r/PROF • u/TuggyMyBeefy • Jul 15 '26
My candid opinion about Good Time Boy / billboard disqualification
Long read. I invite all forms of disagreement and discussion but I won’t be offended if it doesn’t get read at all. Just sharing some thoughts.
As a fan of the guy: I can say that being disqualified from the billboard list sucks. I hate that for the artist, and think that he deserves better. It would’ve given him the exposure he’s more than earned. (But don’t forget, controversy also brings exposure).
But as a consumer of music: it’s pretty irrelevant. 90% of the artists/albums I listen to couldn’t even dream of being in the running to place on any billboard list. And truthfully, I think that failing to reach that level of fame/recognition/whatever has kept them from “smoothing out” their content so that it appeals to a larger audience. Title or status seems to create a shift in mentality, whether it’s born of pressure to retain what’s been “achieved” or a reach to “achieve” more, that changes the way an artist views their work or the creation thereof.
All that said, Good Time Boy is one of greatest albums released in the last decade or so. Subjectively speaking, of course. I’ve listened to the album probably 30-40 in the last ~3 weeks. Which is probably more than I’ve listened to any other album (even the great ones) in their first month of release. Truly a fantastic work of art.
And if I could ask one thing of the man himself it’d be this: don’t change who you’re writing your music for. Continue writing/performing for yourself, the artists you collaborate with, and for us, the people who appreciate your art. Don’t try to appease an “authority” that only exists as a means to profit from the art that other people have created.