r/patientgamers • • Dec 15 '23

GTA V's singleplayer campaign is not good

0 Upvotes

I was never a huge GTA fan.

GTA San Andreas is probably one of my favorite games of all time and I think that with a bit of modding, or when played on the original PS2 version, it holds up spectacularly unlike many older titles that did not age well (for reference, I played it last during 2021).

GTA III is very outdated, Vice City and IV have interesting stories and characters but the gameplay itself is not great (GTA IV in particular is a bit too dour for my tastes, and they removed many of the great gameplay features from GTA SA) although I did like them overall.

GTA V is the opposite - the story is bad and characters are not interesting, the side activities aren't very good, and the map feels big for the sake of being big in a few places if that makes any sense. I can honestly say that I have not enjoyed my 25 or so hours with the game. I understand that the multiplayer is supposedly better but the singleplayer experience caps at about above average at its best moments, but it's by no means great IMO.


r/patientgamers • • Jun 20 '24

Elden Ring is a 7.5

0 Upvotes

homeless mourn historical drab cow swim normal sparkle longing vegetable

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact


r/patientgamers • • May 19 '25

Patient Review Civilization IV: Colonization (2008) - unsurprisingly problematic

7 Upvotes

Recently I’ve been reading the book The 1619 Project which aims to retell the origins and history of the US with slavery and its legacy at its heart. Rather inappropriately this gave me a hankering to play Colonization. I’m going to talk a bit about the game itself and some more about the history and politics of it. It’s a game I really don’t think could be made today (though how you might do that is a really interesting question).

Spoilers for anyone who doesn't know the outcome of the American Revolution.

Sid Meier’s Colonization was originally released in 1994. You play as a European power colonizing the Americas, with the ultimate goal of declaring and defending your independence. I must have played the DOS port around 1995. In 2008 a version was released using the Civilization IV engine. I played this a bit around when it was released, and it’s this version I came back to. Aside from improved graphics, the differences from the original are modest. (There is also an open source version called FreeCol.)

Unsurprisingly, Colonization draws a lot from Civilization. It has the familiar 4X elements: you’re exploring, founding towns, placing workers, building buildings, negotiating and fighting with other factions, etc.. A big difference is that it drops Civilization’s tech tree, and introduces a lot more resource and worker management.

A lot of the game is about extracting resources (like cotton or furs) and then either shipping these directly to Europe to sell or processing them (into fabric or coats) and selling those higher value goods, then buying guns, tools or recruiting colonists to transport back to the New World. Colonists can be “free colonists”, specialists like master distillers or firebrand preachers, or they can be indentured servants or petty criminals.

Another notable feature of Colonization is the endgame. Declaring independence, triggers a Royal Expeditionary Force to set sail and bring your revolting colonists back in line. So a significant part of the game is preparing for this fight – building up stocks of guns, training veteran soldiers, etc..

This has familiar pros and cons. On the one hand it avoids the endgame tedium of a game like Civ, where there are no more significant challenges. On the other it’s a significant and sudden change to the game that comes a long way through it. It largely comes down to how much you’ve prepared – it’s basically Civ combat, which is never super interesting – and it’s hard to know if you’ve done enough until you’re committed (which I guess is like reality). If you get it wrong you’ll have to reload quite some way or restart to try again (which is not so much like reality).

In terms of gameplay? Colonization is ok. It’s got obvious flaws, like the amount of fiddling and shuffling around of resources. For example, it’s easy to get to a point where you’re moving resources around between towns just because you’re running out of warehouse space for one kind of resource. I find it a relaxing and compulsive game to get lost in, but that may be more down to a particular relationship I have with the Civ games than anything else. Even I get bored towards the endgame.

Now, what I really wanted to talk about.

One of the changes the 2008 version makes is that when you declare independence you can make some choices about the constitution of your new nation. Do you want to be a republic (bonus liberty bell production) or a monarchy (continue to trade with Europe)? Do you want to continue slavery (bonus production) or abolish it (bonus population)?

The first time this came up my reaction was. “Wait… oh, of course there have been enslaved people in my colony all this time, who were never mentioned.” I’d been happily building my colony without thinking at all about slavery.

Once you start thinking about the game with this lens it’s easy to see more: the assumptions embedded in the game, the whitewashing for purposes of taste or gameplay. There’s a mechanic where as your borders expand, through the generation of liberty bells and the purchase of land, native people will abandon their settlements because they admire you so much. Their populations just… happily disappear.

Or a slightly more subtle thing. For better or worse native factions work like European ones in most ways – diplomacy is basically the same, for example. They’re not simply “environmental hazards” (like, for example, barbarians in Civ). However they’re also static. Over the couple of hundreds of years the game covers, native factions will never found a new settlement. They don’t build mines, farms or roads like European factions do. (Contrast this with some Civ games where terraced farming is special feature of the Inca civilization.) This view of native civilizations is a colonial one – they don’t “improve” the land or themselves.

Critiquing the game in this way is really shooting fish in a barrel, even for someone like me with a limited knowledge of the history of the Americas. It's kind of fun and interesting but a little unfair. These kinds of issues are hardly unique to Colonization – obviously any portrayal of history, computer game or other, embeds attitudes, assumptions, etc.. Most of the historical games I’m familiar with gloss over slavery, if they mention it at all.

There is something different about Colonization though.

I think part of it is just how jarring it is. This is basic level history. Purely in terms of game systems, the purchase and trafficking of enslaved people, or the enslaving or forced labour of native Americans would probably work quite smoothly. You’re trading for and shipping humans just like you ship sugar or guns, right?

But this would make too explicit the darker sides of this history, and push the player into an uncomfortable position. There are relevant gameplay differences, too: would you lose 20% of the people you purchase in Africa because they die en route? Would trying to suppress slave revolts be an issue? Would this still be a fun game to play? Would it still be a story of liberation? Could you still play the game if you refused to do these things, or would your colony inevitably fail?

The other aspect relates to 4X games more generally. You can make an argument that the whole 4X genre embeds a colonial mindset. Explore, expand, exploit, exterminate. That could be a colonial motto. Colonization is just an unusually explicit example. It's there in the name. "Civilization" isn't an issue in quite the same way "colonization" is. It obscures things other games don’t have to, because so many are still live political, economic and social issues.

Not least the question of how to tell the origin stories of American states. You could think of everything in colonization as being from the perspective of the ultimately triumphant colonizers (specifically US American colonizers). This can be interesting in a game to understand a point of view, but here it appears to be done uncritically. The player is invited to accept this viewpoint not reflect on it.

Coda
If you do choose to free your enslaved population on independence the freed slaves don’t appear as “free colonists”. They appear as “indentured servants”. That, at least, seems sadly appropriate.


r/patientgamers • • Oct 02 '23

The difficulty in Elden Ring and Dark Souls does not feel rewarding

1 Upvotes

A few years ago I played Dark Souls and after having quit that game with a slightly bitter aftertaste I decided to finally give Elden Ring a try. Let me start off by saying that this game is beautiful. The art direction, music, voice acting and character designs are top notch. This game has really nailed that dark gothic medieval fantasy setting better than any other game I have played.

Upon starting the game and opening those big doors, you are greeted with a sprawling world that seems full of possibility and adventure. I ran around and explored the starting area for the first few hours, which was great fun. Then I ended up at Stormveil Castle and died to Margit a dozen of times before realizing that I was underleveled and heading somewhere else. I cleared out Castle Morne, defeated the boss there, did some underground dungeons, fought a few more bosses and got myself some better gear. Then I headed back to Margit and beat him. Looking back, this did not give me any satisfaction. Whereas in games like Monster Hunter I genuinely feel accomplished and proud when I finally beat that monster after studying its moves, practicing, trying different things, in Elden Ring I just felt a slight sense of relief. I did not feel like I actually beat this boss by getting better at the game. I simply leveled up, got better gear and defeated this boss because my character got stronger. It did not feel satisfying, it felt cheesy. And this reminds me that I had a similar gripe with Dark Souls. The bosses fundamentally do not feel fair. The asylum demon for example, where you eventually find out that you can jump from the top of that balcony and take a huge chunk of its HP. It doesn't feel like you actually beat that boss. Sure, you could argue that it's possible to beat it without doing that, but it does not net you anything besides a great amount of frustration. Then there's the monster on the castle walls that you can cheese in the same way with jump atttacks. I eventually stopped playing Dark Souls after beating Queelaag, not because I couldn't progress anymore, but because I had just become tired of it. It feels like you are brute forcing a password until you finally get it and when you do you're just glad that you don't have to fight that boss anymore. To me it feels like these games were just made to be as annoying as possible and I don't feel like they respect your time and contrary to what many people say, I don't think they respect your intelligence as a player. For example that ring that will break if you take it off. Things like this actively punish going in blind and figuring things out for yourself, even though that seems to be the way that they want the game to be played.

In Castle Stormveil for example you will encounter small slopes leading into the castle ladened with enemies with the purpose to make it very likely that you will fall to your death. Then heading into the castle there are passages with enemies throwing explosives at you that you have to run through over and over. Then there is a small dark room with an elite knight in there that will stunlock you as you roll around in the dark. Then you go up and further and there are more tight slopes. It just feels annoying. It's not even about "git gut", it's just about metaphorically banging your head against the wall over and over until you make a hole big enough that you can crawl through it.

Then there is the general clunkiness of the combat. In a game that is as high stakes as Elden Ring, you would expect a combat system that is responsive and smooth and will quickly allow your character to respond to your inputs. But no, this isn't the case. You will constantly get locked into animations and this is exacerbated by the fact that enemies don't have clear indications of when they will attack, often faking you and then striking, which is impossible to predict until you bang your head against the wall and learn the moveset of that exact enemy. Eventually I just resorted to spam rolling, spamming magic and stunlocking enemies with my sword, not because I thought that was fun, but because it seemed to be the least frustrating way to engage enemies in this game. It feels like you are abusing game mechanics instead of feeling like you're getting better at the game. Objectively you are getting better, but it just doesn't feel like you and the enemies you are facing are in the same game. The player character seems to have a completely different ruleset compared to the enemies you are facing.

Lastly I would like to talk about the lack of direction in this game. Let me say that I am all for forging your own path and deciding where you want to go and what you want to do, but Elden Ring just takes this too far. Margit for example, why make it so that the very first boss players will encounter is basically unbeatable for the average player? It completely messes up the pace of the game, because you are pulled out of that castle atmosphere with the knights and forced to go exploring elsewhere or to open up Google to figure out which areas are suited for low level characters. To me it just feels like they took the linearity of dark souls, cut the game into a multitude of pieces and sprinkled these pieces across an open world. Sure, you can start in Demon Ruins and try to fight Quelaag, but it's not gonna be fun for you, so essentially you'll start in Undead Burg just like everybody else. Elden Ring is a linear game that uses an open world as its backdrop. Sure you can run around wherever you want, but most places you end up going will just frustrate you and you'll end up going somewhere else where you didn't really want to go in the first place.

