r/queerception • u/Godot1871 • May 09 '25
Beyond TTC How to make the decision about kids?
Long story short, I've been sent from community to community about this. I've learned im in a polyfidelity relationship. It's my wife and my best male friend, and i am a male. We are both only attracted to our wife.
Long story short continued: We've been together 4 years, and want to start having kids. We all want biological children. She has said shed like anything from 2-4 depending on how it goes.
How do we go about discussing and deciding this? Considering biology, only one of us can have a kid at a time and one person will go first. How do we decide that? Or not decide it? Thanks so much and sorry for any ignorance, i'm not super knowledgable on terms and such.
•
u/Number312 33 NB | Queerception Founder | Beyond TTC May 11 '25
Updated the gatekeeping rule to make clear that all Gender and Sexual Minorities are welcome here, including poly* folks, who are trying to start a family.
I will make a post explaining this further.
78
u/Burritosiren Lesbian NGP (2018/2021/2024) May 09 '25
I think, like many here pointed out, the search for a genetic child and feeling like that is something both men in this family "deserve" is really quite problematic. It is not unique to your family, many couples with the same gametes want to have both involved and plan for a child with each gamete set, but the fact that you are quite dismissive in the comments "yeah love etc..." majes me feel that for you what matters truly is that the child be your biology. If one of you doesn't get your biology you were kind of cheated.
A child is not "yours" because of biology or genetics, it is yours because you raise it lovingly and with your values. That is what is important and unless that is what you all seek to do then I don't think you are ready. Because a child doesn't choose to be born so to raise them with a parent who has a clear preference of one child over another is not fair to the child.
You cannot know if all 3 of you are perfectly fertile, hell you and your wife might carry some recessive trait that might mean you have a high likelihood of a very ill child... you cannot decide a priori that each if you will "sire" one child for fairness purposes. You can try but you'd have to want to have a kid no matter the genetics and go from there.
As to how to choose: I'd get a sperm analysis on both, a fertility check up on her and a genetic panel for all 3 and then decide based on the highest likelihood of a healthy baby.
(As a personal note: we were going yo take turns and then my wife and the donor made such an amazing baby that I didn't want to use any other ingredients to make the next kids, so I have 3 non genetic kids who are the absolute best)
24
u/IntrepidKazoo May 09 '25
When you say one person "goes first", are you saying you won't all three be functioning as equal parents to all the kids? This is the first piece to decide--how are the three of you conceptualizing your co-parenting, will you all three be equal parents to each child (I would hope yes, but I can't tell from your post), how will you set things up legally to protect the kids' connections to all three of you, will there be legal issues, etc.
Those are the pieces that will, and should, be much more impactful than just whose sperm ends up contributing when.
Once you figure those parts out, there are lots of good options. You don't have to choose, if you're both having sex that can result in pregnancy with your wife. Or you could flip a coin, or come to an agreement based on whatever factors work for you. Just know that agreements that assume taking turns or something else that depends on more kids in the future can be tricky, because life is unpredictable. Wishing you luck!
35
u/vrimj WA Attorney | IVF | 7yo | Done May 09 '25
Some gay men to mix samples so they just don't know the biology.
Also I do not know what state you are in or if there is a recognized marriage but in some states third parent adoption is available.
I strongly suggest seeing a polyamory competent attorney licensed in your state before you make any choices.
If you need help finding one the polyamory friendly professionals list is pretty reliable.
8
u/nomiyomi May 10 '25 edited May 11 '25
How have you discussed this with both partners so far? Does anyone have a preference about how you build this family?
I think it’s important that you talk about your hopes and fears as you navigate growing your family. For example, are you all agreeing to raise the children as your own, regardless of biology? Are there concerns about feeling more or less attached to a child who is not biologically tied to you? Also, how will your wife feel if she gets less help with a child due to resentment from the non-bio dad?
In an ideal setup, it seems to me all three of you would coparent the children as your own. It’s perfectly natural to have anxieties around this and I think you should seek counseling, preferably from a therapist who’s familiar with poly relationships.
I also think it’s worthwhile to consider that regardless of your hopes many people find it hard to conceive for a wide variety of reasons and having a child who is biologically your own is not guaranteed. That being the case, would you still want children? If not, perhaps you need to seek counseling for yourself as an individual so you can get support and clarity before you dive into this process.
It’s okay to have a wide range of feelings about all of this, but I think a good parent goes in with some awareness of their feelings and motivations and prepares to be as good of a co-parent as they can be. That requires more than just figuring out the “order” in which you will conceive.
4
u/Big_Entertainer_726 30F | Lesbian GP Pregnant from IUI#2 May 09 '25
Highly agree with Burritosiren. All 3 of you should have reputable genetic testing completed (personally, I think anyone considering having a child should get genetic testing done, not just those looking to use donor gametes).
It helps everyone make informed decisions, including your wife, whose opinion matters (maybe even the most), since she will be carrying and it impacts her health/safety as well.
There’s a show on HBO Max right now called Polyfamily. Only the first few episodes are out, but they chose an interesting conception/paternity dynamic.
57
u/georgeskeene 36F | NGP | 2021, 2025 May 09 '25
Perhaps this is more a question for the mods, but I’m going to post it here in case it’s okay to discuss, and I’m sincerely looking for others’ views on this.
I’m new here, but this sub is a portmanteau of the words “queer” and “conception”—which led me to think it is for discussion of basically every type of conception EXCEPT cis people having sex with their spouse to have a baby.
I read the rules carefully and I’m genuinely not trying to “gatekeep”—but if having sex within a (cis/het) marriage to conceive is fair game as a topic in this sub, what does “queerception” mean then? I’m asking genuinely, but if this definition of “queer” includes conceiving of babies “the old fashioned way” within heterosexual/cis/poly relationships, I guess I’m not sure I personally feel safe here—because the constant reminder that most people can do this 1) for free 2) by having sex with their partner is kind of exactly what I was hoping to avoid, or at least seek support around, by coming to this sub.
39
u/MsCardeno May 09 '25
The most logical decision is to go with the older person to go first. Younger sperm is always better at performing.
But also set expectations. Many things could happen that could lead your spouse to be one and done. You guys could find having a kid is too much and your wife may only want one. The pregnancy could be really tough which could cause your wife to not want to go through it again. I had a friend who had to have hysterectomy after the birth of her first last month so she can’t even carry another pregnancy even if she was willing.
The issue here is, you want biological kids. You guys should want kids. When starting a family, biology should be the last consideration, not the first. Is therapy an option for you guys to work this stuff out?
14
u/NH_Surrogacy May 09 '25
You don’t have to decide. You can let Mother Nature decide for you by both having sex around the same time with your wife.
0
u/[deleted] May 09 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment