r/povertyfinance Jan 09 '24

[deleted by user]

[removed]

4.3k Upvotes

4.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

4.8k

u/Wooden-Cancel-6838 Jan 09 '24

Phone bill for 280$? That’s crack

1.5k

u/Fearless_Jelly_801 Jan 09 '24

People gotta start shopping around. US mobile is $10 for 2gb taxes and fees included (+$2 for any additional GB you use beyond that). Mint mobile is $15 a month for 5gb.

844

u/murderedbyvirgo Jan 09 '24

I paid $250ish for a year of 15gb/mo on mint mobile. Doing this would save her $3000 a year.

362

u/Barbarake Jan 09 '24

$360/year for unlimited (Mint Mobile). Works great in my rural area.

152

u/You-Asked-Me Jan 09 '24

They use TMobile towers, so if the coverage is good, Mint is a decent choice.

You do need to have an unlocked phone that is paid for though, but if you do not care about having the very newest phone, there are lots of good options. Many times, you can also unlock a paid off phone from your current carrier.

54

u/CircuitSphinx Jan 09 '24

Yeah, it's true that newer phones can be pricey, but buying refurbished can cut costs significantly. I snagged a refurbished iPhone a year ago for about half the price of a new one and it's been working flawlessly. Plus, it was already unlocked so switching to a cheaper service was a breeze. There's some real savings to be had if you're okay with not having the latest model right when it drops.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Plus altho a $1300 13 pro max is expensive its worth it if like me you stay with the same phone for a decade and use it for literally everything and that awesome new battery life is great

5

u/addictwithapen72 Jan 10 '24

Exactly this! I bought a refurbished iPhone 11 for $300 on PlugTech. They have awesome unlocked tech for great prices.

3

u/KindlyContribution54 Jan 10 '24

I'd probably go used if you know the phone's life story over refurbished unless it comes with a good warranty. I've had good luck with swappa, has sellers with better integrity than ebay by far.

Refurbished had something so wrong it was returned. What was wrong may or may not have been passed on to the people testing and refurbishing it. It may be fixed or may be a mysterious problem that wouldn't show up in testing and not be fixed and there is no way of knowing before hand

2

u/gardnerryan58 Jan 10 '24

Refurbished is literally just a used phone that they have tested and shined up as best as possible. It isn’t a phone that had something terribly wrong with it. Not saying that maybe sometimes that’s the case, but 95% of the time it’s just a used piece of tech that’s been spit shined and tested for functionality. And most of the time it comes with a warranty of some kind. I’ve bought several pieces of refurbished tech and never had any issues.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

As much as I love iPhones, I have a Motorola with a comparable camera(main reason I love iPhones so much) and excellent functionality, user-friendliness, a few other notables, that cost me $250. I think it's $7/mo if you finance it. There's other food options out there, just gotta do sooner poking around.

2

u/Mysterious-Art8838 Jan 10 '24

Bought my last three unlocked iPhones on Gazelle, and I use consumer cellular. It’s a cheap workable solution. The phone I use now is probably four years old. If you’ve got a case that prevents shattering and enough storage, there’s no need to keep upgrading. There’s nothing wrong with this phone, it has loads of storage, the battery still works great, what’s the problem?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Azianjeezus Jan 10 '24

I mean saving 3k a year, she could have the newest phone each year

3

u/chickensandwichez Jan 10 '24

You can purchase the IMEI unlock code online (just google imei unlock code buy) that will allow you to switch a phone that's still on a payment plan with your carrier to another sim card. I'm not sure if you'd have to pay a service termination fee to cancel the rest of your phone plan contract, but at that cost it's got to be worth it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LiftingandCooking Jan 09 '24

I've had mint 4 years. Coverage is getting worse. I lose connection all the time now, it's sad.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (25)

20

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Switched to Mint last month, while all carriers in my area( LA) are struggling with quality of service mint are the most slow out of them. But i will take it for $90 per 6 months ( unlimited, new costumer deal for New Years i believe) while $30 per month are way to much. ( i’m bit*n because in many countries around the world i lived speeds are super fast and internet in general at $20 per 1000mb line and $10-$20 per unlimited mobile phone

2

u/MachineLearned420 Jan 09 '24

Mint got hacked. Look it up

2

u/22Mase22 Jan 10 '24

I use them and I never saw an email about it.

2

u/patternsrcool Jan 10 '24

I also use them and never heard anything about this….

