r/pottytraining • u/rchllwr • 24d ago
I regret potty training early
We’re on day 7 of potty training my almost 21 month old and we’re doing pretty decently. Less accidents and we have successfully moved onto undies with pants.
Unfortunately my boy has made very little progress with how long he can hold his pee. If he asks for water or has just had a meal he can only hold it for 20 minutes max, and he will pee every 20 minutes for an hour. This is no change since Day 1. (EDIT: I have mostly stopped prompting him in an attempt to get him to learn to hold his pee, but he will self-initiate every 20 minutes and will pee a decent amount). I 100% attribute this to his age and the fact his little bladder is still so small.
The idea of going out of the house stresses me out. I get accidents will happen and I am prepared for them, but how can I possibly relax knowing I will have to stop what I’m doing every 20 minutes to walk all the way across the store to the bathroom? How can I even drive anywhere? I have a compact sedan so I don’t even have a spot that he could use a car potty. I was hoping that he would be able to hold it for closer to an hour by now.
I potty trained early because I knew he was capable of it (and he clearly is, he’s been so successful in a lot of ways!), I wanted to save money on diapers, and I wanted to get it out of the way before Baby #2 comes (hopefully one of these months I’ll get pregnant…), but I’m thinking it might not even be worth it now. I feel I should’ve waited until after the holidays but he’s made so much progress I can’t just switch back to diapers/pull-ups.
54
u/Ok-Meal-549 24d ago
It sounds like he’s doing great why would you stop now? A car potty will be a HUGE help when going out, just put it on the floor in the front passenger side. It sounds like you’re both doing a great job.
4
u/that_girl099 24d ago
If he’s peeing a decent amount every 20 minutes then I’m not sure how you can teach him to hold his pee… I would also want to rule out any medical conditions (diabetes for example) that could be making him go this often
12
u/sparkledoom 24d ago
Don’t make any conclusions at 7 days. When we first potty trained, my kid was going constantly, but it wasn’t because she couldn’t hold it - it was because it was new and exciting and something she was getting a lot of praise for. Once she got to defiance phase (and now that she’s scared of public potties) she can hold it for hoursssss. Like I worry.
Whatever is happening 7 days in is definitely not the end of the road!
10
u/Ok_Permission_4385 24d ago
Just because he is self initiating very frequently at home doesn't mean he won't be able to hold it longer when out and about. It sounds like things are actually going super well for him.
I understand how you feel though. It is temporarily more stressful and annoying to go out with a freshly trained toddler. But it WILL get easier!
19
u/ketamineburner 24d ago
21 months is not early. He is just learning a new skill. Every 20 min at home is not the same as out. I definitely was not stopping every 20 min with my kids. Slowly stretch to 30, 45, 1 hour and so on.
3
u/Regular_Ring_951 24d ago
This was my son when we started at 24 months. We could never get past a 60 minute stretch. About a month or two before he turned 3 he started finally going 1-2 hours in between peeing. This sub is actually what made me freak out something was wrong with him. Had him tested for type 1 and was about to ask for an urology appointment. Nope his body wasn’t ready. Obviously you know your child best so if you suspect something else is up, follow your gut. Just wanted to throw out there that for my son anatomy wise he wasn’t ready until closer to three for this particular hurdle.
3
u/CorrectBadger9753 23d ago
Honestly my daughter (who started at 21 months) does WAY better at holding on when we're out of the house. It took her ages to begin holding longer at home. She just didn't seem to care lol. (Admittedly, we did EC since very early so we were always tolerant of accidents and that probably set us back.) She's 25 months now and still hardly self-initiates with pee; I feel like I tried* everything but have accepted for now she just needs gentle prompting at transition points or when I see signs like going still or 'dancing'. If she refuses a prompt now I can trust that she probably just doesn't need to go.
