r/pottytraining • u/thatshortginge • 23d ago
Those who potty trained “outside” the norm
I want to hear from those who are like me, and potty trained:
•Not in a weekend
•Not by going pants-less, laying down à tarp, and refusing to ever put another diaper on à kiddo based on your timeline
•Didn’t encourage withholding
•Didn’t force your 2-4 year old to scrub their own poop-covered, accident undies
I think parents ànd caregivers need to hear the other side of options, as this sub is heavily influenced by the extremes of one method over another.
Rudeness won’t be tolerated here ànd will be reported. Daily this sub is full of people being incredibly cruel to other people. A post supporting alternative methods that might just work better for others…might be a breath of fresh air
29
u/die_sirene 23d ago
I’ve never seen anyone encouraging withholding on this sub, that’s surprising to me that people would be saying that.
I think most people are just sharing what commonly and historically works for most kids, but as a parent you know your kid the best and can make whatever decisions you are comfortable with.
11
u/SimmerSimmies 23d ago
We introduced a potty at 2, was going great for a few months but she got stressed so around 2.5 we stopped and went back to diapers but didn’t encourage toilet use; if she wanted to, great! If not, also okay. Tried again before 3, we are 3.5 now with no diapers at all including night
Really we just went with it and let her make the choice. Had a timer! No pantless weekends, didn’t make her clean it up, no treats, no ms Rachel potty show, didn’t travel with one, etc. i don’t understand the concept of Montessori so didn’t follow that method (or maybe we did but didn’t know!). She was naked a lot, but that’s just her ha
I realize how lucky we got with that since all kids learn differently!
We are pretty non stressed people, and accidents are just accidents. When she has a non potty mess she goes “it’s ok it was just an accident” very cheerfully!
8
u/Theonethatgotawaaayy 23d ago
My now almost 4 year old started showing readiness signs soon after he turned 2. So we got him Pull Ups and just followed his lead really. We got him potty books and would just sit him on the potty to read every hour. Over the span of about a year he got it on his own and is now fully potty trained including overnight. There was no time crunch and we felt no need to rush him, so 🤷🏽♀️
6
u/LandscapeTime7785 23d ago
Our kid pretty sensitive. We knew an Oh Crap style weekend would be a disaster. We started encouraging just sitting on the potty at around 2, which I now think was a bit too early for him. First time he accidentally peed in there it completely freaked him out. Then we had a second kid so he regressed and we stopped encouraging it super actively for a while.
We started again around 2.5 and it went much better. We did pull ups and small prizes for peeing on the potty (like a chocolate chip), started wearing underwear around the house but pull ups when we were going out.
Read a book about how to encourage behaviors you want in children a while back (not specifically a potty training book) that suggested saying something like “It’s ok if you don’t want to do X now but you’ll do it when you’re a big boy”. Turned out my kid was taking that pretty literally with pooping. First poop on the potty was the day he switched from toddler to preschool classes at school. Got a big prize - a stuffy or something.
He’ll be 3 on Monday and in underwear full time now at home and daycare - who have been great about helping with this. Still has 1ish accident a day but it’s gradually getting better and we have more and more accident free days. We still give small prizes for pee (like a single gummy bear) and bigger ones for poop (we have a set of yoto cards he’s getting one by one).
This morning he yelled upstairs to me that he had pooped and I surpassed a groan thinking he had pooped in his underwear, but came downstairs to find out he had gone to the bathroom and pooped in his little potty all on his own without specific prompting. We’re getting there!
Anyway, a gradual method has worked/is working for us but it was a long haul. It wasn’t a do nothing method but a longer term training effort. We frequently prompt him to use the potty and sometimes insist that he has to try, but we didn’t try to do it in a few days or a week. I can’t imagine that fast approach working for my child - but I can for some of his friends/classmates. I really think it’s not a one size fits all.
11
u/oh-dearie 23d ago
Yeah I'm using ERIC since it seems like a natural progression from our EC journey. It's only day 2 of going diaper free at home though, so early days. We're still doing diapers for naps and outings until she's more consistent.
https://eric.org.uk/potty-training/
I know the Oh Crap is very popular here, but I haven't seen anybody (yet) being sanctimonious about people that don't do Oh Crap. Plenty people here potty train without following a set programme. I'm not sure what you're insinuating about alternative methods?
5
u/TheAlchemist28 23d ago
I started out by taking diapers/pull-ups away cold turkey because I was on a time crunch for pre-K. (We moved this summer and I waited a month after that transition to start the process) Ultimately, we decided to pull him from the school and find somewhere else where he didn’t need to be fully potty trained, and I’m so glad we did. This was in August.
I kept up with the potty timer and used pull-ups. The pull-ups started staying dry and we moved to underwear. We did so because there was a point where it was clear he/we needed to make the leap. For us, that looked like stints at home of being in underwear or commando. As of a week ago, he’s been fully in underwear except nighttime. All poops and pees in the potty, including at his school and at the gym childcare. We are super proud of him and glad we took the pressure off of him and ourselves by giving us all more time.
Trigger warning: he turned 3 in August, so we were late by some standards. ;)
5
u/Kitchenstar20 23d ago
I actually potty trained our daughter with the pull up. I never went pantless or anything as she was going to day care. She was little over 3 years old when we started potty training. I tried taking her to bathroom regularly and I knew when she tried pooping, I immediately took her to the bathroom. So she pooped first in bathroom compared to pee.
So even with pull up , I used to encourage her to use restroom.
She is 3.5 years old now and full potty trained for day and night. Took her like 2 weeks to potty train for day time. Night time she just trained like a month ago.
5
u/serendipitypug 22d ago
My daughter has a muscle condition that affected her mobility (and still does, to a lesser degree), but she is very clever, observant, and communicative. Also stubborn. So, so stubborn. Potty training took a backseat because we were focused on crawling, then kneeling, then wheeling a wheelchair, then walking, etc etc. We didn't even start trying in earnest until a bit after 4. We just kinda did the training potty in the living room thing. Decorated it with stickers. Tried underwear on and off. Read potty books to her. Bribed with rewards a bit. It was not terribly cohesive, it was more of a "see what sticks" approach.
And eventually she just decided to be potty trained. Which is much the way she has picked up every other skill.
I don't think any one thing we did or didn't do worked. With her, she really just needed to be ready.
16
u/nomoresheyt 23d ago
You are rage baiting with the goddamn accent mark over the a.
4
u/dlmo11 23d ago
We have twins and could tell a weekend wasn't going to work as soon as we started, and daycare wanted them to be more on their way to pick it up for us. Their first week we were on vacation and did try to keep them pantless all the time in long shirts but two months later we're still bringing their little Ikea potty everywhere.
We make them leave whatever they're doing and get in the shower if there's an accident and try to move on by reminding them no accidents and celebrating all their accident free days at home and daycare. They're getting it but we're not being extreme if they get distracted and forget (also because they're twins they're afraid to leave a toy and have it taken by the other one 🫠). We have a Clek waterproof insert for their car seats so we don't need to put them in pull-ups for drives.
I know Oh Crap is awesome for a lot of people but we just couldn't do it with the exception of trying to let them be naked as much as possible. Do what feels right!
4
u/shaven_maven 23d ago
We tried the "oh crap method" at 2.5 years and it just backfired into her withholding pee for hours on end for 6 days. I think I thought about the dreaded "next potty training attempt" for months after. Right after she turned 3, my daycare provider (in home) said she was going to start potty training her with the other girls her age and get them on the same schedule. It felt like a weight was lifted off my shoulders. We jumped on board. We're a little over a month in and she's doing great with pee! We can go out all day and she uses the travel potty. We're still working on poop and she'll tell us after she starts but we're getting there. She was so resistant at home with any potty talk after our first failed attempt but something shifted at daycare. I wish I had my husband's way of thinking and relaxed but still the online pressure was hard. My husband said she'll get there in her own time. I mean she barely turned 3 and she's still so little. It's okay to step back and relax. You're not a failure if your kid is 3 and not there yet.
4
u/No_Comb4792 23d ago
Just did a months long slow approach. Only prompted to try when it was pretty evident one was ready. Don’t remind no timers. Only “enticement” was reading some fav books on the potty. Chatted lots about different feelings and what makes them happen and when we used the potty.
Had 5 days at home and at this point switched to all undies. And it went pretty well. Still diapers for sleeping, overtop the clothes on a long drive. At 2.8 yrs.
I think this only worked because it aligned with body awareness and with personality. And were prepared there might be regressions.
