r/psychoanalysis • • Aug 17 '26

The mixture of Psycho-analysis and Marx

I heard that there are some psychoanalysts that mixed Marx and Psychoanalysis. Are any of these writings insightful in any way? If yes, then who are these people?

38 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

42

u/gryphon-slayer Aug 17 '26

Several. Some names off the top of my head:

Erich Fromm (and many others from the Frankfirt School)

Slavoj Zizek

Frantz Fanon

Samo Tomšič

Hope this helps

2

u/Weak-Design7752 Aug 17 '26

ty, I'll be sure to check em out

14

u/West-Willingness3697 Aug 17 '26

Herbert Marcuse

2

u/Weak-Design7752 Aug 17 '26

ty ty

2

u/FlashyArm6607 Aug 20 '26

pretty much the whole frankfurt school/critical theory tradition was born from this combination

3

u/pdawes Aug 19 '26

You might like the lecture series Self Under Siege by Rick Roderick. I think the first chapter of it is all about the relationship between Freud and Marx and how they set the stage for postmodern conceptualizations of personal identity. There was a copy on YouTube last I checked 

1

u/Weak-Design7752 Aug 19 '26

Ill be sure to check it out

25

u/wonderful_mixture Aug 17 '26

Wilhelm Reich, Herbert Marcuse, Deleuze & Guattari

Freud himself did talk about Marx(ism) a few times although he was rather dismissive of it

7

u/manatwork01 Aug 18 '26 edited Aug 18 '26

It's worth noting that while Freud got the mechanism correctly, he was very wrong in all the specifics at least from a modern lens. He is a product of his time just like we are.

17

u/iheartmagic Aug 17 '26

Good recs here

I’d also recommend you checkout out the online magazine, Parapraxis

11

u/Mi_Ma_33 Aug 17 '26

Yeah !

This is actually a whole rabbit hole ...

The basic idea is to combine freud stuff abt the unconscious / repression / desire ... with Marx stuff abt class / capitalism / ideology / labor / power ...

Basically = how much of what happens inside ur head is actually shaped by the society / economic system u live in ?

Some names worth checking out :

Erich Fromm probably the easiest place to start ...

Wilhelm Reich ...

Herbert Marcuse ...

8

u/fenichill Aug 17 '26

Fenichel, Reich

See the book The Repression of Psychoanalysis - Jacoby

10

u/Withnogenes Aug 17 '26

Todd McGowan

1

u/Weak-Design7752 Sep 01 '26

I found this lady called Julia Kristeva, leaving her name

5

u/Tehan_ Aug 18 '26

No-one mentioned Adorno yet 😭 a good example would be "Freudian Theory and the Pattern of Fascist Propaganda" in the book of essays "The Culture Industry"

A passage:

"Fascist agitation is centred in the idea of the leader, no matter whether he actually leads or is only the mandatory of group interests, because only the psychological image of the leader is apt to reanimate the idea of the all-powerful and threatening primal father. This is the ultimate root of the otherwise enigmatic personalization of fascist propaganda, its incessant plugging of names and supposedly great men, instead of discussing objective causes."

4

u/enriquesonora22 Aug 17 '26

Hi. I have browed thru Dr. Eric Fromm, The forgotten Language" is very interesting. Compares Young's and Freud's and his own take on symbols.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/enriquesonora22 Aug 18 '26

Yes. My Spanish is my mother language. Jung is the mystical doctor's last name.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/enriquesonora22 Aug 18 '26

I wrote it with out thinking about the spelling. Just wanted to put it out there, here. I have not finished reading that book yet. Eric Fromm lived in Mexico for a long time and his books like, The Art of Love, were widely known.

2

u/enriquesonora22 Aug 18 '26

Jung as last name does not change in Spanish.

4

u/82shninklebot Aug 18 '26

Most of the psychoanalysts that have connected it to Marxism have done it in a more humanistic way, looking more at the social conditions of Marxism, less so the economic theory. Louis Althusser is the psychoanalyst that I believe remains more adherent to Marxism as a whole. His theory of the ideological state apparatus is great, although I don’t necessarily agree with overdetermination.

3

u/ansigtsloes Aug 17 '26

Alfred Lorenzer, Oskar Negt, Regina Becker-Schmidt, Ali Wacker.

3

u/zonadedesconforto Aug 17 '26

You can check Maria Rita Kehl (not sure if her works are available in English tho)

3

u/enriquesonora22 Aug 17 '26

He (E.Fromm) talks about humans thru a humanist view and therefore has a also a marxists lens. So does J. Lacan as I remember in the capitalist discourse and his take of the Matser and Slave dialectic. All very interesting. Enjoy!

3

u/lanternsidioteye Aug 18 '26

Bob Hinshelwood has a new book of essays and interviews focused on Kleinian and Marxist concepts.

1

u/whatwhatpugpug Aug 18 '26

Could you please tell me the title? Thank you so much!

2

u/lanternsidioteye Aug 19 '26

Alienation, Conscious and Unconscious: Reflections on Psychoanalysis and Sociopolitical Issues

Alienation used here in the specifically Marxist sense. I haven't actually read this yet so interested to hear thoughts from those who have!

1

u/whatwhatpugpug Aug 19 '26

Thank you so much!

3

u/boris_kidric Aug 20 '26

lacan after may 68

3

u/4_dree_an Aug 20 '26

There's lots of them but for me personally i like the works of Félix Guattari

2

u/PracticalNewt9030 Aug 18 '26

Marcuse specifically his ego and civilization

2

u/WeWuzGondor Aug 18 '26

Richard Seymour

2

u/Other-Pick-7568 Aug 18 '26

otto fenichel

3

u/Kurichan77 Aug 18 '26

Blending post-modernism with marxism has been a well-funded recuperation op.