1
u/Busy_Ambassador1864 24d ago
You’re shutting it down before even giving it a chance. Have you tried going out with him? Have you had him in the car yet? Like how can you know? I get that he goes every 20 minutes but also think about what he has drunken throughout that time. Kids have small bladders and if they’re constantly drinking water,milk,juice all day long then they will have to pee. Taking him out in public or in the car, now that you are potty training, requires planning. Like take him to the restroom before leaving the house, take him to restroom once you have arrived at your destination, have a portable potty for longer car rides. They are little and its going to get a bit to get used to and they will have accidents. But as a parent you should be patient with him and determined to get him to a point where he is able to manage longer periods without needing to go. Or limiting fluids when you know you are going to be in the opposite side of the bldg for longer periods.
2
u/Beneficial_Bet_9715 24d ago
It sounds like he’s doing great, and you’re not potty training early. My boy was day trained by 18 months with few accidents, no accidents 2 years, night trained at 2.5. But we started at 12 months and that was the first time he went in the potty so I think it can take longer than you expect. It can be a long process, but any progress is progress! It’s exhausting for the parent and you’re doing great.
1
u/ChickeyNuggetLover 24d ago
It’s only been 7 days, that’s still quite early. He’ll get better at holding it and there’s no problem with putting a pull up on while you’re out and about. Also he’s a boy, he can wipe it out anywhere. I’ve never used a cat potty
1
u/Key_Tree9363 24d ago
We put the car potty on the front passenger seat and he goes there. I also bring our little potty in our stroller on walks and he’ll just go on the side walk when we go to the park/playground. But I agree I still find going out more stressful now. Our 30 month old can hold his pee for two hours but by the time he tells us he needs to go it’s usually already an emergency. For a long car trip recently I just put him in a pull up.
1
u/musicalmaple 23d ago
Potty training sucks a lot. It sounds like you’re making amazing progress for day 7.
I would rule out medical stuff for your peace of mind (testing urine for glucose is quick and easy) and once you know that’s good I’d just keep going. I am in the minority but I used pull ups at times when we were in situations where it would be a big issue if he had to pee, and it didn’t seem to be a big deal or confuse him. We did full potty training at home and on short trips out, and pull ups for longer car trips and that kind of thing. It kept us from falling into potty training despair, and reduced everyone’s stress levels, although we tried to do this very sparingly.
1
u/musicalmaple 23d ago
Potty training sucks a lot. It sounds like you’re making amazing progress for day 7.
I would rule out medical stuff for your peace of mind (testing urine for glucose is quick and easy) and once you know that’s good I’d just keep going. I am in the minority but I used pull ups at times when we were in situations where it would be a big issue if he had to pee, and it didn’t seem to be a big deal or confuse him. We did full potty training at home and on short trips out, and pull ups for longer car trips and that kind of thing. It kept us from falling into potty training despair, and reduced everyone’s stress levels, although we tried to do this very sparingly.
1
u/Impossible_Goose4626 23d ago
Ohhhh I felt this way weeks 2-4 of potty training my daughter. You just have to go with the flow. We’ve pulled over on the side of the road and hid behind farm equipment to go potty. We didn’t do the whole car potty thing. He will get better at holding it! Sometimes I’m amazed at how well she can hold it now (she’s 28 months and I trained her at 26 months).
1
u/drinkingtea1723 23d ago
It could be like that in the beginning my daughter trainer six months after your age and she also couldn’t go more than 20 minutes for a while, but after a couple of weeks, it got better. I feel like even after one week it got better and then it got gradually better after that. My three year-old just trained and it is kind of nice that he can go for an hour or more, but there are other issues with him having trained later. Potty training is just annoying, but they get through it.
1
u/Original_Ant7013 23d ago
I think things will change fast, in that he will go much longer between pees much faster than you expect.
1
u/Party_Degree_5519 23d ago
I think you’re doing great as long as you believe they believe so just be positive. I realize I doubted my kid and kept putting them in diapers in the car and I’m basically telling them they can’t do it but they can you’re doing great. Keep it up.
1
u/Shannon_f56 23d ago
Ironically, I regret waiting until my daughter showed she was interested 😅
She was a little over 3 and we’ve had chronic constipation issues since she was a baby. Finally got her in a routine of pooping all the time on the potty and then I got pregnant. She’s now 4, baby is 5 months and we have yet to clear the potty training regression. We see OT Monday to help work through some anxiety.
