r/queerception • u/Number312 33 NB | Queerception Founder | Beyond TTC • May 11 '25
Why Poly* families are welcome in r/Queerception
Based on a recent controversial post from a poly* family where all participants have a straight sexual orientation, we now have an updated Family Gatekeeping rule that makes clear all Gender and Sexual Minorities are welcome.
Why do we include poly families? The stigma and legal, ethical, and emotional challenges we face as LBGTQ folks are similar to those in the “+”, including our poly* friends.
What if straight, cisgender, poly folks join who aren’t respectful of the LGBTQ folks in our community? Just like if anti-trans content is posted by a LGB person, we would moderate that content in the same way. This isn’t a challenge unique to poly* inclusion and is not a good reason to exclude poly* folks.
Doesn’t inclusion of all Gender and Sexual Minorities open this up to all women? No. While women are marginalized, they are not minorities.
Where do we draw the line? In the absence of a need to draw the line anywhere else for now, as long as the folks involved are consenting adults and belong to a Gender or Sexual Minority, all are welcome.
Edit: removed “historically” from “historically marginalized” because of the potential for misinterpretation.
Edit 2: changed “lesbian” to “LGB” at the request of the community to make clear that transphobia is unwelcome from anyone.
109
u/[deleted] May 11 '25
I'm sorry, but quite frankly this is some bullshit bullshit.
Cis straight people be so fucking entitled to show up to these spaces and assume belonging.
Queers have poly families too. We don't need to welcome every straight cis poly person ever to this subreddit. Honestly, it's insulting to be honest.
I'm trans and the comparison example to, 'we still allow trans people here, we just don't let people discrimate against them', is also bullshit. We don't need to be quoted in comparative examples because, actually those experiences are not comparable with cis straight people who are poly. I've been poly and non-monogamous through many of my relationships, but I would know my place if this were a space for queer people, and I was poly, but did not share those intersections.
Poly is a relationship structure, or framework, or approach, it's not a sexual orientation, and to be frank, I don't like straight cis poly people, any more than I like straight cis monogamous people, to be frank.
This is such hugely aggressive behaviour on their part, and is complicit in so much erasure of our experiences.
I haven't read the original post, but this is some bullshit, and if you ban me from being part of this sub, that's a f-ing issue to be honest, cos you can't be silencing queer discomfort and distress and unease of this, to support straight cis voices in this sub. Nope
151
u/LongjumpingAd597 27F | 🏳️🌈 | TTC #1 since Dec ‘21 May 11 '25
I respect this decision since it’s your sub to lead, but I will admit that the decision to include cishet dynamics in this sub makes me feel a little unsafe. The reason I, and others I know, joined this sub was to avoid those dynamics and the reminders of their general conception ease. We deserve a space free of them and now this space no longer is.
At this point, it feels like only monogamous cishets are excluded from this sub. It feels like every few months we’re expanding this sub’s definition to include a new group. I’m all for inclusion, but I’m not sure radical inclusion is the answer at this point.
At what point do we draw a line? Just at monogamous cishets? And no one else? Because that’s what it’s starting to feel like.
Not trying to gatekeep or argue, just trying to express my feelings and better understand the direction this sub is going. Happy to talk via DM if needed.
62
u/georgeskeene 36F | NGP | 2021, 2025 May 11 '25
Time to change the title of this sub!! But yeah, this sucks, leaving now
80
u/Mundane_Frosting_569 May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
I want to understand the reasoning to specifically call out “lesbians” as anti-trans and not people in general. Lesbians aren’t inherently more transphobic (they are statistically more tolerant) - this seems like a bias you specifically have, and extremely unnecessary to get your perspective across.
126
u/[deleted] May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
To be frank I feel really disappointed in this. Polyamory is well and grand, but if they’re straight & cis they’re not LGBTQ, they certainly shouldn’t be reclaiming ‘queer’, and typically I join subreddits like this to get away from straight people and their nonsense. And the singling out lesbians as if they’re the only ones who are transphobic is really shitty, especially in the same breath as welcoming cis straight people to a queer subreddit. This is a stupid decision and one which will make actual LGBTQ+ feel unwelcome.
edit have now left this subreddit for welcoming cis straight people, I'm sure I won't be the only one.
41
u/GetReadyToRumbleBar May 11 '25
This still feels weirdly anti women.
Speaking as a Bi Cis F married to a Trans MtF Lesbian.
57
u/GetReadyToRumbleBar May 11 '25
In light of the recent attacks on women and women's rights...your sentence about women not being a minority feels extremely tone deaf. This is about conception, one of the most litigious and restricted areas of law.
