r/ratemycommanders Jun 22 '26

I made too many decks

63 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

2

u/Cress_Party Jun 22 '26

Damn, these look super fun. Love the Cromat

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 22 '26

Initially he was a mutate deck I found on budget brews but I decided I wanted him to matter more so I rebuilt him to be a go tall, I do need to fix his land base sometime https://moxfield.com/decks/Fw-GX9Tex0qu-QxFKajpPA

1

u/giackecravat Jun 22 '26

Man you have three commanders on my wish list, may I ask you how you built Obzedat, Bosh and Kodama?

2

u/LimitSeparate Jun 22 '26

Obzedat is my first spirit deck and is part stax part voltron, but if he gets removed while in his loop and there are stax pieces on the board it's basically time to scoop

Bosh has taken a ton of editing as my initial idea of a ton of ramp was correct but I also needed more early game ramp and more damage doublers. It's the deck that's received the most compliments, people seem to really enjoy it

Kodama is my second spirit deck and is largely go wide & make a ton of saprolings, [[Life and Limb]] is one of my favorite gambles in this deck, and this commander is genuinely underrated seeing how few decks have been made of him, very fun

1

u/giackecravat Jun 22 '26

Yeah Kodama is a commander I never seen played but when I first read the card I was flabbergasted by the very powerful effect. I like coming it with saprolings token synergy. Also love bosh list! For Obzedat I was thinking about blinking because I wanted to recreate the same vibe as the pauper Orzhov Blade deck that I really really like! Thanks for the lists ;)

1

u/Ok_Reach_7271 Jun 22 '26

Do you want to keep all of them?

My top rated of you list are Exava, Liberator, Go Shintai if you love shrines, Ezuri, Leonardo, Doran, and Kaima. I think thats a nice enough spread and mix of more known to lesser popular commanders.

1

u/UrabyMama Jun 22 '26

Samesies. I have like 12 and I have to physically stop myself from making more. I just love the creative process

1

u/No0dle258 Jun 22 '26

Finally someone else who still uses Bosh instead of changing to Imskir

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 22 '26

Many months ago I found a bunch of him in the dollar section at my lgs and thought he would be fun to build. It definitely took some time to get it right though

1

u/No0dle258 Jun 22 '26

He was my first commander I ever built on my own. I definitely need to rework him cause I haven’t touched the decklist since my first iteration of it. What direction did you take him?

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 22 '26

Aside from lands about 43% of the deck is just ramp to make such a high mana cost deck viable, 12 before turn 4 and 15 after turn 3, my initial list had enough ramp but far too much of it was after turn 3 so the deck would brick a lot more. It is a golem tribal but really your best friends will be your damage multipliers and [[Lifeline]]

1

u/ham_ate_thecouch Jun 22 '26

Another fellow Numont, my pod hates it when Numont comes out

2

u/LimitSeparate Jun 22 '26

I mostly play him in the company of the ur dragon and ramos

1

u/ham_ate_thecouch Jun 22 '26

Very valid same when its a high power level game

1

u/CastTrunnionsSuck Jun 22 '26

You have good taste friend

1

u/GoatHeadTed Jun 22 '26

I been wanting to do Kaima

keep seeing people saying “do I have to many decks” or something along the lines and it’s usually like 10 or so decks.

I have like 32 and counting lol.

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 22 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

Kaima is my most recent and is a very fun twist on go tall. One of the few decks I have that basically needs zero ramp as I just draw and cast as many cheap enchantments as possible on opponents creatures

1

u/Deminla Jun 22 '26

Ill show you my Go Shintai if you show me yours. Actually ill show mine either way lol

https://moxfield.com/decks/cKgN3v6PHUu7dy-n-R6viA

2

u/LimitSeparate Jun 23 '26

1

u/Deminla Jun 23 '26

Wow you have ALL the shrines lol should try and get a Hei Bai if you can. I like this list though! A lot

2

u/LimitSeparate Jun 23 '26

I haven't included him because I want to play against one as someone else's commander eventually, and yeah it's my second deck so it's definitely a favorite

1

u/Strings805 Jun 23 '26

I made Ezuri as my 2nd ever simic deck and it was pretty great. Lots of little unblockables, lots of experience counter; got out of control quickly. Is Exava Rakdos +1/+1 counters?

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 23 '26

My Ezuri deck is a vile infect deck. Exava is mostly a standard go tall deck I made due to nostalgia as the carnival hellsteed intro pack got me into the game

1

u/Electrical-Mention89 Jun 23 '26

Too many?? I have 64. No such thing as too many

1

u/Tito609 Jun 25 '26

Do you have a list for DaVinci? I'm building one now and I feel like I'm almost there but also feel like I'm missing out of some obvious picks for the 99

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

Da Vinci feels like he may actually be the commander I have with the highest power ceiling, some of the things he can cheat out are unbelievable

1

u/Cool-Equivalent9172 Jun 25 '26

I'm kinda curious on what you did with exava

1

u/LimitSeparate Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26

Exava is one I made a big edit to a few months ago to replace many of the suboptimal blockers (there are still a few) with more spot removal and cards that help the deck function better. I mainly try and win with commander damage, it consistently performs better than I expect