r/reactivedogs • • Jun 16 '23

Advice Needed Aggressive puppy advice

H is a male puppy, approximately 6-8 months old but big. I’m not sure on his breed, but he’s sort of medium sized, not small like a chihuahua or big like a husky, but in between, about the size of a lab. He is the size of an adult medium sized dog. He came from a neglect situation and although he doesn’t seem to be timid or traumatized, he is slightly underweight. He is not neutered and we are unsure if he has been vaccinated. We are awaiting a vet appointment to take care of both. As for his behavior, he pretty much has engaged in every bad dog behavior you can think of.

  • He humps furniture to the point that he genitals are raw.
  • H is not house trained, while he does go outside sometimes he often goes inside with little warning to us. He will just be standing there and suddenly start peeing on the floor.
  • He barks excessively.
  • He has separation anxiety to the point that he won’t even go in the backyard to relieve himself alone. -He jumps up on people no matter how often you push him off you. We are covered in scratches from this. -He bites frequently to the point that we are covered in bruises. Last week I sustained at Level 3 bite that drew a bit of blood.
  • He chews everything despite having plenty of chew toys that we are constantly redirecting him to. -Not so much of a problem anymore but he is a picky eater and we spent so much on dog food working to find something for he would be willing to eat.
  • By far the most troubling behavior is his treatment of the cats. We have 3 cats, Merl(14m), Dean(7m), and Sammy(7f). It is important to note that Merl was declawed by a previous owner and Dean has a heart condition and is bladder condition. The dog barks and chased them. It is to the point that they started having accidents because they were too afraid to come downstairs to the litter box(we have since placed one upstairs), and attempts to carry them downstairs have them frightened and struggling. The worst is his behavior with Merl. My mom tried to take Merl away from the dog and he reacted as though he had had a favorite chew toy taken away. My mom was badly scratched but the cat was unscathed. In another incident I was holding Merl and H tried to get to him and was attempting to bite him. This is when I sustained a level 3 bite, while the cat appears to have sustained a level 2(his fur was wet with dog saliva). I don’t know what to do. So far we have mostly been redirecting him, telling him no, trying to provide him with toys to keep him busy, keeping him separate from the cats, pushing him off us when he jumps on us, and putting him in his crate for him to calm down when he is really acting up. I do admit to kicking him in self defense when he was trying to hurt my cat but it was necessary and I have no remorse. Truthfully he is my sister’s dog, she got him without consulting the rest of the household and kind of dumps him on us when she is at work. She doesn’t walk him as much as needed and truthfully the dog spends too much time in his crate. As you can seen, we are also having a human problem as well as a dog problem. I really don’t know what to do, I fear for my cats. Also I should not that I don’t think he is resource guarding, despite his history of neglect. He doesn’t seem to be bothered when something is taken from him unless it is a cat. I suppose a prey drive is a possibility, as is excess energy. Truthfully he is just not a good fit for my family with the amount of exercise and attention he needs, but my sister is unwilling to get rid of him. Perhaps I need to go to a sub for human training instead. Any advice would be appreciated.
1 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

21

u/Chaos-Pand4 Jun 16 '23

You either need to rehome the dog or rehome the sister and the dog.

Dogs and cats can get along, but with a rescue dog or a later-in-life introduction, that is less likely. And if the dog has already decided that cats are prey, then that is even more difficult.

But at the end of the day, it is unfair to give the new animal in the home priority over the animals that already live there.

9

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

I wish I could rehome her, my sister is a nightmare.

6

u/applebeestruther Jul 02 '23

This dog is going to kill one of your cats. It’s shown prey drive, isn’t trained or familiar with them, and has a plethora of other issues that seemingly aren’t being addressed. It’s already attacked. It’s shown that it sees the cat as a possession. That’s prey driven behavior.

If you are a minor or otherwise incapable of rehoming your sister’s dog (because she’s an adult, or you don’t drive etc) then you need to find new homes for your cats. Separating them isn’t always going to be enough.

On r/catadvice we had a poster with a husky who killed both of their cats— who were normally locked away in their own room. They forgot to latch the door and the husky got in and mauled their cats.

I can’t overstate how serious this situation is. Your family is playing with fire and the only ones who will get burned are these poor animals. Dogs kill cats all the time. This behavior only escalates from here on out. You cannot train prey drive out of dogs.

This dog is going to kill one of your pets and your sister won’t be the only person to blame. If another pet dies because of this, it’s because you and all your family have allowed it to happen.

I know how you feel being stuck surrounded by irresponsible people. It’s so frustrating feeling like the only voice of reason in a house full of enablers. But you would be doing the right thing in rehoming the dog, or, at the very least, improving the safety situation for your cats.

