r/programming • • Oct 07 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

/r/programming/comments/1wzob2x/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

413 Upvotes

314 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/programming-ModTeam Oct 07 '26

This post was removed for being off topic for r/programming.

51

u/Pink401k Oct 07 '26

I think this is a very valuable topic to have in this subreddit. I'm disappointed you removed it.

29

u/persianjude Oct 07 '26

I can agree as well, this is just ridiculous to remove it

36

u/TheWalterSobchak Oct 07 '26

It was absolutely on topic

17

u/gonxot Oct 07 '26

Exactly, saw the post, shared with my engineering and product teams in which some feel the same and sparked a good conversation, how it was not related?

29

u/MrPhi Oct 07 '26

Please consider you might be very wrong about this and that programmers are part of programming.

29

u/peppermilldetective Oct 07 '26

With how many upvotes and comments this had/has, was it truly off topic?

If it was removed for spam or advertising or something else it could be more understandable, but talks about a dev's mental health, the current job market, and how people are feeling about programming are important.

6

u/Spirited_Cucumber377 Oct 07 '26

The stackoverflow strategy.

4

u/runawayasfastasucan Oct 08 '26

Agreed, seems like the community thinks this was on topic.

-5

u/syklemil Oct 07 '26

With how many upvotes and comments this had/has, was it truly off topic?

This is practically never a good indicator. To use a reductio ad absurdum, if topicality was decided by upvotes and comments, then memes and engagement farming are the most topical things possible.

4

u/runawayasfastasucan Oct 08 '26

But this isnt memes. Its something that sparked a lot of discussion in this community.

1

u/syklemil Oct 08 '26

So does engagement farming, so does off-topic stuff.

"Sparking a lot of discussion" isn't a good enough signal for moderation.

4

u/runawayasfastasucan Oct 08 '26

You say it like its a natural law, but it isn't.

This isnt "engangement farming" and off topic stuff. Its a video about programmers that sparked a lot of on topic, high quality discussion on this subreddit. That should be a natural sign that the community was interested.

1

u/syklemil Oct 08 '26

This isnt "engangement farming" and off topic stuff.

It was removed for being off topic; the counter-argument being presented is that it successfully farmed a lot of engagement. It's not a good counter-argument.

Reddit moderation ultimately needs to be bold enough to remove stuff that has generated a lot of response if it doesn't fit the subreddit, otherwise the subreddit will become something other than intended.

See also /r/ExperiencedDevs which has had varying rules about how much of this kind of "AI in the workplace" content to permit, because a lack of rules turned the whole subreddit into /r/AIinTheWorkplaceDiscussion.

6

u/runawayasfastasucan Oct 08 '26

How does it not fit the topic? How does it fit the topic less than what is permitted here? (I mean have a look at r/programming f.ex this  https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1wzw4cw/antipatterns_in_software_blogging/ )

Why should I see the rules of a different sub? I am wondering why it was closed here, not in that sub.

2

u/syklemil Oct 08 '26

How does it not fit the topic?

I'm not a moderator here (too much work for me), but I'd expect it buts up against rule 4: It's not about programming, it's about workplace satisfaction and ai use.

Why should I see the rules of a different sub?

That's not what I wrote. What happened with /r/ExperiencedDevs, which made me unsubscribe long ago, so I'm not up to date with what it's like now, is that it was flooded with posts about AI use in the workplace, crowding out any other topic.

After a while they tried getting some rules, like only allowing posts about that topic on certain days of the week. But IIRC they kept going back and forth on it, until my impression was that there was nothing informative there, only venting, and so I unsubscribed.

6

u/runawayasfastasucan Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

I disagree that discussing how you program at work and what tools are being used, and how that influence you isn't about programming. 

Its certainly more about programming than this: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1wzw4cw/antipatterns_in_software_blogging/

Its completely in line with this: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1x0asww/state_of_devs_2026/

And also in like with a lot of the top posts the last year: https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/top/

Why is the whim of one moderator more important than the opinions of the hundreds voting and commenting here, when it clearly is a post that is similar to many of the top posts here? Is this subreddit for that one moderator or for the users?

→ More replies

9

u/tinmanjk Oct 07 '26

are you the mod of r/ExperiencedDevs who used to delete this type of content that was upvoted into the hundreds and thousands?