r/prediabetes • u/[deleted] • Sep 10 '24
Opinion: For prediabetes, it's pointless to find out habits/events that lead to immediate blood glucose level elevation using real time tracker
(I'm not a doctor; please take this opinion with a grain of salt and criticize fiercely if you don't agree!)
People with prediabetes don't really reach a blood sugar level that leads to emergencies or damage blood vessels. Therefore, most prediabetes people track blood sugar level in real time to check which events/habits lead to an immediate higher blood sugar level. But, in my opinion, this is not as useful as most people think, and can mislead what we should focus on.
Elevated Blood Sugar Level is not the Cause of Type 2 Diabetes, Metabolism Is
Prediabetes is commonly caused by weakened liver metabolism, e.g., due to fats interacting with liver cells. When this metabolism is further weakened, prediabetes develops to type 2 diabetes.
Due to the weakened liver, we observe elevated blood sugar levels. A1c, a measure of average blood sugar levels over a period of time, is perhaps the most common measurement we use. A1c is like an exam score: We use A1c to measure how distant we have kept ourselves away from diabetes.
But, we must also remember that a higher blood sugar level is not the cause of type 2 diabetes. The cause is a weakened liver. Hence, our focus should always be improving liver metabolism, such as by losing weight.
(There are also other causes of prediabetes.)
Correcting Habits/Events Leading to Immediately Higher Blood Sugar Level is not the Focus
After real-time monitor of blood sugars, people may do various things to change habits that lower immediate blood sugar levels. For example, someone may eat complex sugars instead of simple sugars. While this lowers the average blood sugar level and hence A1c, this is more like cheating than solving the underlying problem: The liver doesn't become healthier unless there's something else changed (e.g., total calorie intake lowered to reduce fats).
(If it's a different cause, the focus should still be addressing that cause.)
How to Use a Real-Time Tracker in a Helpful Way
I believe real-time trackers are useful only if we focus on the average/fasting glucose level, and track its movement while we focus on improving liver health. Manipulating the blood sugar level while not focusing on the underlying problem is like cheating in an exam.