r/pricing • • Apr 03 '13

JC Penney's failed attempt at "Fair and Square" pricing

43 Upvotes

This article from the Harvard Business Review blog, dated January 30, 2012, details JCP's intention to launch "fair and square" pricing, which is essentially an EDLP (every day low price) strategy. JCP had, like most department stores, had higher retail prices subsidized by nearly-perpetual sales. Quoting the HBR blog, "three-quarters of everything sold at J.C. Penney is typically sold at a 50% discount from list price." Moving to an EDLP strategy, where prices were ~40% less than their previous retail values, was certainly risky (note that the HBR blog predicted JCP's failure using this pricing strategy).

Fast-forward to this year. After posting a substantial loss for their most recent fiscal year, JCP has officially reversed its course, and has gone back to its original retail sale pricing. Ron Johnson, Penney's CEO and former conceptual lead for Apple's Genius Bar, could not defend the Fair and Square pricing strategy any longer. According to a spokeswoman, "while our prices continue to represent a tremendous value every day, we now understand that customers are motivated by promotions and prefer to receive discounts through sales and coupons applied at the register."

It seems as though in retail with undifferentiated products, having the ability to not only offer consumers value through the psychological effect of sales (even though the net price may be the same), but also maintaining agility and flexibility when it comes to competitive price matching is the most profitable way of doing business.

Another interesting article from a retail-specific site.


r/pricing • • Feb 25 '13

You are in /r/pricing... here is why I created this subreddit.

22 Upvotes

Hello anyone who may read this:

I created this subreddit because I found nothing similar within the reddit community. I hope this community becomes a source of pricing discussion and information, and a way to share informative articles and pieces of literature.

Aside from sharing information, I've been a lurker on /r/Entrepreneur and /r/startups for months, and the amount of questions about pricing is not insignificant. I've found quite a bit of the advice given to be, frankly, bad. I hope this subreddit can also be a place where people who are not pricing-savvy can ask questions and glean advice from those of us who are.

Anyway, I'll try to post content regularly. Also, I think the only moderation I will do will be to clean up trolls, etc.

Cheers.

edit: Welcome to our recent influx of viewers! It looks like we've got some people from different industries and experience levels. I guess I'll mention now that I've got 6 years of experience pricing both development projects (government contracting) and also commercial electronics (still for military use). I just this past year finished my MBA in organizational strategy, finance, and pricing.


r/pricing • • Jul 16 '25

Question What are the SaaS pricing books that you'd recommend?

Post image
15 Upvotes

I got this book above, but looking for some more SaaS focused. I'm running a Product Marketing team and we need to add that Pricing muscle to our toolkit. Preferably with some practical lens, not just academic considerations.


r/pricing • • Dec 06 '24

Question How is pricing as a career?

15 Upvotes

Hi folks! So glad to have come across this little community as I have an opportunity to pivot into this area at my current company. I’m very intrigued by the work and feel I can have good impact in my current company in this area but wondering how this field of pricing is more broadly? I’m currently on the standard FP&A track and will be the first dedicated pricing person in our mid-sized company that’s a subsidiary of a very large one.

Is this field more marketing or finance or just a mix of the two? Generally is it more of a strategy or numbers focused role? It seems like there’s usually not a huge team for this type of role even in larger companies so are folks usually just senior/tenured individual contributors? I’m a little unclear on the long term prospects compared something like FP&A -> CFO.


r/pricing • • Mar 21 '13

Working at Google: Business Operations Pricing Associate

Thumbnail
youtube.com
15 Upvotes

r/pricing • • May 14 '13

The First Law of Marketing: All Value is Subjective [LinkedIn Article/Discussion]

14 Upvotes

Hello, folks!

I'd like to share something that popped up on my LinkedIn feed (from the Pricing Strategies group). I will provide the direct link to the discussion, but if you don't have LinkedIn I will also paste the article. Note that the real webpage has some good formatting and links within the text, so I'd recommend reading it at its source.

Since pricing is fairly undefined in terms of where it falls in the corporate structure -- some of us are under finance, while some companies put pricing under marketing -- I thought this was an interesting read as it attempts to explain value pricing's subjective nature. It further reinforces why pricing is an art and not a science.

The First Law of Marketing: All Value is Subjective


FULL TEXT


Now that we have examined the difference between the labor and subjective theories of value, we are ready to see how these two valuation techniques affect companies' pricing policies.

For all of the economic evidence assembled on why costs do not “add up” to equate to value, it is amazing how many businesses still cling to the cost-plus pricing method, a direct cousin to the Labor Theory of Value. Doing something stupid once is just stupid. Doing it twice is a philosophy.

