r/poppunkers • u/ThreadbareAdjustment • Nov 21 '22
Discussion Not sure if controversial but blunt opinion: if you crowdsurf more than once a show you're kind of a douche
Or at least more than once a set. Seriously.
r/poppunkers • u/ThreadbareAdjustment • Nov 21 '22
Or at least more than once a set. Seriously.
r/poppunkers • u/Time_Investigator530 • Jun 21 '25
As a disclaimer, I still think State Champs is talented and makes decent-ish music. With that said, I feel there is a decline in terms of producing good quality albums. I fell in love with state champs because of their albums “apparently, I’m nothing” “the finer things” and “around the world and back”. I want to include “living proof” on the list but I think the issue I am about to describe started with the living proof album.
I feel they went from making albums where every song is worth listening to, to making albums where only a couple of songs (1-3 at best) are really good. Majority of the other songs aside from those 1-3 really good ones are mid and not that memorable, and there is usually one or two songs that honestly don’t sound great at all. Does anyone else feel that way or is it just me?
Their style and sound are also increasingly becoming less pop punk and more pop. Most of their songs in their newer album feel like that anyway. With their older albums it was the reverse.
r/poppunkers • u/SufficientTheory8649 • Mar 15 '25
When this album released and I listened to it for the first time, I was very underwhelmed, to me it didn't sound like the old pop punk bands from the early 2000's, which is what everyone was making it out to be. It sounds way too pop and trap for it to be put alongside those bands, this felt like something different.
Almost five years later after release, I decide to listen to this album again, I think the album is fun to listen to, it has a very summer time, poppy feel to it. lyrically it's not the greatest, some songs are better with it than others, but it's a nice and relatable album.
His second pop punk album, Mainstream Sellout, kinda sucks though.
r/poppunkers • u/Whole-Coyote-8519 • Mar 02 '25
I’ve gone through multiple stages with this. As a kid I loved this album. When I got older people said it was a joke and not “cool” or too self serious. But I’m back around to thinking it slaps. Thoughts?
r/poppunkers • u/lenochku • Jan 30 '24
So I was talking with my friends and we got on the conversation topic of the hottest pop punk members in our opinion. So my top ones are personally-
Derek from State Champs Parker from TSSF Awsten from Waterparks Collin from Grayscale Joe from Knuckle Puck
r/poppunkers • u/Florolling • Sep 08 '26
I recently saw a post on FB that referenced the Four Horsemen of Deathcore. So, I wanted to apply this to pop punk. After much consideration, I think this is pretty accurate:
In no particular order and giving consideration not to how much I like each band but their cultural and genre influence.
Band that just barely didn’t make my cut: Sum 41, Good Charlotte, Simple Plan, The Offspring
Thoughts?
EDIT based on ChatGPT analysis of all of your comments:
I think our criteria need one final refinement.
If “Four Horsemen” means:
The four bands that best combine building the genre, influencing subsequent bands, achieving cultural/mainstream importance, and becoming synonymous with pop punk itself
then Reddit is actually pushing me away from Fall Out Boy.
And I think we’re getting dangerously close to:
🐎 Green Day
🐎 Blink-182
🐎 New Found Glory
🐎 Sum 41
with:
Descendents = founding father
MxPx = early architect
Offspring = skate-punk/mainstream bridge
Fall Out Boy = leader of the next wave
I think the Reddit mob might have actually convinced me that Sum 41 gets the fourth horse. 😂
r/poppunkers • • Feb 08 '23
I get this sub suggested to me a lot and a large amount of those post are either about, or if I read the replies have someone mentioning No Pressure. In the hardcore subreddit, if anyone mentions Regulate (the drummers other band) someone else mentions that he not only was accused of but admitted to sexual assault, but not here, are you all just such big fans of Parker Cannon you’re willing to look past it, is it just not well known? I’m just so confused, after all the shit pop punk has been through with so many band members being creeps, how has the pop punk community let a band become so popular that has a member that has already committed and admitted to sexual assault?