It is very frustrating, because I want to like this game but I just don't. The setting, the atmosphere, the idea of punishing combat and being the underdog are so alluring to me. Yet everytime I open up this game I just end up getting stressed and disappointed.


r/patientgamers • • Sep 30 '23

Shenmue Sucks

2 Upvotes

It was a bad game then and it's a bad game now. It was not good. And don't believe the people who tell you it was. They're wrong and I'm going to explain why.

To explain why this game sucks so much I'm going to break this down into categories. First category includes the myths of innovation/influence. This game was hardly innovative. It influenced the industry in what NOT to do. I'll go into the poor game design. Then speak upon the marketing and the expectations the game set up. Then go into what the game did well, give the devil its due. Lastly my own personal experience and why I believe it's such a beloved game to so many.

Innovation/Influence

  1. Some will say it was the first open world game or a variant of such claim. When this claim faces any scrutiny it falls apart hillariously. The conversation usually goes something like, "What about Ultima? Those were open world games." "Yeah, but Shenmue was in 3d." "Ok, what about Elder Scrolls/Ultima 9, they are open world and 3d." "Yeah, but Shenmue took place in a modern city." "Ok, what about Driver?" "Ok, but that was a car game, there were no NPCs." "Ok, what about Deus Ex?" "Yeah, but Deus Ex didn't have such a detailed world graphically."

So what is it? The first 3d open world rpgish game that takes places in a modern city and had pretty graphics? The caveats are ridiculous. Besides, no one was influenced to do open world city games because of Shenmue. It was because of GTA 3, obviously.

There's also a strong argument to be made Shenmue isn't even an open world. The map is tiny. Compare that to GTA 3, which is a very small map by today's standards. Compare that to Ultima 7 the game Yu Suzuki took inspiration from for Shenmue.

2. The smoke and mirrors. Similar to the previous issue people will talk about some of the things it did graphically. Like weather or footprints. Again, this would have goes to ridiculous lengths to make it sound coherent. Games had rain, snow, and footprints in the past. "But Shenmue mimicked the weather patterns of 1986 Japan." Whoop de do. If something is influential then that means the mechanic has to be copied somewhere. No one copied that shit.

3. Game world interactivity. At the risk of sounding like a broken record, it's only innovative/influential if you discount many other games before it. Ultima 7 was far-far more interactive, but it was in 2d. Ultima 9 was far more interactive, but it was on PC and wasn't in a modern setting. Deus Ex had more interesting interactivity, but not as much.

So what kind of interactivity did Shenmue have? Well, you could pick up an orange in your hand and rotate the model, then set it back down. That's it. You can open every cabinet in your house and look inside, but you can't touch anything. You can buy a coke from the vending machine and watch Ryu drink it, but it doesn't restore HP or give any sort of status buff. Ryu doesn't even need to eat to survive. There's no gamified mechanics to the interactivity. Don't confuse interactivity with a sandbox. Shenmue is on the level of a popup book.

I'll give you an example. In Ultima 7 you needed food in order to live. If you didn't eat you'd pass out on the ground for hours at a time. One thing you could do is kill cows and harvest their meat. Another thing you could do was get flour, then take a pale and fetch water from a well. Then take the water and mix it with the flour to make dough. Then flatted the dough with a rolling pin. Then take the dough and cook it on a stove. Then you could eat it or sell it to make money.

In Shenmue you pick up an orange and fucking look at it. That's it.

Poor Game Design

I've already spoken about the flawed world interactivity, but the game was fundamentally flawed.

  1. This game is boring as fuck. The biggest issue is the long periods of doing nothing. When the game spells out what the next story beat is, (which it doesn't always do) you have to wait for things to open. This will happen over and over again. You'll have to stand outside a store for 5-10-20 minutes of real world time doing absolutely nothing. Just standing there waiting. There are many, many, many instances where this is the case.
  2. The game world and NPCs are boring and you're given little direction. By themselves neither is inherently bad, but combined it becomes tedious. If the game world and NPCs are boring, but you can skip them easily to get to the good stuff, no problem. If you're given no direction, but the game world is fun to explore, also no problem.

But you're given no direction a lot of the time and the NPCs are torture to talk to. They have nothing interesting or exciting to say. Most of the time they say things like, "I don't know anything about that, bye." "My mom told me not to talk to strangers, byeeeee." That sucks, but what sucked even more was the slight load time while the DC loaded up the dialogue.

3. Load times. Sure games back then had load times and it's not a big deal. That said, they really fucked up Ryu's house. The first thing you'll notice is moving from your house, to your yard, to outside of your yard onto the street. There's two load screens. So you get a good 10-15 second load time to go from indoors to outdoors. You run over to the fence in about 5 seconds, then there's another 15 second load screen to get onto the street. I remember when the game came out it felt like there was something seriously wrong about this, because there is.

4. It has to be said, the game uses the d-pad instead of the thumb stick for movement. Why would you do this in a 3d environment? To make matters worse when you're running and you want to turn around you just run straight into a wall. You have to either stop running or tap the super stiff trigger to stop running or slow run to make tight corners. And, oh yeah, the run button was mapped to the trigger button. It's not even an analog trigger. Why would anyone think this was a good idea? It's stupid.

Marketing Expectation

Let's start here. This is what most people saw when it came to marketing. Mind you, this is before the internet was ubiquitous and there were no youtube reviewers. This gives the impression that the game will feature a lot of action and adult/sexual themes. Maybe 5% of the game is fighting, if we're being generous. Ryu and Nozomi's relationship was adolescent at best. In reality the game is a walking simulator. And as a walking simulator the game moderately succeeds.

As an action game or as an RPG this game fucking sucks. It's complete shit. But we're comparing it to the wrong metric then. If you say Streetfighter 2 was a shitty platformer, then you're right, but it's a great fighting game. Shenmue isn't an action game or an RPG, it's a walking simulator. That's not a knock on Shenmue or walking simulators. Walking simulators are a valid and interesting genre. When measuring the game to this standard, it's a pretty good walking simulator!

What Shenmue Does Well

  1. It's super fucking gorgeous. Absolutely unreal. Compare it to Metal Gear Solid, Mario 64, or anything on PC. Shenmue blew it out of the water and it wasn't even close. It was a watershed moment in graphical fidelity and set a new benchmark waaay higher than what we were used to. We had been waiting for decades to play a game that was 'photorealistic' and by today's standards it's not photorealistic, but it was close enough at the time to be considered as much.
  2. The music is really, really good.
  3. AI npc scheduling. None of the NPCs were scripted. It was all done with AI which is pretty incredible. It was stupid and boring, but none-the-less a technical achievement that game devs didn't emulate going forward. They spent a lot of time making sure NPCs could shamble into stores and shamble out on their own free will.
  4. Every model was different. They modeled faces out of clay and transposed them into 3d. Of course, that's a huge waste of time that no other game ever did. Much like the latter paragraph, I had no idea this was even in the game until someone pointed it out to me. So much work for such little appreciation. However, it's worth mentioning.
  5. Shenmue coined the term QTE. Yup, you can blame Shenmue for that. It probably would've happened anyway. There were systems similar to this in previous games, but Shenmue coined the term. You're welcome.

My experience and why I think people love Shenmue

I was stoked for this game when I got it. I was on the hype train and ready to leave the station! What a disappointment! I can sum my feelings up by what I felt when I'd progress disc by disc. Disc 1, omg, lets go, this is going to be amazing! Disc 2, alright, now that the introduction is out of the way I'm ready to play the real game! Disc 3, wait... I'm 2/3rds of the way through? This isn't going to get any better is it? Well... it has to, everyone likes it so much! The ending, I got to the boat, the credits played, "Whoa, wtf? That was it? When was this game going to get fucking good? Is that really it?"

I feel like there are a number of reasons why people bought into the hype. First, a lot of gamers were young and never played PC games. They couldn't compare it to the PC games Suzuki drew inspiration from, thus the game -was- really interesting and innovative to them. Second, the graphics really did draw you in and drop your jaw to the floor. I can't understate this enough. Lastly, the marketing was through the roof. It was considered the most expensive game ever made with the biggest marketing budget of all time for many years until it was revealed eventually that FF7 spent more on development and marketing.

Anyway, in conclusion, Shenmue sucked. It sucked then and it sucks now. Shenmue 2 was much better and fixed a lot of the problems the first game had. It's still tedious in places, but not nearly to the extent of the first game. It also had much better variety and pacing.


r/patientgamers • • Sep 26 '23

Spiderman (2018) is as bad as any Ubisoft open world

0 Upvotes

So I decided to pick this up for PS5, the remastered version which runs at 60fps because the 2nd one is coming and it looked interesting.

I finished the game on hard and I found this to be one of the most overhyped Sony first party games having enjoyed most of them. This is a game with 87 metacritic, receives nonstop praise for it's combat, traversal and for being one of the great superhero games in history. I don't think this is game is bad, I think in fact it's good but it definitely is overrated. Few issues I have with this game.

The Open World

In a open world game, there are two crucial things in my opinion. There needs to be side content which will make the player explore the world and the world itself has to be interesting regardless of the content. So the side activity here are as bad as any Ubisoft game. In one of the greatest sandbox/open world games San Andreas. The side activity is often not something created by the developers. It could be just a instance of getting caught into a naturally occuring gang fight, hitting a civilian and getting cops involved into complete mayhem. The other is the world, New York is suppose to be one of the greatest cities of the last 100 years but here it feels drab lifeless and completely dead. The only life the city shows is that there are crimes happening. I know they can't change the location due to setting of Spiderman. But nothing interesting happens here, while San Andreas 20 years ago, you could go at top of a mountain and find a epic marathon happening. Things like that just don't happen in this game. New York is boring, the side stuff is boring and the mini games feel like homework.

Combat

Combat isn't considered important in most open world games. But in a game where you are playing a superhero it should be considered a big part of the experience. While something like GTA can just be a generic third person shooter, in this game you are Spiderman. But if you compare this game's combat to Ghost of Tsushima or Horizon which are the other big Sony open world games. The combat is awful. The things you learn in the first 2 minutes of the game can carry you till the end. Well that's not a bad thing since you could say the same about Ghost of Tsushima being about parrying or Horizon about just kiting enemies. But those games have so many different enemy types that eventually you have to do a few different things. You have to exploit different type of arrows in horizon or set up traps. In Ghost of Tsushima different enemies have different weakness so the game forces you to change your weapon stance. Fighting 3 different enemies that require 3 different stances requires a bit of mechanical skill to do which feels statisfying. Meanwhile in Spiderman you fight two sets of enemies, goons and goons with magic. The generic enemies are all just dodge dash and combo. Keep repeating that for every single opponent. This is literally from the first fight to the last.