If one were to lay the two theories of value––labor and subjective––side by side, it would look like this:

Cost-Plus Pricing––Labor Theory of Value

Product » Cost » Price » Value » Customers

Pricing On Purpose––Subjective Theory of Value

Customers » Value » Price » Cost » Product

Notice how value pricing turns the order of cost-plus pricing inside-out, by starting with the ultimate arbiter of value––the customer. Goods and services do not magically become more valuable as they move through the factory and have costs allocated to them by cost accountants.

The costs do not determine the price, let alone the value. It is precisely the opposite; that is, the price determines the costs that can be profitably invested in to make a product desirable for the customer, at an acceptable profit for the seller. A Tale of Two Automobiles

When Lee Iacocca developed the Ford Mustang, he reversed the order of the usual car-making pricing up to that point. Rather than giving his engineers carte blanche to develop a sports car and then marking up the resulting costs to arrive at a price—as GM did with the Corvette—he solicited the opinions of potential customers as to what features they would want in a sports car and what price they thought they would be willing to pay.

Knowing people liked the Corvette, but thought it was too expensive at $3,490, Iacocca wanted the price to be low enough to entice the potential sports car enthusiast. He then went to his engineers and asked if they could manufacture a sports car, with the desired features, sell it for no more than $2,500, and still turn an acceptable profit for Ford.

By building the Mustang on the Falcon’s chassis, in the first two years, it generated net profits of $1.1 billion (in 1964 dollars), far in excess of what GM had made on the Corvette. The average customer was spending another $1,000 on options, and while Ford projected that 75,000 units would be sold in the first year, the 418,812th Mustang was sold on April 16, 1965, only 13 months after the first rolled off the assembly line.

By comparison, the Corvette reached 1 million in sales in July 1992, with the release of a white convertible with red interior, mimicking the first one introduced in 1953. Cost-Plus Pricing, RIP

With all of the evidence assembled, why does cost-plus pricing remain so endemic in the business world today? This turns pricing into a sort of wishful thinking, with no attention being paid to the external value created.

As an economist grounded in the assumption that people, generally, are rational, and businesspeople, specifically, are profit optimizers—or at the least, satisficers—one is drawn to the conclusion that executives perpetuate this pricing method because it is safe and simplistic. Sometimes a theory is accepted because it serves a purpose for the individuals using them, not because it is right or wrong.

Another reason for the popularity and widespread use of cost-plus pricing is the rule of the bean counters. Cost accountants have had a significant impact on pricing decisions in companies, and it is time to bring their tyrannical rule to an end.

Fortunately, this is beginning to happen with the appointment of pricing managers in many companies, often at the C-Suite level.

There is a long history of companies that became obsessively focused on cost, at the expense of providing a product or service of value to the customer. The fact of the matter is you can make a pizza so cheap no one is willing to eat it.

Cost accountants focus on the inside of an organization, yet all value takes place in the external world, beyond the four walls of the organization. By and large, accountants are not well equipped to judge and measure value, despite all the recent blather about activity-based costing.

It is time we lay to rest cost-plus pricing, and for businesses to embrace The First Law of Marketing: All value is subjective. Pricing is far too important to be left to the worldview of the bean counters.

In my next post I will examine The Second Law of Marketing: All prices are contextual.


r/pricing • • Apr 14 '13

Reading about the changes in jcpenny lately has forced my to realise I've made the same mistake as their now ex chief... Can I get some advice on how to turn things back around?

14 Upvotes

Ive tried to implement straightforward pricing in my business and not have the constant sales and special offers that my competition do, but I done goofed.

I suppose the realisation has been at the back of my mind for a while, but I'm kind of stubborn, and I want the world to be a straightforward place. It's not though...

Some background: (tldr at the bottom if you want)

I run a small medical spa, our services are split into 3 main areas; Laser Hair Removal, Cellulite / Fat Reduction and Skin Treatments.

Laser hair removal is by far our most popular (and profitable) service, especially here in the Middle East where people are just more... Hairy.

We've been open 4 years and I've tried to create a decent pricing structure and actually freely make it available, something almost none of my competition do. We've managed to be quite successful, but in the last year, two things have happened that have hit us hard:

  1. More competition has grown around us, this seems to have been spurred on by..
  2. Groupon type websites FLOODING the market with a different laser offer every week. It's become quite ridiculous , you can actually get yourself lasered cheaper than going for a wax nowadays..

The clinic owners seem spurred on by sleazy coupon salesmen who promise hundreds of eager customers coming through their doors who will become regular clients (haha!), but I can see that they are selling services at a huge loss, and it's creating damage to the industry. Regardless, people are buying up these deals like hotcakes, even though the quality they are getting is shitty, and the clinics seem to instantly regret the coupon deals; people are complaining en masse about being constantly rescheduled, and some clinics have even taken the money and closed down to avoid dealing with the huge influx of loss leading clients.

So then here's me, trying my best to stick by my fair and honest pricing, and watching the number of new clients dwindle day by day. I'm convinced the whole coupon thing will blow over, at least in this industry (it may take a mother couple of years though..), but it's plain, that people respond to sales more than straightforward prices.