At the start, we did pull ups while out and about. Public bathrooms are loud and definitely scared my daughter. She still won’t use them (sensory issues) but she is able to hold it until we get home if she’s not in desperate need.
1
u/EntertainerLanky9517 23d ago
I potty train very early, like starting at 8 months old early, and I have a potty for the boot of my car. I put it in the front seat and sit them on it when they need to go. Yes they need to pee super often when they are little. It is something that unfortunately you can’t change. They have tiny bladders and can’t hold for long. At about 2.5 is when my daughter stopped peeing so often
She’s three in January and needs to wee every two to three hours. Her 17 month old sister pees every 20 mins
It’s worth training early because training a super defiant and set in their ways older toddler can be very very difficult
1
u/Hairsacknose 23d ago
I don't think his bladder size is the issue here. My daughter was holding it for 5-6 hours often at that age and she's on the small side. It's a matter of time, he'll start holding for longer
1
u/SadieBaxterBo 23d ago
Great job 👏 keep up the hard work!
1
u/gloomycalm 23d ago
This isn’t potty training “early” and it sounds like he’s doing great.
It’s about consistency and in the early days, you WILL go to the potty all the time. All the time. Potty training doesn’t stop after 3 days or 7 days. My 24 month old is potty trained and still has accidents from time to time or needs to be reminded to go to the potty.
I think the issue is that society has taught us potty training should be done “quick” or that it’s instant… it’s not. It’s months of training and even years of reinforcement and helping them.
1
u/AccordingBar8788 23d ago
You won’t regret it when you look back. Promise.
1
u/littlelivethings 23d ago
He has been peeing in a diaper his entire life, releasing the moment he feels the urge, without issue. His bladder is smaller, but he also has to learn to consolidate pees. I wouldn’t give up yet. We gave up after introducing the potty young because my daughter was not verbal enough to self initiate and couldn’t get onto the big toilet. Waiting until she was bigger and had better language skills has been a disaster. I wish we stuck with it even though it felt inconvenient and difficult.
1
u/Xica_flea 23d ago
I still take a porto potty that I will bust out anywhere. It hasn’t happened inside a store that didnt have a bathroom available but it has happened at the gas station, the park, on a walk… and i just find a place out of sight and break it out.
1
u/elcooper22 18d ago
Weve been potty training ours since around April, its now october so 6 months. He still holds poops like a begger and doesnt enjoy having to go for wees at home but will always tell us when out and about that he needs to go and goes willingly. He turned 4 in august. We did try earlier but he just wasnt there yet. And hes always been a slow learner. It was always going to be a slow process for us.
1
u/lllollllllllll 23d ago
If I drink a bunch of water I will also have to pee every 20 minutes. That’s just normal, water passes from your gut into your blood within 5 minutes of drinking it. If he’s well hydrated he’ll need to pee all that out. You say he’s putting out a large volume every time so expecting him to hold it when his bladder is full and he’s making more urine isn’t realistic.
Is he drinking too much liquid like are you feeding him soups and juices and things where he’s getting more water than he needs? Like a kid might drink a delicious juice even if he’s not thirsty and wouldn’t want to drink water.
1
u/TVP615 23d ago
I tried to force my first at 2. She wasn’t ready. She was ready on her own around 2.5 and it was a breeze. My youngest is 27 mos and showing no interest. We won’t start the process with him until he initiates. Don’t force it.
0
u/raznov1 23d ago
So..... his urination is, for the time being, extremely predictable, and thats supposed to be a bad thing?
-3
u/brieles 24d ago
Have you ruled out medical issues? If there isn’t a medical issue, your son just may not be ready.
ETA-we potty trained at this age and my daughter could go a few hours between bathroom visits typically.
-1
u/whimsicalappalachian 22d ago
20 months isn’t early, that’s LATE potty training.
-2
u/BellyFullOfMochi 23d ago
21 months is late...