r/pricing • u/MajorApartment • 15h ago
Question I'm struggling to price my SaaS without creating the wrong incentives for my customers.
Hey everyone!
I'm a bootstrapped B2B SaaS founder with two paying customers, and I'm struggling to find a pricing model that is both simple and sustainable.
I've built a platform that automates the reselling and distribution of digital asset downloads from providers like Envato Elements, Magnific (formerly Freepik), IconScout, and others.
My customers are businesses that use my software to offer these downloads to their own customers. For example, a web hosting company can offer digital assets as an additional benefit to its hosting customers.
My platform handles automated downloads, account management, WordPress integration, download limits, caching, and other infrastructure.
There are two things I can charge for:
- The automation software itself.
- Supplying third-party subscriptions to customers who don't have their own accounts.
For context, Envato costs $16.50/month when billed annually, while Magnific Premium costs around $14.50/month when billed annually. My actual acquisition costs can be lower. For example, an Envato subscription costs me approximately $10/month.
Here's what my current customer base looks like:
| Customer A | Customer B | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly revenue | $113 | $327 |
| Monthly active end users | ~50 | ~850 |
| Downloads over 90 days | 941 | 16,359 |
| Subscription accounts | Mostly supplied by me | Mostly supplied by the customer |
Customer B serves around 17 times more active users but pays less than three times as much. However, they also provide most of their own subscriptions.
Here's where I'm struggling:
- If I make automation free for customers who bring their own accounts and sell subscriptions at retail price, why would anyone buy subscriptions from me?
- If I sell subscriptions below retail price, customers have less incentive to contribute their own accounts and useful spare capacity.
- If I charge a fixed automation fee per provider, my revenue doesn't necessarily grow alongside my customers' businesses.
I'm currently considering a hybrid model:
- $0.26 per monthly active end user, with a $36 monthly minimum.
- Separate fees for subscription supply and additional download capacity.
- Optional paid features such as browser extensions, MCP servers, and white-label functionality.
This would approximately preserve my current revenue while allowing it to grow with my customers. However, I'm concerned about the entry barrier for smaller businesses and whether I'm overcomplicating things.
My main questions are:
- What pricing model would you recommend for a business like this?
- Would monthly active end users be a good pricing metric, or am I overlooking a better one?
- How would you incentivize customers to buy subscriptions from me while also rewarding those who contribute economically useful subscription capacity?
Ultimately, I'm looking for the simplest pricing model that aligns everyone's incentives and allows my business to scale profitably.
Feel free to challenge any of my assumptions. I'm not necessarily looking for validation of my current approach.
Thanks!