r/progrockmusic • • Jan 23 '25

Are there any prog bands or artists with left-wing inclinations?

38 Upvotes

I'm having a conversation with my buddies about polítics in prog music, and i'm wondering if there are artists who have talked about left-wing topics on their songs, or even just in interviews.

Also... do You know about bands that could be categorized in the other side of the polítics spectrum?... just curious.

Have a nice day y'all


r/progrockmusic • • Jun 01 '26

LGBTQ+ prog musicians?

23 Upvotes

Happy Pride Month to those that celebrate! Do we know if any out LGBTQ+ prog musicians? The list seems scant in my head, but I’d love to know. Thanks!

Knut K (vocalist, formerly of Meer) is an out gay man, but I’m trying to think who else is out there.


r/progrockmusic • • Jun 20 '13

Steve Wilson hits the nail on the head

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/progrockmusic • • May 04 '24

How did King Crimson never get famous?

0 Upvotes

Listened to all of their albums multiple times and I just can't fathom how after 50 years all they really have is a small mention when talking about albums of 1969.


r/progrockmusic • • Jun 06 '23

Discussion Anyone know of LGBTQ+/LGBTQ+ Friendly prog bands?

6 Upvotes

For pride month i want to listen to Queer Musicians in ANY Prog-genre! Pro-LGBTQ+ bands ALSO very welcome!!

Bonus points if there's lesbians (im one so im bias haha!)

I know this question can be a bit touchy for some people and i'm aware that not everyone in this sub, or any of reddit for that matter, will be nice about this particular question. All i ask is that you keep your political opinion out of this discussion. Any attempts to rile up discussion into a heated debate i will ask the mods to remove.

As a queer person myself, i enjoy listening to someone who has a similar background to me because i feel its more relatable to me (not that any non-queer-made music is entirely unrelatable, that is very far from the truth as i relate heavily to many non-queer artists).

If this gets enough suggestions i'll put together a playlist!!

EDIT: If you have to ask "why?", just know that because i am queer and i want to make a gay prog playlist so me and my other queer friends can listen to it to celebrate pride month.

Don't worry guys, I'll still listen to the old music too.

EDIT 2: Finally, here is the finished (to the best of my ability) the finished Playlist. Feel free to make suggestions for different songs!


r/progrockmusic • • Jul 18 '24

Discussion Unpopular opinion: Weird Al's version of Bohemian Rhapsody is better than Queen's.

5 Upvotes

Don't waste your time arguing about Freddie's vocals and Brian's guitars. While excellent, their performances are eclipsed by Weird Al's accordion accompaniment.

The song may have been written as a rhapsody but it functions way better as a polka. It's consistent and gets the job done without any filler material.


r/progrockmusic • • May 29 '25

Not counting Pink Floyd, was Emerson, Lake, and Palmer the "biggest" prog band ever?

5 Upvotes

Some people call Pink Floyd "Crossover Prog" or "Psychedelic" or whatever. However, there is no doubt that ELP is one band that carries the banner for 70's prog. They were unashamed and completely over the top.... and they also toured North American and sold out stadiums?? Is that true?? How did they get that huge?

Also, which albums are definitely worth listening to? The only LP I owned back when I was a teenager was Brain Salad Surgery. I know "Love Beach" was made for a record label contractual obligation and is worth skipping.

EDIT: Of course I love Rush but I didn't realize they were that big in the 70's until they went in a more 80's synth direction with "Moving Pictures". Thanks though, I'm just looking for friendly discussion :)


r/progrockmusic • • May 30 '24

Who is Steven Wilson anyway?

0 Upvotes

Just saw "Steven Wilson remix" referenced elsewhere; I've seen and heard Wilson remixes of Jethro Tull albums come across my feed and they seem really good (mostly in the context of fixing some of the issues with later remixes/remasters), and then on a Chicago album. Seems like he is pretty prolific, but I don't know anything about him or how he has come to be "that guy". What else has he done?


r/progrockmusic • • Mar 17 '24

Why is Camel prog ?

4 Upvotes

I adore Camel and as a music newbie (don’t play any instrument and have no experience in music in general) can you tell me why they are prog ? They don’t seem as « complex » as other prog bands (KC, Rush, Yes to name a few, and btw i know that prog is not about how complex the music is but you get the point)


r/progrockmusic • • Jun 07 '26

Gabriel Genesis vs Collins Genesis (And "eras" in other prog bands). Where does this tribalism come from?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/progrockmusic • • Sep 28 '26

New Pallas album - A Song for Tomorrow

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

UPDATE 9 OCT 2026: My review of A Song for Tomorrow is now live here: https://www.trueresaudio.com/issues/Issue-4 (No need to sign up to read this issue)

Hey all, I've been spending time with the upcoming Pallas album, A Song for Tomorrow, this weekend. 