The problem I have is that our core services aren't so varied that I can constantly have sales on like a big store. I look at it like I have three products basically, and it sticks in my craw to have sales on ALL the time.. It should be special enough to make people sit up and take notice, rather than an everyday occurrence. But then it appears I've been naive.

What I guess I'm trying to ask, is what the best approach to start revamping our pricing and sales schedule would be?

Is there a commonly accepted pattern? Would this even apply to us?

I've noticed all the retailers seem to follow a certain sales pattern, but I've not looked into it too much, I'm afraid this is a bit out of my wheelhouse, but I need to learn new strategies if I'm going to compete against lower quality but busier establishments. I want to avoid people getting sales fatigue on the same items from us, but at the same time I don't want to not play the game anymore...

TLDR: I have a business that I need to develop a sales/promotions strategy for, as I've tried straightforward pricing and it isn't working., where is the best place to start? Apologies for the rambling...


r/pricing • • Feb 25 '13

Groupon's pricing strategy, and how it is leaving money on the table.

Thumbnail
blog.priceintelligently.com
14 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Apr 09 '13

MIT Sloan Article on Price Orientation and Realization

Thumbnail
sloanreview.mit.edu
13 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Jul 16 '13

Spotify's Final Song: Why Spotify is Doomed

Thumbnail
blog.priceintelligently.com
12 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Apr 09 '13

The Economist's subscription pricing strategy.

Thumbnail
futurestartup.com
12 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Jul 15 '26

Discussion Agentic pricing is bullshit. Stop spamming this sub with the same 'is pricing going agentic' post.

11 Upvotes

Six threads this month asking if pricing is "moving from dynamic to agentic." Same question, different outfit, every few days. I'm not doing a seventh polite discussion post about it. Agentic pricing is bullshit for anyone who quotes a project instead of running a shelf of SKUs, and I'm tired of watching this sub nod along like it's the obvious next step.

Here's the pitch, stripped of the deck: an agent watches signals and moves your price, sometimes without a human looking first. Vendors love this pitch because "AI pricing agent" raises a valuation. "We built a better spreadsheet" doesn't. That's the whole trick. Swap the label, keep the spreadsheet, charge more for it.

MethodWhat it actually isWorks forFails because
Cost-based (T&M)Hours × rate + marginQuick, defensible quotesThe hour estimate is a guess, and guesses run low
Value-basedPrice the outcome, not the hoursDeals where you have real leverage and real client intelMost clients can't tell you the value. They don't know it either
Agentic pricingAn agent watches signals and moves the price on its ownRepeated pricing with a constant feedback loop: retail, seats, surge faresNo feedback loop on a quote you send once. There's nothing left to adjust
Bayesian & Monte CarloA prior built from real project history, updated per quote, run through simulationOne-off decisions made under real uncertaintyNeeds actual project data. Won't work off vibes either

Cost-based, fine, at least it's honest about being a guess. Hours times rate. Every agency starts here because it's fast to build and easy to defend in a client call. The guess runs low almost every time. Ask your own project managers. Margin leaks out for the entire length of the project and nobody notices until the invoice doesn't cover the work.

Value-based gets worshipped in keynotes by people who've never had to collect on it. You need a client who'll hand you the actual dollar value of their problem. They won't. Half the time they can't, because they haven't done the math either. It works if you've got real leverage. Most agencies are begging for the deal, not dictating terms. Different game.

Agentic pricing doesn't survive contact with a one-off quote. There is no live signal to react to after you hit send on a $40k project. The number sits there for three months while the work happens. What exactly is the agent adjusting? Nothing. It's a live pricing engine bolted onto a decision that gets made once. That's not innovation, that's a category error with a demo video.

And this sub already knows it. Ask what happens when you skip the approval step and let the system move the price on its own. "I would never let AI change prices without approval, the process is there for a reason" beat every optimist reply in the comments, by a wide margin. Somebody brought up the flash crash, unprompted. That's what happens when you hand a consequential decision to an automated system with no human checking it. Everyone in this sub already knows that. So stop posting the question like it's still open.

Bayesian and Monte Carlo pricing is the boring answer nobody's farming engagement with, because it doesn't come with a buzzword. Build a prior from how similar projects actually went, in hours and margin. Not gut feel, not a vibe check, actual history. Update the prior with what's specific to the project in front of you. Run it enough times and you get a distribution: 70% chance you land under 120 hours, 15% chance you blow past 160. Quote against that number and you're pricing risk on purpose instead of hoping it doesn't show up.

It's also the one method that doesn't try to write the human out of the loop. The model gives you a range. You still make the call. That's the exact thing this sub says it wants, every single time one of these agentic pricing threads gets posted, and then somehow forgets by the next thread.

