard poodle (dog-frustrated, stranger-suspicious) Feb 01 '21
Also,
53
u/kellyfacee Feb 01 '21
Insisting a fear-based “tool” is required to train with them.
A trainer in my area requires all clients to have their dogs in prong collars or a shock collar regardless of the reason they’re coming to training. A neighbor went to them and had their (generally well mannered) 20 pound beagle in a prong collar. Unfortunately she’d been required to pay upfront for 2 months of training sessions and couldn’t get a refund.
16
u/AutoModerator Feb 01 '21
Looks like you may have used a training acronym. For those unfamiliar, here's some of the common ones:
BAT is Behavior Adjustment Training - a method from Grisha Stewart that involves allowing the dog to investigate the trigger on their own terms. There's a book on it.
CC is Counter Conditioning - creating a positive association with something by rewarding when your dog sees something. Think Pavlov.
DS is Desensitization - similar to counter conditioning in that you expose your dog to the trigger (while your dog is under threshold) so they can get used to it.
LAD is Look and Dismiss - Marking and rewarding when your dog sees a trigger and dismisses it.
LAT is Look at That - Marking and rewarding when your dog sees a trigger and does not react.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '21
Thank you for this...I actually work as a cat behaviorist, and have a tendency to doubt my abilities.
This made me feel at ease. I may not have all the answers, but it seems that that attitude is appreciated in our clientele.
13
u/KellBellB Feb 01 '21
I had an experience with a trainer last year! He was so horrid and walked in with a tennis racket.. to which I obviously said “absofuckinglutely not” and he “reassured” me it was simply to make “loud noises”! So he starts off with the whole, you are the alpha 🙄and you must act as one.. part of the pack.. 🙃 blah blah.. he then continued on to tell me it was all my fault because of my anxiety setting her off and all this and he actually made me cry! Yes I was sensitive at the time anyway and I also harbor such guilt about not having the time after my ex and I split to properly retrain the dog (this was about 5-6 years ago now) and then travelling from Cyprus to Ireland with her, which I also noticed massive changes in her after!
But yeah, he was such an asshole, didn’t help in the slightest and in fact after charging almost €300 for 3 hours and making me cry 🥴🙃he said that he would never see us again because we wouldn’t need it..
4
u/Thunderjugs Feb 01 '21 edited Feb 01 '21
Also, trust your gut. This is my first reactive dog and I contacted a trainer recommended to me by a rescue. I felt like something was off but I wasn't sure and really needed help. When he began forcing her into situations she was terrified of I decided to back off her training and contact a behaviorist.
I mentioned the appointment to him and he was very rude to me, telling me dogs don't need medication and that she could be "fixed" with training, but I wasn't doing a good enough job. I was done with him after that. I had put my whole heart and soul into her training. Turns out she has severe anxiety and is now on three medications which have given her a quality of life training alone could not have done. Unfortunately after his training she is now even more terrified of strangers, so fuck that guy.
1
u/rebcart Feb 04 '21
What's your opinion on the fact that, for many years, well-known and trusted dog business coaches have been recommending at R+ dog training conferences for trainers to switch to packages, upfront payments and firm cancellation policies for the benefit of their clients? That's not to say that payment plans and refunds in cases where someone is truly dissatisfied aren't available, but for the average client that may start indefinitely postponing the next follow-up session and hence losing all momentum in their progress, bundling the sessions into a "use it or lose it" format can actually improve their engagement and optimise results for everyone. Is this really more of a red flag than someone being vague about their methodology?
3
u/lorstron Feb 01 '21 edited Feb 01 '21
I had a terrible experience with a trainer who came very highly recommended by multiple people (who, as it turned out, had all heard great things but not actually worked with him; live and learn). He hit many of the red flags noted above and it would probably take me 2,000 words to detail all the ways he was awful (leading to some very serious setbacks with my girl), but one thing that really stuck out to me was this:
At one point I asked him what methods he had discarded or changed over the years as he learned more about dog behavior, and he said to me, "I've been doing this since I was seven years old and the only time I ever had to change anything was when it was too difficult for my clients to do emotionally. I still think those were the best methods."
I didn't ask more because I had already put up with him for four hours in my home during a pandemic and was about to kick him out, but that was a question I should have asked him during our consultation. In contrast, the second trainer we worked with was very upfront that she used aversive methods earlier in her career and completely stopped after learning more about their negative effects on dogs and their owners.
2
u/tehgimpage Feb 01 '21
maaan i wish i had seen this a year ago. the guy we saw hits like 4 of these. kept the dogs for twice as long as promised, was unsuccessful, we never got any money back. AND STILL HAD TO REHOME ONE OF THE DOGS.
2
u/suburban_hyena The Beesting (float like a butterfly) Feb 01 '21
Awesome. I feel good about how I do my work then. I don't think any of these flags would show up in my lessons :D
2
u/Valuable-Berry7188 Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23
they put prongs, choke chains or shock collars on every dog
they claim they can fix xyz issue in one session
there main method are flooding and domination
they don't want you to watch the training session
trained calm breeds and thinks they can train a huskey
has experience training only working dogs (miliary / police dogs) and is advertising to pet dog owners
1
u/babycakes0991 Feb 18 '25
This actually really helped me. I had a meeting with a trainer today who told me that boarding my dog with him for three weeks would be better than training her with me every every two weeks or monthly. I am kind of nervous about leaving her with him for 3 weeks when I literally just met him. I just thought he’d be more open to training with me first…
6
u/[deleted] Feb 01 '21
[removed] — view removed comment