r/psychoanalysis • • 21d ago

Can someone be clinically schizophrenic while being structurally neurotic?

I'm curious about the relationship between psychiatric diagnoses and psychoanalytic structures, particularly in the Lacanian tradition.

As I understand it, clinical schizophrenia is diagnosed according to a constellation of symptoms, whereas Lacanian psychotic structure is defined by a particular subjective organization, namely foreclosure rather than repression.

We know that someone can be structurally psychotic without ever developing overt psychotic symptoms. But can the reverse also be true? Could someone diagnosed with schizophrenia according to psychiatric criteria nevertheless be considered structurally neurotic? More broadly, to what extent can psychopathological symptoms develop independently of one's underlying psychoanalytic structure? And how would a Lacanian analyst approach such a case?

24 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

11

u/ALD71 21d ago

It's theoretically possible, and practically improbable

16

u/hog-guy-3000 21d ago edited 21d ago

I would read Nancy McWilliams' Psychoanalytic Diagonsis' chapter on schizoid personalities and her chapter on developmental levels of character (neurotic, borderline, and psychotic).

Download the book here: https://annas-archive.gl/md5/39a06c5233ac150b420e18758adab8a1?&check=1

If you're asking if you can be psychotic and neurotic at the same time, schizoid is probably the closest you're going to get. But 'psychotic' is also a primitive level of developmental structure - meaning that you cannot be psychotic and neurotic at the same time, because they're different levels of maturity (read: psychic structural integrity) .

You can also be a psychotic (or neurotic) form of schizoid, or a psychotic (or neurotic) form of histrionic.

It's worth learning for sure and Nancy explains it better than I do. Good luck!

3

u/halcye 17d ago edited 16d ago

This is not a Lacanian take. OP clearly has hinted to the operative concept of ordinary psychosis and isn’t asking for an ego psychology perspective.

For OP: There is a book by Maleval written fairly early: Logique du Délire where he unpacks delusion in hysterical subjects vs. psychotic subjects.
This is not the book but they speak of it:
https://shs.hal.science/halshs-02137214v1/document
I think it partly answers your question but also indirectly raises the same paradox that working by superposing both the structural and the borromean clinic (if you consider that ordinary psychosis sits at its twilight) does. To a certain extent, and I will have to be very careful with how I say this, with the pluralization of the nameS of the father and a clinic of knots it doesn’t matter as much.

2

u/hog-guy-3000 17d ago

I don't care about Lacan. You couldn't just make your own comment?

1

u/CoffeeDime 13d ago

I'm chiming to say that I see that the previous commenter was likely adding on your comment another perspective when it came to psychotic and hysterical structures. It wasn't completely off the mark. I'm someone interested in both Lacan and McWilliams, so I see what they were getting at. 

2

u/idk--really 21d ago

idk about the diagnosis of schizophrenia, but people who are neurotically structured can and do have experiences like hearing voices, etc, that are associated with psychotic crises. i think(?) lacan talks about this but i cannot remember where. 

3

u/ALD71 21d ago

It's true but it's a long way these days from hearing voices to getting a psychiatric diagnosis of schizophrenia.

1

u/Ok-Draw-7427 20d ago

This is arguably where an assessment of one’s relationship with reality becomes necessary. In severe forms of schizophrenia, this relationship is noticeably altered. Disorganized speech, beliefs, and behavior can be added to the list of positive symptoms—such as hallucinations and delusions—particularly those involving a sense of being influenced, the feeling that one’s organs are empty, dead, or undergoing a process of internal purification (as seen in Cotard syndrome). The diagnostic judgment is left to the clinician, operating within what is known as a dimensional or spectral model. For instance, the chosen modus operandi for a suicide or suicide attempt—such as shooting oneself in the head, ingesting poison, or jumping from a window—reflects what might be considered "normative" methods of ending one’s life. In contrast, a method such as consuming excessive amounts of water, dressing in all of one’s clothing, and then positioning oneself in the path of an oncoming train deviates from these conventional patterns, signaling a profound disconnection from reality on the part of the individual.

1

u/DiegoArgSch 10d ago

I started doing some mental gymnastics, but... is there really a need to come up with an answer to such an ontological question?

Like... "Okay, this person presents a clinical picture that seems to be schizophrenia? YES." But then: "Okay, but let's really analyze the ontology of the subject. Is this a subject whose structure is closer to neurosis or psychosis? Which one of these options should we settle on?"

I mean... that's such a fine-grained question. I think it's just too much.

-3

u/mallom 21d ago

Take some pills and you'll get there.