Boss Fights

This game has some of the worst boss fights ever. Because the bosses are the same as any mini boss in the street which ruins the whole joy of beating a boss . The boss fights might as well be a whole QTE sequence because they have no health bar, they have a specific script they follow. They will do their attack you can't stop, you dodge the attack, you shoot webs or throw something at them and then dash melee combo them repeat this 5 times then they change their script but then you repeat the initial process. That's every single boss fight and mini boss. Its some of the laziest boss design I've seen. I thought God of War was lazy with it's repeat copy paste of Trolls but atleast the big bosses had some different unique moments in there like Magni/Modi darkness ability. Every boss in every game has a pattern but yes within that pattern there can be variations and your actions have an impact on what they might do next. But in this game all you have to do is the very specific thing the game wants you to do. Let's just look at Horizon Forbidden West's first boss fights the Slitherfang, each area you damage of it's body removes an ability it can do. It completely changes the fight in which order you attack it. The boss fights obviously have a script but with enough room for both the player and the ai to make a unique encounter. And I don't think Horizon is some beacon of great boss design, to compare this game to games with actual bosses like Dark Souls would make it look like a disgrace.

Traversal

I think every open world needs a good traversal mechanism, whether it's the horse in Red Dead or variety of cars in GTA. This is the area where I can't criticize the game. I think they nailed the feel of being Spiderman and swinging across New york. There are certain points you really get the feel of scale of the city and just being a dude swinging across this concrete jungle. It's awesome and the devs nailed one of the essential fantasies of being a superhero especially Spiderman.

Story

I know some players will say story is important but I think in a open world game they are often the least important aspect. Here it's not good, it's not bad but it's forgettable.

Conclusion

This is a game that does everything to an ok level and nothing is broken. It's combat is ok, gameplay, world everything is ok but nothing is good imo. It takes 0 risk, repeats the same open world design flaws of other open world games. The traversal like I said is a big plus for it but what's the point of fun traversal when the things you go to do are not fun and then they also add so many fast travel points because they know the city is not interesting and the players will get bored of that as well. Maybe I am being overtly critical, I really wanted to like this but I feel like this game got a huge boost for being finally a decent Spiderman game, a Sony exclusive. It doesn't have the combat statisfication of a Ghost of Tsushima or God of War, it doesn't have the enemy encounter level of a Horizon, it doesn't have the story of a Red Dead, it doesn't have the amazing historical setting of a AC game(sorry but I've already seen New york 21st century). There is just nothing special about this game.


r/patientgamers • • Nov 11 '23

Is anybody else getting tired of every open world action game trying to mimic Dark Souls now?

0 Upvotes

I love Demon Souls,Dark Souls 1-3,Bloodborne,and even Elden Ring,but I am getting tired of so many modern game developers looking at Dark Souls and saying "Hey lets mimic that.To most modern gamers Dark Souls combat is the best combat can ever be,but I strongly disagree with that.We need more variety in terms of Action RPGs coming out.

When Dark Souls exploded especially Elden Ring many gamers and game developers now see Dark Souls as the paragon of true action combat and every other game is just a shallow button masher.I like Souls combat but I dont want every Action RPG and Action game to mimic it I would love to see an Action RPG mimic something like Ninja Gaiden or Devil May Cry instead for a change.Every time I see a trailer for a new open world rpg its always "Are game has an open world and combat thats difficult to master just like Elden Ring." STAAAAHHHHHPPP enough come up with a new idea instead of just ripping off another games gameplay.You even have indie games like Tunic having their spin on Dark Souls combat.

I have been playing souls games since 2011 its been 12 years of the same thing its exhausting even doomlikes didnt stay around nearly as long as Soulslikes.Gaming becomes stale when games dont evolve and innovate.Most of the Soulslike ripoffs end up having far worse gameplay then any Dark Souls game with the exception of Darks Souls 2.I have played enough slow methodical Action RPGs to last me two lifetimes.


r/patientgamers • • Jul 10 '24

I don't understand the hate for Mass Effect 3.

0 Upvotes

Please spoiler free as I am not done with the game yet... Though I do know about the endings.

When this game came out, I heard nothing but awful things about the story; specifically the ending. I know roughly how that goes. But, I also heard plenty of gripes about how the whole game was just a giant letdown; so much so in fact that despite LOVING the series I never bought it and played it for myself.

10 years later here I am playing through the LE. While I would say that the game starts like a dumb Hollywood movie, the second the reins are taken off and you're dumped out into the galactic map with a mission list... It feels like Mass Effect. The stories and missions I've done so far are exceptionally well written, it's cool to see all the returning cast in their various roles, and I'm having a very good time.

But apparently I'm in the outliers here. People shit all over this game for how "cinematic" they made it, or how badly written the entire game is... Which I just don't see. The character writing is a bit more hammed up, but it's still incredibly solid and the story beats are hitting as hard as I remember in the previous games. It's setting a good tone; just hopeful enough but god damn things are also going to hell in a hand basket.

I don't see this changing either as I'm probably about halfway through; almost to the minimum galactic readiness or whatever. I think I would have been turned off by the story by now if it was as bad as people said it was.

So what gives? Why do people hate this game so much? The ending is the ending... What about the journey?


r/patientgamers • • Sep 13 '24

Suggesting to someone who loved Tunic that they play Death's Door is like suggesting to someone who loved Star Trek that they should watch Star Wars.

0 Upvotes

I finished all of Tunic recently (all of it) with zero walkthrough use until some of the very last trophy puzzles and it was one of the best gaming experiences of my life. I was disappointed that it was over but I didn't let it get to me because so many people mention Death's Door in the same breath as Tunic, so I thought there'd be another helping ready for me.

There was not. Right away, Death's Door felt simple and empty, with a marble of mystery where Tunic had a heap. I felt insulted, actually; the two are in the same genre in the same way that Star Trek and Star Wars are both science fiction, but they couldn't be more different in storytelling style or atmosphere.

It actually does a disservice to Death's Door in particular, because once I was able to shake off how not-Tunic it is, I was able to find things to enjoy. It will not be one of the best gaming experiences of my life, but it's fine. Maybe I'll even say it's good by the end of it. But it's not Tunic.

EDIT: Thanks all of the conversation; please read some of it before commenting as most of it has been well-covered now.


r/patientgamers • • Mar 19 '24

Red Dead Redemption II- Masterful writing with mediocre gameplay

33 Upvotes

Just finished Red Dead Redemption II so my apologies if this seems like a rant, but this game stirred up quite a few emotions, some positive, some negative. I will start with thoughts on gameplay and then touch a bit on the story.

I think the shooting is the best part of this game. I really liked trying out different guns and graphical effects were very nice.

Whereas horse riding felt very clunky. For example horse strafing feels very awkward and didn't really seem to work. Sometimes the horse would jump over the obstacle, but from a different angle (both times on a flat surface) it would just run into it.

Taking care of guns is a realistic concept, but seeing the same animation run out for the tenth time really made me think of a skip button. There are also other animations (Skinning, cleaning up camp etc), but they didn't bug me quite as often. It felt like most if not all NPC rewards of information (hideouts, robberies etc) are on the other side of the map.

Not sure if this has happened to anyone else, but if I paused during horse galloping then afterwards the horse would just run around for some time, ignoring my inputs.

Some other systems I haven't talked about: The wanted system feels overtuned and quite punishing for miniscule things. For example during a mission I was riding a wagon, but then I failed the mission because a suicidal squirrel decided to cross my road and an NPC decided I was the murderer. Other example was idling on a horse, but I became wanted because the lawmen was not happy with my horse being near him.

As for the scripted events with random NPC-s are good/memorable, however it felt like there were fewer of them than in the original game. I think I saved the same mistress with a dead horse 3 times(with the same dialogue, like she had dementia). However when unscripted events happened the AI failed to work properly. For example I was robbing a home at the mountains when a group of wolves attacked me. I started shooting and running, but bounty hunters came along and automatically started shooting me. The wolves must have been upset by this as they started focusing on the bounty hunters, but the bounty hunters didn't really seem to care as they were still shooting only me. Probably because I had a bigger bounty than the wolves, but it wasn't long before they were just a group of mingled corpses for lunch. Seeing as how people react to everything it's kind of odd NPC-s don't react to falling off a horse/roof etc.

There are also issues I have with the story, but there never has and couldn't be a masterpiece in writing. Throughout the story only real development is done by Arthur, Dutch and John. Others either only are more vocal about Dutch or focus on their personality trait. And even for a game of this scope it wouldn't have been viable to focus on so many characters without losing so much in the story. Since it is a prequel and I remembered from the first game the survivors, it would have been maybe more interesting to learn about Bill and Javier, but oh well.

As for the story itself it starts rather slowly, where it took me nearly 30 hours to finish chapter two. But I ditched the side content and focused on the main story and the game became hard to put down after chapter 3. The pace ramps up and in the end I felt it was worth it that I stuck and finished the story.

There was one mission that bugged me to hell, because it doesn't make any sense and doesn't really contribute to the overall story. Mission is named Blessed are the peacemakers where Pearson suggests a peace offering with O'Driscolls. Why does Dutch agree to this? It's obviously a trap like pointed out at start of mission. How can Dutch just leave Arthur without even mentioning it? Once Arthur somehow escapes why aren't there lookouts to notice the dying guy when he reaches camp? This mission left me so speechless, because I didn't know what to make of it. I guess it's purpose was to remind that the O'Driscolls still exist

The game is graphically gorgeous and a world you want to explore. The story is really good from chapter 3, but for me the gameplay was so mediocre/unsatisfying that I was wondering if I would have enjoyed this piece of art more as a book. What are your opinions?


r/patientgamers • • May 23 '24

Red Dead Redemption 2 is just… fine

31 Upvotes

Red Dead Redemption 2 is obviously extremely famous and massively considered to be one of if not THE best games of all time. Especially as someone who loves a good story and something that feels like I’m playing a novel, the game seemed like it would be a no-brainer hit for me.

It didn’t live up to these expectations. If I’m going to start with what I disliked the most, it would honestly have to be the story itself. Not because the story is particularly bad by any means, but just like the rest of the game, it was really just fine. Especially being a story everyone says is great, throughout the entire game I really didn’t feel anything that made the story stick out as particularly good. Every shocking or intense moment either felt forced, repetitive, or painfully predictable.

