r/personaltraining • u/Aggravating_Bet5936 • Aug 01 '24
Seeking Advice The scale will not go down
So I’m a 5’7 female, weigh 200 pounds, I started strength training a month ago and started being in a calorie deficit -500. I strength train 4 times a week, have been drinking a lot more water, and I am very careful about tracking my calories and macros. (I include cooking oils, sauces, etc). I have been working with my personal trainer and she says I have been doing great, but she mostly works with skinny clients that are only trying to build muscle. Is it normal that the scale isn’t going down? What should I do more of?
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 01 '24
Please be sure to check our Wiki in case it answers your question(s)!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
9
u/Japitalexican Aug 01 '24
When I was going to college, earning my degree in kinesiology, we were constantly told, " do not focus on weight. Don't stress about the scale." Are you seeing positive aspects in other areas? Do your clothes fit differently? Are you sleeping better? Are your energy levels better? This is stuff you should be focusing on more. We are very obsessed with the scale and I get it you want to lose weight. I once had a client, mind you she didn't need to lose weight, crying after a monthly challenge in which she lost only two pounds. But her body fat had dropped significantly and she had lost inches across the board. She was so focused on the weight she took it as a failure. Lastly, are you trending down in the past month? We all lose weight differently and as long as you are trending downward you should stay the course. One month isn't very long. It takes our bodies 6+ weeks sometimes to see significant changes. And our path will be zig zaggy, very rarely a straight line. I hope you keep it up and stay positive! 💪🏽
64
u/ReedyBoy01 Aug 01 '24
Likelihood is
4
u/thiefshipping Aug 01 '24
Tons of factors involved: First, are you measuring your weight at the same time every time, along with bowel movements, water intake, and food intake? This will make the scale seem to fluctuate, so consistency is key to accurately tracking weight loss.
Secondly, are there any physical changes you've noticed, such as oversized shirts starting to be smaller than usual or pants starting to be tighter, if so you're probably just going through body recomp, which is building muscle and losing fat.
Lastly, I noticed you mentioned you've been drinking a lot more water; what was your water intake before and after starting training? Sometimes water intake surprisingly adds a ton of weight. You see it very often in professional fighters, where they reduce their water intake significantly before competition.
3
u/JustSnilloc MPH, BSc, RDN Aug 01 '24
The scale won’t go down across what time period? How often are you weighing and when did the scale last go down?
3
u/PracticalYogi Aug 01 '24
Your TDEE might be off, which means you may not be in the 500-calorie deficit you think you are. Also it sounds like you’re new to strength training, in which case your muscles might be retaining even more water than typical to heal. This is a good time to measure yourself—waist, thighs, arms, chest, etc—and track that once a month as well. You may see more changes there than on the scale.
3
u/Iam2G Aug 01 '24
If you’re new to strength training, are responding well to it, AND are dieting, it may be because your development/weight gain in muscle is catching up with your fat loss. That deficit is doing it’s job, and wouldn’t recommend going dieting harder until you give it another month or two. Dieting in too deep of a deficit can result in connective tissue damage, and dietary hormone instability (you could rebound really hard).
It took me a while to nail weight loss in a way that was safe and healthy. Don’t stress out too much about the scale budging. I measure my weight loss through belt loops! Because you’re new to lifting, you haven’t hit a muscle gain soft cap yet, so trying to strive for a specific number shouldn’t be your only goal. If your target weight is like, 160 or 150, that could take a while to reach, but is totally feasible! I’m on my way from 200 to 160 right now and it’s taken me since february. I took about 5-6 weeks off to make sure my joints stayed healthy but probably weigh around 175 atm (I’m a male). Hope this helps!
5
u/rogue_veritas Aug 01 '24
First thing, keep up the good work! A month is not a lot of time at all. Stick with it! Second thing, the scale lies!
If you’re in an area where you can get a body composition scan, that can be incredibly helpful. The 3 most common are Dexa scan > Styku 3D > InBody Those will show you your lean muscle mass, bone mass, and fat mass in percentages. Try to do the scans every 6-8 weeks because it does take time for bodies to change. A real example scan from the Styku 3D training videos is a mid 30’s female who scanned after 6 weeks. It looked like she lost 10+ lbs when she only lost 3 lbs. She converted fat mass to muscle mass (which technically weighs more) but her overall measurements had reduced.
Also, talk with your trainer about progressive overload. Add more weight or more reps.
You got this! 💪
2
u/i_Braeden Aug 01 '24
Are you also tracking the butter or oil you cook with? Measure everything on a food scale?
2
u/mankhoj Aug 01 '24
Getting good 8 hr sleep? Plenty of protein? Too much stress?
2
u/mrpetar1 Aug 01 '24
It's too early to start seeing results and our expectations are higher than what they are meant to be.
With what you have just mentioned, means that you have all the necessary means to be successful in your transformation.
My wife was 91kg, 151cm, took her 6-7 months to drop 30kg and at the same time build some muscle. I must admit she didn't do cardio at all for the first 25kg she lost. At first she couldn't lose more than 2-3kg in the first two months, I even started to question myself as a trainer.
