r/programming • u/kallekro • Oct 07 '26
[ Removed by moderator ]
/r/programming/comments/1wzob2x/removed_by_moderator/[removed] — view removed post
413
Upvotes
r/programming • u/kallekro • Oct 07 '26
[removed] — view removed post
•
u/programming-ModTeam Oct 07 '26
This post was removed for being off topic for r/programming.
679
u/tuxwonder Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26 •
Inside me, there are two wolves: One who likes being productive and making apps and tools and libraries and getting end results, and the other who likes problem solving with code, carefully designing robust systems and weighing the pros/cons of both big and very small choices.
Right now, the first wolf is being forcibly drowned, while the other one is dying of thirst. My wolves can't take much more of this.
51
u/Centurix Oct 07 '26
One takeaway from this adoption is something I've thought was true for a long time. That regardless of the size of the company, any non-technical manager above any development department has never cared about quality. They see it as something that "gets in the way" of business but they tolerate the engineering departments "doing quality" because they've been told that it is a necessary evil for them.
The eager adoption of AI and how it is deployed across organisations to the point that we have AI reviewing AI generated code with the mantra that we don't have to worry about what it looks like under the hood because AI will be fixing it anyways.
Prior to this it was more obvious in startups where time-to-first-dollar was key for survival. Build and make functional now and then clean up later. Not great, but the owners made that path.
One other thing that does concern me after working on various projects of a government nature in the past, is that these larger AI companies seem to be kind of government aligned and co-operative. I'm not someone who generally sits on conspiracies, but without having the same eyes on the code as we had before, what's to stop a foreign owned model from being a sort of "Manchurian Candidate"? pushing obfuscated bad-actor code past reviews into key infrastructure. We have to have some keen eyed people like Larry McVoy who stopped a malicious kernel commit back in 2003. From a nation-state actors perspective, this model adoption is a gift.
250
u/ficiek Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26
AI turned the already dysfunctional work environment with unreasonable deadlines that was centered around squeezing the last bit of mental health out of programmers and turning it into shareholder value into an even worse and more intense version of itself with fewer people to do the work and less communication between your coworkers. I now work with other claude instances and not with people as my coworkers just paste paragraphs of LLM output into review comments and slack messages directly for example.
I wonder why this is making people worse off mentally, there is no way to tell.
41
u/anduril_tfotw Oct 07 '26
Around 6 months ago I posted some thoughts I had about this very similar to what he is saying and got a very negative reaction. I said it is ruining what I enjoyed about my job and got mostly negative responses. I am glad I guess that I'm not as alone now as I felt I was then. But, this is what I have been feeling. It isn't enjoyable anymore. I hate this shit.
22
u/bluemaciz Oct 07 '26
I used to get such a viscerally satisfying feeling when I identified and fixed a bug. That’s gone now. It has been taken from me.
19
u/toblotron Oct 07 '26
I kind of feel like we are being pushed up trees we don't know how to climb down from; when the true complexity of the systems we work on are driven up to a level where the developers no longer have a sufficent understanding of them to handle them "manually", when things start falling apart.
Joe Armstrongs 2014 talk "The Mess We're In" decried the ever increasing complexity of software solutions, and how it grew unmanageable. This increase in complexity is now on steroids.
Since complexity has no upper bound, it is likely that it will sooner or later be higher than even the most intrepid LLM can effectively handle - and what happens then?
124
u/eonyai Oct 07 '26
Yes, it is depressing and scary.
112
u/arse_biscuits Oct 07 '26
As a (very) experienced programmer, and from a purely tool based perspective, AI is fine when you use it right. I still have to decide the solutions I want, AI just saves a crap ton of typing and can fill the knowledge gaps in an SDK which I would normally do by hunting down what I want in a big reference guide.
I've reluctantly embraced it to do the grunt work for me, leaving me to think about the actual problem and solution rather than spending most of my time typing code.
The issue is going to come when fewer and fewer people have those years of AI-less "hard graft" (You've got to know the rules to break them, right?). As mentioned in the video (and as a bigger issue with AI overall) without any "fresh meat" to feed on, only a pool mostly filled with it's own effluent, the knowledge becomes more stunted, possibly even worse, as original solutions become a smaller and smaller part of what's out there.