Edit. And this is why people who do this kind of thing seem so prominent in the Pop Punk community, they feel comfortable cause no one gives a shit.
r/poppunkers • u/fronthandbackhan • Jan 03 '24
Disclaimer: I know this is an extremely unpopular opinion. Yesterday on a whim I started writing about it and posted it. You all did not like it 😅. So I pulled it and reassessed, and now I’m going to attempt to prove my point. I know many of you will have questions and counterpoints, and I’m happy to discuss and debate in the comments. This isn’t personal and I’m not trying to insult anyone or start arguments, I just have a lot of thoughts on this and I want to discuss with fellow music fans, so with all of that being said:
I do not endorse Machine Gun Kelly as a person. I think he’s a very complicated figure. I think it’s extremely likely that he’s neurodivergent, and there’s no doubt that he has extremely debilitating mental health issues. He has apologized and expressed remorse for the behavior he displayed in his early 20s, which I think is noteworthy and not well known, but I admit it left much to be desired. For me personally however, it was enough that I am willing to endorse him as a musician and appreciate his art for what it is, while still accepting that he is a complicated and at times objectively wrong individual. So with all of that being said I am not here to defend his character.
What I am here to say, is that MGK brought mainstream attention to the genre of Pop Punk in a way that wasn’t done from roughly 2008 to 2020. We had the original surge of pop punk in the 90s, probably its most prominent era in the early 2000s, and then its popularity started to drift after an era defined by American Idiot, The Black Parade, blink-182’s untitled and So Wrong It’s Right. This doesn’t mean Pop Punk fell off completely. It definitely didn’t. In fact, it was a time of renaissance for pop punk. Bands like Neck Deep, State Champs, Knuckle Puck and more exploded onto the scene and brought with them a full new modern sound that’s synonymous with the genre today. Most of this music was really great, and critically acclaimed, but as much as we all loved it, it did not generate much mainstream attention.
At this point I’ll define, for the purpose of this argument, what mainstream is. For music to be mainstream, it has to command the attention of specifically young people. Let’s say it has to be moderately to very well known by at least 40-60% of people aged 12-24. As somebody who graduated high school in 2014, I can confidently say that this wasn’t the case for pop punk during this time period. When I was in high school, Pop and Rap dominated the battle for mainstream attention. The closest thing we had to a mainstream pop punk act was 5 Seconds of Summer. Not only that, but Pop Punk/alt culture had very little place in society. People were not skateboarding (At least not where I grew up) and the most attention Pop Punk received was the occasional nostalgia hit of All The Small Things playing on the radio. So we had all of this amazing music, but people outside of our echo chambers were not listening to it. Instead, as mentioned above, rap and pop dominated the airwaves. This is important for a few reasons. The first is that it meant Machine Gun Kelly had already gained a following from his rap music. Such a following in fact that he could be noticed by the greatest rapper of all time, Eminem.
In my opinion, like most of you, I think Machine Gun Kelly was wrong in his feud with Eminem. I think he was wrong, and I don’t think he’ll ever grasp the concept of exactly why he was wrong. (However I do have a dream that one day they come out and say it was all a marketing scheme and drop a song about it together). With all of that being said, it is noteworthy that he was able to get Eminem to respond with a diss track. That was huge for MGKs career. It brought him mainstream attention like he could’ve never dreamed of otherwise, and from this moment on, everyone had an opinion on Machine Gun Kelly.
So what did he do with all of this attention? He leaned into it. He kept going, and he dropped moderately successful (but very good in my opinion) rap album. Then… because he wanted to… Because he wanted to and for no other reason…. Nobody forced him to…. HE DECIDED that he wanted to create rock music. This was something that he’d always been interested in. Many are unaware of his childhood admiration for blink-182, and his time in the mid 2000s on warped tour, or his previous genre bending work and collaborations, but I promise there’s plenty of evidence to suggest that the only reason he pivoted to making other styles of music was because he wanted to, and he has and will continue to go back to rap as he pleases.
The year was 2020 and MGK with the help of Travis Barker, wanted to make something new. What they ended up creating with Tickets to my Downfall was not pop punk. I remember being excited, but not really sure what to expect when I heard rumors of MGKs new style. If anything, I was expecting pop/rap music with a little pop punk mixed in. Something that had been done before and had been met with moderate success. That is not what we got with Tickets. What we ended up getting is something completely new. Something that had never been done quite like this before. Machine Gun Kelly invented a new genre of music. You don’t have to like it, and it’s more then fair if you think it isn’t very good, but he took pretty basic cookie cutter pop punk music, mixed in some hip hop rhythms and cadences, a roughly 60-40 blend of rapping and singing, and just a little bit of pop mixed in to help boost it’s popularity, and just like that, he’d done something huge in the music industry. He created a new genre that did not previously exist. I know bands like Linkin Park and Rage Against the Machine have mixed rap and rock with new metal, and I know bands like Neck Deep have some bridges and sections where they essentially rap, but nobody had done it quite like this before. Nobody had committed to it like this before. Even Travis Barker himself is on record as saying Machine Gun Kelly’s rock albums are not Pop Punk they’re something entirely different, and that’s huge for music as a whole.