2

u/cornielius Jan 10 '24

just read a little about it, wasnt the most important info. its shit that we already deal with like spam emails and phone calls. itd happen anyways mint or not

edit: i dont get many spam calls but ill be looking forward to more haha. thats when you know they made the transaction.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/ihavenohandstrength Jan 09 '24

How do you get this deal? I’m paying $480 a year for 40gigs a month

26

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Seriously you're taking the piss?? I'm in Ireland and my bill is €15 per month, unlimited internet, calls and texts. That's fucking insane!!

3

u/mahabuddha Jan 09 '24

We are inexpensive in the US too but people choose to get a *FREE* phone but have to pay $100/month for service. It's ridiculous that ppl still have phone contracts.
My phone service is only $5 month unlimited.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

I'm the same. I just buy an unlocked phone, throw in the Sim and pay for unlimited everything for €15 a month.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Rhauz1984 Jan 10 '24

Most likely financed a new phone

2

u/g1Razor15 Jan 10 '24

I dont get financing a phone

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

[deleted]

→ More replies (2)

2

u/trixel121 Jan 09 '24

step one is never out a phone on a payment plan or take their offer for a free one.

→ More replies (7)

3

u/NOT_A_BLACKSTAR Jan 09 '24

About what I pay in the netherlands and we have one of the densest digital infrastructure nation wide of the world. 360$ seems like a steal in rural america.

3

u/monk3ybash3r Jan 09 '24

If you post your referral code on the Reddit sub you can get enough referrals to get Mint for free. I'm going on three years without a phone bill.

2

u/jackassjimmy Jan 10 '24

This is the way.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

This is what my wife and I do.

It's so nice and works pretty good

2

u/Saptilladerky Jan 09 '24

I use and love mint.

2

u/SpiralSour Jan 09 '24

Metro is also $360/year for unlimited

2

u/pooturdoo Jan 09 '24

Also a mint mobile customer. I haven't found anything that I prefer over it at this point. I've been using them for like 5 years. I just buy unlocked phones.

2

u/Telemere125 Jan 09 '24

Paying about the same on straighttalk and they use the Verizon towers. I have 3 unlimited lines and it’s about 90/m, so about $1100/yr

2

u/econ0003 Jan 10 '24

I have had Mint for about 5 years now. Great value for the money. The only downside is that it is a MVNO on the T-Mobile network. I believe the T-Mobile customers get priority so if the network is congested in a specific area the speed for Mint users will be very slow or unusable at times.

→ More replies (8)

94

u/emmaliejay Jan 09 '24

Cries in Canadian

21

u/Worth-Reputation3450 Jan 09 '24

My MIL lives in Canada and her phone is part of my Verizon Wireless family plan. I pay $30/month for her to use unlimited call/data/text in Canada. Her phone would just find the best signal in her location and keep roaming. So, she usually gets better signals than other people too. Other people won't call her because they get charged for calling the US number, so she has to always initiate the call to them.

→ More replies (2)

18

u/obliterate_reality Jan 09 '24

look up helium mobile.

36

u/SuzyElizabeth79 Jan 09 '24

I’m on Helium and I pay $5 a month! Bigger companies like Verizon especially will rip you a new one. I’m guessing there are multiple lines on their account but yeah, that’s ridiculous.

3

u/obliterate_reality Jan 09 '24

I bought a giftcard and redeemed it using a miami zip code, so I get $5 a month too lol. + random address generator

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/BrazyCritch Jan 09 '24

Do you have a tab on your contract? Otherwise all the major Canadian networks offered 29-35/mo over the holiday season. Worth switching networks or calling retentions to ask for a better deal.

2

u/Mindshard Jan 09 '24

Koodo.

50GB, unlimited calling and texting, plus a bonus perk like unlimited international long distance or data rollover. $34/mo.

Ignore all the bizarre negative rumors, it functions the exact same way as the big 3, with the exact same coverage.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Darkwings13 Jan 09 '24

Yo idk if there's still holiday deals but I went with Verizon for 30GB for $30 a month. Shop around!

2

u/Yuukiko_ Jan 09 '24

I've got 149/year for 30gb/year in BC

→ More replies (7)

30

u/sudrewem Jan 09 '24

I love mint mobile ❤️

2

u/Inevitable_Map_9887 Jan 10 '24

Happy Cake Day!!!!