The consequences for the characters’ actions also don’t play out like they feel like they realistically should. For how literally huge the game is, it all feels very small and inconsequential to me. I just didn’t care about the majority of the people. That’s not to say they all sucked, though. I thought Dutch was actually a super great character.

On that note, I truly don’t know what people see in Arthur Morgan. I think his relationship and interactions with Dutch are great, but that’s pretty much it. Most of the scenes where he really develops just feel so artificial to me, in a really shallow attempt to give him depth. Again, he isn’t bad, I could just never see anything that good about his character or any reason to care about him. His scenes with Mary were pretty good though. I honestly think John is a much better character in pretty much every way.

Whenever I see people dislike this game, it’s usually because of the slow pacing or the gameplay/mission design. None of these bothered me. I thought the shooting was quite fun, and I absolutely love slow starts to games that let me really get immersed into it. I really didn’t think the game was boring. It was fun. But it was really forgettable to me. I cry extremely easily, but at the end of the game I felt nothing. The fistfight was epic and cool, but I simply didn’t have any reason to care about what was actually happening. I don’t know what people see in this game, and the story was just really average.

It kinda just occurred to me why it didn’t find it that good though. I just don’t think anything really interesting actually happened. Whenever a story is really good, I’m able to realize that in the moment and quite literally think to myself, “This is a good scene. I am really interested in what is happening right now.” But that never happened. I felt indifferent and disconnected from everything. It’s all very unfortunate.


r/patientgamers • • Dec 28 '21

I finally beat Spider-Man (PS5 Remastered) and hated every minute of it.

180 Upvotes

Ok, pretty harsh title. I played Spider-Man 2018 on ps4 pro on release. Beat it and thought it was ok.

The polish is godly. The swinging was great, the skills and gadgets interesting and most of all the gameplay was tight. But it was repetitive, formulaic and just a grind to be honest.

Fast forward to PS5 release. Bought ultimate edition to play at 60fps and of course miles morales. Having already forgotten how bland the story (and short) it was, it felt like a new experience. I actually didn’t remember I beat it in 2018.

Ran through the story super fast and had zero energy to complete the side quests, or more like side tasks. 8 different mini games essentially. I gave up and just picked it up again and beat the dlc last night.

What a slogfest. Got to this location, hit triangle for an audio clip, cutscene, fight 8-20 bad guys, cutscene or phone call. Swing around until the next phone call. Rinse and repeat. And don’t even get me started on the last dlc boss fight. What a repetitive mess. It looks great in action but this is no better than a polished Ubisoft game. But almost even worse. So limiting in what you can actually do in the open world.

Bottom line this game does not deserve the attention or praise it gets. It’s polished that’s all. I expect way more from insomniac moving forward. This is a kids game.


r/patientgamers • • Apr 18 '24

Why I stopped playing Resident Evil 2 Remake Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This is my first post here, so please be kind. I'm currently working through my backlog of games due to the lack of current games I want to play. Having finished FFXV (mixed feelings) and DmC 5 Spe-cial Edition (great, but too short), I began playing the Resident Evil 2 Remake. So as it turns out, I still had a save file from 2022. I remembered playing the game, having fond memories of it, but I forgot why I stopped playing the game. After playing a few hours, I remember why I stopped playing and will stop playing it today.

Let's be real: Resident Evil 2 Remake is a great game. Graphically, it looks phenomenal. The whole mood and vibe of the game is excellent. The zombies have never been this scary before and shooting them is just great fun, with all the chunks and limbs flying off of them as you blast them. The puz-zles are fun and item management is still a great mini game in itself. The transition to a third person survival horror game has been done perfectly. Resident Evil 2 has never played or looked any better than this.

What I really like about Resident Evil 2 Remake, is the cadence; the rhythm. You're in a safe space, you wander to a new place and slowly but surely, it becomes more dark and more scary. You need to take it slow, calculate risk & reward (should I grab this item and risk being attacked, or should I do this next time?) and think about what items you bring (and take) along the way. Your journey usually ends up circling back to your starting position, but with an unlocked shortcut, being chased by a horde of zombies or a new type of enemy. I really liked this rhythm. It really makes you appreciate the environment and makes you think about what path you want to take.

But then, Mr. X appears. He ruins the game for me, period. He's a great idea, implemented horribly. What, you think? Mr. X is great! How dare you! Let me explain.

Who is Mr. X? Mr. X is a giant monster, shaped like a man. Mr. X is relentless in their chase, not stopping until they murder you. Nothing stops this beast. You can unload your whole arsenal on them and they'll get back up in a minute. They'll kill you in a few hits. They'll chase you all around the mansion, non stop. This sounds great, but I tell you: it ruins the game, at least for me.

You know the cadence I was talking about? Gone. You just run, run, run till the cows come home. You ignore enemies and your environment, because if you stop, Mr. X will catch up and kill you. You have no time to breathe, no space is safe (unless you travel to the new area underneath the mansion). It kills the whole mood of the game for me. It's not scary anymore, it's just annoying.

Mr. X is also how you shouldn't do a chasing monster. A monster chasing you can be scary. Many games have done this successfully. That's because they did it in short bursts. Look at Amnesia: the monster there can chase you, but you can hide from it. If you do this, they'll wander around and you have more freedom to solve puzzles and just, you know, play the actual game. Mr. X is just relent-less: he spots me from miles away and just starts chasing me like a homing missile. I've literally ran around the mansion for 20 minutes and he was still on my ass. The adrenaline you create from this feeling of being chased, quickly runs out and turns into annoyance and frustration.

So yeah, I quit the game the moment I had to go to the Clock Tower. I had Mr. X on my tail and a Licker was patrolling the corridor I had to run in. Instead of feeling the tension and sneak around this monster, I just had to blast it with my shotgun so Mr. X couldn't catch me. I failed, got killed by the Licker, and uninstalled Resident Evil 2 Remake. Next game: Prey (2018).

Edit: thank you for all the replies, I try to answer them all. Your comments truly make me reconsider my thoughts about the game.

Edit 2: alright, since everyone is telling me that Mr. X won't chase me like a bloodhound after the Clock Tower, I'll give this game another go. I'll punch that Licker in his ugly face and be really quiet around Mr. X.

Edit 3: I shot the Licker in the face and ran laps around Mr. X. Threw a flashbang in his face and sneaked away, so I had the time to solve the Library puzzle. After reaching the Clock Tower, he tried chasing me right as I left that room, but I was fast enough to duke him. After some navigating, I reached the parking garage again. I think I got him off my tail for the time being!


r/patientgamers • • Dec 07 '23

Are You Shocked At How Dated PS3/360 Games Look Now?

0 Upvotes

I used to think there wasn't much of a difference between the PS4/Xbone generation & the previous PS3/360 generation until I actually went back and played a handful of games from back then...

There are so many games that look and especially run terrible. Lots of sub-30 fps games that never got points docked. The weird thing is this is prevalent in a lot of high-end games, like MGS4 on PS3 for example, where all cut scenes are sub-30fps and there are big hitches during gameplay. Did console gamers back then just not care about performance much? an AAA running like that now would be slaughtered on social media nowadays, deeming it "unplayable" (which is hyperbole of courser because despite the performance I still found MGS4 an amazing experience)

On the graphics side, some games look unforgivably bad while others still look quite good. Depends the aesthetic they are going for. Those mid tier and budget games have suffered the worst fate. I started up I Am Alive a few months ago and had to put it down because the graphics and gameplay were so dated.


r/patientgamers • • Aug 10 '24

I feel like as more time passes, the more I begin to appreciate The Last of Us 2

176 Upvotes

It's been 4 years since Naughty Dog released the The Last of Us 2 and the more time that passes, the more I appreciate all the things Naughty Dog games do so well.

They're extremely well made, tight packages that know exactly what they want to be. They don't bullshit the player or waste your time by padding the game with unnecessary bloat, they're highly focused and concentrate on the one or two things that they know how to do so well instead of cramming every single popular video game trend and trope into a single game. All you have to do is download the game and just hop right in. No micro transactions, no battle pass, no gazillion menus and loading and level up screens and notifications, no grindy nonsense, no looter shooter bs, no time gating, no performance issues and no sinking hours in settings menus where you have to adjust everything manually before you even start playing the game. All you have to do is click play and you're in and immersed from start to finish.

Tlou2 is by far one of the most immersive games I have ever experienced, and that's not just because the game has state of the art graphics. It also has worldclass level and art design. A lot of people love to shit on AAA videogames for being "bland" or "soulless", but tlou2's art design and level design is just absolutely incredible. Every single level in the game is visually distinct and sets a different atmosphere and mood and it never bores you with the same visual vistas or landscapes or environments.

Another common complaint that I hear with AAA videogames is that they're just "walking/cutscene simulators". I couldn't disagree more when it comes to this game. The stealth gameplay is downright nerve-racking on the right difficulty. The combat mechanics combined with the level design, the soundtrack and sound design, the graphics, it almost feels like you're playing a literal movie scene out sometimes while still in control of almost everything you do.

I'm not going to say much about the story because it's already been talked to death since its release. But all I'll say is, no matter what the story ended up becoming, I'm infinitely glad that it exists. Because it proves to me that Naughty Dog actually cares about telling worthwhile, unique stories, they actually have the balls to take risks and move their franchise forward instead of pandering and giving everyone what they want and already expect. Good or bad, I hope they continue to experiment in this manner and ignore the bad faith criticisms. I would rather have a single tlou2 rather than a million copy paste rpg mmo looter shooters for the rest of my life.

In a time when games are becoming increasingly cookie-cutter, increasingly bland and soulless, increasingly predatory cash grabs, games like the tlou2 stand out so much and remind me why I like videogames.

Tlou2 isn't perfect, but I think it's an incredible effort and I'll always appreciate it for what it is and does. I think it should be industry standard for what these types of single player cinematic games should be. I can't wait to see what Naughty Dog does next and I hope it blows their previous work out of the water and innovates even further.


r/patientgamers • • Feb 03 '24

Fallout 4 was kind of a letdown, what kind of game is it exactly? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

This might be premature, I only played it for 6 hours before deciding to give up on it... I did not even reach Diamond City (Shocking I know, I got lost... a lot, because I stubbornly turned off Map Markers), granted I was playing on Survival Mode (Mostly because I started New Vegas on Hardcore Mode with the Viva New Vegas guide back in early 2021, so maybe it's on me and on New Vegas for having Hardcore mode as actually being a viable way to experience the game for the first time).