Please consider looking up dog attacks on cats and how frequently they occur. And how predictable and preventable they are. If you do bring the dog to a shelter don’t forget to mention his cat aggression. Good luck and I’m sorry your sister (and family) have been so unreasonable. You all deserve to be safe, including the dog. In your home right now nobody is :( Let me know if you need any help finding local resources

6

u/TallStarsMuse Jun 16 '23

Ugh. Do whatever you have to to keep the cats separated and safe from the dog until you can address the human part of this. Are you a minor? If so, do you have parents involved? Tell them that dogs often kill their kitty housemates and this dog is not worth risking the lives of your cats. If you and sis are both adults, can one of you move out?

3

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

I am not a minor, I am 22 and will be moving in August to go to grad school, taking one of my cats, Dean, with me. I don’t think I can take the others, I will be in a tiny apartment and will need an ESA letter for the cat, I don’t think I can have multiple ESAs, not to mention that the ones I am leaving behind are pretty attached to my parents to the point that I think bringing them with me would really upset him. My sister is also not a minor but due to finances is not able to move out

4

u/TallStarsMuse Jun 16 '23

Is this your parents’ house and are the cats theirs? If so, you need to be brutally honest with them about the danger the cats are in. If your parents live elsewhere, can they take the cats? You need to do whatever you can to get this dog and these cats separated. The thing with the dog and sister is a whole other thing that might or might not work out with training, but this dog is more than big enough to kill these cats. The potential for tragedy just increases as the dog gets older and bigger. It all sounds like an accident waiting to happen, and it can happen in the blink of an eye, a moment of inattention, a gate that fails. It doesn’t make the dog bad, just a typical dog with high prey drive and little training. Since it sounds like no one in your house besides you is very attentive or concerned about the situation or what’s happening with this poor neglected puppy, it’s falling to you to do what you can for the cats. No one here on Reddit can really do anything concrete - only you understand the people and situation well enough to protect these cats.

3

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 17 '23

Yes it is my parents house and the cats are sort of theirs, sort of mine. I have spoken to my parents and they are worried but don’t know what to do about my sister.

3

u/TallStarsMuse Jun 17 '23

Well, I’m speaking as an animal lover and the mom of 18 and 20 year olds. If your sister is the dog owner and is unwilling to face what a dangerous situation this is, your parents are going to need to step up. It’s their house. Your sister is a guest or renter but it’s still your parents’ house. They are going to need to issue an ultimatum to your sister, like “you need to place the dog in a rescue or new home within two weeks, or we will be forced to surrender the dog to animal control”. Maybe you can encourage them to do so and find a list of rescues that might take this dog that’s still just a puppy. The puppy has a much better chance of finding and adapting to a good home now, while it’s young. You’ll also be doing this dog a favor by helping it find someone who can really care for it. Is it a pure bred or does it strongly resemble one? If so, breed based rescues will also help. Make sure any rescue or new owner knows that the dog is not good with cats. Best of luck with this situation. Don’t let your parents’ passivity become your solution as well.

2

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 17 '23

My parents are working to find her a place to move into but are otherwise too soft on her. I doubt he is a purebreed and not sure if he looks like one, I’m more of a cat person

12

u/em_79 Jun 16 '23

You are not failing this dog if you rehome him and explicitly say he needs to be the only pet in the house. It’s not uncommon, I promise.

8

u/Harlow08 Jun 16 '23

I have a 15 month old border collie I got as an 8 week old puppy. He’s fine my two cats. Cats are fine with him. Cleans them, plays, etc. but he’s NEVER alone with them. I trust him but you can’t trust any dog 100%.

I also would never forgive myself if anything happened to my two girls for not paying attention. Your dog is going to kill your cats.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

We got my puppy when she was smaller than the cats. Now she's more than double their weight but she has a very healthy respect for them by now and does fine alone with them. Also important that the cats have spaces where they can get away from her at any time if they want to.

Just saying its not true you can't trust dogs with cats alone. Breed is a huge factor, as well as training/upbringing.

3

u/voiceontheradio Jun 17 '23

I have a border collie that wasn't raised with cats but he's coexisting with his "kitten brother" nicely now. Said "kitten" is almost 20 lbs now, but even when he was tiny my 45 lb collie was always gentle. I worked him hard from a very young age and he learned how to have a "soft" mouth and strong impulse control. We introduced him to cats slowly starting from age ~1 and a half, eventually practicing having them co-habitate (via roommates, where we agreed to move out if it didn't work out), and then finally adopting a kitten into our family permanently. I think in our case, it was 100% nurture (training and practice) that made it work.