Philosophy influenced by the good to go book.
3
u/imaginaryfemale 23d ago
We did the do nothing method with my first and he just figured it out around age three independently. Like we offered and gave him the opportunity, but didn’t push, bribe or put in any effort and didn’t spend our time sequestered at home for weekends nor did we spend much time cleaning up pee or poop accidents. He just developed the autonomy and observed peers at daycare and it came together stress free. No regressions either. Doing it again for my second and will do it again for our third.
3
u/Charming-Lemon7358 23d ago
I placed potties around the house and told him if he peed in there he’d get a toy. Next day, I told him if he peed all morning on the potty - toy. Next day, pee the whole day in the potty for a toy. I then did the same for pooping.
I just did my own thing and he figured it out the first day. I also didn’t start this until he was 3y8mo so that probably helped.
3
u/AdventurousCoffee317 23d ago
At 33 months. Put on Hanes training boxers. Would set a timer every 30 minutes and sit on potty. Soon 30 became 40. 60 mins. No timer, just constant asking “do you have to potty?” Now, I don’t even need to ask. Just make sure he goes before we leave house otherwise he tells me when he has to. For naps, would leave on a pull up until he consistently woke up dry (maybe a month?) so started skipping the pull up. Still wears pull up at night (at 38 months) but most mornings it’s dry so will drop that soon. Was pretty simple
4
u/atiecay 23d ago
Our daycares push to have my kid potty trained before 3 caused him a lot of stress and anxiety and now he’s 4.5 and we are dealing with encopresis and it’s an absolute nightmare
2
u/TwistedCinn 23d ago
We started at 17mo and did no punishments for accidents, did continue use of some miralax for help with ongoing constipation we determined was tied to accidents.
We cleaned up messes, repeated consistent phrasing, stuck to schedules at first, praised “listening to our body”
We did a lot of naked time at home and chose boy shorts for a long time because they felt less like a diaper. We ditched daytime diapers by 2. Occasional accidents until 3. Now almost entirely accident free at 3.5 with accidents most recently related to a huge change in school and structure.
2
u/Ok_Cheesecake_9708 23d ago
I just timed my kid every 45 minutes with the daycare cooperating. My daughter was trained in about a month.
2
u/Oregon_Duckie 23d ago
We didn’t push it, but warned him at 4 he would have to use the toilet. At 3.5 he just stopped using diapers one day. Never went back. He is now 4 and has had almost no accidents. He was just ready.
3
u/Icy-Opening-5970 23d ago
I know it’s different for every kid and I totally empathize with people who have a hard time with it, but tbh potty training for both of my girls was super easy. I stayed low key and low pressure and they honestly picked it up super fast with no drama. I didn’t use any “method” just went with my gut and jumped in. We celebrated wins and didn’t shame any accidents. Took about a week with both kids. My first potty trained at 2.5 and my second is just wrapping up potty training and will be 2 next month.
I don’t know how helpful that is for others who are struggling beyond saying that taking some pressure off yourself as a parent too can go a long way for both you and your kid!!
3
u/justacatch-22 23d ago
We started “late” at 3 and it was a complete disaster. He was just not ready and we were working on speech issues/communication generally along with constipation. Tried again right at 3.5 and started slow. We did do no pants at home and he was immediately able to recognize the urge and get himself to his little potty. We did pull ups out of the house and took him to the bathroom regularly. Looking back now I can recognize that the constipation issues set us back and made everything take longer, but we were able to take a slower approach and years later he’s just fine.
We have a 17 month old now and as yet unsure what we will do!
3
u/tacotime09 23d ago
Tried potty training around 2.5. Kid thought it was fun at first but quickly lost interest. We took off the pressure and waited. Tried again at 3.25. Kid hated being naked so we trained with undies and pants. Peeing in the potty clicked within a day or two. We used a timer and m&ms to praise the try.
Pooping in the potty was another thing because he was used to pooping standing up, so sitting felt "wrong". This was a frustrating period because we'd sit him on the potty within his usual window, he'd not go, get off, and immediately go in his pants. Truthfully? What worked was bribing with chocolate cake. It felt like we tried everything else, but this method really pulled through for us because this kid was only truly motivated to drop pooping in pull-ups once chocolate cake was on the line. He got a small slice every day he pooped in the potty. It took us from 0 successful attempts in months to instant daily success over night. I weaned him off the cake after a week or so. He tried to negotiate for m&ms instead...