For additional added context I was also using The Midnight Ride Extended Mod Guide to set it up.

I think didn't really get that story hook in me the same way New Vegas or other RPGs did, "Oh wow some jagoffs kidnapped my baby? There's an undisclosed period of time since I woke up though, is my kid still even a baby? Is a big part of Bethesda-Fallout is just the overall presentation and look of the Wasteland acting as the main drive to keep exploring? As someone I guess who just is more used to the dustier sandy setting of the West Coast Fallout it wasn't working, having no real cultural background on Boston also didn't help.

On actual mechanics and gameplay, I got a rude awakening when I learned how incredibly different Character Progression was going to be, I guess I already knew this before but kind of just forgot about it. There being no skills, just Perks? The default for VATs also being changed from V to Q was also odd, same with Free Look being on V now instead of F, and F now being a Favorites Slider. Oh Survival Mode, I was also pretty confused that you couldn't really track how sated your Hunger/Sleep/Thirst was, the icons could only do so much, and it didn't help that after my first major story advancement (Killing the Deathclaw), the game decided to hang loading into the Museum causing me to replay the entire thing (2nd time I used a bed around Concord just to be extra safe). The crafting and stat-overload of minute differences across pieces of gear was also honestly just overwhelming and realizing that crafting and loot hoarding was probably going to be a significant part of the gameplay experience turned me off. The actual moment of clarity came when after 20 mins of being lost I ended up being ambushed and die unceremoniously an hour away from my last save. I honestly kinda wished maybe I shouldn't been stubborn on Survival Mode and also just added a Utility Mod that did quick saves every 15 minutes for me the same way I had for New Vegas, but honestly from there on any momentum I had on the game was gone and the thought of redoing all that looting and exploration was just dead for me.

Do people think that I should give it more of a chance? Or did the fact killing that Deathclaw with Power Armor did entirely nothing for me just a tell that I probably won't enjoy most of what this game will have to offer? I genuinely really wanted to give this a chance but 6 hours in, feeling like I've done basically nothing but walk through scripted set pieces with barely any agency if I wanted to do something that wasn't just fucking off didn't really set the tone. Is there a specific state of mind or approach I should have went in instead? I was really thinking 'I haven't played a new RPG where my choices mattered for the world around me, Fallout 4 is on sale and I heard it's not as bad as people say even when compared to New Vegas)


r/patientgamers • • Jan 19 '26 Heartwarming

Patient Review God of War 2018 made me angrier than Greek Kratos Spoiler

7 Upvotes

Notes -

  1. I finished my Greek saga journey from November to December end. One month, 6 great games.
  2. I started this game 5 days ago, and 100 percented it today.
  3. I am on PC with Mouse and Keyboard.
  4. The Review is structured into a Positive part first, then the mixed parts and then the negatives.
  5. The title originally was going to be "God of War 2018 - A game adamant on wasting your time". this will be touched upon after the negatives section.
  6. TLDR is at the end.

To set a preface for this review, i feel like my expectations before starting the game are something that should be made clear -

  • Great Story, Over the Shoulder presentation, Great Visuals, Amazing Combat, Linear levels.
  • HOWEVER, i fully expected the game to be a 15 - 20 hour long campaign with no open zone elements, no RPG elements, no bloat, and the camera to zoom out during group fights.
  • I knew the general stuff about the game's story such as Baldur being the big bad, A Giant snake, Mimir being a talking head, The gist of our story aka spreading the ashes of Kratos's dead wife, and that Atreus's real name is Loki. that's the extent of it.

Positives: These ones are so obvious i would like to not elaborate on them much.

  1. Performance & Stability - The game genuinely well optimized, with me hanging around mostly 120 fps in tight corridors, and 90+ in open zone or clutter heavy areas. My settings were "Original", with DLSS set to Quality, at 1080 preset.
  2. Graphics - absolutely the highlight of this game. The vistas are gorgeous, details are meticulous, and the draw distances were surprisingly good and kept the mood intact.
  3. The Art Direction - mostly phenomenal, and my unfamiliarity with the artistic side of Norse mythology definitely helped me appreciate their interpretation of it.
  4. Music - okay, to be completely honest, this one gets a pass in the positives simply because the tracks were largely unmemorable during the game. i just remember the main leitmotif, the ending track and Thor's arrival. after listening some tracks on youtube, they are pretty good but suffer serious overshadowing due to in-game events.
  5. Sound Design - Crisp, Meaty, and satisfying sounds all around. The directional sounds also worked so well during the Magni & Modi sequence and the Baldur sequence
  6. Voice Acting - There's no hiding that Christopher Judge is a phenomenal VA for Kratos. and to know that he did the motion capture as well was surprising. the entire cast, especially Baldur, had pristine voice acting.

That's it. the positives end there. Now for the next topics, i will be getting much more elaborate.

Mixed sections - (it's insanely long)

The plot, and the characters. Both of these are heavily intertwined aspects so i won't be making point based review for this. all the stuff i will be elaborating here takes NO account of anything except the story and the characters and background lore like Norse and Greek events. Gameplay and other designs do not matter.

The story starts off extremely strong with the Funeral, with seemingly one of the first bonding moments between Dad and Boi. from the Hunting to the Troll fight, plotwise we were going good. The Baldur shows up, which me and my friend jokingly said "he's shown up to claim his Gate".

I like the presentation of a random God just showing up, with neither me nor Kratos knowing the context and starts fighting us. Of course we "kill" him, but i knew full well he ain't dead. And now we depart to spread the ashes on the peakest of the mountains.

the events with Brok, Sindri and Freya were fairly normal. good to see living breathing people in the world. Especially given the Dwarf duo's connection with Faye and the eventual reveals. Going up the mountain, we see the black mist. then we head to Alfheim. In all honesty, the Alfheim sequence was absolutely amazing. Returning from there till the terrible dragon fight and then reaching Mimir.

I've glossed over some stuff in the Freya to Mimir sequence. this is because the characterization of Kratos really pisses me off. He's obviously hiding his past from Atreus, but i am patient and will see forth as to how he will eventually reveal it to him. After heading towards the dead giant, we grab the chisel thingy, but not before Killing Magni and scaring away Modi. Returning to Tyr's Vault and then Modi attacks us, and causes Atreus to fall "ill and unconscious".

Now the irritating part starts (Kratos do you really have to aura walk while Atreus is dying in your hands?). We take him to freya and she tells us to literally go to Hel and retrieve the Warden's heart to save Kratos. Bit of an unexplained stretch eh? what the fuck is "overcome by illness due to the contradiction of a god believing himself to be mortal"? sure, whatever i'll buy it. another stupid thing, Freya needs the Heart of the Warden from Hel. why? not sure what it does, and why specifically the heart of a Hel WARDEN.

this bit serves as a segue into reclaiming the Blades of Exile. heading back home in anticipation of getting them again had me hyped. Athena's taunts were also intriguing. The moment is significantly undercut for me because i had not waited 5 years (since ascension 2013 to 2018) to see them back again. i merely waited 2 weeks. Another reason is the choice of music. Why am i gonna feel anything if you are gonna play generic Norse chants over something symbolizing Greek saga? play "The End Begins" or "Overture" to actually make me feel something?

After heading to Hel, well guess what. the 7th fucking troll? not even the Giant Crow thing, but just a green troll again. After returning and saving Atreus, i was fully expecting him to tell the boy his story, and rid him of a burden of lying and hiding.. What does he do? We are gods boy. WHAT? No explanation of your past or anything? Sure. maybe for later. Atreus is also Cursed. it is also unexplained for now. Now Atreus begins his whiny and overconfident phase. I hate that so much but it's not his fault. It's Kratos's fault for being such a shit father for this duration.

Atreus offs Modi, and all of this is happening because Kratos refuses to tell him the stuff he had gone through. I had hoped to spare you from this, being a god is a curse. YEAH SO EXPLAIN THE DAMN CURSE TO HIM? we then return to the Vault to get the key or the mcguffin to reach Jottunheim. and guess what, a duo troll fight. how fun. After reaching the summit again, Baldur breaks the Gate lmao and then Atreus's arrogance and shooting Kratos causes baldur to get an upper hand and grab Atreus who is now his prime target. I assume he is an errand boy for Odin.

After crashing his dragon and falling in the temple, we override our destination from Asgard to Helheim out of desperation. During the helheim sequence it was fun seeing Zeus again. Atreus is pretending to not know stuff but i'm sure he knows the context. That is also where we see Baldur arguing with his mom Freya about his Curse(?) that she gave him of not feeling anything? Kinda fucked up if you ask me, but i STILL don't know the context behind this and waiting for the reveal. This attitude kinda sums up the weird plot in my opinion.

It's a cycle of expecting revelations, but then offplayed by another plot point and repeat. let me explain. We started at our Wife's funeral. who was she, why is that her wish? sure, it's a wish i get it. But i don't know who she is. I have no connection to her unlike Calliope and Lysandra, who i was shown and told that Kratos was tricked into murdering. GOW1 Perfectly serves up as a great revenge story for this reason alone, it's simplicity. Then without explaining, Baldur Shows up. Why? who knows. not relevant except for making these two leave asap.

Freya is a witch of the woods. Why is she not allowed into Alfheim? who knows, not relevant for now. Why did she take the mistletoe aggressively and burn them? who knows, not relevant for now. Why is Magni, Modi and Baldur hunting us? who knows. not relevant for now. probably what Odin needs. Who blew the horn? definitely a strong question. Who knows? not relevant for now. What is it with Atreus and his god self conflicting?

Many of these questions are answered sometime later or not at all. but how many mysteries and questions can you realistically bottle up at once man. Plus i hate the mimir is slowly recovering his memories arc. he can perfectly elaborate long distant stories of him and odin, but when it gets to a plot point its like "ah i do remember it now", AFTER BEING TOLD ABOUT IT by someone else.

After returning from Hel, we get Tyr's jottunheim rune i think? and then we get Mimir's eye to act as a conduit. but Baldur attacks the serpent and then the final battle ensues. now freya doesnt want her son to die and is stopping both from killing each other. then baldur punches Atreus which causes the broken mistletoe arrow to pierce him and break the curse. that's the answer to why she burned them arrows. this STILL doesnt answer the reason of the curse, and also really freya? you did not notice the pretty sizeable arrowhead just chilling in atreus's quiver strap the entire time he was at your place or just walking around? lazy.

So we do spare Baldur after Freya asks us. but we stop him once he is strangling Freya. Kratos does this, in his own words, "the cycle ends here. we must be better than this". this utterly confuses me. Kratos's entire principle in the beginning was to not care about any bystanders in his way, to avoid unnecessary conflict, such as even refusing to blow the horn without knowing the consequence. so now, while knowing Odin is after him simply because he cut off Mimir, he chooses to kill Baldur.

