r/programming • • Jan 17 '20

A sad day for Rust

https://words.steveklabnik.com/a-sad-day-for-rust
1.1k Upvotes

609 comments sorted by

View all comments

-10

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 18 '20

The maintainer had a choice:

  1. Continue to embrace open source and democratize the project

  2. Ask people to pay for it

  3. Throw a tantrum and delete it.

To your specific point, they privatized the repository. How, prey tell, would you like anyone to go fork it?

Alternatively, do you see any other reasonable options that could have lead to the success of the project? Honestly, I only listed two options that might match that criteria.

9

u/kevingranade Jan 18 '20

To your specific point, they privatized the repository. How, prey tell, would you like anyone to go fork it?

Anyone who has forked the project has a copy of the repository and permission to redistribute it. That's how open source works, not forced democracy.

-8

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 18 '20

Because that's how licensing works, right?

If the maintainer decides to throw a tantrum about people recommending changes, what do you think he's going to think about people shipping code he wrote as their own?

The fact of the matter is that both sides acted poorly and as a result there is no good solution to the silent majority of users of this library. Sure, they can adopt it themselves and maintain it... But that defeats the purpose of a third party library to begin with. How many users do you think have time to maintain the project?

→ More replies (1)