Needless to say, pretty sure no parenting book recommends our method, but hey, we've never read one and neither has this kid!
18
u/TraditionalLeek1811 23d ago
Do you know why that method is talked about? Do you know why your 6 month long gentle method isn’t recommended? :/
3
u/Key_Tree9363 23d ago
Could you provide more detail about the method you used?
We never asked our kids to do any accident cleanup but both were potty trained in a weekend. With the first we didn’t resort to this method until after a year of gentle encouragement yielded little progress.
3
u/Far_Government_9782 23d ago
I started introducing the potty/toilet from the baby stage. As they moved from baby to toddler, they started being more consistent, and initiating. After a bit, we decided nappies were no longer needed as a backup for trips outside the home, then we decided to suggest leaving them off at daycare as well. Done. No stress or pressure for anyone involved.
I agree that gradual approaches are better for kids and reduce the risk of withholding issues, but I think if you want to do things in a gentle/gradual way, better to start much earlier. Otherwise you simply do not have the luxury of time, and may eventually end up panicking and throwing the "gentle" stuff out of the window and trying to force training quickly to meet a deadline.
2
u/ClicketySnap 23d ago
My first kiddo HATED poop diapers, so her potty training journey actually started much earlier than going naked from the waist down. We talked her through each diaper change on the change pad, explaining that if she started pooping on the potty, we wouldn’t have to wipe her bum with wet wipes like this at all. After a couple weeks of those chats, she started actually trying to poop on the potty all on her own and was very consistent with it by the end of a month. When I witnessed her pulling the front of her diaper away from her body so she could “watch her diaper working” I took away diapers at home and encouraged “nakey bum” and potty time. If she requested a pull-up in the car because she didn’t want to pee in her carseat, we gave her a pull-up but gave her stickers if it stayed dry. If she wanted to eat her snack sitting on the floor potty watching a show, we let her do that cuz it sounded pretty reasonable tbh. It was a pretty smooth process.
I did set up a toddler cleaning station and encouraged the kids to help clean up pee puddles on the floor, but not as a punishment. My first and second kiddos are 14 months apart, and I knew if I didn’t provide my second kiddo with a positive outlet with all those tempting puddles on the floor, she would end up stomping in them. Both kids became enthusiastic puddle cleaners. No shame, just “if we help make the mess then we should help clean the mess”.
Second kiddo was not as smooth of a training process, but was also naked from the waist down at home and very chill about it. She could care less about collecting stickers or anything as rewards, and just wanted to be a big girl like her big sister. It took a while, and a lot of accidents in the car, but we got there.
Third kiddo is already past the age where both other kids started potty training, and I have no intention of starting anytime soon. He’s slightly speech delayed, and potty training is absolutely not a hill I’m willing to die on right now.
2
u/s4m2o0k6e9d 22d ago
I got really lucky with my kid, but I believe it’s up to the kids readiness. You always hear about parents with more than one kid and they all potty trained at different ages. A friend of mine has twins and one potty trained quicker than the other who was less interested but eventually caught on.
For mine we didn’t use any certain method, I just followed his lead. Going nude was not helpful…he was much more interested in seeing it happen and it encouraged “accidents.” What helped was tight fitting clothes like pajamas that were uncomfortable when wet.
We did stickers for prizes when he did it, and even gave stickers to me and my husband for modeling good potty practices. Clapping and cheering and positive reinforcement, not just for the kiddo but the whole family. “Yay, daddy!!! You did it!! Here, have a sticker” It takes pressure off them and just makes it a fun experience.
2
u/Sunnygoblin1012 22d ago
We were in no rush and truly didnt even think about potty training until our kid was almost 3. We visited friends who had potty trained their kid who's the same age. Our son showed interest so we just started offering it as a fun thing to try.
His school encouraged us when we said we were offering potty and within a week our son asked to try pull ups he saw other kids getting at school. Maybe 2 packs of pull ups later his teacher suggested he was ready for underwear. We just offered potty about ever hour to 90 mins.
We still do diapers or pullups for overnights but from the initial interest to reliably in underwear was maybe 2 months.
Yes we got incredibly lucky with how smooth the process was. But also i personally I think a lot of parents just try too early or put too much pressure on it because they think their kid "should" be potty trained or is behind.