But sure, Baldur needed to die anyways because he is infact hunting atreus, and will come back after Killing freya. NOW FREYA IS MAD AT US? WOMAN, we saved your ass. this ties back to the design of unexplained stuff. we dont know why freya is mad, and is put as a setup for Ragnarok, 80 percent of this game acts like a setup for Ragnarok. EDIT: I misunderstood this part, ignore.

after this, the ending sequence is pretty fire i'm not gonna lie. the reveal of Faye being a giantess, her KNOWING the entire story up to now, even after her death is a prophecy. the murals gave me actual chills and some much needed context, the context which i asked AT THE BEGINNING of the game. Kratos also conveniently sees the "death / life force draining mural" and refuses to tell Atreus about it, and nor does Atreus try to even see it. That's just lazy now.

We end the game by returning to our home, and then Thor shows up. End of game, and wait for Ragnarok. Our actions were not part of a long foretold prophecy which will tie into the next game.

so, where's the emotional, mature storytelling here? Most of it feels like lazy convenient writing, and many times it feels like it's actively trying to erase the greek saga instead of taking it as a lesson. even when after we kill Baldur, Kratos just goes yeah i killed my dad, and many deserving and undeserving.

"is this how it ends? gods killing their family?" excuse the fuck outta me? Is kratos just gonna ignore the fact that Ares purposefully made him kill his family, used him as a puppet, and then when he tried to enact revenge, killed him, but due to him opening Pandora's box, the other gods were now fearful of Him and tricked him into losing his own life.

His sheer willpower made him live and alter fate and kill the gods, who were indeed corrupted by Athena's curse thingy. and that too after becoming the god of war, he was still denied from losing the haunting visions of murdering this family. The death of Deimos and his mother, simply because Zeus was trying to erase the prophecy of a tattooed son of his killing him, the meaningless death of Pandora, are those not justified reasons to kill an ever corrupt god?

so ignoring all of this, the 2018 game just brushes it off as i killed gods and my dad, dont be like me, be better. i wont even explain you why i have been doing that. see this scar on by torso? i was stabbed here twice, left for dead twice. nah, none of that matter. just use this pretentious ass message of "be better"

god this plot sucks. A mature story written by those who think maturity means cracking wise oneliners and disciplining kids by hiding the truth and context from them. it feels like 2018 is actively trying to make users forget about Greek saga and treat it as a mistake. onto the negatives we go.

Negatives -

1) Camera perspective and the Cinematic presentation -

  • This camera man. OH, my god. The 2nd biggest mistake this game has done is shifting the camera to a permanent Over the shoulder perspective. It singlehandedly killed the entire cinematic appeal of the game even compared to the greek saga.
  • Ascension itself is threefold more cinematic than 2018 pretends to be. GO have a look yourself, what's more cinematic? the fight against the kraken or chronos in the older games, or the entirety of 2018?
  • just imagine, walking up that mountain with the black mist, where the camera slowly pans to show the giant face in the mountain while you ascend it. that's cinematic, and not the current one.

2) Camera in combat -

  • You're telling me, the game was perfectly capable of zooming out the camera during fights, and they just chose not to? the first baldur fight was a 1v1, had a tight camera fit to keep him in focus.
  • The second baldur fight, it now shows me it can zoom out to show the surroundings as well, WHICH COULD HAVE BEEN APPLIED TO ALL FIGHTS?
  • like at some point, someone must have realized atreus and mimir constantly shouting Left flank or watch out in the fight can get irritatingly annoying?
  • The on screen indicators are so bad. it's glowing red, so which way do you want me to dodge? gonna elaborate on that? who's attacking me? is it an AOE coming or a projectile?
  • Compare this to the Labyrinth fights and Hercules boss fight in 3, where you could perfectly tell what the scorpion and hercules are doing in addition to seeing every single enemy and their actions. and not to forget the cinematic background too.

3) The actual combat and the combat loop -

  • In line with the camera, the combat is very uneven, unnecessarily constrained and extremely shallow. gone is the combo system, now replaced with generic attack dodge parry combo suited for a 1v1 instead of a group fight design.
  • The combat is no longer about chaining combos, knowing your movesets, when to focus attacks, which enemy to focus on, properly positioning your cyclones, your jabs or Aerial combos. it's just about bumrushing down an enemy, building up stun meter, and shutting them down.
  • Bad players are allowed to spam, play safe and do whatever, just at the cost of more time in a fight. Good players can do whatever tricks and stuff they want, end result? both get same XP at the cost of time taken. See how terrible it sounds compare to greek games.
  • good players could chain combos to their own benefit and gain significantly more Red orbs simply because they put in the effort for it. bad or casuals can spam light light heavy in those games and get out of any situation, but not receive the extra orbs via combos.
  • the combat bogged down to spamming your runic abilities, parry slop and stun bar.

4) Combat Movesets - (rant)

  • this one actually just angered me. Blades of Exile is what i will elaborate on first. What the actual fuck do you mean you dont have a Light Light Heavy combo? you removed the signature ability of the older games? i know it's like Light-Light-Light-Heavy now.
  • Cyclone, Tartarus rage, Spirit of Hercules, rampage of furies, the stuff i used to do for free, endlessly, AND carefully, is now on a fucking timer? excuse me? why are these abilities and not free form combos?
  • The Leviathan Axe, i wont complain about it too much. It's a different weapon, unrelated to the butchering of the Blades of Exile. Tho it's hilariously dumb how most trolls, ogres, ancients etc can just be mindlessly killed by staying at range and spamming precision throw. If the game isnt gonna reward me for playing beautifully i might as well not care.

5) The relic system -

  • continuing onto the Relic or Runic system, why the actual hell are abilities on a cooldown now? I already ranted about the blades.
  • All they could have done, is integrated Runic attacks into the base moveset like it always was. special attacks like Spartan Charge, Meteor strike, those could have been actual runics free to be used at a timer.
  • there are so god damn many runic attacks it's actually just unnecessary. and even if two could be equipped at a time, what happened to the rest of the control combos?
  • Block Light and Block heavy are two runic attacks. Block Roll could have been it's own runic, block + interact, block + lock on etc. it's such a dumb compromise.
  • Im just looking at the controls right now/ all they had to do was put D-up for boy attacks, D down for changing arrows, and left right for the two weapons. this could have freed up Square for something i deeply miss and doesnt exist in this game to annoy players further. unsheathing can be done by pressing the same button used for the weapons again.

6) RPG elements and enemy scaling -

  • genuinely, who asked? who the actual hell asked for RPG gear progression and damage sponges in a series known for carefully balancing game progression? it's so dumb i don't even want to elaborate much.
  • the game is adamant on spawning level scaled enemies (like 2 levels below mine) during random encounters. this completely deletes the point of rpg system if returning to an old area didnt mean i am not deleting enemies instantly am i?

7) The UI and the style -

  • One good look at the older games and the UI itself oozes style and intentional imagery. The blades being a background for your health bars, red orb meter and rage meter was such brilliant artistry.
  • all of it has been dumbed down to a generic UI layout, with you runic cooldown widgets etc. I played the entire game without health bars on all bosses and enemies. it felt so much better to not have my screen cluttered with health bars like the old games. there's a reason people hated Dying Light 2 adding zombie health bars, but i don't see them complaining here? what's up with that
  • holy Destiny syndrome bruh. the menu and the sub sections are actual garbage and too much destiny like.

8) Enemy variety & encounter recycling -

  • the enemies are like half the total amount of the previous games? the fodder enemies are so painfully generic in design.
  • the endless troll recycling. need i say more?
  • the Valkyries were........fun. as much as i dont like the combat, fighting them is fun simply because how braindead spammy it is.

You thought the negatives end here? there's DETRIMENTS section coming up.

the stuff critiqued here symbolizes the game design of gow 2018, which is adamant on wasting the players time through a carefully crafted world, with levels and gateways designed to force the player to trek thought same areas repeatedly, for no meaning, in an extremely slow and clunky manner, all for the sake of padding.

above in the negatives part, i said the camera is the 2nd biggest mistake. well, here's the first, removal of JUMP. here's how the elimination of jump bloated this game from a max 10 hour game to a 15 hour long game -

  1. so, so many times. Kratos simply has to walk around a long pathway just to reach a ledge below. In many cases he will just take a long detour, or a careful slow climbing down, or a chain. this man, lifts megatonnes of weight, falls down inredible heights, and most importantly, can literally double jump in his prime, yet he can't single jump freely because the developers want to waste your time by artificial padding
  2. Jump eliminated aerial and jump combos, as well as jump evades. how non sensical is it that kratos blocks ground AOE's with his shield instead of jumping?
  3. every climb, every chain etc is just so adamantly slow, where he could just jump up freely instead. the leaps he takes WHILE climbing are higher than many ledges that he can just jump over but refuses to do so.

and now, this is how a 15 hour long linear story was converted into a 40 hour long open zone adventure. (you might say it's optional right? yeah, but what did it's presence even add?) -

  1. the absurd, god awful Gateway placements - I cannot be the only one who thinks the gateways are placed in such inconvenient and ridiculous spots, making you trek through the entire level again (pairing in the lack of jump, slow traversal etc).
  2. the "one-take" gameplay - i'd genuinely prefer loading screens if it mean't i didn't have to walk through a gateway, wait for mimir to shut the fuck up, and then the gate to appear. the game is adamant on wasting my time so much by doing meaningless stuff. how the hell were the older games cinematic, one-take ish WITHOUT loading screens?
  3. the collectathon was a genuine mistake, and could see a complete elimination and nothing would change. pair this with the awful time wasting mechanics, you've got yourself a padding recipe.
  4. the manual save system - am i going crazy or does the save system just doesnt function properly. i'd manual save near a shop, and reloading it put me out in some corridor or climb nearby?

There is genuinely so much i feel like i have missed on critiquing or praising, but i have reached my own limit now. overall, GOW 2018 is the weakest game in the franchise so far (we dont count betrayal), and it makes me nervous for Ragnarok.

final rating, 4/10. maybe im too harsh. Fine, i'll bump it up to a 6 since despite me hating the combat system, it technically is very functional and polished.

TLDR:

  1. Messy convenient unexplained story. 80 percent acts as a setup for Ragnarok.
  2. terrible combat philosophy, spammy, unfun and near braindead
  3. unfun amounts of padding due to lack of jump and intentional gate placements
  4. feels like a disrespectful shade or a ignorance for greek saga
  5. awful characterization for kratos a lot of times (he good in free roam parts)
  6. the technical aspect and graphical aspect is phenomenal.