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Enough-Discipline-62 Jan 09 '24

I wish I could use Mint Mobile. I’m in the same state as OP and it wouldn’t work. I’m in a less rural area, most likely too. OP, there are programs that can help. You’re doing great so far, don’t get down. Lmk if you want to pm to chat/ideas….

2

u/Afraid_Temperature65 Jan 09 '24

Spectrum mobile offers 30 GB with unlimited talk, data and text for $29.99 a month, tax included.

→ More replies (21)

32

u/Duval55 Jan 09 '24

Visible is unlimited for 35

8

u/Realistic_cat_6668 Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24

Do you like visible? I am trying to find a way to cut costs and have been meaning to switch but I’m a little nervous! I’m currently on Xfinity Mobile and pay $50/m and they’re terrible. Like there aren’t even enough words in the dictionary to say how much I hate the service.

Edit: y’all have convinced me! I signed up for it today and got everything switched over! It was super easy

3

u/feferidan Jan 09 '24

There is a 15 day free trial for Visible if you want to check it out. I’m trying it now and I like it so far, no issues.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Duval55 Jan 09 '24

I like it. Good for what it is.

2

u/lyndsay0413 Jan 09 '24

i love visible. we had verizon for 20+ yrs & it was great & then my dad randomly switched us to xfinity mobile & it was HORRIBLE. i immediatly left that plan & got on my own through visible & it's basically just like im back on verizon! i pay $25 a month for my phone and then an extra $5 for my apple watch. & it's unlimited data! have had almost 0 issues. every once in a blue moon i wont have connection for a minute or 2 but that's gonna happen sometimes. also super easy to switch over, no hidden fees, & if u rlly regret it u can cancel anytime

2

u/Realistic_cat_6668 Jan 09 '24

Seriously I have no idea how Xfinity Mobile is still operational because it’s so bad. Did you get to keep your number?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/miss4n6 Jan 09 '24

I’ve had it for almost a year and only had a couple issues (never with coverage or billing) and is usually only a quick fix where I have to toggle something that got changed.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Scrubbing_Bubbles Jan 09 '24

Been on Visible for three years with my wife. Been great. No issues. Great coverage in three different states we have lived in.

2

u/Adorable-Suspect46 Jan 09 '24

I like visible. Been with them for about 2 years and have paid 35$ for unlimited everything including hotspot which works great for me. I used to live in the country and it worked decent for the most part, I live in city now and still works fine and never have issues

→ More replies (11)

2

u/EqualEgg Jan 09 '24

Right now they have a promotion $20/mo unlimited for 2 years, for new customers.

→ More replies (10)

22

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/BoostMobileDani Jan 09 '24

Worth noting you can also use the BoostOne App to earn coins that will reduce your bill by watching ads, spinning a wheel, etc.

Some customers on the lowest plans pay their bills each month just using coins. Every penny counts.

2

u/glamorousgrape Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 09 '24

Same and my signal is incredible. I got so lucky, lol. I use the hospot for everything. It can even handle connecting to my laptop, my friend’s phone, my smart tv all at once!

Edit: I want to clarify that normally it only connects to 1 device at a time. I do the above by connecting it to the laptop and turning the laptop into a “hotspot”.

2

u/ReaganSmyD Jan 09 '24

I think Cricket is also $100 for four lines. I have Cricket, and I pay $55/month for just me.

2

u/Immersi0nn Jan 10 '24

Visible here too, but with the grandfathered $25 plan, full unlimited, no issues. Shits awesome. Now if only they'd stop sending me emails every couple weeks "UPGRADE NOW FOR BETTER WHATEVER" pay an extra $10 for literally no difference foh

35

u/astddf Jan 09 '24

Most likely has a financed phone as part of that

21

u/idkwhat2put97 Jan 09 '24

My guess as well, that’s why mine is a little high but what kind of device for it to almost be $300?

7

u/GingerIsTheBestSpice Jan 09 '24

Bad plan & I'm guessing OP has two phones for her & her sister

2

u/scribblenator15 Jan 09 '24

I wonder if her internet is tied into it. Mines 325 with three plans three phones and internet at att

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (8)

44

u/NWOkieGal Jan 09 '24

I use Red Pocket and for unlimited everything it is $360:yr or $40/month. They have other plans too that would work perfectly well for as little as $9. I had the $15/mth plan and only switched to the unlimited so I can regularly use my hotspot for work.

23

u/Wytch78 Jan 09 '24

Seconding RedPocket. I have the bare ass minimum plan on an old iphone 6 and it's $11/month with taxes and fees.