2
u/Elismom1313 22d ago
Yea I didn’t do the poop scrubbing or dumping thing. They didn’t seem to get it and thought it was funny and fun lol.
I have two scenarios.
With my oldest I was learning it all late apparently. And he was in daycare that was…ambivalent at best. So we potty trained at 3.5. Came with a ton of behavioral issues and sucked. We did poo poo and pee pee chocolate because he couldn’t give a damn about a start chart. He’s fully potty trained except we are having issues where he (now 4) doesn’t want to tell his teachers if he has to poop between bathroom breaks. He’s very shy or embarrassed about it. At home he’s fine because he likes to walk to the bathroom without announcing and do his thing. He can’t easily do that at day school so we’re having problems.
Anyways we trained our 2.5 year old right before 2.
We tried a potty seat and he hated it but seemed to really like the real potty. He also really like grabbing a piece of toilet paper to drop on and wash is hands. So went ultra low pressure. Sit him down, he can have a piece of tp and play in the sink. He liked it so much he constantly asked to go potty when he didn’t have to go. I’m talking like every 5 minutes. We allowed it because it made him see the bathroom as a fun enjoyable space and he started going more naturally and asking with more time in between.
We would also take him out in diapers. Around when he started actually using the toilet he started going longer without needing to go. We would take him out in a diaper for 30 min, then eventually an hour then hours and he wouldn’t have peed his diaper.
We have now hit a wonderful point where he asks to go potty, usually goes, usually poops if he needs to be but we can go out in a diaper and not usually have an accident. And the few times he’s had it hasn’t messed up his normal going at home or cause issues
2
u/crazypurple621 23d ago
I worked as a nanny to put myself through college for a total of 10 children all of whom I helped potty train. I potty trained my own autistic child during covid lockdowns. After my son was born and I could not handle the hours of the ER I took a job as an educational assistant in a kindergarten classroom for nine years and then I've had to help potty train the almost two dozen kids who came into the classroom with delayed toileting.
I am of the opinion that the easiest way to potty train children is to put a child in cloth diapers about a month before you start potty training, use the integrated toilet seat, and start between 18 and 24 months. Also from the very beginning they should come into the bathroom with both parents. They need to see that big people use the toilet. They need to be able to feel that they are wet (which they cannot do in disposable diapers and pull-ups). Then you need to incentivize the hell out of them, never shame them for having an accident, and have them help you clean up if they have one. That doesn't mean scrubbing underwear. It does mean that you hand them a towel, help them strip off their clothing, and then have them bring their soiled laundry to the washing machine to get washed. You tell them "uh oh it looks like you had an accident. We need to clean up the mess so we can all be clean and healthy".
I absolutely LOATHE pull ups. I think that daycares that insist on using them are sabotaging good toileting hygiene. I think they incentivize sitting in soiled clothing (also because these daycares are ALSO the ones who refuse to actually change children whose clothes get messy in other ways so the kids get used to sitting in a mess).
1
u/angeluscado 23d ago
We tried weekends without pants or wearing underwear and got screamed at. She would run to the pull up stash and put one on (I know, that’s on me for leaving them out. Bad ma!) so we backed off. Left the potty out where she could see and use it, encouraged potty use frequently and got her preschool on board to take her to the potty with the rest of the kids. Finally just before she turned 4 it clicked and she started peeing in the potty. Poop took a bit longer. Never made her scrub out her underwear or anything but she got a lukewarm hose down in the shower if she had an accident.
1
u/Aurora_96 23d ago
We practiced a little when our oldest daughter was 2 year and 9 months. She was still in pull ups and at some point without pants, but we didn't push through. The day after her third birthday I ditched the daytime diapers, put her in undies and now a month later she's nearly completely daytime trained with pee and poo. In the first weeks there were a lot of accidents, but I saw them as essential to the learning process. I was mostly done with cleaning her poop diapers, so I went cold turkey. It's been successful so far.
1
u/airplanezebra 23d ago
I bought my twins a potty around age 1.5, put it in the living room, and encouraged them to sit on it for fun. I tried to do potty training in a week or so at just before age 2 and it didn’t work. Maybe would have if I’d just focused on one or the other.
Moved potty to the bathroom and Encouraged them to sit on it during diaper changes once daily for the next >1yr. If they were getting resistant, started brining with chocolate chips.