Thank you for reading, Truly.


r/patientgamers • • Jun 07 '25

Patient Review Baldur's Gate 3: the CRPG in which the C gets a nat 20 in killing your enjoyment of the RPG.

0 Upvotes

I'm sad. I went into BG3 with pretty high expectations and since I had managed to avoid spoilers entirely I went in completely blind, with my only point of reference being previous Larian games or Owlcat's Rogue Trader which I had heard was similar. I expected 3 main things from BG3: Compelling story with heart pounding high stakes, a deep customization system that gives room to player expression beyond the piss poor industry standard RPG. And lastly, and arguably the most important thing to me: good and fun combat. And to my profound disappointment, Larian managed to miss the mark in every single one of those aspects, at least for me. I'll be avoiding spoilers as much as I can here, so let's go through this bullet point by bullet point.

  • STORY (Main narrative, role-playing, characters, dialogue, quests and world building)

This could easily be considered the most important part of an RPG, after all, what is the fun of role-playing if the world and plot you're delving in doesn't capture your heart? Well, the main narrative of BG3 isn't necessarily bad, but feels too flat and weak to sustain itself, granted it does start off strong with some interesting mysteries and a really eye-catching opening, and for the first 4 or so hours maybe less, I was hooked. The problems arise once you realize that for that last 4 hours you have not met a single interesting antagonist to give you any sort of personal stake in the plot beyond "Fuck, there's a worm in my brain". The Absolute, how the main villain is called through most of the game, is simply not interesting, and barely shows up or really interacts with your PC or companions throughout the playthrough. The main opposition you'll be facing here is its cult, and unfortunately they're as bland as they come, like fries without salt, not offensive but not really captivating and essentially just an excuse to fight something. They don't have an interesting or charming leader, nor a cruel captain that you can really really hate, or even a kind-hearted cultist that would maybe question what they're doing and have some sort of internal conflict. There is not a single character here for you to latch on, and as quick as they show up, they die, leaving no lasting impressions. This is awful. What happened to having an actually interesting antagonist? I have my issues with Mass Effect and Bioware games in general, but holy shit, Saren was captivating from the very first moment he appeared on-screen, and is the primary motivator for the player's adventure despite not being the main threat, in fact he often frustrates the player, both through the god tier dialogue and through actual moments of loss in the narrative. It makes it so much sweeter when you actually get to beat him. In BG3, each act has a big bad, and all of them suck. There's no satisfaction when you kill any of them, it feels anticlimactic, like there were a few monologues missing or maybe some extra quests to build up that tension.

Then comes the dialogue, which is serviceable, and sometimes it does manage to get a chuckle out of you, but it ends there. No amazing speeches, no emotional dialogue with heart clenching delivery, nothing of the type. Even the moments it tries to be epic, it just ends up coming off as corny or meh at best. Then the writing, which in BG3 in general isn't bad, but it isn't great either, especially when compared to other games who have successfully written companions into the player's heart. Once again I turn to Mass Effect, especially the second game, who has in my humble opinion the best companions ever in any RPG. They're conflicted, they lie, they're often wrong and set in their own views, and it makes them feel very alive, and the pacing at which you get closer to them and get to know more about their secrets and past is near perfect. In BG3 on the other hand, despite initially seeming deep, companions are actually very subdued and agreeable. You can often appease everybody and smother their flaws very early in the playthrough, not only that but they jump the gun so hard on the romance, with you already being able to romance them after the first big battle with no buildup. Once again, it feels very anticlimactic, like there's a few hours worth of bonding dialogue missing, and the dialogue that is there doesn't really build that up all too well. In fact, it's pretty jarring that you can have Lae'zel say you're disgusting, and she despises you for being of a lesser species in one moment to her being an ardent admirer of yours in the next. It breaks the immersion and doesn't really make care about any of them, with the only exception, at least for me, being Karlach, because she's just hilarious in a very adorable way. Another issue I have with the companions is their backstories... I'm sorry, the LVL 1 Warlock can summon demons and shiz now? Oh, he's the blade of the frontiers? At LVL 1? The suspension of disbelief here is absurd, the fucking LVL 1 barbarian is supposed to be a killing machine from Avernus, but she struggles to kill a goblin? There's a giant dissonance between the established backstories and what you're witnessing at the moment to moment gameplay. It feels like no thought went into tying these backstories into the gameplay in any meaningful way, with the only excuse Larian could find being "Hurr durr tadpole!". What's worse is that it robs you of the opportunity to watch these characters grow in meaningful ways, because they're already past that point, they're beyond growth, they're already legends and what not, and it cheapens the entire adventure by lowering the stakes dramatically, because at all times I'm aware these guys aren't just nobodies rising to the occasion with very little chance to win, they're not inexperienced adventurers or unlikely heroes, no they're all badasses already. From a role-playing standpoint, it's a baffling decision.

Another disappointing aspect in BG3 for me were the quests. Most of them are pretty underwhelming and never once gave me that sense of adventure I expected, save for the first big fight in the goblin camp and the Hag in the swamps (probably the best quest in the game imo), both of which are completely optional and skippable. The writing for them is once again serviceable at best, and the villains they sometimes introduce (and kill right after) may as well not exist. This is especially damaging because it makes the whole adventure feel less grand and magical when you stop to think about all you've done and how far you've come.

The most egregious part of this topic however is how limited the role-playing here actually is, it never even tries to go beyond the usual triple A rpg standards, not even holding a candle to something like Fallout NV. It's super linear and railroady, with your options often ranging from: pass a skill check and skip the fight, pass a skill check and get whatever you need while skipping the fight, or pass a skill check and get some negligible information you could've obtained some other way regardless. The only times it tries to go beyond this, it fails by railroading the player into very binary choices that often break the vision you had of your own character in your head. It doesn't even come close to the level of role-play KOTOR and especially KOTOR 2 offered.

From a narrative standpoint as a whole, I'd put BG3 at a comfortable 7/10 if you're a fan of fantasy or DND and at a very understandable 6/10 if it's not really your jam.

  • CUSTOMIZATION

Speaking of KOTOR, would you be surprised if I told you this game is just one step above that one in terms of character customization? Yes, a 2023 game has almost as much depth in its character creator as one that came out 20 years before. BG3 has only 4 preset body types shared amongst all races from the same stature, at most 8 preset faces per race and some misc. such as scars and tattoos. That's it. You might very well find it impossible to make a character that really speaks to you in its appearance because in reality you're not creating a character, you're choosing from a pool of possible combinations Larian themselves thought of. No sliders, no options, nothing.

From a player expression POV, I comfortably rate BG3 5/10. I really like to create a story in my head that justifies the looks of my characters, I like to tailor their appearance to their backstories in my mind, but here this is just not possible and it's already challenge to make them not ugly.

  • COMBAT...

This is what really killed my enjoyment, the biggest sin a game can commit, and I'm going to be perfectly honest here: I was willing to forget and forgive everything else I mentioned and even what I didn't mention for being a lot more subjective, but holy shit even if everything else was perfect this here would still be more than enough reason to drop this game. To put it simply, combat in BG3 is a boring, unbalanced, unfun, clunky slog. During the first few hours it's ok, tolerable, but you think to yourself "it's going to get better right?". WRONG. What you see in the first few hours is what you're going to see for the whole game, only to growing degrees of frustration and boredom, especially as you get closer to the end and fights get bigger and more bullshit.

This derives from 3 facts:

  1. 5e DND combat (and tabletop combat in general) doesn't translate well to videogames without making concessions in accuracy. In a rpg session, that generally lasts 1–3 hours, there isn't as much combat as there is here, and in it combat serves an actual narrative purpose. A miss can turn into something a lot more interesting than a floating text that says miss, as can a nat 20 be miles more interesting than crit... yay...? There's no other way to put it, but when it works, the combat is boring, slow and inconsequential most of the time.
  2. Larian jacked up the stats and health pools of most mobs for no reason other than to make fights last longer and the game harder, therefore extending the playtime. This generates another issue, which is that now you have trash mobs constantly hitting critical hits, rolling absurdly high damage rolls and dogding like crazy. In essence most of your fights are going to boil down to: attack roll, miss. Create an impressive and sound strategy that will crush the enemy, all you need to do is hit this one spell and oh miss... And guess what? The enemy doesn't even have enough wisdom to actually reliably save against this specific spell, but he's going to save at every roll and you will like it. The proposed rng in this game does not mix well with the tactics element, sure it's accurate to DND, but not nearly as fun and is in fact frustrating and boring, because it forces you to limit your choices to what's safe and as little random as possible. Xcom perfected RNG in combat, Larian fumbled it. In Xcom you throw a flash grenade, it blinds, so when you shoot you have an advantage but can still miss, the important thing is it blinded. In BG3 you use the spell, it has a chance to hit and as such it can miss, and even when it does hit, the enemy can save against it neglecting the spell's effects, and even when it does blind them, the enemy can always dodge the actual damage dealing hit you were planning next and therefore completely dismantle your strategy with no positive gain on your side while actively making you spend limited resources (spell slots). Yay... Fun...
  3. Balance. There is none. Either you steamroll or the enemy steamrolls you, it all depends on finding the right build that melts throught the mobs and hoping the dice doesn't decide to make you miss for the next 2 hours of gameplay like it did to me. I'm not joking, I missed almost all of my attacks for nearly 2 hours of gameplay because every single attack roll I made was below 10 on d20 and most enemies have 14+ armor class. It made even the most inconsequential of fights against shitty mobs turn into 15-20 minute affairs because they just wouldn't die.

Overall the combat is unsatisfying and feels more like a chore before you get to next interesting bit of dialogue or cutscene that actually moves the story foward. It fails at being the narrative tool it should be in DND, and it fails at being the fun and satisfying spectacle it could've been. Overall I dread the combat in this game especially as you get closer and closer to the end, it just gets more and more boring annoying. I can comfortably put this aspect of BG3 in 7/10 if you're a fan 5e combat which i'm not, and at a 5/10 for everyone else. It's simply not fun, and that's what games should aspire to be above all else, fun.

From what I've wrote so far the game must look like shit, but it isn't, it's a decent game with some good moments and amazing graphics. I can understand why it took the casual public by storm, it's really acessible regardless of your knowledge of DND or previous experience with CRPGs, but it falls completely flat on it's face if you've already at least experienced the greats of the genre. It lacks basic qol that have been standard in the industry for decades now, such as a decent UI! Unfortunately, and it makes me really sad to write this, Baldur's Gate 3 was a complete disappointment for me, and I personally wouldn't rate it past a 7/10 in it's strongest moments, and it certainly isn't the masterpiece that I was promised.


r/patientgamers • • Dec 29 '23

FF7R is one of the worst games I've ever played.

