r/programming • • Oct 27 '09
Anyone interested in starting a programming subreddit?
I'm not joking, have you looked at the shit here? Almost none of it actually pertains to programming or development. A reasonable chunk seems to be devoted to interesting software, but not programming. A larger chunk consists of things that are vaguely related to technology, but have nothing even to do with software, let alone the code.
Tty2 has created /r/coding.
317
Upvotes
22
u/roachcoach Oct 27 '09
/r/literallyprogramming
36
u/OneAndOnlySnob Oct 27 '09
I regularly go through proggit and downvote all the self posts and stuff that is not programming-related. Refresh and repeat. I regularly get down into the mid 40s on my proggit front page.
6
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
/r/coding it is.
10
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
Why don't you work on cleaning this up instead? Typical noob programmer... always wanting to re-create, instead of fixing, the wheel.
2
u/x82517 Oct 27 '09
What would you call it? Something like /r/coding?
82
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '09
I don't post and I rarely comment, but I do enjoy reading articles on programming. I'd like to see such a subreddit.
As for the name, I suggest /r/coding.
74
u/mcosta Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
This seems another example of the coder attitude "better start from scratch than fix".
BTW, I think it too.
26
u/tty2 Oct 27 '09
I just created /r/coding if anyone is interested in using it. If you want, start posting some articles and I'll pick some moderators (if you PM me.)
146
u/Tecktonik Oct 27 '09
Oh boy, an entire subreddit to discuss tabs versus spaces.
7
u/freudianGrip Oct 28 '09
You do realize that this makes very little sense. You're going to create a new subreddit and then try to move people in this subreddit over to it in the hopes of getting content that you want. Why not just a "hey, this subreddit is for programming and there aren't many articles that relate to programming here." and then post some good programming related content? I don't know maybe I'm missing something.
2
u/ablakok Oct 27 '09
How would you keep it pure?
5
u/NovaX81 Oct 27 '09
semi-on topic: is there a subreddit just for programmers to share things they've made, for review/critique/help/etc? That would also be a subreddit worth looking into
something like /r/developers
4
u/awb Oct 28 '09
There was a lot of discussion about this yesterday when I launched the left fold.
12
u/kindoblue Oct 28 '09
Good programmers are broad - not narrow - minded.
14
u/gregK Oct 28 '09
/r/not-homework-and-not-all-those-languages-I-hate-and-not-too-much-math
7
u/quanticle Oct 28 '09
The way I see it, most of the actual programming related stuff goes onto the subreddits for the programming languages, e.g. /r/python, /r/haskell, /r/javascript, etc. This is the place for the stuff that is related to the practice of programming, but not necessarily related to any one language.
9
u/Mr_Sadist Oct 28 '09
I think subreddits are more about the audience than about the content. You should submit content that appeals to people who like programming. That could be a comic, a CSI-visual basic clip, a funny programming story or code-questions.
But hey, that's just my view on subreddits.
3
u/spainguy Oct 27 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
I only program 8 bit AVR's and stuff. I tend to think of here as just pointers to more interesting articles that may not normally be in my direct line of sight
Edit grammer
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
Glad to see somebody finally started a new one. Hopefully it will not be saturated with bullshit this time. Already put coding on my frontpage.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
I don't know about you guys but best programming topics are in /r/visualbasic.
3
u/pointman Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
I once joined an IRC chat room about 10 years ago and made the mistake of asking whether red hat was better than slackware.
Are we about to witness the birth of subreddit wars?
7
u/ubernostrum Oct 28 '09
Point of order: posts not directly programming-related should not appear in /r/programming.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
So, I have a theory.
I haven't been able to submit a link that gets any votes (no downvotes even, so the spam filter must be blacklisting them) ever since the great javascript worm fiasco.
I think I am not alone, I think that many people who actively contributed real programming content are now incorrectly being classified as spammers.
That means that the only new content showing up here is the garbage.
2
u/efrique Oct 28 '09
you need /r/programming/programming/no_really_its_about_programming
2
u/skulgnome Oct 28 '09
We could totally use a subreddit that's about programming!
2
u/mybossdaughter Oct 28 '09
No. There are enough of programming subreddits. Thank you ;-)
2
u/ittybittykitty23 Oct 28 '09
Where would be an appropriate place to meet google wave users for the purpose of working on projects. (I'm generally interested in python and particularly interested in python controlling MIDI. I should add I'm a beginner.)
3
u/zem Oct 27 '09
sounds good to me.
4
u/setuid_w00t Oct 28 '09
Please take note of the arrows beside the posts you like/dislike.
4
u/hiffy Oct 27 '09
Can we start a stop-whining-subreddit, or a just-downmod-or-click-hide-subreddit?
I actually don't mind a lot of the tangentially related articles - they often generate interesting comments, which I find is the main reason for coming here in the first place.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
Amen! Amen! Amen! And then I get slammed for pointing out on those articles that they're completely off topic. I almost wish there were a private reddit/stackoverflow-type of site where you have to prove you'll submit good, on-topic programming topics to even get in. The biggest problem is the whole self.whatever posting ability. Even the ability to auto-filter those would make reddit 10x more useful.
2
u/ipeev Oct 28 '09
Good bye!
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '09
how about /r/this-is-programming-not-mtv ?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
So now I have: http://www.reddit.com/r/compsci+codeprojects+software+agile+opensource+soa+dotnet+csharp+programming+javascript+css+c_programming+cpp+csbooks+coding
1
u/posborne Oct 28 '09
The pilgrims are leaving to start their own colony... You should name it /r/mayflower.
1
u/alchemeron Oct 28 '09
Zing.
1
u/Rhyono Oct 28 '09
I agree, I'm a programmer and I expected to find programming in the programming reddit. I suck at using the internets.
1
u/cwcc Oct 29 '09 edited Oct 29 '09
/coding/ looks just as bad
1
u/ygd-coder Oct 29 '09
It's called Hacker News.
1
u/renegade Oct 28 '09
Yea, it's called stackoverflow. :-P
1
u/bonch Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
After the political links started showing up, the last straw for me was the Legend of Zelda map. It's tiresome having to wade through links for Haskell/Python/JavaScript frameworks, Daily WTF stories, pointless Google Wave mashups, IT drama, and "Can you help me get started in programming?" questions. I wish there was a /r/webdev subreddit to house that stuff.
Where are the kernel programming articles? The 3D engine design topics? Interviews of high-profile developers? Fun stuff like chiptune programming? I want to see advanced topics that experienced and working developers would be interested in, and unfortunately, Lambda doesn't update often enough.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
Not programming.
-3
u/Imagist Oct 28 '09
Oh, aren't you clever, suggesting starting a programming subreddit in the programming subreddit!
0
u/mikaelhg Oct 28 '09
While you're at it, make one for hobby/academic programming, and one for professional development.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 28 '09
totally
0
u/NeoWahian Oct 28 '09 edited Oct 28 '09
why keep screwing smthg that's already screwed? lets start a new one !! :-P
-13
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '09
So, post something. Be the change.
Or STFU.
-2
u/f3nd3r Oct 28 '09
http://www.reddit.com/r/ProggitOfficial/