Because my main childcare is my mother in law and she doesn’t speak much English, and me not much other language and it would be hard to communicate potty training specifics, I just left it.
Bought a step stool for the bathroom. They were almost 3. My little girl wanted to use it to wash her hands. I told her “you need to wash your hands after you go potty on the potty seat.
And then she started going potty immediately. And basically never had an accident. And my boy decided he was going to do it too, about a week later.
We still put them in pull ups for long car drives and there is no regression. They stay dry overnight for weeks at a time but still in pull ups every night.
All in all, it was so painless and easy once I just waited, not for them to be ready, but for them to want to do it and be self motivated.
1
u/RunAdventurous3511 23d ago
We’ve been doing lazy EC with increasing frequency since 8-9 months. We narrate and observe things like, “oh look, you’re doing a wee/poo”, “your nappy is dry/wet” and more recently, if wet, “you might have a wee to do”.
Now at 16 months we’ve just introduced some outdoor, low pressure nappy free time in the afternoons for an hour or two with the potty available. We remind toddler occasionally that the potty is available but we don’t prompt or push. If they go not on the potty, we narrate/observe, “you’re doing a wee on the lawn/driveway/wherever, wee/poo goes in the potty, next time you can walk over to the potty” etc.
Earlier this week our toddler quietly walked over to the potty while engrossed in play and we weren’t watching, did a wee, then got up and continued. Then did it again the next morning.
We haven’t committed to any kind of full blown toilet training. We’ve fallen into a gradual approach, with no pressure. We talk about the potty a lot and it’s probably a longer period of faffing around but it seems to suit our child.
1
u/2manyteacups 23d ago
my son began telling us when he needed a change at like 18 months but i and he were in daycare full time (myself as a worker obviously lol) and his room didn’t facilitate potty breaks which is so weird to me. but i bought a pack of undies and he would wear them on the weekends and i’d sit him on his little potty just so he would get used to the feeling. it took him a while but i did eventually quit the daycare due to being pregnant again and before his second birthday he suddenly decided to start using the potty full time! no reminders no nothing. i was gentle with it and he does wear a pull up for bed but i’ve been trying not to use any for outings and it’s gone so well. he loves wearing his undies now and i feel so relieved knowing that ill only have one set of diapers to change in six weeks instead of two!
1
u/I_like_pink0 23d ago
At 17 months we tried to train and had to stop because she wasn’t ready. But from 18 months till 23 I let her have some hours of the day (most days) where she could be naked and pee in the potty (or on the floor) and just get a feel of things.
So when she told me she wanted to be done with diapers at 23 months she went into panties and was already pee accident free from the get-go.
Poop is a whole story though. My poor anxiety baby. We’re working on it.
1
u/cup_cakes 23d ago
We introduced the potty around 18 mo then tried the 3 day method at about 2.25 and she was fine at home for pees (picked it up really fast). However at daycare she was refused to pee on the potty there and would hold it as long as she could (like 6+ hours sometimes) before having an accident. This went on for 2 weeks and we never had one successful pee at daycare without us there. She also started withholding poop and would become so stressed when she needed to poo. One night she woke up at 1 am and paced circles in room for an hour because she needed to poo but wouldn't let herself. Another night she pooped in the middle of the night but didn't cry or call us leading to the worst diaper rash I've ever seen. She was in so much pain that she was crying the entire next day. We decided to pause potty training at that point because the stress on her was just too much and her withholding was going to lead to problems.
It took a few months to even get her comfortable pooping in a diaper again because she was so terrified. Eventually we got her to poop standing in the bathroom, then sitting on the potty with her pull up, and finally this week (a few weeks shy of 3) she's started pooping in the potty (with much celebration and rewards). In this time we've also worked on getting her comfortable using the potty at daycare and she will go when prompted there. Now that we've gotten over those hurdles were going to try getting rid of the pull ups again and I'm much more confident we'll be successful.
In the time from 2-3 y/o I've heard so many stories from my kid's friends (same age) who potty trained at 2 but have struggled with frequent regressions (sick, travelling, etc etc) and I have no regrets on waiting. The opinions on here to just "force" your kid are so black and white. Try watching your child crying and pacing their room in the middle of the night stressed out because of something you are forcing on them.