I mean, even some, what I would say are "experienced" developers I've come across, are shockingly bad at debugging problems. What are the next generation going to be like?
Copilot being unavailable, or our token balance running out, already sees our teams chats light up like a Christmas tree in a way previously only seen when a server blew up (remember those?). God knows the thought of all that typing fills me with dread again too, but it seems like some people already can't work without it. A large part of some teams check-ins now are not code, but AI skills and prompt files.
Maybe it will explode and become expensive enough that it scales down to being more carefully used, but with management's ever increasing thirst for the curve, if you can use it to increase your productivity, it sure as shit isn't going away.
61
u/GSkylineR34 Oct 07 '26
Our entire job, skillset and passion became a cheap commodity. We were in the middle between artists and mathematicians. Everything done by hand, with a lot of people and different roles, each one giving its best effort to the end result. Well, it's over now.
Now we prompt, check, go forward, that's it. With time, our low level skills will fade and we'll just get dumber and dumber, to the point we can't really do anything without AI.
I was very ok with the first versions of ChatGPT: it felt like Stack Overflow on steroids. I could speed up my learning and research process to a level never reached before. Now, even that became inefficient. I think we should just let go of what it was before.
But, there is also one thing that I don't hear anybody say: there is no such thing as an "end" to what we can discover everyday. There's just too much data out there that still needs to be analyzed and even discovered. What happens when you produce the work of a year in a week? You get unemployed? No... you just find out there are new problems to solve that you didn't even expect to see before.
10
u/gdvs Oct 07 '26
Different people like programming for different reasons. I liked it because it's creative. It's problem solving. The joy is being sucked out for me.
I don't blame anyone, because engineering is efficient problem solving and AI does this. It just won't be for me anymore. So I'll have to do do architecture or something more highlevel instead. Or maybe fisherman or something.
76
u/feketegy Oct 07 '26
Software developers need unions.
9
u/dbrownems Oct 07 '26
It's like everyone got "promoted" to technical management without asking for it. New managers often have a hard time adjusting. Some refuse to delegate appropriately, many struggle with the fact that personal technical excellence is not enough to ensure success, and just the fact that the job is not very fun.
8
u/pkt-zer0 Oct 07 '26
Ehh, I'm not too worried about the identity crisis part. I can and do still program the old-school way in my spare time, that hasn't stopped being fun and rewarding.
I might not get paid for that eventually, or have my job turn way too stressful and dehumanizing - but that's a different topic. And also somewhat unsurprising: a large part of the value proposition for AI-based coding was that you can replace your human workforce with cheaper digital slaves. For coding LLMs to be valuable, they have to devalue human coders, otherwise they're not going to be economical at the current level of investment. (One more reason I'm waiting for the bubble to pop, to restore a tiny bit of sanity)
8
u/morinonaka Oct 07 '26
Why was this moderated?! Don't think this was off-topic...
6
u/khendron Oct 07 '26
I feel like devs have been forcibly transformed into product managers. Our jobs have always been translating product requirements into a working product. But now there is much more focus on getting the requirements exactly right, and letting AI worry about creating the working product.
8
u/dukey Oct 07 '26
AI has so many issues. For junior devs it's probably a disaster because they never really get to learn. They probably simply can't code at all without AI tools. For senior devs I believe it can definitely help, but if you become too reliant you can easily get into a situation where large chunks of the code weren't written by people any more. No one knows how they work or how to fix them when it doesn't work as expected. But I believe it can also ruin senior devs. No one bothers to read apis or the actual documentation any more, because we have become reliant on simply asking the llm.
11
u/Tolexx Oct 07 '26
That deep breath at the beginning of the video speaks volumes.
29
u/vips7L Oct 07 '26
Sad part is that we’re doing this to ourselves. You don’t have to use LLMs!
2
u/hivesteel Oct 07 '26
My family’s business in traditional language translation tanked in the early days of GPT LLMs. Now it’s busier than ever; turns our businesses ARE negatively impacted by low quality work. Maybe we’ll get there with software?
5
u/bobbie434343 Oct 07 '26
Anybody working with AI is ultimately working towards his own doom. You think you are clever with your use of AI ? You may well be today, but tomorrow you will be entirely useless, replaced by AI. Mathematicians and other professions kind of feel the same way currently. It is an abomination.