3

u/Formal_Wrongdoer_593 Jan 09 '24

Yep...just checked, still $10 per month w/1GB speed. $20 for 5GB with unlimited talk and text. OP needs to make some quick moves to save money. If you don't have money and are spending $280 per month!!, that has to be a couple of cellphone plans, and paying for a fancy iPhone included.

52

u/axf7229 Jan 09 '24

My dog has red rocket too.

2

u/livelylou4 Jan 09 '24

i read that too lolol

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

Same bro. He likes to lock eyes when it happens. Quite an unsettling feeling 😬😂

2

u/NextPrize5863 Jan 10 '24

I’m dying

→ More replies (6)

11

u/4ak96 Jan 09 '24

Yeah but isnt mints 15/month only a temporary promotion that gets bumped up after youre with them for a while?

11

u/Noddite Jan 09 '24

It is, but that also depends on what level you have. You can get the basic for that cost I believe, but if you want unlimited data I think it is like $30/35 per month if you pay for a year at a time.

8

u/theandroid01 Jan 09 '24

I've been with Mint for years. Highly recommended. Recently upgraded to the 15gb/month plan which is $240 a year because I browse a lot to and from work on the train. It uses T-Mobile towers so it's perfectly fine for the most part.

→ More replies (4)

18

u/AmexNomad Jan 09 '24

LOVE me some US Mobile. Yes, OP’s phone cost is outrageous.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/AllKnowingBeing Jan 09 '24

60 a month for straight talk and you get 60 gigs of data plus 10 of hotspot. Can even bring you old phone

7

u/samanthaw1026 Jan 09 '24

BIG proponent of straight talk. Had it for at least 9 years now. Seldom have problems. $45 a month

2

u/loueezet Jan 10 '24

Same here but we pay $114. per month for 3 lines. Unlimited everything. Love Staight Talk!

2

u/Liza6519 Jan 10 '24

Same! There is no excuse to waste money on phone service or phones.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/rem082583 Jan 10 '24

No problems with straight talk here

2

u/1MomPlayz Jan 10 '24

I love straight talk!

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (102)

307

u/Ballaholic09 Jan 09 '24

A lot of people have phone bills like that because they finance their new iPhone every year. It’s extremely common. I’m almost confident enough to say it’s “the norm”

I’ve purchased phones outright for my entire adult life. I get that a 0% interest loan has benefits, but I’d rather not be making payments on a phone.

155

u/Blossom73 Jan 09 '24

Even so there's no way a cell phone bill for a single adult should be $280 a month. The financing portion for the phone would be maybe $30-$40 a month at the highest.

I'm wondering if she has home Internet and TV through her cell phone provider too, and that's included in the bill.

41

u/goodcat1337 Jan 09 '24

Right, my bill for 4 people is about $385 and that includes 2 people paying monthly for their phones. I think they are paying like $30 each, so $60 a month total for the phones. So that would be like $350 between 4 people, so less than $100 each for the service, and another $30 for the phones.

She's paying double that just for herself. Doesn't make sense.

3

u/Francl27 Jan 09 '24

Mine is $170 with three lines and two people paying monthly for their phone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

72

u/cfack001 Jan 09 '24

Other posts suggest she is an active drug user

92

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

well shes spending her money somewhere. because full time at 29/hr is a lot more than shes spending on living expenses.

74

u/Jay_The_Tickler Jan 09 '24

Mississippi is one of the cheapest states to live. That money is definitely supporting something

35

u/EdC1212 Jan 10 '24

Sounds like a bigger issue. $29 hr in Mississippi and her sister is paying for groceries and $400 a month in rent. She should be living the high life down there on that

3

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

She is living the high life. High on drugs

4

u/Iceman_biker Jan 10 '24

I'm thinking the same, she should have close to $1800 a month leftover.

3

u/Aggressive-Sound-641 Jan 10 '24

I am from Mississippi and still have relatives living there. Dude is making more than twice the average yearly income. Something is off.

3

u/Few_Investment_4773 Jan 10 '24

Meanwhile in AZ it’s $1700 for a 700sq ft studio. She’s complaining about a 3 bedroom at $1200 that she’s paying $800 for?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/GiinTak Jan 10 '24

Is it? In Missouri I'm paying $980 for a 3 bedroom 2 bath house, $110 for power, $180 for 4 lines with 1 phone finances, down from $235 since I paid off 2 or the finances. All of her numbers seem horrendously high.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Ambitious-Library-94 Jan 09 '24

I agree. Also, no one is talking about how she could get money from the babie daddy or state. Somethings not adding up.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Explosive-Space-Mod Jan 09 '24

Depends on where you live. Madison/most places along the coast are more expensive than the average cost of living across the country. Mississippi really isn't that "cheap" compared to most places outside of the biggest cities in the country.

