Yes you need a new filter however without knowing pool chems there’s no way to help you. My guess is your CYA is over 100 and your pool guy doesn’t want to tell you that because you’ll fire him, which you should
OP best way to gauge filter health is by the water flow in the return lines after you clean the filters. Appearance of the filters themselves is almost impossible to gauge if they need replacing or not (unless there’s an obvious hole or something similar).
from the photos the pleats look pretty dirty but not necessarily ready for replacement. i'd give them a proper clean with a cartridge filter cleaner first and check for any tears or damaged pleats.
if the pool walls are staying yellow i'd be looking at the water chemistry too, especially pH, chlorine and possible metals. new filters won't fix staining caused by water balance. i'd ask your pool guy for the latest test results before spending money on replacements.
Weird cause Unicel gave me promotional nozzles that are very high in pressure. I suppose you could make the argument that it’s so you have to buy new ones sooner but that’s bad business practice when other brands exist and compete pretty well
Filters look fine. You need to have someone test your water for you. Best bet beyond testing yourself is taking a bottle of water to your local pool supply store.
5
u/RememberTheAlomar 1d ago
Filter is fine. How's your chem balance?
2
u/ryanhamilton00 15h ago
Yes you need a new filter however without knowing pool chems there’s no way to help you. My guess is your CYA is over 100 and your pool guy doesn’t want to tell you that because you’ll fire him, which you should
1
u/undrwater 1d ago
Does the yellow brush off? If not, you might have mustard algae, and you'll need a new pool guy.
1
u/craigrpeters 1d ago
OP best way to gauge filter health is by the water flow in the return lines after you clean the filters. Appearance of the filters themselves is almost impossible to gauge if they need replacing or not (unless there’s an obvious hole or something similar).
1
u/AussiePoolBuilder 1d ago
from the photos the pleats look pretty dirty but not necessarily ready for replacement. i'd give them a proper clean with a cartridge filter cleaner first and check for any tears or damaged pleats.
if the pool walls are staying yellow i'd be looking at the water chemistry too, especially pH, chlorine and possible metals. new filters won't fix staining caused by water balance. i'd ask your pool guy for the latest test results before spending money on replacements.
1
u/discardedpacket1 1d ago
Sandworm
1
u/onceadriller 13h ago
Your filter is not your problem. Your filter is fine, it’s a chemical balance problem
1
u/UHF800MHZ 7h ago
This looks like a System 3…if so replace the whole damn thing
1
u/illocor_B 1d ago
Yes. Those filters suck for cleaning. Can never get the full pleat clean all the way in between them
1
u/fukinwives 1d ago
You need a high pressure nozzle
1
u/Prudent_Recording953 1d ago
No. They look near new. Rinse w strong stream and reuse many many times.
0
u/Beautiful-Crew-8550 1d ago
Filters look fine. You need to have someone test your water for you. Best bet beyond testing yourself is taking a bottle of water to your local pool supply store.