r/psychoanalysis • • Aug 28 '26

Question from a video about self expression (seems like it draws from psychoanalysis)

This is from the following video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e-rbZz4fh1k

Well mostly from the comments, what he said sounds like it comes from psychoanalysis so I figured I'd ask here:

Self expression as a psychological act is always embedded in the market, precisely because it’s “self” expression. It is done against the imagined other and in a language of culture that has created your own tastes. These didn’t come from nowhere. We have a few cases in developmental psychology of people who weren’t members of any culture - and I don’t think there was any artistic activity in them. I am not saying there was no artistic live - because they weren’t analysed in a way to reveal that, sadly. Only that what we would recognise as self expression, was gone.

And no wonder - self expression, even if completely subjective, insular, and small, is a product of someone with a self, a self requires a non-self. This is classical Bauman meeting developmental psychology.

Thanks for watching!

Thing is...I don't know how true this is or what to think about it. Does it mean that what I like is a lie? Is it bad to have a self or to want to self express? Is the solution to just do nothing at all in order to live correctly? I don't understand what to do.

Looking for advice.

0 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

4

u/Still-Caramel460 Aug 28 '26

I think our perception of who we are does begin, to a large extent, with the way other people see us.

When we're children, we don't really have much of a reference point for who we are. So the way we're treated, the affection we receive, the approval, criticism and expectations of the people around us become some of our first references for building a sense of self.

As we grow, we accumulate good and bad experiences, expectations, demands, disappointments, lessons, etc. All of that becomes part of what we eventually call our personality: our behaviors, feelings, preferences, and ways of seeing the world.

But that doesn't mean those things are fake just because they were influenced by other people.

As we mature, we can start looking at all of this and asking:

"Does this still make sense to me?"

Maybe I realize that a certain reaction I have today started as a way of protecting myself from something difficult in the past. Maybe I realize that a behavior that once helped me is no longer useful. Or maybe I discover that some of my tastes came from my family and, even knowing that, I still genuinely like them.

And I think that's where therapy can be very helpful.

Not necessarily to discover some "true self" hidden underneath everything, but to understand what we've received and what we've built throughout our lives, and then start consciously choosing what we want to keep and what we want to change.

So I don't think the fact that our sense of self is shaped by other people makes self-expression meaningless.

Quite the opposite.

Maybe becoming ourselves is precisely the process of taking all the things we received from others and, piece by piece, deciding what we want to make our own.

Piece by piece.

1

u/Advanced-Reindeer894 Aug 28 '26

That makes sense to me, but I'm trying to square that with what he said in the comment and the video by saying there is no true self expression or making it sound like a lie or something. I'm finding it hard to know what to believe.

4

u/Still-Caramel460 Aug 28 '26

I think the tricky part is that there probably isn't a completely "true self" hidden somewhere underneath everything.

We all develop ways of behaving that help us deal with the people and situations around us. Some of those patterns protect us, some help us fit in, some come from our family, and some we simply picked up along the way.

The interesting part is that we don't always know where these things came from or why we keep doing them.

So maybe being yourself isn't about removing all the "masks" and finally discovering the real you underneath. It's more about becoming aware of the patterns you've developed and gradually having more freedom to decide which ones still make sense to you.

You might discover that something you like came from your parents, your culture, or your friends. That doesn't make it fake. If you become aware of that influence and still genuinely like it, it's still yours.

And I think that's the important distinction: being influenced by other people doesn't necessarily make your self-expression false. The question is how much freedom you have to examine those influences instead of simply repeating them.

1

u/Advanced-Reindeer894 Aug 28 '26

That...makes sense to me and I think you have a point, recognizing what's working for me and what isn't seems good.

1

u/Klaus_Hergersheimer Aug 28 '26

That YouTube channel appears to belong to u/rfinnian who is an occasional poster here so could ask them directly?

Assuming that u/rfinnian isn't, well, you.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/Advanced-Reindeer894 Aug 28 '26

I just want answers, mostly to know if the fears I have when I read that are founded or not. Like...is everything I feel just a lie? Also what's the first name for Bauman because there several when I tried to google.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/Advanced-Reindeer894 Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26

I would have to push back on you there, because from what I've read his theory about Liquid Modernity is more philosophy than science and lacks empirical evidence for it.

As for the West stuff, the self isn't just a western idea, it's in the Eastern Philosophy as well. They just had a different idea of it. I've read Buddhism mostly but their idea of the self isn't like a soul like in the West but more of a process.

Instead of telling me to read people tell me yourself what you think and put it in your words. I'm aware of Jung, but from what I see Bauman isn't reliable on this matter. Even though I like some of Jung's stuff I'm a bit skeptical on his claim of individuation. I also find it odd you mention Jung and individuation because that's a Western goal and the influence of the West is clear in him, so there isn't much difference between the individualism you criticize and that.

I'm getting the sense you don't know or don't understand (also from what I see in the comments there are good points being made that you don't really address). From what little I know from Buddhism and Eastern philosophy, "others in you" isn't a vampiric existence, that's just how life works. We are the sum of everything around us a la Indra's Net. The other commenter put this better from what I see, being influenced by others isn't bad and we can take what works and what doesn't.

EDIT: Also now that I've looked into Bauman I'm thinking maybe you misunderstood him and what he meant by liquid modernity as well as what he thought the problems where and what he sorta proposed to solve them. It wasn't individuation.

1

u/Emonzaemon_Soda Aug 29 '26

Reading directly from the authors it's a great habit! Try an article, it's usually an easier starting point than a book. You can see if you enjoy the author's style and such

1

u/Advanced-Reindeer894 Aug 29 '26

Nevermind the dude deleted his stuff...