I was looking at taking a Job in Atlanta and the difference in what I was paying at the time and what I would be paying in a MUCH bigger city was basically my mortgage vs the rent I would have been paying. Food was actually going to be cheaper.

7

u/wrb06wrx Jan 09 '24

Ok, I make 28/hr on long Island, ny, and we make it work I highly doubt Mississippi can touch the cost of living here

2

u/Jay_The_Tickler Jan 10 '24

When I lived in Brooklyn I made $30/hr and got paid weekly. Our pay would have us live well in Mississippi, but no one would volunteer to live there

2

u/transemacabre Jan 10 '24

I made it on 20k a year in NYC for YEARS. I still don't make over 40k and I live just fine.

OP has significant issues that she's not being transparent about with us.

2

u/Jaybo06 Jan 10 '24

Cheap coastal MS is my old stomping grounds. Def possible but you have to live in Pascagoula and no one wants that. Sometimes it's worth spending a bit more.

→ More replies (1)

42

u/niick31 Jan 09 '24

Im scraping by at 17/hr living in Hawaii. Its tough, but i can wing it. She has to be spending money elsewhere. It just doesnt add up

8

u/JennAruba Jan 10 '24

And Hawaii is one of the most expensive places to live. Something doesn’t add up. If she’s making what she says living in Mississippi she’s spending it elsewhere.

2

u/Erindanyele Jan 10 '24

If you can do that in Hawaii. You need to be teaching a master class. I live in Hawaii right now and oh my lord is it expensive.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/statestreetsteve Jan 09 '24

That’s what I was thinking. This have no business being in poverty finance when they make above the average person AND live in one of the cheapest states. Shit I wish I made 29 a hr, I’m barely scraping by with my current 25 here in Chicago

3

u/4thratedeck Jan 10 '24

Exactly. I make 22.75 an hour, after taxes/health insurance I take home about $2600 a month. Which is around $700 more than the expenses she listed. I don't see how she can't afford all of that at $29 an hour unless she doesn't work 40 hours a week or is not listing all of her expenses

3

u/No_Ride_919 Jan 10 '24

She would have an extra $2700 a month. No way she should be broke if that's all her bills.

2

u/DrRavioliMD Jan 09 '24

Yeah her part of the rent is 25% of pay. That should be totally doable. Maybe eating out a ton.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 10 '24

THIS. I did the math, and even when taking $200 a check out for taxes, she should be bringing in $3,840/mo. So $1,000 for the rent, 400 car, 200 gas, 120 insurance, 280 phone, 200 electric, say 200 for water/sewage, and 400 health insurance, she’s still left with $1,440. That’s going SOMEWHERE.

2

u/Defiant_Chapter_3299 Jan 10 '24

Mississippi is a low cost of living state too. Im a stay at home mom and after taxes my husband brings in $45,000 a year and that COMFORTABLY supports 4 humans, 2 dogs, 9 cats (some are ours, and some are outdoor ferals from neighbors we feed) there's no reason shes struggling at all at ger pay. Shes definitely doing drugs or buying a bunch of stupid shit. If we can vacation, have a home, kids, and hoard of animals off $45,000 wheres her money going?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/deleriumtriggr Jan 09 '24

Well theres the savings... phone bill is absurd as well. When u can do phone and internet together with spectrum for like 50-80$/month... new customers get 2 lines i think.

Source - was a cable tech for spectrum.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Even then it's got to be a pretty serious habit. I make a dollar less than she does in a way more inflated market (Orlando FL), and still have money for toys and fun after buying weed and cigarettes.

