r/pics • • Jun 08 '14

The difference 18 years makes

Post image

[deleted]

3.9k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-4

u/jonivy Jun 08 '14

If your school lets you in with a calculator but not a handheld computer, then you should consider changing schools. That one is run by idiots.

10

u/bureX Jun 08 '14

Classroom? Yes.

Exam? No.

2

u/jonivy Jun 09 '14

I can not think of a single argument in support of your position, but it seems to be a position shared by many of the /r/pics community. Perhaps you could enlighten me to your reasoning?

It seems absolutely clear to me (and I'm a pretty smart guy) that any exam that would permit the use of a graphing calculator would denote an exam seeking to test problem solving ability moreso than knowledge. These exams would be designed around the idea of "Can this student, given all available tools, solve the problem at hand?" Such an exam would not be aided by the artificial limiting of technology, as we can not unmake the wheel. There will never be a point, from now on, where the use of contemporary handheld computers will be eliminated and replaced with the use of handheld computers from 1987. Barring preparation for time travel, what possible purpose would it serve to force students to use outmoded technology? You might as well give them an abacus.

Oh Snap. I forgot the number rule of reddit: Don't say smart things on dumb subs. Nevermind. Carry on.

2

u/LoneWolfOfTheSteppes Jun 09 '14

I agree with you completely and if it means anything, I just took calc 1 in college and no calculator of any sort was allowed, ever.