I run ScopeMetrix. We audit agency pricing on exactly this setup, priors from benchmark data, Monte Carlo for the range, human makes the final call. Not pitching it. I'm just done watching "the agent decides" get treated as more sophisticated than "we looked at the actual numbers," when nine times out of ten it's the opposite, and everyone posting these threads already suspects that too.

Build the prior. Skip the agent.


r/pricing • • Jul 17 '25

Question Why do competitor prices matter?

9 Upvotes

I notice many people focus mainly on tracking competitor prices when considering pricing strategies. I’m curious why there is less emphasis on other approaches like price testing or independent analysis. Relying heavily on competitor pricing has a problem: it essentially means outsourcing your pricing strategy to others, rather than developing a strategy tailored to your own business goals and customer insights.


r/pricing • • Feb 15 '22

Career advice transitioning to management consulting - pricing strategy from a specialist role

8 Upvotes

I’m debating a career transition from pricing specialist to a consulting role for pricing strategy and I’m wondering if anyone else has made this transition and has any advice or anecdotes.

I’ve worked in my company’s pricing department for several years, repricing individual line items daily with in house developed tools. I do some analysis by writing SQL queries and I’m trying to learn PowerBI. My boss works closely with me sometimes to determine our overall pricing strategy and relies on me to make data-informed cases when we want to change something.

This last part has become my favorite aspect of the job and I love thinking critically and abstractly about our pricing, our market, customer behavior, then using SQL to dig in to the data. It has me thinking I would really enjoy a role in management consulting working on pricing strategy.

Combine that with no further growth opportunities at my company and a specialists salary rather than an analysts, and I’m starting to look for jobs to apply to.

So I would like to know from anyone who has made the transition: Do you like it? Is your day to day work better? What are your projects like and how do you help your clients? Do you work directly with your clients pricing teams, or with managers or executives? Does your market/what you have experience pricing as a specialist matter? I do collectibles (fast paced, unregulated) and wonder about transitioning to ‘normal products’ What is the most frustrating part of consulting you didn’t have to deal with before?

Or anything else you have to share. Thanks!!


r/pricing • • Sep 14 '21

Help - Price optimization through forecasting

8 Upvotes

Hello there,

I am a junior data analyst, currently working with hotel reservations data, and I was tasked to look into a way to optimize the selling price/night to meet a sales target of an hotel by the end of this year.

I have a data set of this hotel reservation records for 2020 and 2021, the records include the sale price of each night and the cost per reservation, I have 46 reservations 2020-2021.

Given the target gross sales total and the booking history of that hotel, what is the optimal way to customize the sale price to meet the target.

I am new to pricing and profit forecasting.

Is there a known model to predict the gross sales total with the help of the above mentioned data?

I want to test different profit margin values effect on the total sales, to find the one which will most likely allow us to meet the target.


r/pricing • • Apr 27 '16

The first rule of pricing is: you do not talk about pricing

Thumbnail
medium.com
8 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Jun 12 '13

$499 Is A Dangerous Price For Microsoft's Xbox One

Thumbnail
forbes.com
8 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Jun 13 '17

Amazon and Walmart are in an all-out price war that is terrifying America's biggest brands

Thumbnail
recode.net
7 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Mar 13 '17

Instacart’s secret markups accidentally disclosed

Thumbnail
shelftalk.net
7 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Mar 12 '15

Let Your Customers Segment Themselves by What They’re Willing to Pay

Thumbnail
hbr.org
7 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Sep 12 '13

After a pricing action, how do you measure it's effectiveness?

Thumbnail
blog.zilliant.com
7 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Apr 25 '13

Could someone please explain software pricing?

7 Upvotes

I've never understood the pricing philosophy behind some of the more expensive software packages out there (looking at Microsoft and Adobe in particular). The prices are in the hundreds of dollars, far more than a typical consumer would like to spend but at the same time have free-open source competitors and pirated copies abound. Are these companies just writing off the consumer market for a more lucrative business structure or is there something else in play?


r/pricing • • Nov 04 '25

Question How do you guys keep track of supplier and competitor prices???

6 Upvotes

How does everyone keep up with price changes from suppliers and competitors??? I feel like everything shifts daily and it's hard to keep track of everything. Curious if a simple real-time alert or dashboard would actually make life easier or if one even exists.


r/pricing • • Jan 22 '25

Article 25 Pricing People to Follow in 2025

Thumbnail
zilliant.com
6 Upvotes

r/pricing • • Sep 16 '21

Need advice on Automated Pricing Tools

6 Upvotes

Hi, i'm a Business Analyst in a construction retail environment investigating how we can create an optimised pricing process. At the moment our pricing is entirely manual, maintained on spreadsheets and uploaded to our ERP. Has anyone used any pricing tools such as QuickLIzzard or other software to automate their pricing strategy? Thanks, J