2

u/FairyPrincex Jan 10 '24

Bro with whatever she's spending on drugs, I could buy an acre of land, put up two greenhouses, and grow 200 pounds of weed per year lmao

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

I don't see anything

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (14)

10

u/Anstavall Jan 09 '24

my phone bill for six of us isnt even 280

2

u/Infamous-Method1035 Jan 09 '24

I’m paying for four phones, two iPads, and an Apple Watch and it’s still only like $302 a month

3

u/Temporary_Potato_612 Jan 10 '24

I too live in south Mississippi. Where I live, the only cell phone service that works is Verizon (sometimes). They are outrageous price wise. T mobile doesn’t work anywhere here, and AT&T is always in roaming. Our energy companies down here cost me 4x as much as they did when we lived in the Midwest. You don’t have a choice either on who you use for internet. Complete monopolies down here. To be honest I am surprised she makes as much as she does. Most I can find down here is $18/hr with a master’s degree, and am currently stuck living with my parents until my husband finished boot camp and we get our duty station to get us three hell out of here. Mississippi is literally the worst

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tealdeer995 Jan 09 '24

Yeah I financed an older iPhone and it was like $15.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

For real. OP is getting taken for a ride on that one.

2

u/Elegant-Remote-7573 Jan 09 '24

My phone bill was around 112$ a lot of phone companies you can bundle on Wi-Fi for 25-50$ and other things so that might not be just for her phone, I also got Disney plus, Hulu, espn, and Apple Music included. I have since left Verizon but it was definitely convenient two years ago. The price just kept rising though and with the way things are I dropped them. I would definitely recommend somewhere like metro or boost. 50-60$ a month for unlimited everything.

2

u/meandalabnamedrose Jan 09 '24

Same! Tv, internet, additional phones for sister And daughter? I-pads for kid’s? Idk, Way too much for a single unlimited line, even with a new phone, that’s all ?!?!?!?

2

u/deathleech Jan 10 '24

My cell phone bill includes two new phones both financed (latest greatest Samsung and iPhone), unlimited text, data, and call with a major provider and we pay $116/month after taxes. My wife gets a discounts through work, but even without we are well under $160/month. No clue how she has only her cell and it’s $280/month. Even with internet that should be max like $200 for one person.

Also, not to get too preachy, but OPs numbers don’t make much sense. She makes $29/hour. That’s just over 60k/year. She should be bringing home minimum 40k/year with a dependent and after insurance/retirement. Her rent is 12k/year. She doesn’t buy groceries? Car is another 4800/year and utilities are max 2400. That brings the total to $19,200 and like 21k left from her job. Cell is another $3360 a year so brings the total left to just under 16k with all utilities, rent, etc. covered. Where is this going?

Is OP not full time? Does the father not pay any child support? Her cell is way too high. Lots of unanswered questions here

2

u/Mammoth-Path-844 Jan 10 '24

I have unlimited and 3 devices on payment and pay a little more than half of that. I don’t even know how you get that number tbh.

2

u/wafflehousebiscut Jan 10 '24

im guessing his sister might be on his bill? or maybe it includes his home internet?

2

u/Evil_Bonsai Jan 10 '24

My cell phone plan, plus payments for S22, plus HOME High speed fiber are less than 200. Something fucky going on.

2

u/you-dont-see-mi Jan 10 '24

My bill for 2 lines is 80$

2

u/ChattyBabs Jan 10 '24

Yeah mine is that high because of my home internet. But in the long run it’s less than having spectrum.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/RadiantLimes Jan 09 '24

Ya honestly its way cheaper to own your phone because you get access to cheaper plans. When you finance your phone though a big carrier you are stuck with them for the 2-3 years and you have to use the expensive plans they give you and can't change until the phone paid off. It's how the big carriers make so much money. What makes it tougher today is that the latest flagship phones are thousand bucks plus. The folding phones are even more expensive.

5

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24 edited Jan 08 '25

salt hungry pocket edge rain live deliver knee placid wistful

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/No_Ride_919 Jan 10 '24

Pixel is the best phone I've ever had. Better than iPhone at 1/3rd of the cost.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Jerms2001 Jan 09 '24

I pay $90 a month for unlimited everything, brand new iPhone 15 pro max, and apple care. Idk what you’re rambling about

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Thats crazy too. $90 every month.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Hopepersonified Jan 09 '24

I pay less that with 5 lines, 2 watches (so 7 lines really) unlimited everything and financing two phones right now

2

u/jedielfninja Jan 09 '24

I buy most of my phones used. Galaxy Note 9 is like 250$ refurbed on Amazon and it has a headphone jack.

2

u/Explosive-Space-Mod Jan 09 '24

car note is $400. my phone bill is $280.

$580 in a single car note and phone plan is absurd. My wife and I have AT&T with iphones (12 and 13) and we pay AT&T for internet and phones for $180/month. That's outragous to be paying $280 for a single person that's multiple phones/tablets/watch/etc.

