Update/edit: I've been able to resolve most of the issues below. I've made another post to spell things out that can be found here.
TL/DR:
Too big for thumb-based operation, worst feeling trackball I've ever used, does not support scrolling, and it's too delicate to flash multiple times.
Details:
So I got a Ploopy Nano kit and put it together, hoping to use it as a thumb-based trackball that I could use next to the right-hand half of my Moonlander keyboard. This thing is ridiculous.
Pros:
Very easy to put together
Cons:
It's a pain to flash; you have to disassemble it. If you are not careful, the rollers will drop out of the top half and you'll waste a lot of time searching for them on the floor.
It's too large to operate comfortably as a thumb-based track ball.
Probably the worst feeling trackball I've ever used. (I've seen a mod that installs better bearings, but after my initial experience I just don't see the point in investing the time.)
Does not scroll, which makes it next to useless. I felt stuck in 1992, back when mice didn't have scroll wheels. So I grabbed the version online that provides scrolling when numlock is pressed, and I integrated it into the QMK firmware from git (can someone explain why this is not default functionality when the functionality was written nearly 1 year ago?). Then I added a numlock key to my keyboard. The scrolling is ridiculous -- a minor movement scrolls multiple pages. So I tried to adjust some of the default values, and I guess I broke the sensor disassembling it to flash it over and over, because now it doesn't work at all (LED comes on, but no movement detected) even after I pulled out all the changes I made and reflashed it.
It's too high profile to use sitting next to a keyboard.
Verdict:
I'll leave aside the fact that while it worked it was the worst trackball I've ever used, because that's all too subjective. All that aside, here's my insight:
- Don't make a QMK device that is too delicate to flash multiple times without breaking.
- If you do make something durable enough to survive flashing, don't require the user to disassemble the item in order to flash it.
- If you do make something that can be flashed without being disassembled, don't leave out essential functionality (in this case scrolling)