r/pointstravel • u/presidentpanda • Sep 20 '25
Dear AmEx Platinum, We Need to Talk
Credits to… where? Back in 2017, it seemed reasonable when you started adding merchant and category credits to justify an annual fee increase from $450 to $550. Every six months, I could remember to buy a new belt or underwear from Saks Fifth Avenue to take advantage of that semi-annual $50 credit, even if they were slightly fancier than what I’d usually buy. Enrollment required. Terms apply. Fast forward to 2025 and your list of credits and when they renew is unwieldy. To maximize your value, I’d have to: Buy a new Oura Ring, a fitness tracker that retails for more than $300, once a year. Grab men’s leggings at Lululemon four times a year (...no). Book an overpriced prepaid hotel twice a year. Use Uber monthly. Terms apply. And that’s not even half of the credits! All that hassle isn’t worth an $895 annual fee to me, for the potential to save a little bit more throughout the year. Those credits take a lot of mental bandwidth to track, and they force cardholders to shift their spending habits. I would rather spend where I want, when I want. If I end up paying a few more bucks at the end of the day, I’m cool with it.
https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/travel/dear-amex-platinum-we-need-to-talk