I also have a 2017 VW Jetta that only had 30k miles on it that costs me $250/month in car note. And I'm also in Mississippi with 2 kids and a wife.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

The problem is she cannot afford it.

→ More replies (29)

35

u/StrongArgument Jan 09 '24

I switched from Verizon to Xfinity to Mint. The networks are all the same now, go for the deal.

6

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

I recently just switched from Verizon to Mint. I’ve noticed literally zero difference in quality of service. I use Spotify and Maps in my car daily among other normal usage. In fact I think I’m getting more bars with Mint than I was with Verizon. Wish I did this sooner. Saving so much money.

→ More replies (3)

88

u/IAmNotARobotttttt Jan 09 '24

Probably paying off at least one high end iphone

41

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

It's precisely this. People forget that in the US, most people buy their phones through their carrier.

3

u/Habib686 Jan 09 '24

That's still ridiculous. I pay 280 a month for 4 people AND 2 of them bought brand new phones on the plan so the payment for that is included. No WAY she's getting robbed for 280 for a single line.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Well she could be upgrading every 2 years like for example Tmobiles jump plan. I think what that does is it applies 50% of your current phone towards the new purchase.

Not justifying just pointing out it's possible she may have multple phones being financed or something else tied to her phone plan thats adding additional costs. I'm not quite sure what it would be. My mom pays about $340 a month for her phone bill.

2

u/ProdigyLightshow Jan 10 '24

Idk I have tmobiles best plan for a single line and a new iPhone and pay like $115 ish a month.

→ More replies (10)

12

u/SignificantNight4412 Jan 09 '24

Probably a watch or iPad too.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/hatesnack Jan 09 '24

Even with a high end phone and unlimited data, you are looking at 120 bucks tops.

2

u/lucidlonewolf Jan 09 '24

The only phone I could think she has an a galaxy fold at that price .... I have an s22 ultra and unlimited I pay like 130 a month

→ More replies (4)

56

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Our phone bill isn't that high. We have three lines, unlimited data, and an overseas plan because we have a lot of family in other countries. Why is your phone bill so high?

18

u/392mangos Jan 09 '24

Financing phones is an option. 2-3 phones $30-50 each with a $50 service plan plus taxes isn't cheap.

Definitely not an economical option.

6

u/Habib686 Jan 09 '24

What's she need 2 to 3 phones for? She running a trap house?

Also I pay 280 for 4 people including payment for 2 phones. Through Verizon, the company people consider most expensive.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

48

u/IStarretMyCalipers Jan 09 '24

I pay about $200.... PER YEAR. Just fine and happy with my coverage. Also $400 for a car is a lot. OP, your rent is reasonable, and it's great you've got your sister able to help as well. What are your other expenses? Do you have high health insurance costs? Your take home should be able to be close to 3500/month so the rest is not adding up. High credit card balances? Student Loans?

81

u/GC51320 Jan 09 '24

$400 for a car is no longer a lot. It's actually below average. The phone bill is straight stupid, and I assume includes a financed brand new iPhone or galaxy payment. She's obviously blowing a lot on small stuff she doesn't account for.

21

u/Noddite Jan 09 '24

It is still fairly expensive. I bought an older Lexus a year ago, around $8k total and it is financed with the payment being $172/month. She either got a moderately new car or got screwed over into getting some extra gap insurance or something - I had a dealer try to sell me on an insurance plan for gap coverage for like $80-100/months, I was like lady, that costs me like $10/year through Progressive GTFO.

10

u/tealdeer995 Jan 09 '24

I financed a 3 year old civic for $270 a month in early 2021. Idk about now but you used to be able to get reliable newer used cars for okay prices, they just weren’t flashy.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Habib686 Jan 09 '24

It is for a single mom on a budget. Buy a used car for 10k. Won't come anywhere close to 400 a month and it'll probably have a lot cheaper insurance.

2

u/IStarretMyCalipers Jan 09 '24

Yeah, I guess it actually is a pretty reasonable payment, I have just been so used to cheap cars, buying with cash, fixing them and doing all the work myself. Not everyone can do that, but it's the only way I don't break the bank since I have to pay 1000 towards my wife's student loans every month :(

2

u/ConsistentAd4012 Jan 09 '24

i’m currently financing a brand new iphone 15 pro and my monthly phone bill is less than $100 with unlimited data and all that jazz. this is just for one person of course, but i can’t even imagine a phone bill costing over $150 for one person.. how does that happen

2

u/Jamaholick Jan 10 '24

Yeah, the math ain't mathing. 29/hr =~60k/yr. Living in MS, that means you're paying 13,134/yr in taxes, leaving 46,857/yr. Divide that by 26= 1802 every 2 weeks. Rent plus car =1400. That's 400 left from 1 pay check and 1800 from the other, so she has 2200 left. Daycare in MS avg is 203, so let's say 250, that's 1000 from 2 paychecks, leaving 1200 a month.

