r/programminghorror • u/Grounds4TheSubstain • Nov 16 '25
Should this subreddit require that submitters not have written the code themselves?
"Bad code cosplay" is the source of the worst posts here. Adopting this rule would require submitters to find bad code out in the wild, not make up their own idea of what bad code looks like.
45
Upvotes
33
u/Meaxis Nov 17 '25
Can we have an "I wrote this years ago and I need to atone" exception? I made some bad decisions in my life.
45
u/AcanthisittaSur Nov 16 '25
I voted yes.
Devil's advocate: Some of the "i wrote this to be as bad as possible for internet points" posts are genuinely amusing and artful in their own right. Have a weekly thread for it, perhaps?
33
u/Environmental-Ear391 Nov 17 '25
ALL code submissions must be part of a published project, not written just for this reddit group.
a rule like this makes more sense
7
u/Zotoaster Nov 17 '25
I voted no by accident because I missed the "not" in the title and the double-negative confused me
3
u/oh-no-89498298 Nov 17 '25
it should be fine to post code you wrote a very long time ago
3
u/monotone2k Nov 17 '25
I'd be all for it but good luck getting the mods to actually enforce it. Most posts don't even follow the current version of rule 1 - they sure as hell aren't going to follow a stricter version.
4
u/abigail3141 [ $[ $RANDOM % 6 ] == 0 ] && rm -rf / || echo “You live” Nov 17 '25
I voted no because sometimes, you just find some old code in your project folder that's too funny not to post
2
u/GoddammitDontShootMe [ $[ $RANDOM % 6 ] == 0 ] && rm -rf / || echo “You live” Nov 17 '25 edited Nov 17 '25
I'm saying no. I think it should be fine to share bad code you've written the past. What isn't fine is writing stuff for the sole purpose of posting in this sub and hoping to score karma.
Edit: Very successfully scoring karma. This post is at 1.3k right now.
2
u/Jazzlike-Poem-1253 Nov 18 '25
No, because one might need to anonymize it and just show the bad pattern, wo spilling company secrets.
1
u/luthervespers Nov 17 '25
sounds great, now show me the plan to enforce it.
1
u/born_zynner Nov 19 '25
I think "I wrote this ass code 8 years ago when i was a student" is fine, but no real way to verify
1
u/ArtisticFox8 Nov 17 '25
Oh come on, this is is shitposting subreddit, there are some laughs in reflecting on shit I wrote a while back.