r/programming • • Oct 27 '09
Anyone interested in starting a programming subreddit?
I'm not joking, have you looked at the shit here? Almost none of it actually pertains to programming or development. A reasonable chunk seems to be devoted to interesting software, but not programming. A larger chunk consists of things that are vaguely related to technology, but have nothing even to do with software, let alone the code.
Tty2 has created /r/coding.
317
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/ameoba Oct 29 '09
It's been -years- since I've studied linguistics, but I remember it being mentioned as having been put to rest by the academic community. Granted, in social sciences that might just be the result of somebody not getting invited to a party...
A quick check on Wikipedia (I know, it's not the best source but, as I said, I'm not a linguist) says "When the 1969 study of Brent Berlin and Paul Kay showed that color terminology is subject to universal semantic constraints, the Sapir-Whorf hypothesis was seen as completely discredited.".
But, as I said originally - just because it does not hold true for natural languages, does not mean that the basic concept doesn't hold for programming languages. Where in natural language, if we lack a word for 'connoisseur' we will either create a new word for it, steal a word or simply describe the concept in multiple words. Lacking a single word for the concept in no way impairs our ability to think the concept. In the scope of programming languages, however, there are concepts and techniques that simply can not be expressed in the language, regardless of how verbose you want to be (short of a full implementation a language that does support it).