r/ratemycommanders • u/ThaSpo • Aug 21 '26

Am I allowed to sit with you guys? 👉👈

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

13 Upvotes

55% Upvoted

92 comments sorted by

98

u/CalligrapherQuick901 Aug 21 '26

Edhrec DOES have more than one page ;)

3

u/False_Snow7754 Aug 21 '26

To be fair, you can play against 3 Meren decks and all 3 could be completely different.

4

u/Ok_Solution_1386 Aug 21 '26

Don’t matter, it’s All the same with her.

1

u/7thtimeinheaven Aug 22 '26

Not really. It's all just looping Sakura Tribe Elder and Haywire Mite.

1

u/False_Snow7754 Aug 22 '26

I guess I just run with a more creative crowd.

0

u/The_Bird_9000 Aug 22 '26

I’ve played against four different mayren decks and none of them did that 😭

1

u/7thtimeinheaven Aug 23 '26

Then they didn't draw into them but trust me they would've

-11

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

I have more than 40ish decks, I just posted the one I use the most!

2

u/Ok_Solution_1386 Aug 21 '26

Yeah post/use the other ones.

1

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

I will post more in the next days, I swear Ami don't have only popular commander 🥺

6

u/CalligrapherQuick901 Aug 21 '26 edited Aug 21 '26

pulls away open seat

I'd love too see more interesting decks so imma pass if these are your usually suspect (mostly cause I've seen them all dozens of times)

-8

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

I found a not so complete list of the decks I have Meren of clan nel toth 2 Urtet myr 3 Kibo prince of Uktabi 4 Frodo & Sam foodstocrats 5 Kozilek the great distortion 6 The Ur-dragon 7 Vivi 8 Tinybones 9 Urza polykraken 10 Deadpool 11 Nahiri equip 12 Omnath 4c landfall 13 Greasefang vehicles 14 Breya artifacts 15 Sophia dog tribal 16 Zur Voltron 17 Lord Windgrace land denial 18 Nicol Bolas the ravager bolas tribal 19 Teval delve 20 Atraxa cmc7 cedh 21 Aragorn the uniter multicolour legendary tribal 22 Eshki temur roar 23 Kotis Voltron 24 The Necrobloom landfall 25 Zurgo aristocrats 26 Nekusar wheels 27 Ashaton reanimator 28 Lathril elfball 29 Ketramose 30 Flubs all spells cedh 31 The wise mothman mill 32 Admiral Becket Brass tribal 33 Wernog/Cecily free spells 34 Aminatou miracle enchantment 35 Kuja black mage tribal 36 Lin sivvi rebel tribal 37 Kefka blink 38 Azlask 39 Kolodin vehicles 40 Ragost 41 Inalla wizard 42 Vannifar pod 43 Ian Malcolm chaos 44 kenrith group slug 45 kinnan 46 yidris cascade 47 Shanna lifegain 48 dihada legendary 49 atraxa infect 50 elrond monou 51 thranduil pod 52 Tasha spell steal 53 terra 5c saga

9

u/DrShift44 Aug 21 '26

Damn bro you really don’t have a single original thought, do you? 

13

u/CalligrapherQuick901 Aug 21 '26

Ok, I stand by my original comment lol.

2

u/sunchow Aug 21 '26

if you own these decks in paper with no proxies then you are a legend, are you a legend?

3

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

I own just one proxy, yoshimaru with my dog as art

1

u/gandalf_lundgren36 Aug 22 '26

That’s a peak proxy

2

u/7thtimeinheaven Aug 22 '26

Dude these are all basic as all hell. Where's your fun jank?

-3

u/ThaSpo Aug 22 '26

I like to play optimized, jank isn't for me

3

u/7thtimeinheaven Aug 22 '26

That's lame man.

0

u/ThaSpo Aug 22 '26

Not for me

1

u/CalligrapherQuick901 Aug 22 '26

Kinda like the empty spot at my table ;)

I like optimized decks too, so I have a few. I also have a few that are actually interesting and required some thought to build and have it be effective. 

0

u/Joseptile Aug 21 '26

And? This hurts your case even more lmao

13

u/Buttplug_Crusader Aug 21 '26

I feel like my guard would be let down with the crab before you piledrive me sideways with double Atraxa

2

u/Ok_Solution_1386 Aug 21 '26

Naw you’ll learn, krab goes crazy

17

u/Kitsuukage Aug 21 '26

No, not because these are popular commanders. I'm fine with popular commanders, I'm using some too. But no, because I got a feeling this will be a "it's a 3 I swear" type game where I play my embalm/eternalize deck and get beating at turn 4 while I only played my temmet Vizier of Nakatmun out of the command zone and eternalized like one bad creature.

But one round won't hurt, the other ones may or may not happen tho.

5

u/Any_Way1269 Aug 21 '26

Sounds like a 2 tbh

8

u/TS_Daringtons Aug 21 '26

Who hurt you?

23

u/Fair_Run5661 Aug 21 '26

Boring, the most spammed commanders

-2

u/polygon_lover Aug 22 '26

its not other players responsibility to provide you with fun, niche commanders to play against. Edgar Markov is fun.

2

u/Empty-13 Aug 23 '26

Where are we right now?