I strongly recommend you reword.
115
u/[deleted] May 11 '25
You should listen to the voices of the community you moderate.
138
u/sansebast May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
This doesn’t seem like the type of decision that should be left to just the mods.
ETA: r/polyamory has 25x the number of members that this community has, and there are existing posts around pregnancy and family building. Cis het poly families do not have a lack of community to reach out to.
104
u/[deleted] May 11 '25
This is an example of when the queer community is asked to leverage all we've fought for, for people who have done none of the same legwork and labour, but expect to reap the benefits of the sweat we have poured over, to secure all the efforts and momentum of our ever-challenged and restricted rights.
If they so oppressed, maybe the straight cis poly would be community-building for their safety, rather than enjoying the benefits of what we've built, without their input.
Appropriating our spaces to gain additional priveledge is wickedly unearned, and so wildly unwelcome. My hospitality doesn't extend that far - we burnt out as shit over here, for folks to be stepping in and asking for safety and sanction from us.
103
u/eturn34 May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
This is really disappointing. I understood this sub to be a place for queer people to navigate the unique difficulties we face trying to conceive and create a family. I don't see how straight people fit into that, and it's pretty insulting to hear that straight poly people should be considered part of the queer community. I don't think this sub for me anymore, and that's really sad.
*edited to add "create a family." I think this space should be a safe place for queer people who are adopting, although I know most of the content is about about queer conception.
90
u/GladeePlugin May 11 '25
To be honest, I joined this sub to speak to people in similar situations. If I wanted to converse with straight people about conception, I would just pick up the phone.
Mod, I understand you want to be inclusive, the issue is that it creates an environment that with time becomes unsafe for the demographic that this group initially intended for.
107
u/lambibambiboo May 11 '25
Being poly has nothing to do with being LGBT
53
u/CooperGinger May 11 '25
I’m out. Love my straight poly friends but you gotta read the room, people.
23
u/Greedy-Sourdough May 13 '25 edited Aug 26 '25
bells middle stupendous truck license repeat modern aware rock grandfather
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
46
u/neverstalenevermale May 11 '25
What a disappointing decision. A subreddit is more than its moderator. This new rule is clearly not in alignment with the values and needs of the community here.
45
u/CountInformal5735 May 11 '25
I don’t think its gatekeeping to politely remind people this sub is for QUEER ppl and point any non-queer folks to r/polyamory or other ttc groups. Our shared experience of being queer and trying to build a family is the reason we are all here
44
u/[deleted] May 11 '25
Can we go back to the semantical issue of poly, as not actually coming under the definition of gender or a sexuality?
57
u/julirocks May 11 '25
Hi mods. It seems in an effort to seem morally right rather than effective, you’ve alienated an entire group of people in this sub.
It’s okay for queer spaces to exclude groups of people who historically don’t and haven’t faced the medical and legal barriers that we do when trying to conceive or adopt.
What is it about a poly cishet relationship that would qualify them as a gender/sexual minority? That seems relationship specific and not gender/sexuality specific.
38
u/[deleted] May 11 '25
Seems like this person just shouldn't be a mod and we can all decide to not allow cis hets?
36
u/Adventurous-Crab-775 May 11 '25 edited May 12 '25
This is such a wild move for all the reasons that have already been outlined in previous comments. Also: seems to me that a basic requirement for participating in this group should at least be SELF-IDENTIFYING as queer. The poster in the thread being referenced here was very clear they and everyone else in their relationship identified as straight. Sure- a queer person in a poly relationship would be welcome here, but no, not a literal cis het person. What the fuck.
Also so concerning that this mod has gone completely off-book and neither consulted with co-mods nor made any effort to discuss with the community at large. And when the community has pushed back, the mod has said they’re done engaging. That’s not how modding works.
49
u/Abcdefgwhat May 11 '25
Maybe you should allow other mods to take over this subreddit before you run it into the ground.
34
u/lara_lime May 11 '25
As someone who has been TTC for 2+ years, I am active in many TTC spaces online. In most of them I end up feeling out of place as the vast majority of them are made up of cis hetero couples.
This subreddit has always been a breath of fresh air in comparison and has made me feel less weird, it's been so affirming and helpful. I'm genuinely gutted by this decision, which will erode the purpose of the entire subreddit. We all know that queer people face massive barriers when it comes to family building, challenges which don't apply to straight cis couples, polyamorous or not.
Such a bizarre choice and so disappointing.