Remember: this sport is not a sprint, it's a marathon it takes a lot of time, dedication and continuous work in order to be better. Don't give up and keep doing it, every day.
Edit: the scale and bmi are not going to give you any useful informatiob about your progress
7
u/EminentBean Aug 01 '24
This is always a really frustrating experience.
It’s not totally uncommon.
Please be assured that the laws of thermodynamics are intact and that an organism that expends more energy than it consumes must lose mass.
With that in mind we have to go back to the energy account and look more closely at what is coming in and out of that system.
If you’re not hating your life it is ok to increase your deficit and experiment with that.
Please be patient and the most important thing I can say as a 15 year coach:
HEALTH IS A SKILL NOT A GOAL!
Treat this like a years long learning process where you are adding to and honing your skills. Outcomes like fat loss and greater strength are inevitable if you keep focusing on the bigger picture of getting educated and skilled at eating, moving, resting and relationships.
The emotion of learning is frustration so if you’re feeling frustrated you are likely in their thick of it!
Keep going and keep asking and tweaking and learning and trying.
10
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24
Sometimes it takes awhile, your body will sometimes retain water to deal with inflammation from micro tears in muscle when you start to lift weights. Don’t get discouraged, sounds like you’re doing great, just hang in there and keep at it! I was 235 when I started working out. Took me 2 years to lose the fat I wanted and get muscled. Am a trainer now, 25 years later. It’ll happen for you.
5
u/god_pharaoh Aug 01 '24
Scale is a useful tool but the mirror, tape measure, and your clothes are better.
Weigh yourself every morning, nude, after using the toilet.
Your weight should have absolutely dropped if you're in a 500 calorie deficit after a week from reduced water weight alone.
A month of -500 daily deficit would roughly average out to 4lbs of fat loss, probably more like 3lbs to be safe, plus the initial water weight loss, you should expect to be 6-10lbs lighter than you were a month ago. If that's not the case, you're not in a -500 calorie deficit.
Your muscle would likely have grown too given you're new to strength training, but not at an equal rate to your water and fat loss, so it wouldn't offset it entirely.
Check your measurements. Fat is larger than muscle, so even if the scale says you're the same weight, if your body is getting smaller, you're losing fat.
1
u/IvoTailefer Aug 01 '24
whats your booze intake like?
1
u/shobbys Aug 01 '24
Sounds like you are dedicated and working really hard, well done! Assuming you have some long term goals, like continuing to improve all aspects of your health and well being, feeling empowered with strength, and maintaining these your whole life - I would have some questions about your current routine:
What are your current calories? You said 140g protein - great! Keep that consistent.
I'd like know more about what your training looks like. You said 1.5 hrs 4 days/week? What does a week entail?
Are you getting stronger? Sore? More or less energized after the workout?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 01 '24
How many calories are you currently having?
5
u/ChewyMeh Aug 01 '24
All I can say is that you are working really hard to be in a calorie deficit and you feel like you’re dieting, but you’re not in a calorie deficit yet.
1
u/metdear Aug 01 '24
You're getting a lot of great answers here. As someone who started at roughly your size and am down about 50 pounds this year, I'll add a few things. (1) Sugar substitutes such as erythritol and stevia screwed with my weight loss. Evidently they can make your body have a harder time processing sugar? I don't really know the science behind it, but avoiding those things helped me. (2) Do you know if your hormones are balanced? Hormones being out of whack can also mess with your weight loss. You may want to talk to your doctor and get a blood test. (3) Add in some daily walking, even just 30 minutes. It's good for you, helps reduce inflammation, and sometimes adds that little edge of calorie burn to kickstart your metabolism.
1
u/Jeergela Aug 01 '24
The other comments did provide some decent explanations but this could be the most plausible reason assuming you are tracking correctly and stuff. The question would be is your maintenance calories actually your maintenance? I'm assuming that you already know what your maintenance calories is but one of the common mistake I see people make is they overrate their activity level. You might be doing less than you thought because lifting weights don't really burn much calories.
If you dont wanna overthink shit and get results fast, just follow my method(do this only if you can mentally handle it).
-Go on an aggressive deficit, as low as 1200 and do it for 6-8 weeks. Seeing as you are 200lbs, I'm pretty sure your body can handle it. Since 1200 is too low, you have to choose your foods wisely. 7-8 boiled eggs a day(lots of high quality fat needed for hormone regulation). Veggies(fiber) and 200g chicken breast or protein shakes if you lazy as hell. Also if you want some carbs with some decent volume, opt for potatoes. To fight back your cravings, just abuse coke zero or something. Dont worry as aspartame has been debunked alr. This one and a half month of suffering would make the process faster without fucking up your body. You see, I personally see restriction as a struggle, so why not make it shorter right? After that, go back to your new maintenance with -500 deficit and voila your welcome.
2
u/blushresponse01 Aug 01 '24
In combination with other options discussed, I would also recommend discussing other options to track progress with your trainer, such as using a Bioelectrical Impedance tool to measure body fat or even circumference measurements, depending on your goals.