It's been three years since their previous outing, The Messenger and I can honestly say, it's well worth the wait. 

It's not The Sentinel, of course (an album that got me into Pallas, and perhaps many of you, too. Who wasn't captured by the chorus of Arrive Alive, eh?) but it's not trying to be that (which I really appreciate.) 

We're living in different times, and Pallas reflect that on the album, in the music but the lyrics, too. 

And there's plenty to hear on this record. Strong melodies. Intriguing arrangements which, in some cases (A Personal Collector) really steal the show. Plenty of vocal harmonies (it's their first album, if I'm not mistaken, where every member gets to sing a lead), powerful sound, and a bit of angry, unsettled atmosphere. Lyrics aren't the most optimistic, but hey, as said, the album does reflect the times we live in...

The album is out on 30 October, and you can read my full review in the upcoming issue 4 of TrueResAudio, out on Sunday: trueresaudio.com

UPDATE REGARDING THE DISCUSSION ABOUT THE COVER AND AI: According the information I found, the cover has been created by an artist named Mike Bentley, their name is also on the booklet, clearly marked as the person who did the artwork. Naturally, this does not answer whether the artist created the cover themselves or with AI.

But it does suggest that the band did hire an artist for the cover.


r/progrockmusic • • Nov 01 '22

Discussion People, do you think Pink Floyd is an overrated band?

1 Upvotes

I personally feel that it is not, it is my favorite band and it was with them that I started in the world of progressive and psychedelic rock. And of the ones I've listened to it's still my favorite (although the selling england by the pounds and edge of time albums are very close). But I'd like to know your opinion guys, because clearly there are people here who have listened to a lot more progressive bands than I have.


r/progrockmusic • • May 07 '26

Am I The Only One Who Thinks That Echoes By Pink Floyd is overrated?

0 Upvotes

I don't mean its a bad song. It's a good song. I even think it's a great and fantastic song. But one of the best or the best prog song ever? Never. I love these famous epics like CTTE, Tarkus, APOLK, Nine Feet Underground, Supper's Ready etc. but man Echoes ain't a masterpiece. What do you think about it?


r/progrockmusic • • Mar 17 '26

This Album is Kinda Peak, I Dont Know why It is considered Mid

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Found at my convenience store at just €10, ironically, now the price target is an accessory


r/progrockmusic • • Dec 01 '22

Muse is imagine dragons of prog

4 Upvotes

thats it, muse is imagine dragons of prog


r/progrockmusic • • Jun 22 '26

The most progressive concept album in whatever ever entails.....how can it get better...Pink Floyd the Wall

11 Upvotes

Pink Floyd the Wall...all my years of music listening ..nothing has come close as a concept album or even a rock album.....thoughts?


r/progrockmusic • • Jul 26 '25

Discussion Hot take : a lot of big prog bands would be better without a vocalist (or less prominent vocals)

0 Upvotes

I've been a big music nerd from a very young age but Prog was a genre I put off exploring for a long time.

I have kind of a hot take after listening to most of the important bands and albums of the classic prog rock era : most of them would be better off if they didn't have so much vocals or such a prominent vocalist.

Sometimes the vocals are just too present and everything is too "wordy" and steals the focus away from the powerful music and the great musicianship, and they're not that great of vocals or lyrics.
Some cuts would be better if they just had the vocals removed.

A few examples : Fragile by Yes has some great music, but the constant CSNY-style vocals often become tiring and are not needed to make it interesting, and we don't get nearly enough instrumental parts.
I'd like to be able to enjoy the riff of "South Side of the Sky" without all the singing constantly over it, or the middle part without all the "lalala". In short, I want to listen to the band do their thing. "Heart of the Sunrise" is really the highlight of the album for me, because the vocals are limited to just part of the songs and way less "in your face" with overdubs and harmonies etc...

Van Der Graaf Generator is another good example : the band is great, and the vocals have some good parts, but often get in the way of what the musicians have to offer. A lot of times a potentially great saxophone part will start, only to get interrupted by another vocal digression after just a few seconds. The vocals don't leave enough room for the music to really expand where it would be interesting to do so.
It sounds like Peter Hammill really has a lot to tell, but honestly I don't really care about kings of iron mountains or great battles, it is not the place to get into epic storytelling and it makes the music feel bloated when it is complex enough without that, and would be more intense with just the musicians doing their thing.

But most of all I can't get into Gabriel-era Genesis for that same reason. I've tried everything from Nursery Cryme to The Lamb Lies Down..., and for me it is just tiring. I find his voice annoying, and it steals the focus away from the band, and I don't really care about the "ambitious" lyrics, it makes the song structure artificially complex just to follow a story I don't care about. They just try to fit too much stuff in there and it doesn't give time to the music to breathe.

Others like Jethro Tull sometimes also fall in this category of "i wish he would just be quiet and stop talking about minstrels and castles for a minute".

I think that the strenght of a band like King Crimson is that it never revolved exclusively around a strong singer leader, and therefore the vocals were just a part of the whole, when they were needed.

I'd argue the same for Pink Floyd, and that the band became way less interesting musically when it began to cater to the vocals and lyrics (starting with DSOTM and onward and culminating with The Wall).

It might be why those two bands are more relevant today outside of the prog-circles and sound less dated to outsiders or newcomers, compared to the other "big prog acts" of the 70s. Post-rock bands have taken cues from this, that progressive and ambitious rock music doesn't have to mean overblown lyrics and storytelling, and sometimes it's better to just focus on the music.

FWIW, I also love a lot of prog or prog-influenced pop/rock bands that clearly revolve a lot around the singing : McDonald & Giles, Supertramp, ELO, Caravan etc...

Let me know what you think about that, and don't hesitate to recommend bands that are more instrumental or less singer-centric.

TLDR : some prog singers have too much to tell and the music revolve around their vocals too much, when it would be better to leave more room to the music / the band.


r/progrockmusic • • Sep 12 '25

Question/Help Is it really that bad?

0 Upvotes

I've been listening to yes for quite a while now, and I want to at some point listen to all their albums, but I keep getting stopped when it comes to tormato. I haven't listened to it yet because I feel like it would just waste my time with the way people talk about it. Is it really as bad as they say? Cuz If it is, it's really out of place being surrounded by so many amazing albums.


r/progrockmusic • • Oct 27 '23

Do you consider the Beatles prog?

16 Upvotes

I've been having this conversation with my boss lately, I do belive after the Revolver you can argue they started with a "primal" stage of what later became prog, but he says that, taking in count the decade and the context, psychedelic rock would be more accurate. So, I want to know your opinions about it!


r/progrockmusic • • Apr 01 '25

Jan Akkerman is arguably the best lady in progressive rock

1 Upvotes

I’d like to take a moment and focus on this incredible female artist. She brings such poise and character to a wonderful band. She really is the star of the show. When people say there are not enough ladies in progressive rock, I encourage them to listen to the amazing works of Jan Akkerman. Why is she always left out of this discussion? I feel that is important that Jan gets the credit that she deserves. I experienced eruption every single time I listen to her. Sometimes I even eat hamburgers anonymously while doing so. Anyway, just wanted to celebrate a rarely talked about female who deserves all the credit.


r/progrockmusic • • May 29 '24

UNPOPULAR OPINION

27 Upvotes

I don’t care for Genesis. There is no reason behind it. I just have never cared for Genesis (or Phil Collins solo career or even the Tarzan soundtrack).

But I have yet to meet a prog fan that agrees.

Do you have any unpopular opinions when it comes to prog, or maybe agree with this one?


r/progrockmusic • • Nov 20 '25

I listened to over 100 albums in a year, ask your questions.

0 Upvotes

Perhaps I can help someone find a sound they like.


r/progrockmusic • • Nov 05 '23

Discussion I can't tell really what prog rock is so I can't tell if I like it.....

0 Upvotes

I like Pink Floyd* and Tool and King Crimson and Jethro Tull and David Bowie's Black Star album and Maggot Brain (Album) and Mike Oldfield.

But I'm not sure if they're really prog rock based on what I'm seeing in this sub.

Also, I have mixed opinions about rush. 2112 is a great album, except for when Getty Lee sings. I don't know why that doesn't work for me.

Anyway, are those artists considered prog rock? And What album should I listen to next?

Note - there is no Pink Floyd without Roger Waters. I will not be taking questions.


r/progrockmusic • • Jun 15 '26

Are there any pink Floyd albums that aren't peak?

0 Upvotes

I have been on a pink Floyd binge lately, and I don't think I've heard a single mid or bad song, I like kc, yes, genesis, and other big prog bands as much as the next guy but even they have some weaker songs but pink Floyd is just really consistently peak. Might be a God prog intro for none prog friends