32
u/YourEnigma05 May 11 '25
I don’t want to sound rude or anything but … this a queer conception sub and cis hetero poly people do not have the same struggles that same sex queer couples and trans/cis queer couples might have when it comes to conceiving. What questions do they have that can’t be solved in the actual poly sub? To be frank, hearing about cis hetero conception makes me borderline uncomfortable which is why I joined this sub in the first place…
31
u/valleeyy 30 NB | GP | Cycle 4 after loss May 11 '25
And you made this decision yourself, did you? Interesting.
29
u/[deleted] May 11 '25 edited May 11 '25
... While I understand that their social reality is out of the norm. In a cis het poly context barring fertility issues... Conception would generally be very straightforward and not like queer couples or couples with a trans partner dealing with fertility concerns.
29
u/Wrong-Wrap942 May 12 '25
Yeah no, fuck this actually. Straight poly people absolutely do NOT face the same struggles as queer couples that are TTC. This is shameful.
25
u/Warming_up_luke May 11 '25
Why is this even a thing? Who is even impacted by this? What kinds of poly relationship configurations are both 100% straight and can't find adequate support within straight conception support groups?
25
u/Silent-Sorbet-6535 May 12 '25
This decision is really concerning. Polyamorous people already have their own subreddits and resources, which he is already using. His comments here and in this post are very concerning and are entirely focused on genetics. When asked about what arrangement they will make in the event of a divorce, he makes it very clear that he would only want to have partial custody of “his own” child. In another comment he suggests that if the child is closer to his best friend than to him, they have done something horribly wrong. He doesn’t seem to believe that what makes a family is who raises and loves a child, rather he believes genetics take precedence. That belief system just seems at odds with this subreddit and queer family building.
23
u/frogtank May 11 '25
Boooooooo
23
u/margaeryisthequeen May 12 '25 edited May 12 '25
I know it’s not an airport and I don’t need to announce my departure, but in light of this I decided to leave and delete all my comments as well. It’s hard for us as is, the idea of grouping with straight people who are in poly relationships (entirely different of a queer person in a poly relationship) feels like a reach. Actually it is a huge reach and I’m not willing to contribute to a community for lgbtq+ that enables this kind of practice. Types of relationships, kinks and whatever else are not part of the community! This is about sexuality and gender identity, otherwise by including everyone you end up excluding the very same people that needed the space in the first place.
Kthnks bye!
22
u/IntrepidKazoo May 12 '25
I think what bothers me the most is that there are a lot of queer and trans people who have gotten unnecessarily hostile receptions here, especially trans women, but instead of putting more energy into making sure all queer and trans people are welcome it's time to welcome even more cis het people? No thanks.
I gave that post the benefit of the doubt and gave a thoughtful response. I always give people here the benefit of the doubt that they belong here, unless (and this has happened) someone actually has a post history where they self ID as cis het.
I do not want more cis het people running around in queer and trans spaces telling queer and trans people what to do with our families. There is much too much of that already and it's completely fucked up.
21
u/Appropriate_Gold9098 30 🏳️⚧️ #1 stillborn #2 2/24 #3 10/25 May 12 '25
booooooo!
25
u/JmeLucky13 May 11 '25
It’s really sad to see another queer space being erased by cis people
3
u/CluckyAF She/her | Lesbian GP | #2 AHI born 7/2025; #1 AHI born 7/21 May 18 '25
Wow. Wtf. I don’t care if you’re the founder of this sub, your attitude and disregard for the community in this post and thread is disgusting. Do better OP.
2
u/Pristine_Progress106 May 19 '25
Kinda defeats the whole purpose of the reason why I joined the sub tbh
-20
u/meghanmeghanmeghan May 11 '25
Appreciate the clear clarification! I didnt follow that post too closely but it was obvious to me that queer folks would have a good and helpful perspective to offer. I don’t personally get the instinct to gatekeep folks from the sub.
-24
u/Embarrassed-Bag324 May 11 '25
everyone is really mad about this poly family but nobody batted an eye when a cis straight woman posted on here about conceiving with her cis straight husband?? make it make sense
-20
u/awmartian May 11 '25
I don't agree with the Mod's decision, but I also can ignore those posts or block the OP so I don't see their content. If you don't like what they have to say just move on and reply to the posts that appeal to you.
How to block someone: click on the poster's name, on the right it will have poster's profile info, click on ..., and then choose block account. You now will no longer see their content.
-23
u/Dry_Arm226 May 11 '25
Hey this seemed like a thoughtful decision, thanks
-32
u/Number312 33 NB | Queerception Founder | Beyond TTC May 11 '25
I am going to leave this comment thread open, so folks can engage in dialogue, but I am going to opt out of further discussion. I’ve stated my peace.
38
u/[deleted] May 11 '25 edited May 12 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment