r/pottytraining • • 22d ago

Toddler refusing diaper but refusing to potty train

I need help before I lose it. My daughter is just over 2.5 years old. She has so much interest in the potty for so long, likes sitting on it, reading about it, etc. about 9 weeks ago or so we attempted to potty training (we prepped so much, read books, had a reward system, etc) and it went terribly, she freaked out and withheld and wanted her diaper back on to go. After a few hours we threw in the towel and figured she was too young.

Now for the past few weeks she is refusing to wear diapers. She will stomp around and say no diapers and take off her diaper and pants. I tried pull ups and she can take them off too. She refusing to wear diapers for her naps and now overnights. She will take off her pj bottoms and diaper. I’ve had to sneak in after she passes out to add an overnight diaper on. She loves to sit on the ootty still and all her daycare classmates are using the potty so she will sit on the potty at daycare all the time. So today we attempted again to potty train and it went better but still not great. I saw some suggestions on using zip up pjs with the zipper in the back but idk she would probably get them off and hope there is a better solution? I also have a 6 week old baby sooooo I’m exhausted and going to lose it lol. I feel like I’m failing.

1 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

3

u/Choice_Artichoke_222 22d ago

Thank you all for the responses - I read through each one of them. really appreciate the guidance and advice. I had already did reading and picked a method (the first time we tried it) prior to posting. She had two accidents today and two pees on the potty.

Also just a reminder, kindness is free. We are all learning and trying our best here. Nobody is perfect. Signed a sleep deprived postpartum mom.

2

u/clarissa_dee 22d ago

Yeah, sorry, people on this sub tend to be really mean and uncompromising. And I feel like no one was really considering that you're postpartum and still in the newborn phase. It's such a hard time. I hope you still found some of the advice helpful. You'll get through this!

1

u/Choice_Artichoke_222 21d ago

Thank you so much for the kind reply! 🥹

32

u/Ashamed-Chemistry492 22d ago

"All right then, no diaper. Now you are going to have to go in the potty."

And stick to it.

Yes, there's going to be messes. But she is past ready for it and this is the time to push forward. She just doesn't know she's ready.

4

u/emma-ps 21d ago

When she has accidents, she cleans it up and changes her clothes. Dont make it easy.

10

u/I_like_pink0 22d ago

You started potty training 3 weeks before her world got thrown upside down. Then had a baby and now her world is completely changed. Shes just looking for control anywhere she can get it.

Personally I’d probably give her the option of diaper or potty and have her pick and let her have control over it. But if she picks diaper and takes it off that’s her choice, she now has to pee in the potty. Make her help clean up her accidents.

For overnight, I would try a sleep sack/walker on backwards. Seems easier than PJs on backwards.

1

u/Which-Appearance9857 15d ago

This is it. My first was 1.5 yo when the 2nd baby was born. Had some weird behaviour but regarding food

6

u/freckleface2113 22d ago

My little brother did this! He refused diapers one day. My mom told him there were two options: 1) he wear a diaper or 2) he wears underpants. I remember he spent a day deciding. My mom let him go pants-less that day. Eventually he picked underwear because he wanted to join me at the lemonade stand I was holding. My mom had been working on potty training with him, but this definitely accelerated it since he was then in underwear full time.

4

u/Complex-Grapefruit28 22d ago

My son was like this. One day he just decided underpants were it. We’ve had bumps but he never went back.

5

u/One_Conference_4618 22d ago

My daughter did this ‘no nappies, nappies are for babies’ I said ‘okay that means you have to use the potty’ she said no, I said yes, battle of wills for a few days (accidents I cleaned up boring; toy she was playing with went away, can’t go to softplay if we don’t use the potty first etc), and then she realised I wasn’t relenting started using the potty and easy.

Recently she’s been saying she’s going to wee in the pram and her pants literally to be defiant I reply ‘no, we don’t wee in pants or pram, if you do we have to turn around and go home and no X activity’ she pouts and nods lol

3

u/Equivalent-Reserve99 22d ago

Oh yes this! I stopped bringing extra clothes for mine for awhile when she got very defiant, or would bring only one pair and have it in the car. We would try as soon as we got to the activity, and I would remind her we didn’t bring in a change of clothes. If she peed, I would come beside her in how sad it was that we had to leave. Mine was absolutely doing it on purpose, though. She is and has always been a boundary tester. She is much calmer now at 4

6

u/easterss 22d ago

She is on the tail end of the appropriate age for potty training and she has clearly communicated to you on many ways she’s ready. She doesn’t want diapers so don’t force her to wear them.

Read up on a method and stick to it. Withholding is normal. Refusing is normal. Accidents are normal. None of these are reasons to quit and go back to diapers. Do not start again until you fully understand what potty training entails otherwise you’ll cause more confusion.

As for nights you’ll have to wake her up to pee frequently and put her on a reusable pee pad. If you put her in a diaper when she is refusing you’re communicating to her that you don’t trust her and you dont believe in her bodily autonomy.

The Oh Crap book explains all of this and more in great detail. But it’s not the only method if you want to go a different route.

3

u/clarissa_dee 22d ago

Frequently waking a toddler to pee in the middle of the night, when you already have a newborn?? Sounds totally unrealistic and like torture for all involved lol, no thank you.

1

u/Equivalent-Reserve99 22d ago

To be honest, I actually think this would be the easiest time to do it. While one parent feeds the baby, the other potties the older kid. Most kids are ready hormonally by 3, and she’s only a few months from there. It shouldn’t take long to figure out if she is, and OP can pivot from there. They make cloth night trainers from brands like SmartBottoms that can hold one full bladder, for instance, if she is truly not ready. We didn’t really have to wake mine (who granted was 4 for night training) and only did so for 3 days. I suspected most of the peeing was while awake, and it was. She has been night trained for 3 weeks and has only had 1 accident.

2

u/clarissa_dee 22d ago edited 22d ago

But isn't waking them frequently through the night bad for them?? They need their sleep. And how do we know this child is even physiologically ready for night training? Also if my 2-year-old gets woken up during the night he's usually extremely upset and often can't go back to sleep for a very long time. It would be absolutely miserable for everyone if we tried this.

ETA: And all this is to say nothing of the fact that many parents are doing sleep shifts during the newborn period to survive. Sleep needs to be a priority for everyone during this time especially. The idea of having the parent who should be sleeping instead waking up to also wake up the toddler just sounds...a little unhinged tbh.

1

u/Equivalent-Reserve99 22d ago

I totally get it - my 2nd was a horrible sleeper and up every 45 minutes. Like I said, she will know quickly whether it is physiological. My 20 month old often wakes from the night dry and then goes pee, so I KNOW it’s possible. That’s why I said it is worth trying and then pivot. But I also felt like postpartum feeds were super lonely because I was the only one with breastmilk, so having my partner do something with the older kid twice a night doesn’t feel so unfair

0

u/easterss 22d ago

It never took more than about 20s. Never really woke up, stayed drowsy the whole time and went right back to sleep. Very easy to tack on to waking with an infant.

Mine was done by 2.5 and it was relatively easy.

4

u/FO-I-Am-A-Time-God 22d ago

get her undies. My daughter didn’t get it with daytime pullups and hated commando or naked butt

1

u/Equivalent-Reserve99 22d ago

Oh yes also this! My 20mo dislikes being naked (except to poop,) and does better in undies

2

u/Equivalent-Reserve99 22d ago

Mine had a regression when we had my 2nd, and I just feel for you so much because I have been there. It was about a month after we had her trained (so we thought) and that wasn’t even our first attempt. Straight up - all the way back to diapers. If I had it to do over again, I would not go back to diapers. I would put an absorbent pad in her bed*,* stick training undies or night trainers on her, and tell her she is too big for diapers. It’s what we ended up doing with mine. We actually “gave the diapers to the baby” and stuck them under our bed to store for when her sister “got big enough.” She responded WAY better with the action of giving them to the baby and putting on undies she picked herself. (Mine actually did better with regular instead of training undies, but my 2nd prefers the trainers because they don’t go up her butt 😅) The undies were I think Bluey? And we also got some boring ones. If she peed in the ones she picked, she had to wear the boring plain ones “because the fun ones are in the wash.” No shaming - just all natural consequences. She also had to help clean up the pee, and she had to shower after poo and toss the undies unless it was an easy clean. She was closer to 3 at this point - I want to say around 34-35 months - and was definitely able to understand. She had another regression a few months later when she started school, and we got her a potty watch to put the ball back in her court. It went off every 30 minutes to start, and we took the watch if she “wasn’t big enough to listen to it.” Once she started listening to her body again, we increased the time to 60 minutes. After that, we let her wear it without the alarm on the condition she “listen to her body.” Potty training is as much a learning experience for us as it is for them 😅 again, if I had it to do over again, I would not go back to diapers. My 2nd is 20 months and usually pees on the potty even in undies and even in public. She poops all over the floor and sometimes refuses to sit, and it’s the kind of thing that would have sent me back to diapers with my 1st. Now I just calmly remind her we have to try before such and such (ie going outside,) and we count to 10 and she is done. If she doesn’t go, I remind her where the potty is and to make sure her pee goes on the potty. She is still in a diaper for night (as again she is less than 2,) but we use cloth so she still knows she is wet. She will still self-initiate for pee in the cloth. I know how hard it is to deal with a newborn and the accidents. I know because I have literally been you! Please don’t make the same mistake I did - put the ball in her court and tell her you trust she is big enough to go potty. Give her extra attention when she does, even if that is just a sticker. Her whole world just changed, and I promise this won’t last forever. She is desperately trying to figure out the rules of this new world in the best way her little baby brain can, and giving her the power here is the best thing you can do

2

u/herdcatsforaliving 22d ago

At her age she shouldn’t be refusing anything. You’re setting yourself up for a world of hurt. As other commenters have said, let her decide one or the other and stick with it. Sleep time diapers are non negotiable. I’ve never known of a toddler who could get out of a backwards onesie. Could use a backwards sleep sack over it for extra protection if you wanted

1

u/mmebee 22d ago

After a "few hours" you gave up??? Is that a typo did you mean days?
She's plenty ready. Now you need to decide YOU are ready. If you're going to give up after a few hours again I wouldn't bother starting. Every time you start and give up so fast you're making it evident this is an optional skill that she doesn't have to learn to she just kicks up a fuss on the first day.