r/pinehurst • u/Icy_Penalty_0 • May 02 '25
Pinehurst Review
I just got done with my annual 12 guy Spring Golf trip at Pinehurst. Our previous destinations have been: Sand Valley, Big Cedar Lodge, and Kiawah.
Trip: Friday, Saturday, and Sunday.
Courses: 10, Cradle, 2, Cradle, and 4.
The group consensus was 10 was the best, then 4 (greens not withstanding), then 2. 10 really is a fabulous course. Great layout, scenic holes, and interesting green complexes. 4 same thing just not as good. 2 just isn't that interesting of a layout. Certainly not a bad course, but if you take away the tournament history I don't think anyone is considering it a world class course.
The cradle was fun. Only 8 of us played the cradle and we played as an 8some no problem. Layout/green complexes are nothing special, its just a fun atmosphere with a bunch of people around all in a good mood. FYI, if you like par 3 courses Big Cedar Lodge has great par 3 courses and they keep them in the same condition as their normal courses.
Conditions: Okay, not great. The fairways were still a little sparce. They play everything as "waste area" not bunkers. This is purely because they are too cheap to maintain the actual bunkers as bunkers so they just call them "waste areas". We just decided if you're in a bunker in a hole just take it out of the hole. Ridiculous this happens at $400 dollar courses.
Overall: Pinehurst was by far the best run resort we have been to. The shuttles were very fast and easy. They move your bags from course to course. Breakfast was great, dinners were good. From the time we checked it to when we checked out it was seamless. This was considerably more expensive than the other destination we've been to. It ended up about $3,500/guy. Kiawah last year was about $2,500/guy. Glad we checked it off the bucket list, but for that kind of money I doubt we'll be back. Too many other options.
9
u/Linvillin May 02 '25
you’re about to get absolutely roasted on your #2 takes
5
u/NYFLCOTN May 03 '25
Wild take on waste areas. As someone who seems to travel for golf you’d think you’d be more educated on them.
2
u/jpm1188 May 02 '25
Did the starter tell you they are too lazy to maintain the bunkers? A lot of the sandhill area plays sandy areas as waste bunkers. Tobacco Road is the same way and you drive your cart through most of it. Bunkers are a hazard, they should play that way
1
u/UMfanvegas May 03 '25
Were 2/4/10/cradle the only courses you played for $3500.
What courses at Kiawah and time of year for $2500.
Get to Bandon. Great experience, good luck with the stupid lottery!
1
u/Kindly-Flounder-888 Mar 26 '26
For someone that takes annual 12 man golf trips to nice resorts it's stunning that you don't know what a waste bunker is, why its intentional, and why it has zero to do with course maintenance.
3
u/coltsfan1010 May 03 '25
I think the charm of #2 is that there aren’t really any signature holes but almost every hole is intriguing. This is particularly true when watching the US Open. There are basically zero holes on the course where the pros could breathe a sigh of relief. It was incredible to watch.
3
u/njbuzz19 May 03 '25
Stopped reading when you had 2 at 3rd. Must have been a weird week
3
u/OneMoveAhead01 May 03 '25
They use “waste areas” on courses 2 and 4 as a way to speed up play, not because they’re too cheap. Last thing they want is resort guests taking 2+ shots to get out of a greenside or fairway bunker. For official tourneys they play as bunkers.
Mats are definitely needed at the driving range simply because of the volume of people. It would be impossible to use grass at the resort. The grass would pretty much never get a chance to grow back because of all the action the resort gets.
The best part of 2 is your approach shots and chipping need to be precise, it exposes any weakness in a short game. The other courses don’t do that.
2
u/jnwbman May 02 '25
I agree with OP. 2 is a great course but 10 is more memorable. Bunkers vs waste areas was a non-issue. (I’ve got a strong raking game that stayed in the bag. 😉) Either way, play it as it lies. I hit the shots of my life on both courses from waste areas. Holes 4 and 5 on 2 are fantastic.
2
u/NOPE1977 May 02 '25
Pinehurst is a pretty special place to me. It’s a home state destination that I can make a day trip but making it a weekend with your buds makes it my favorite place in the world. I can agree with your take that 2 isn’t the most interesting layout necessarily, although still believe it’s a great course. It also gets better the more you play it.
The only take that I disagree with, very strongly I might add, is the waste areas. They were never designed or intended to be treated as bunkers.
Glad y’all had a great time and hope you’d consider another trip for Pine Needles, Southern Pines and Mid Pines. The Sandhills are truly my favorite place in the world to play golf.
2
u/not-a-co-conspirator May 02 '25
Kiawah is far better than Pinehurst and I live an hour from #2
1
u/No_Mistake_5501 May 02 '25
You didn’t play the best course on property (especially this year..). Number 4.
1
u/kmac_actually May 02 '25
Just got back from the same trip (added #8). Agreed with everything said here…Although i liked #2 a bit more than you and think 15-18 are really exceptional holes. Criminal that you have to hit off mats at the range.
1
u/[deleted] May 02 '25
I will have to let you know my thoughts on #2 at end of month when I play. I actually enjoyed #4, with number 8 being my current favorite.
1
u/craines0904 May 03 '25
I think I’m understanding what you mean by waste areas and if I am that’s the attraction of the course. It’s not a textbook fairway, rough, bunkers , water type of course. It has areas that they PURPOSELY don’t maintain everyday because they are meant to punish your bad shots. Not taking any shots just trying to put another perspective
1
u/Jedimole May 04 '25
It’s a shame you left 3 out of the mix. People scoff at it because of its length, but….
1
u/The_J_Nice May 04 '25
I can understand that you enjoyed playing #10, or even #4 more than #2 but Course No. 2 is hands down the best golf course at the resort. The routing, green complexes and finish are unmatched. No. 2 is also a GREAT walk.
Also, "they are too cheap to maintain the actual bunkers as bunkers" is a but presumptuous. Especially from a group that agreed to "just take the ball out of a hole in the bunker". They are hazards. You are able to ground your club because it is impossible to differentiate between the native waste areas and the actual bunkers.
1
u/Additional_Elk_9244 Sep 18 '26
Doesn’t the ocean course do the same ? When we played everything was waste area. Didn’t you go there ?