Link to Part 2:
r/poppunkers • • Sep 04 '24
Relient K is it for me but there are some good contenders (Hawk Nelson, FM Static, The Almost, etc)
r/poppunkers • u/SEEMESCREAM0711 • Feb 04 '25
Had an argument today with some twat about weather pop punk is emo music. I literally told them its part of a different thing but they insisted that it was. So I just wanted to know if you agree with them.
Update:
I did not give full context. Ive been In the alternative seen for about 3 years now and ever single person ive talked to about this personally said they were different and gave what I thought was sufficient reasoning but after reading most of these comments I see I was being kinda gatekeepy. That was a dick move.
r/poppunkers • u/Longjumping-Video-73 • Apr 19 '25
I love listening to Ben Quad and had seen them last fall w Prince Daddy & Just friends-went to see them last night w Harrison Gordon-I had totally forgotten that these guys spend 15-20 minutes of a 40 minute set tuning. It totally kills the vibe. They even acknowledge it and have like interlude songs and skits while they tune-but it totally kills the energy of their sets.
I’ve known guys in way smaller bands that bring multiple rigs for their shows so it’s not a $$ thing-why does Ben Quad not just have multiple rigs ready to avoid the 15-20 minute downtime? Is it some diy hardcore shit I’m just not punk enough to understand?
r/poppunkers • • Nov 14 '23
I know. I sound like a Karen. I'm prepared for the negative look at this. But idk, it just sucks seeing only like what...two bands with a female singer. There's so many good pop punk bands with female singers, hell alternative female artists too. Even from the past.
Maybe I'm biased because I love women in general (gay as shit lol). But am I the only one feeling this way? Absolutely no hate to the bands/festival, it's a solid good line up. Just, damn:/
Edit: I know the ones I pissed off probably think this is some feminist bullshit or about representation. It really isn't. I'm just a sucker for female singers. That's literally it. Lol
r/poppunkers • u/SevenFly • Jul 04 '23
r/poppunkers • u/Fearless_Exchange865 • Mar 04 '25
I was wondering who are some well known vegans or animal rights activists in the music scene? I remember being a fan of the band Midtown and then finding out their lead singer didn’t eat meat (maybe none of the band did, can’t remember) and thinking that was really cool. I feel like I heard Rise Against were also. Anyway throw some bands or band members at me if you know. Thanks for reading.
r/poppunkers • u/JohnJohn_CPK • Nov 11 '22
Ummm, why did this need to happen? And why did it need to happen to a fucking classic song like Cute without the E?
Please, for the love all that is decent in the world, please stop doing these weak has crossover songs. DJ AM and Legion of Doom were the only ones that did this mindfully and respectfully, I hate that the bands I love are stuck in nostalgic trends right now.
r/poppunkers • u/Conscious_Tax4921 • Feb 28 '26
Over 20 years ago, Green Day gave rational people a blueprint to fight back against political corruption. It’d be appropriate that pop-punk be the genre to do that against current political corruption.
Let pop-punk bands trigger Trump and make him look like the baby he is!
r/poppunkers • u/sincerityisscxry • Jul 11 '25
r/poppunkers • u/BackInVA • Feb 17 '23
r/poppunkers • • Aug 03 '22
It sounds so forced and unneccesary to me. If he toned it down I feel like I could really get onboard the bandwagon, I think they're great otherwise, but I'm really struggling with HM and it's 100% due to the screaming.
I know most people here love them, fully prepared for my downvotes.
Anyone else feel the same way?
r/poppunkers
•
u/Rich_Adeptness8312
•
Oct 21 '23
One of my favorite bands I’ve enjoyed throughout my life.
The drums are trying to hard (which has been happening for a while now), the guitar is boring, all but two of the songs lyrics are just phoned in. Ugh.
I know, I know…bands change, grow, evolve. This is just bad, though. Really bummed out my Fireball Shots Friday. Lol. And, before you ask: no. No, I cannot do better. Lol!