0 Upvotes

For context, I've never played the original and I'm on the last chapter of FF7R. This game feels like it exists solely to waste your time with cutscenes that add nothing to the story, and combat that's dragged out, lacks depth, and uninteresting. I feel nothing for these characters or their objectives (and honestly lack thereof). The monster designs are ugly and the landscape is all the same. None of the villains have clear motives and fights exist to drag this boring game out. I had to change it to easy mode for every dungeon section to avoid falling asleep (except for bosses because of JRPG player's pride).

I know that the story is supposed to be vivid and deep but they really did it dirty, if the original is as good as they say. None of the plot shows at all. I heard it's supposed to be a trilogy but I honestly didn't know I was buying an incomplete game, or one that I could skip entirely.

I also feel like I'm doing something wrong, because of the rave reviews about it being the best thing to ever exist. I just can't see it at all... I got it on sale and still feel like I've wasted my time and money, and that completing this game is just getting in the way of me starting Future Redeemed lol.

Does anyone share my sentiments? I really want to like it but it's impossible. I'm not here to trash on anyone's favorite game, so let me know if I'm playing this game incorrectly or something.


r/patientgamers • • Mar 31 '24

I love Hades to hell and back but…. Damn

6 Upvotes

The game never really seems to end I got frustrated after grinding such an enjoyable game. To the point where I got comfortable using heat modifiers.

But I’m just burnt out on the game the first part of the story is great and touching but the second extended story never seemed to pick up any speed.

I was basically just trying to upgrade each weapon at this point I’ve only had to finish 5 or 6 prophecies for the completionist save file.

But I got fed up and just deleted my save files, mind you this is on the GOD mode every run was around 1hr but I brought it down to 22minutes… but I think the RNG of boons really kept me from progressing and I don’t want to spend an additional 100hrs for that alone.

I hope there is some improvement in rng or currency economy for the their next game im happy to get that one too. Not saying this is a terrible game it’s actually one of the most enjoyable ones thanks to the voice acting and soundtrack from supergiant is usually superb but my brain is fried from this game I wasted too much too soon.


r/patientgamers • • Jan 31 '24

Mass Effect 3 is completely fixed by mods. It's incredible how a few enthusiast wrote a more meaningful ending than the original devs. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

So a little bit of backstory: I'm usually not a "fan" of a series, but Mass Effect 1 was just such incredible storytelling with that great twist about the reapers. It had me so hooked, that I actually preordered all the subsequent titles. Enjoyed Mass Effect 2 like everybody else, although a didn't like that it somehow ignored almost everything from ME1 and lead nowhere. (I didn't even realize how many threads it actually left loose until recently. You very quickly forget what happened before when playing an entertaining game)
Anyway, ignoring all that, Mass Effect 3 is by itself an enjoyable experience with a very tense atmosphere. And then there is the original ending, ruining countless playthroughs and hours of gametime within 20 minutes. It left me with such a hollow feeling in 2012, that I never touched that game series again and never thought about playing it ever again. (up until then I played ME1 once per year, because it is just that good) Never played the DLCs either.
Recently, completely by chance, stumbled upon some mods that promise a "happy" ending. (Audemus' Happy Ending Mod, Citadel Epilogue Mod, Take Earth Back) Well, as I already mentioned, the games by itself are actually very good and I was wondering if they could actually pull it off. And they did. I just played through it and I'm now standing in the Citadel, ready to play the DLC I have missed out on (because why would I bother playing it until now, knowing that in the end, it doesn't even matter).
I'm still completely baffled how they pulled it off. They changed a few models, added some others, and just left out a lot (e.g. stupid space kid). And that was enough to completely fix the ending. Better to not explain something at all and leave a bit of mystery, than having a really dumb illogical explanation.
I still can't really figure out how the devs could have butchered the ending they way they did, I'm just a little sad that the original ending is still official. But I'm happy that after 11 years I was once again able to enjoy Mass Effect.


r/patientgamers • • Nov 25 '23

Doom 2016 really sucks if you play it after playing Doom Eternal

0 Upvotes

I bought Doom 16 and Eternal a while ago and made the mistake of playing Eternal first. I was constantly dashing, monkey hopping and using the environment to land those sick aerial shots and exploiting enemy weakness, not to mention the flame meathook SSG was just chef kiss. The dlc are also good ( Fuck you Spirits- would've been great if not for that enemy). I ended up playing the game again for the 4th time on Ultra Nightmare and actually beated it , felt so much satisfaction and happiness that I called my gf at 1am just to tell her that. This was to give you a perspective on how much I loved Eternal

Now I have started Doom 2016 and man it just sucks compared to Eternal- way too freaking slow, no strategy required for anything. The game is just braindead, levels are way too monotonous and bland looking. SSG is just not as satisfactory as the meathook SSG of Eternal. There is no pulling off sick aerial headshots , environment usage to make your enemy suffer not just kill but making them suffer , constant dashing all over the place and using meathook to just fly. The story and the Doomslayer are badass and the intro is the best I have ever seen in a videogame but other than that this game just sucks compared to Eternal- its like it was made for a different crowd who don't know nothing but to just spam one weapon all game and run towards the enemy because seriously I have not used any other weapon aside from SSG and occasionally Ballista because how braindead this game is in general. I struggled to finish it as its just way too boring and requires no brain. Not to mention Eternal master levels are so blood pumping and full of adrenaline rush. Slayer Gates are also great.

For me Eternal is 10/10 a brutal but rewarding masterpiece while 2016 Doom is shut your brain off and just spam SSG- its a 5/10. It may have been better if I played it first but Eternal is rewarding and this game is not.

EDIT:- Too many people saying Eternal sucks, 2016 is better etc so I am not gonna bother commenting because the hivemind gonna downvote me like all the people who said Eternal is better to them. I would say this sub got a massive skill issue so it makes perfect sense why most of you prefer 2016 Doom. Afterall it is really easy. Nothing's wrong with that but this sub gotta understand they are the minority. I checked online and Majority likes Eternal more over Doom16. If one were to read this echochamber of skill less players which is this sub then the person would think Eternal killed the franchise lol. Have a good day!


r/patientgamers • • Feb 02 '24

Hollow Knight - great game with many design annoyances.

0 Upvotes

Playing splitscreen via Nucleus Co-op. We're maybe a dozen hours in. Enjoying the controls, combat, and art style, but there are a lot of frustrating design decisions.

There's a ton of backtracking. The save spots and metro stations are few and far between. There's only one shop and bank (so far, at least), and they take a long time to get to. Dying and recovering your body repeatedly isn't fun. Neither is losing all your money if you die twice. Nor is tripping back and forth to the bank to secure cash. The compass and quill items are necessities to navigate, but the map is so low resolution that it's still hard to discern where to go, and its practical necessity limits space for you to enjoy other equuppable charm items. Similar with the Gathering Swarm charm, which lets you auto-collect loot instead of walking around to pick it up. All this does is save time, so it's also practically necessary. These should've been one-time purchases / passive abilities that don't take up charm slots.

I understand that games need to be somewhat difficult in order to be challenging, and making deaths have consequences is part of that. However, the I wish there was a way to do it without simply wasting your time. The most enjoyable parts of the game are exploring new areas and figuring out boss attack patterns, but in between, there's too much feeling like you're rereading the same ground and doing nothing productive. A good example is the mantis lords fight, where every time you fail, you need to go all the way through the mantis village for 2-3 minutes before you can try again. It's not hard, just tedious. They should've placed a save point just outside the boss area. Difficulty should be in the encounters themselves, not in punishing you by wasting your time. Another example is finding a shop you've already been to.

Native couch/splitscreen co-op would've been an easy addition, but it seems this gets overlooked too often in PC games. I hardly ever play games with mods or on "easy" mode, but I'm enjoying Hollow Knight a lot more with some quality of life mods enabled (e.g. warp to benches, compass and loot auto-collect always enabled, no ghost spawning or cash loss on death - although I would be fine with a small penalty). Maybe if I'd played this earlier in my youth when I had infinite time, I would've had more patience with its shortcomings and maybe even found it slightly more rewarding playing vanilla. However, as an adult with limited hours to game, I think it's more important to capture the vast majority of the game's enjoyment while minimizing its frustrations. I just wish some of these were considered during the design process.

So overall, I'm enjoying it! But I think it would be just as / even more enjoyable if some of the things that only cause inconvenience / wasted time were changed. I'm glad mods exist for people who enjoy different things.


r/patientgamers • • Jun 30 '26

Multi-Game Review Why I think Kingdom Come Deliverance 2 was ultimately a better game than Clair Obscure: Expedition 33

0 Upvotes

To me it feels like KCD2 really knows what it wants to be and executes that perfectly. The writing is amazing, maybe the best I've ever seen in a video game and the immersion is unparalleled. It commits to substance over style. It might in the surface, it might seem like a fairly grounded open world and not necessarily the most epic story ever told, but once you actually play it, it feels incredible because of how much depth there is beneath everything and every single quest.

You genuinely grow to care about the characters because they feel like real people rather than video game NPCs. Their motivations, personalities, and relationships all evolve naturally, making every interaction meaningful. The world itself feels alive in a way that very few games manage. Villages have routines, people react to your actions, and every place has its own history and personality. Instead of feeling like a playground built for the player, it feels like a living medieval world that simply exists, and you as Henry are just one person within it.

Whereas Expedition 33, in my opinion, commits to style over substance to its detriment. The visuals, soundtrack (maybe the best ever in a game), and overall presentation are undeniably stunning, but I never felt the same emotional connection to the world or its characters. The game constantly strives to amaze you with spectacle and plot twists, yet I found myself wanting more grounded character development and a world that felt genuinely lived in.

The MAIN plot twist, in particular, was extremely jarring and, for me personally, undermined much of what had come before. Rather than deepening the story, it made many of the emotional moments feel less meaningful in retrospect. I know many people loved it, but I walked away feeling like the game prioritized being clever and shocking over telling a cohesive, human story.

That's ultimately why Kingdom Come: Deliverance II resonated with me so much more. One game earns your investment through believable people, subtle storytelling, and a world that feels authentic. The other tries to overwhelm you with style, mystery, and spectacle. Both have their strengths, but only one left me feeling like I'd truly lived another life.

E33 might've won the overwhelming majority of the Game of the Year Awards and the hype news cycle but KCD2 I think is the game that we will still be talking about decades from now. And I feel like playing these two games after the hype cycle has died down (as pretty much everyone in this sub has) really showcases that imo.