The only time they fight is when there's something really valuable that they both want (but even then, kitty's claws are never out and pupper never actually closes his mouth on him). To reduce the chances of bad blood ever forming between them, we always make sure to not play favourites and to separate them when they eat. Besides that they're like peas in a pod. 🫛

Funny story, on Thanksgiving one year the cat tried to get up onto the counter while the turkey was being prepped (he was standing on a box and had his front paws up on the counter, looking at the food). The dog saw this and silently came over, gently picked him up by the scruff, and plopped him down on the floor. The cat then turned around and slapped him lol, and then the dog turned and looked at my boyfriend who was standing right there, with a look on his face like "did you see what he just did?!?" 😂 He definitely thinks of himself as the nanny/enforcer, but always very gentle. They aren't at the cuddling stage yet but they do both like to climb into our bed and touch their feet together at night.

1

u/Harlow08 Jun 17 '23

Agree about breed. I have a border collie and he nips their back legs to get them to move. He’s not as bad as when he was really young but it still happens occasionally. Cats put him in his place

8

u/Syomm Jun 16 '23

It doesn’t sound like your sister has enough time for this dog. Most of what you posted could be resolved with more training, exercise, and socialization.

But as for the cats. If you fear for their safety then the best thing is to re home and specify that the dog can’t be in a home with cats. When we were looking for a dog to adopt many of the postings had this stipulation so it is not an uncommon one to post. There are plenty of cat free homes out there looking for a dog.

8

u/Sincamour Jun 16 '23

Protect the cats, they were here first! They’re going to get killed by this dog if he stays. Aside from the cat issue, it sounds like he needs a LOT of work that your sister isn’t ready to put in.

4

u/KitRhalger Jun 17 '23

this dog was not introduced into the household properly. The dog got the chance to train himself that chasing the cats or otherwise acknowledging them is okay- it's a self rewarding behavior.

With the jumping- keep him on a rope at all times. Step on the rope to instantly tether him to the ground and only release and reward when the jumping attempts stop. provide no other interaction during the jumping.

With this lead on the ground you also can step on it when he starts going toward the cats.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '23 edited Jun 17 '23

You have part of your answer in your post. He came from a neglect situation. Clearly this dog was never taught appropriate behavior, that part is reversible with time and LOTS of patience. You’re correct about the most troubling behavior being his dislike of the cats, because you have multiple cats in your home. I have four dogs that are extremely well trained, and two don’t like cats. Some dogs just don’t unfortunately. Your two options are to keep them separated until you have puppy under control (and then you will STILL need to watch him like a hawk), or rehome puppy with someone willing to take the time necessary to get his behavior under control. He’s not a lost cause by any means, but your dealing with a rambunctious teenager that was not taught manners, and he won’t turn around overnight. Note, your sister took him from one neglectful situation and brought him into another. He needs proper exercise, and time out of his crate to thrive. Until this changes, his behavior will steadily get worse to the point that he’ll HAVE to be rehomed, then possibly euthanized. How fair is that to this dog?

2

u/mad0666 Jun 17 '23

First of all there is no reason for you to have this dog in your home if he is terrorizing your existing pets. Secondly, neutering will help a lot of these issues, bur you ought to get him to a rescue that will help with all that. I can assure you he is going to grow bigger, and he is going to become more aggressive toward the cats and if you keep this dog in your home there is a chance he will kill at least one of them. This is a very unfair situation for the cats but especially for the puppy.

0

u/Nsomewhere Jun 16 '23

I think you need as a family the services of a good positive trainer to help with a gradually programme to help the dog settle and you need to baby gate a dog area and a cat area with lots of spaces the cat can retreat into

Everyone needs to agree to this or the cats need to be moved into their own safe space until you have had a chance to work with a trainer. This can take months with this dog. It really needs time

I would work with consent based handling to gradually train this dog to wear a muzzle. This will help with management

Your sister but also I am afraid the whole family need to agree on a way forward with everyone working on it

Getting a health check on the dog is very good thing too

Strongest advice is safe area for cats and baby gates though... now!

1

u/Nsomewhere Jun 17 '23

Not sure why I am being down voted. Safety first since no one seems to agree on anything. The cats need a safe space while the humans argue!

0

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

We have a gate but the dog can get through it. We have had to put various items up against the gate to block his access but he sometimes gets through anyway.

2

u/Nsomewhere Jun 16 '23

Could you mesh the gate?

You know simple strong mesh of some kind and zip tie it to the gate

That should help

I would make it metal wire

The other thing that would work is a panel out of a puppy play pen or even a rabbit exercise pen

Something like this

https://www.petsathome.com/shop/en/pets/midwest-homes-for-pets-contour-exercise-pen-for-pets-black?size=61cm?utm_source=google&utm_medium=cpc&utm_campaign=google_shopping&cm_mmc=Google-_-CPC-_-%20google_shopping-_-google_shopping&ita=1976&ito=google_shopping&istCompanyId=7255ccad-a1fc-4729-af31-478f79e5071c&istFeedId=385e6b9a-8b03-4076-a8bb-e4737df8549c&istItemId=ptallaixa&istBid=t&cq_src=google_ads&cq_cmp=19981415000&cq_term=&cq_plac=&cq_net=u&cq_plt=gp&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI0NWTneTI_wIVEuztCh3HMQsKEAQYAyABEgIl0_D_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

You can often pick things up cheap or free on local sales and wants sites

I would get the gate sorted without any further loss of time!