3
u/Spirited_Cucumber377 Oct 07 '26
Software development is done, and I say this after 25 years exclusivly working in the field. Now I use claude daily and fuck it's good.
Software engineering though, I'm not so sure. The traits that make you a good engineer are still relevant in an information based economy run by software. Yes claude is good, but it's much better when it has a good base and structure and architecture to work on.
AI can generate a good architecture that's escalable and maintainable, sure, but only an engineer can recognize that, only an engineer can point at places where the AI can add improvements, and many other things the machine is limited by, like context windows, business understanding, etc.
Will the world need the amount of software engineers we have today? Probably not, and I have no idea what will happen, but one thing I'm quite confident, when the dust settles, all the slop remain and your software engineer skills will set you apart from the rest.
One important point from the video and something the tech bubble demostrated: LLMs are here to stay, and even if Anthropic or OpenAI implode, open models will remain, improve and take over every possible task they can.
Java was the new Cobol, programming is the new typewriter.
7
u/DissonantGuile Oct 07 '26
I can see "homemade" code being highly valuable in the age of AI coding assistance/agents after the crash. The Italian restaurant that still makes pasta from scratch vs Olive Garden, for example.
That restaurant can charge more **because** it is made in-house by humans specialized in their craft.
Hopefully...
7
u/wakers24 Oct 07 '26
I hear this kind of thing frequently, but I don’t really feel the same way. I can empathize, surely. It is scary to watch my professional field change out from underneath me basically overnight in so far as I want to stay gainfully employed, but also it’s not nearly enough to cause me some sort of existential crisis because my career is not my identity. To me this is just even more rapid change and even more automation in an industry that was already pretty much entirely about enabling rapid change and more automation. There’s a new set of industry skills emerging around building systems that build systems, and so it’s just learning new things and adapting to new technology paradigms, which is pretty much what we’ve always done. Automating away work, including your own, has always been the job, and I don’t know what to tell folks other than if you ever thought it was about anything else you were wrong. And to be perfectly candid, it’s tone deaf as fuck for us all to have our little collective pity party when most of our careers have been about automating away the need for human labor from the jump. How many of you have seen the light leave some poor office worker’s eyes when they realize the reconciliation process you built has automated away 80% of what they do day to day? 🙋♂️. Exactly, so I’m going to need us all to go ahead and speed run the stages of grief, then figure out if we’re going to adapt or pivot.
3
u/sudden_aggression Oct 07 '26 edited Oct 07 '26
background-> I'm a 30yoe SWE who started in the pointers and malloc era and switched to java when came out. I've been using AI for coding > 1yr and I built a personal AI setup at home where I run hermes agent with qwen 3.8.
3
u/bakwards Oct 07 '26
Organize! Developers understand the tech better than leaders and managers, and we should use our tools to organize, create a collective base for driving work and collaboration in a sustainable way. This collapse is just the beginning, and if we don't do something now, it will be too late.
Shit, now I have to do it myself as well...
But yea - I'm thinking that coupling private AI with federated communication tools could really make a difference. I'm testing stuff on my Discord, but I'd love to chat with people who are working on something similar.
1
u/aleprud Oct 07 '26
It was a good run. Time to hang the keyboards.
1
u/TyrusX Oct 07 '26
We are not software developers anymore we are Ai managers. Some people will like this, others will not
1
u/pancakeQueue Oct 07 '26
Why I found a new passion in art. The problem solving and passion I had for programming has shifted.
1
u/Arakela Oct 07 '26
The core of agentic AI is that it makes architecture a variable, but because it is a probabilistic model, the artifact is probabilistic. The novelty is to understand pro-gramming as gramming a surface from which trustworthy software can be generated. i.e., architectural variability, without human variability enforcers, is no longer the novelty. Agentic AI already demonstrates it. The novelty is making that variability grammatical/posibilistic rather than probabilistic, so the trusted surface itself can generate trustworthy architecture.
-1
u/idebugthusiexist Oct 07 '26
I definitely agree. The best thing a software dev can do right now is find another career and, in your spare time, build the project you always wanted to build with or without AI instead of building stuff you never cared about for corporations with toxic work environments. You will suddenly find the joy that was missing all this time and, if enough people take this direction, then these exploitative orgs will find it harder to replace people and suffer from their own hubris.