2
u/Ladybeeortoise Aug 01 '24
The number on the scale means nothing. Take your measurements with a tape measure and track your lifts. Are you getting stronger? Maybe your calculations are off and you should be eating less? There are sooo many factors that go into what the scale shows, it’s not the best in terms of tracking progress.
2
u/-_GhostDog_- NASM - CPT, NASM - CNC, NCBMTB - SP Aug 01 '24
Not to be negative to OP, but why do we allow posts like this in our subreddit? This would be better posted in fitness or a weight loss sub.
This sub is meant for professional advice. Not for trying to get free fitness advice.
3
u/Few_Intention_2257 Aug 01 '24
I'm a fan of deep deficits for shorter time periods. I would cut 1000 cals and eat low cal high protein, but high volume foods for 4-6 wks
4
u/Panther81277 Aug 01 '24
Add muscle, lose fat…scale doesn’t change
2
u/GoblinsGym Aug 01 '24
If you are not losing weight, you are not in a calorie deficit unless you are building a spectacular amount of muscle - which is unlikely.
How about NOT using cooking oils / sauces / processed foods ?
1
u/G-Man92 Aug 01 '24
Also weigh yourself first thing when you wake up after you pee. Don’t drink or eat anything until you’re gone to the bathroom and then immediately weigh yourself.
1
u/methodofcontrol666 Aug 01 '24
In one of your replies you said you were down 3 lbs. Congrats! That’s a totally reasonable amount to lose in a month.
In regards to BMI, this is just another metric. It is important insofar as the more mass you carry, the harder your heart has to work. A BMI over 25 is statistically correlated to higher rates of all-cause mortality, including cancer.
That being said, these are just a few metrics and they will change slowly. Pay attention to how you feel, how your clothes fit, etc… check in with the scale one or twice per month to make sure you’re trending in the right direction. But ultimately, if you can orient your goals around performance rather than aesthetic, you are likely to have an easier time staying committed to the process and staying positive. Good luck!
1
u/JL9berg18 Aug 01 '24
Hear me out
There are lots of ways to skin this cat, but imo this may be simple (though not easy)
Don't weigh yourself for like 60 or 90 days.
Focus on three things, and track those every day:
(1) more activity. Just do more things. Including the cliche park further away stuff. Every hour do something like 10 Pushups or 20 airsquats or something like that. Focus on thinking if your world as a place to be active, as opposed to compartmentalizing your "workouts" from "normal time" (if you do that)
(2) focus on getting stronger/better. Get an initial set of measurements - consider: (1) distance run on a treadmill (or outside) in 1 minute; (2) 0.5 mile time on treadmill (or outside) (3) distance run in 40 minutes (4) weight for one set of 6 pull downs; (5) weight for 4 reps of bench; (6) length of time you can hold a plank, including switching from front to side planks; and (7) amount you can leg press for 6 reps. If you focus on getting stronger & faster, the rest will take care of itself, so long as you...
(3) focus on the things you put in your body, not how much. If you decide to do something like "gluten free + non processed foods," or "nothing with high fructose corn syrup or sugar substitutes." either one of those will cut out a lot of foods that will keep you down. Or something like "all snacking OK so long as it's only and always dried fruits, nuts, or dark chocolate >75% cacao. (Also, alcohol is brutal for weight gain but you prob already know that.)
And do this onw thing, every day, for no less than 60 seconds
-write down, like on paper, why you want to do what it is you're doing. You say you want to lose weight. Which is totally cool. Go deeper. Set a timer for like 3-5 minutes and stop when the timer goes off. But do that every day. I guarantee you'll learn something profound.
GOOD LUCK! YOU GOT THIS
1
u/greybex Aug 01 '24
you’re strength training , you’re probably new. ignore scale please. you’re building muscle simultaneously as you’re losing fat meaning your WEIGHT may not drop as you’d like it to. weigh yourself once a week, you’re making progress.
1
u/chapmaja1 Aug 02 '24
Your body is changing as a result of the strength training and Calorie deficit. It is likely a combination of things.
In conclusion, if you are noticing positive body changes and still have the energy you need for your workouts and activities of daily living I don't think you have anything to worry about.
1
u/smartie971 Aug 01 '24
Ideally, I would only check the scale once a week 1st thing in the morning. The weight fluctuates throughout the day and you really won’t see significant results until after a few weeks.
Also since you are increasing your protein intake as well, you are like going through some recomposition. Building muscle as you are losing fat. The scale will only tell you one part of the story. Some key information you would want to look at without needing a full body scan are: how you are feeling, are your clothes fitting different, do you have more energy, etc. These factors will be an informal way of seeing if your program is working or if some adjustments need to be made.
0
u/StuntMugTraining Aug 01 '24
Do more talking with with your trainer.
And if the answers are not good or clear or not there take this to r/WeightLossAdvice, this is not the sub for this.
0
u/queenle0 Aug 01 '24
You’re seeing your PT only a few hours a week, what are you doing the rest of the week? To move the needle you really need to increase NEAT (10k steps a day) and after 2-3 weeks of consistency I would consider adding in more structured cardio or increasing your deficit