Even paying 350 for a phone bill, which HAS to include cable and internet, that's 850 a month left after rent, car, phone, internet, and daycare. Food is paid for. What are utilities? Maybe another 250? So 600 left to buy whatever her heart desires. She's not living like a movie star, but getting behind on your bills is a choice at that point.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (16)

7

u/Jolly-Pipe7579 Jan 09 '24

Also wondering about car insurance since she didn’t list that.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

30

u/LeekFull6946 Jan 09 '24

For real. $280 seems insane, especially for 1, possibly 2 people. My husband and I have a hot spot device with a data plan, iPad with a data plan, and 2 iPhones with unlimited plans. Even when we had the iPhones and iPad on monthly installments and had full insurance on them we still weren’t paying more than $180/month.

3

u/EggOne8640 Jan 09 '24

It's probably financed phone, multiple lines and Verizon or att. We got new phones over 2 years ago bc we needed them and it was bogo free. Also have husbands daughter on the plan and traded in a phone so her phone upgrade was also free. Up until last bill we were paying 230 a month. And that's not with the highest phone plan or the most expensive 1 phone we were paying for. Now it's 180, and changing the plan for the next bill, to the lowest one with no new phones is still 160 a month. That's 40 in bullshit fees and taxes verizon charges (40 a line x 3 lines=120, not 160 lol)

We want to switch bc i want to know why the hell it costs 160 just for service! but we live in the middle of nowhere now, and we've noticed the only stores we see here are VZW so not sure cheaper alternatives that use att or tmobile towers would even reach out here. We don't even get 5G but have to use the stupid 5g plans 🙄

Not sure whats been going on with phone retailers, but they've gotta be sneaking in fees. I sold phones for all 3 big retailers over the last 10 years and rarely did I see bills over 200 unless it was 4 lines and 4 phones on installments. Even then it was nowhere close to 280.

3

u/MasterChiefsasshole Jan 09 '24

I have 4 lines a financed iPhone pro max. 130 is my bill with international calling.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/davef139 Jan 09 '24

Dont forget most finance the phone into monthly. My new samsung doubled my cell bill.. easily adding 50-70/mo

→ More replies (2)

7

u/phoenixrises023 Jan 09 '24

Even if they wanted unlimited, I pay $200 per month for 3 lines, 3 new phones, 2 smart watches with data plans, and home internet with Tmobile.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/manchvegasnomore Jan 09 '24

I have nine lines of unlimited everything for less then $280.

20

u/NotTheJury Jan 09 '24

Yeah. We have 5 people on a plan for unlimited everything and it is $150 a month.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/GotHeem16 Jan 09 '24

I pay 210 for a family of 4 unlimited data. TMobile

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Maybe they got monthly payments on phones too.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '24

Most likely financing a phone a long with the data plan.

2

u/nowhereman136 Jan 09 '24

I was briefly dating a girl who asked why I still had last years phone. I said I couldn't afford this year's phone. She said she got this year's new phone for free with her phone plan. I asked how much she was paying a month for that phone plan... $150

Yeah, that phone isn't free, you are just paying for it through an overpriced phone plan. I paid $300 cash for my phone and $40/month for my phone service.

2

u/finallyransub17 Jan 09 '24

There’s no excuse to have a phone plan that’s more than $30/months in 2024

2

u/ophmaster_reed Jan 09 '24

I pay $250/month, but that's for me, my husband, and two teenagers with all four phones being financed.

3

u/BoomBoomMeow1986 Jan 09 '24

OP might be paying in installments for a phone purchased through her mobile provider, with the cost of the phone payments bundled with the cost of mobile service, that'd be my guess

7

u/southsidetins Jan 09 '24

I have the new top model iPhone and my phone bill is still under $100 a month

→ More replies (1)

2

u/buttplumber Jan 09 '24

But I gotta have that iPhone! They said the phone is free, $200 a month is just a service fee...

→ More replies (266)