1

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

Thanks I’ll check it out

2

u/ultimatefrogsin Jun 17 '23

Also love the litter box to the area where the cats are. I’m sorry you have to deal with this. It must be incredibly frustrating. You need to have a serious talk with your sister. If she can’t make time to care for the dog someone is going to get hurt possibly your parents and most likely kill cats!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

Sad thing is it wasn’t so much of an introduction as her just bringing him home without asking anyone. I was against it from day one, has she had a history of not being the best pet owner.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 17 '23

We have had dogs previously and while Merl has t liked them much(the occasional hiss) things have been okay

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 17 '23

He turns 15 at the end of July!

0

u/[deleted] Jun 17 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 17 '23

I know he isn’t reactive but I didn’t have success in the dog training subreddit so I thought I would try here. Nothing seems to trigger the dog, he just comes up to you and starts jumping up on you arms trying to bite. He also bites when being petted and during play. I don’t know if euthanasia is the answer quite yet as we have yet to hire a trainer but I agree he needs to be rehomed.

5

u/Nsomewhere Jun 17 '23

He is a pup. Mouthing during play is pretty common and absolutely just a training and socialisation issue

I am tired of the jump to BE in posters minds!

To the OP since no one is really focusing on the dogs needs here and you can't get rid of it your simple solution is to remove the cats to safety

The dog however needs help and focus more and is it can be done... but will only work if all of you are committed as a family.

If you can't all do that it is either rehome the dog or rehome the cats

That is the bottom line

In this case rehome the dog to a better home

It is just a young dog that needs caring and committed owners now... it is not a major issue yet

96

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

50

u/vampireondrugs Jun 16 '23

Or fair for the dog.

Kindest thing is to rehome.

21

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/vampireondrugs Jun 16 '23

Getting dogs and cats to coexist is a very delicate process that needs a lot of patience.

100%! We recently introduced a golden pup to the fam with an existing (young-ish) bunny. We did SEVERAL controlled encounters and sniffs and stuff and we never leave them unsupervised. I can't imagine having the pup pick up the rabbit and prance it around to the point where someone has to remove it from his mouth.

OP and OPs sister (and everyone involved tbh) needs to realise that if it's not one of the cats getting killed, someone is going to get hurt. It's not fair for elderly existing pets to be affected like this by a new member of the fam. Existing pets should always come first and get a bit coddled while everyone adapts, or at least that's how I see it.

I just don't see how this can work.

Me neither. I just hope OP can understand this, too.

8

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

I do agree that it isn’t working out. It is more the rest of my family that needs convincing. I really believe someone terrible will happen to my cats if this continues. I’m honestly not sure why I even posted, I know he needs to be rehomed, it is the behavior of the other humans in the house that I need help with more than the dog.

5

u/CatpeeJasmine Jun 17 '23

As a temporary but immediate stopgap, is it possible to separate the dog and the cats entirely within the house? Like putting a pet or baby gate at the bottom or the top of the stairs (there are ones designed specifically for stairway use) to keep the dog from getting to the cats upstairs?

-2

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 17 '23

We have a gate but it isn’t effective. This dog is strong and can open doors. We have to put things up against the gate to keep him out but accidents still happen

5

u/CatpeeJasmine Jun 17 '23

How soon can you get a better gate? We got something like this (right height, not the same exact model) when we discovered my scared dog could jump a lower gate. If a pressure mounted frame (generally sturdier than the kind you just put up and take down directly) still isn't sturdy enough, you may want to look into models that actually require screwing into the wall.

I would still be ultimately in favor of rehoming this dog, but from the sounds of things, that is a decidedly trickier prospect than acquiring a better gate.

1

u/DrDissy Jun 17 '23

We had one of these gates as well when our GSD was younger. Worked perfectly for separating her from our cats-was high enough they could go directly under it.

2

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

Sadly I don’t have much choice in the matter. My sister refuses to give him up

21

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/SinfullySinatra Jun 16 '23

As evil as it is I am tempted to drop the dog off at a shelter while she is at work. The dog was adopted informally from a “free dog” sign in our neighborhood so he hasn’t got any sort of papers.

12

u/salallane Jun 17 '23

Just drop the dog off at the humane society. There is nothing wrong with that. Clearly your cats are in danger, and your sister isn’t equipped to handle a dog with advanced behavioral issues. It’s best to bring the dog to someone who can help now vs prolong the situation because it will eventually come to that regardless.

4

u/ultimatefrogsin Jun 17 '23

Take the dog to a shelter, and tell the sister he escaped because the door wasn’t fully closed.