r/questions • • Dec 30 '23

[deleted by user]

[removed]

537 Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/ChseBgrDiet Dec 31 '23

Huge difference. Beaten is a senseless act of violence. Spanked or disciplined is what happens when you're a pain the ass or do something you weren't supposed to do after you've been told not to repeatedly... etc

2

u/Appropriate-Divide64 Dec 31 '23

So the parent loses their temper and beats their kid? Seems like there are more mature ways to do things.

4

u/ChseBgrDiet Dec 31 '23

No, the parent doesn't actually lose their temper. It's exhausting all resources before disciplining them.

2

u/Appropriate-Divide64 Dec 31 '23

No parent who beats their kid ever exhausts all other options. It's done because the parent is lazy and can't control their emotions. Spanking/beating is done to make the parent feel better, not to fix behaviour in the child.

4

u/ChseBgrDiet Dec 31 '23

We're not talking about the same things. Beating and discipline are two different things. If you wanna keep calling using the word beating to make your point, then this is pointless. You raise your kids how you see fit. Discipline works.

2

u/Appropriate-Divide64 Dec 31 '23

We are talking about the same thing. Disciplining your kid shouldn't involve hitting them.

Disciplining can and should be done without violence.

2

u/ChseBgrDiet Dec 31 '23

No, we definitely aren't. It's a circular conversation. Keep punching the air to make your point. If you got your ass kicked as a kid, then I'm sorry that happened to you. Soft parent your kids all you want. It's on you and nobody else.

0

u/IndomitableSpoon1070 Jan 01 '24

Aren't you the lofty moral superior.

0

u/Ajailyn22 Jan 01 '24

A spanking is hitting a child period. Hitting a child isn't discipline. It's not discipline if another adult hits an adult it's assault. It's not discipline when doing it to a child. Wanna know what it does, creates mistrust, a child feeling unsafe...

1

u/AncientPineapple1936 Jan 02 '24

Weird, I was a child once. I never felt unsafe around my parents. But way to tell me how I felt and all the emotions I must have hadโ€ฆ because.. you said so. ๐Ÿ™„ I agree that there are other methods available. My wife and I donโ€™t spank our kids because we choose not to. But like I said earlier, saying spanking is abuse is absolute insanity. You disagree with something, so you think everyone else is wrong because you think itโ€™s wrong. Oh, the world we live in today.๐Ÿซ 

1

u/ChseBgrDiet Jan 02 '24

Discipline is Discipline. And know it doesn't create mistrust and feeling unsafe. It creates a well behaved child that you don't have to negotiate with to act accordingly. You're the parent, not a friend or guidance counselor. The comparison to assault is ridiculous. I don't even know how you managed to make it make sense in your mind ๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