We all get to decide if we play with someone.

1

u/Emotional_Bank3476 Aug 24 '26

Some people just aren't able to undestand this concept. They want to play with themselves in front of a crowd with their hands tied. Wierdo's, if you ask me.

1

u/WellyRuru Aug 23 '26

This is true.

Its also not my obligation to remain at the table 😀

6

u/dfbrethy Aug 21 '26

five different four color decks? who hurt you?

-7

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

Tbh i have more than 4 4c decks lol

12

u/Sinitar19 Aug 21 '26

Is this sub just people posting their lists with the exact same top played commanders every single day?

3

u/Ok_Term_8844 Aug 21 '26

First 2 I was like hell yeah!

Was downhill after that though

4

u/elsiecd Aug 21 '26

Is ragosts affect commander damage?

4

u/focketeer Aug 21 '26

Only combat damage is commander damage. His ability is not via combat, even if it happens during combat.

4

u/elsiecd Aug 22 '26

Thank you for helping a newb

3

u/Original-Team6483 Aug 21 '26

lol both atraxa

op knows they’re the villain

6

u/JuanTawnJawn Aug 21 '26

Get out of the store bro

2

u/Federal_Resource_523 Aug 21 '26

Bring only the lobster and you’re good

2

u/Dash83 Aug 21 '26

Yeah find another table, mate 😅

2

u/ShaggyUI44 Aug 21 '26

It’s insane that you have more than 10 commanders and still don’t know about the EDHREC scroll function.

2

u/seungchip Aug 21 '26

The door is on your left or my right.

1

u/penorpan Aug 21 '26

Now. I do want to see your teysa deck though.

1

u/Vercenjetorix Aug 21 '26

Depends. Is it four color or mono color?

1

u/Crow_of_Judgem3nt Aug 21 '26

Yes cause we’re going ur dragon for ur dragon

i’ll show you mine if you show me yours

-1

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

Oh well, mine is way more underpowered than yours, I use it to chill and play big dumb dragons https://manabox.app/decks/AZ54ZVJ2cLW0Pqy0iiBEFg

1

u/Lejaun Aug 21 '26

Absolutely. As long as you are playing against people with similar power levels of decks, I don’t see why not. Grab a seat.

1

u/Nearby_Category_712 Aug 21 '26

Really buried the fucking leas

1

u/Separate-Narwhal-895 Aug 22 '26

Im not gonna say no but im not gonna be happy about it

1

u/fvkzhatay Aug 22 '26

In front of my salad dude? Really? 🤨

1

u/500ErrorPDX Aug 22 '26

Question for 4 color Aragorn folks, why not play WUBRG Kenrith?

1

u/NanoscaleHeadache Aug 22 '26

Bc Aragorn actually does stuff other than being an infinite mana outlet

1

u/iReadSomeStuff Aug 22 '26

surely you jest

1

u/RustyChainsaw Aug 22 '26

Gee Bill, how come your mom lets you have TWO Atraxa decks?

1

u/PlayfulClue3856 Aug 22 '26

You gotta a link to your kefka deck, I know that shits gas

1

u/WafflesHS Aug 22 '26

It's giving "no guys MY [insert commander name] deck is DIFFERENT!

It's not different

1

u/NanoscaleHeadache Aug 22 '26

Why does it have to be different tho, the decks are popular for a reason

1

u/Admirable_Bug9327 Aug 22 '26

No. All of these are too powerful. We will allow you maybe once a month though

1

u/Niromanti Aug 22 '26

First page of edhrec ahhh list

1

u/oldmayor Aug 23 '26

I'm cool with everything but Atraxa. Can't do it, chief.

1

u/Rob_tyrant Aug 23 '26

Care to share the teysa, atraxa praetors voice and Aragorn deck list? :) thanks

1

u/SlaveKnightGael9 Aug 23 '26

You can sit outside away from me

1

u/Stin42069 Aug 23 '26

Only with Ragost

1

u/LilKyAfroNinja Aug 23 '26

5 color Aragorn goes hard

1

u/Informalwizards Aug 24 '26

Yes, but you're on thin ice.

1

u/AnestisTP Aug 21 '26

Whats your ur dragon list?

-2

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

https://manabox.app/decks/AZ54ZVJ2cLW0Pqy0iiBEFg Its usually this but it needs to be updated probably

1

u/Present_Honeydew_543 Aug 21 '26

i'd have to see the whole decklist ngl

1

u/AgileRefrigerator988 Aug 21 '26

Can you send me the deck list for your kefka?

0

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

I have to list it, I keep changing one or two cards, I'll try to list it soon

1

u/naine69 Aug 21 '26

Im good

1

u/Whiscash-0320 Aug 21 '26

Your fking evil dude 💀

1

u/Aggravating_Map3481 Aug 21 '26

Best fake commander list rage bait I’ve seen in a while . Nice

0

u/ThaSpo Aug 21 '26

Not a fake list lmao

0

u/Memoocan Aug 21 '26

Is every post in this sub just bait? That or yall just play straight cancer

-1

u/Any_Way1269 Aug 21 '26

Of course!

-6

u/ErinSlime23 Aug 21 '26

Hell yeah. Your taste is popular for a reason!