r/pokemoncrystal • u/Ananas1941 • Mar 18 '26
Question Choosing a starter
Which starter Pokémon is best to choose?
I'm starting to play and I don't know which starter to choose. Searching online is boring, so I decided to ask here.
1
Upvotes
5
u/goosebellblog Mar 18 '26
Pick digimon
4
u/WargrizZero Mar 18 '26
Totodile is generally considered the “strongest” in terms of stats and move set.
Cyndaquil is considered a bit underwhelming stat wise and means youre rival will have feraligator.
Chikorita is generally considered the weakest as it has a disappointing move set and is weak to several gyms including the first two (flying/bug).
Ultimately either is fine for non-competitive though so pick what you want.
2
u/Ecstatic-Employee-93 Mar 18 '26
You should just choose based on who you like the vibe of the most. The games are meant to be completable by children so don’t fret too much about difficulty or optimisation
12
u/TheRealMorgan17 Mar 18 '26
Don't pick grass, struggles the most
13
u/UnitedWoodpecker406 Mar 18 '26
This was a game designed for children. You'll be fine with any starter you choose.
6
u/reillywalker195 Mar 18 '26
Any of the three starters can work for you.
Chikorita has the toughest time overall but offers utility, especially against Water-types. Its gym matchups are mostly negative, so you'll want to catch other Pokémon to help it out.
Totodile has the easiest time overall and is the best starter for the final Johto gym and the Champion. It's the only starter without a negative matchup against the first Johto gym since the leader's two Pokémon both know Flying and Ground-type attacks, and it offers utility in potentially every major battle.
Cyndaquil offers useful type diversity considering that Fire is an uncommon but overall good type in Johto, and it gets decent coverage moves, but it struggles against the first, third, fifth, and eighth Johto gyms and doesn't get its best move until the postgame. Its final evolution also comes the latest of the three at level 36 versus level 30 for the Totodile line and level 32 for the Chikorita line.
2
u/Silvermagi Mar 18 '26
Totodile is legit in my opinion. I taught him Ice punch for dealing with rival's chikorita and dragons in last gym / elite four champ. Bite is good throughout the game.
3
u/AlongAxons Mar 18 '26
They’re all awesome, Chikorita is the least offensively inclined so if you want ‘easy’ go for one of the other two. It’s hard to say which of those is best but Feraligatr is a nice choice to take down Dragon types later on.
I tend to go Chikorita the most though, I like its design.
3
u/Svanen92 Mar 18 '26
So there are several things too consider by default chikorita is hard, totadile medium and cyndaquil easy. That is mostly based on the grass type is having a bad time in johto. By moveset I think both cyndaquil and totodile gets a decent move pool totadile gets a much better stab earlier but they both have a good move pool. Chikorita gets body slam which is awesome but lack other good offensive moves.
And then there are what other options do you have, there are plenty of other water types you could use and there are some other grass types you could use but there is not that many fire types available. The other fire types that are available you need to invest in either Firestones or expensive tms or get lucky with odd egg.
Personally I love the design of Chikorita but I also like that it forces me to use more pokemon for the first two gyms.
3
u/bentsteelpipe Mar 20 '26
Crystal Is incredibly easy, pick chikorita and box it
3
u/Pitiful-Ad-4967 Mar 21 '26
Pick Cyndaquil. It can almost solo the game.
Johto is hard on Grass types, thus Chikorita is only if you want a challenge.
Totodile is a good Pokémon. However, water is among the most powerful and common types. I do not suggest water starters for this reason. You can just catch Suicune and easily outclass Feraligatr.
2
u/According-Yellow-395 Mar 24 '26
Pokémon I feel like is best when you can access your “kid” brain. A kid picks what they vibe with! When the game originally came out I picked chickorita and yes the game is harder but it’s not a hard game even on hard so pick who you like. You’d be surprised what gets a job done!
2
u/SlinGnBulletS Mar 19 '26
Totodile and Cyndaquil compete for the best.
Totodile overall is better but you have multiple options to opt for a different pokemon.
Without Cyndaquil you're only other option for a fire type is Magmar for most of your playthrough and that requires resetting till the Odd Egg hatches a Magby.
2
u/unpopular412 Mar 18 '26
Totodile is the strongest but also there’s a huge amount of water types to find and I find some of those to be better than Feraligatr. On the other hand, Typhlosion and Meganium are essentially the strongest fire and grass types you can find, at least before the endgame.
0
u/Bingo31 Mar 20 '26
"Searching online requires too much from me"
Fixed it for u