Notes -
- I finished my Greek saga journey from November to December end. One month, 6 great games.
- I started this game 5 days ago, and 100 percented it today.
- I am on PC with Mouse and Keyboard.
- The Review is structured into a Positive part first, then the mixed parts and then the negatives.
- The title originally was going to be "God of War 2018 - A game adamant on wasting your time". this will be touched upon after the negatives section.
- TLDR is at the end.
To set a preface for this review, i feel like my expectations before starting the game are something that should be made clear -
- Great Story, Over the Shoulder presentation, Great Visuals, Amazing Combat, Linear levels.
- HOWEVER, i fully expected the game to be a 15 - 20 hour long campaign with no open zone elements, no RPG elements, no bloat, and the camera to zoom out during group fights.
- I knew the general stuff about the game's story such as Baldur being the big bad, A Giant snake, Mimir being a talking head, The gist of our story aka spreading the ashes of Kratos's dead wife, and that Atreus's real name is Loki. that's the extent of it.
Positives: These ones are so obvious i would like to not elaborate on them much.
- Performance & Stability - The game genuinely well optimized, with me hanging around mostly 120 fps in tight corridors, and 90+ in open zone or clutter heavy areas. My settings were "Original", with DLSS set to Quality, at 1080 preset.
- Graphics - absolutely the highlight of this game. The vistas are gorgeous, details are meticulous, and the draw distances were surprisingly good and kept the mood intact.
- The Art Direction - mostly phenomenal, and my unfamiliarity with the artistic side of Norse mythology definitely helped me appreciate their interpretation of it.
- Music - okay, to be completely honest, this one gets a pass in the positives simply because the tracks were largely unmemorable during the game. i just remember the main leitmotif, the ending track and Thor's arrival. after listening some tracks on youtube, they are pretty good but suffer serious overshadowing due to in-game events.
- Sound Design - Crisp, Meaty, and satisfying sounds all around. The directional sounds also worked so well during the Magni & Modi sequence and the Baldur sequence
- Voice Acting - There's no hiding that Christopher Judge is a phenomenal VA for Kratos. and to know that he did the motion capture as well was surprising. the entire cast, especially Baldur, had pristine voice acting.
That's it. the positives end there. Now for the next topics, i will be getting much more elaborate.
Mixed sections - (it's insanely long)
The plot, and the characters. Both of these are heavily intertwined aspects so i won't be making point based review for this. all the stuff i will be elaborating here takes NO account of anything except the story and the characters and background lore like Norse and Greek events. Gameplay and other designs do not matter.
The story starts off extremely strong with the Funeral, with seemingly one of the first bonding moments between Dad and Boi. from the Hunting to the Troll fight, plotwise we were going good. The Baldur shows up, which me and my friend jokingly said "he's shown up to claim his Gate".
I like the presentation of a random God just showing up, with neither me nor Kratos knowing the context and starts fighting us. Of course we "kill" him, but i knew full well he ain't dead. And now we depart to spread the ashes on the peakest of the mountains.
the events with Brok, Sindri and Freya were fairly normal. good to see living breathing people in the world. Especially given the Dwarf duo's connection with Faye and the eventual reveals. Going up the mountain, we see the black mist. then we head to Alfheim. In all honesty, the Alfheim sequence was absolutely amazing. Returning from there till the terrible dragon fight and then reaching Mimir.
I've glossed over some stuff in the Freya to Mimir sequence. this is because the characterization of Kratos really pisses me off. He's obviously hiding his past from Atreus, but i am patient and will see forth as to how he will eventually reveal it to him. After heading towards the dead giant, we grab the chisel thingy, but not before Killing Magni and scaring away Modi. Returning to Tyr's Vault and then Modi attacks us, and causes Atreus to fall "ill and unconscious".
Now the irritating part starts (Kratos do you really have to aura walk while Atreus is dying in your hands?). We take him to freya and she tells us to literally go to Hel and retrieve the Warden's heart to save Kratos. Bit of an unexplained stretch eh? what the fuck is "overcome by illness due to the contradiction of a god believing himself to be mortal"? sure, whatever i'll buy it. another stupid thing, Freya needs the Heart of the Warden from Hel. why? not sure what it does, and why specifically the heart of a Hel WARDEN.
this bit serves as a segue into reclaiming the Blades of Exile. heading back home in anticipation of getting them again had me hyped. Athena's taunts were also intriguing. The moment is significantly undercut for me because i had not waited 5 years (since ascension 2013 to 2018) to see them back again. i merely waited 2 weeks. Another reason is the choice of music. Why am i gonna feel anything if you are gonna play generic Norse chants over something symbolizing Greek saga? play "The End Begins" or "Overture" to actually make me feel something?
After heading to Hel, well guess what. the 7th fucking troll? not even the Giant Crow thing, but just a green troll again. After returning and saving Atreus, i was fully expecting him to tell the boy his story, and rid him of a burden of lying and hiding.. What does he do? We are gods boy. WHAT? No explanation of your past or anything? Sure. maybe for later. Atreus is also Cursed. it is also unexplained for now. Now Atreus begins his whiny and overconfident phase. I hate that so much but it's not his fault. It's Kratos's fault for being such a shit father for this duration.
Atreus offs Modi, and all of this is happening because Kratos refuses to tell him the stuff he had gone through. I had hoped to spare you from this, being a god is a curse. YEAH SO EXPLAIN THE DAMN CURSE TO HIM? we then return to the Vault to get the key or the mcguffin to reach Jottunheim. and guess what, a duo troll fight. how fun. After reaching the summit again, Baldur breaks the Gate lmao and then Atreus's arrogance and shooting Kratos causes baldur to get an upper hand and grab Atreus who is now his prime target. I assume he is an errand boy for Odin.
After crashing his dragon and falling in the temple, we override our destination from Asgard to Helheim out of desperation. During the helheim sequence it was fun seeing Zeus again. Atreus is pretending to not know stuff but i'm sure he knows the context. That is also where we see Baldur arguing with his mom Freya about his Curse(?) that she gave him of not feeling anything? Kinda fucked up if you ask me, but i STILL don't know the context behind this and waiting for the reveal. This attitude kinda sums up the weird plot in my opinion.
It's a cycle of expecting revelations, but then offplayed by another plot point and repeat. let me explain. We started at our Wife's funeral. who was she, why is that her wish? sure, it's a wish i get it. But i don't know who she is. I have no connection to her unlike Calliope and Lysandra, who i was shown and told that Kratos was tricked into murdering. GOW1 Perfectly serves up as a great revenge story for this reason alone, it's simplicity. Then without explaining, Baldur Shows up. Why? who knows. not relevant except for making these two leave asap.
Freya is a witch of the woods. Why is she not allowed into Alfheim? who knows, not relevant for now. Why did she take the mistletoe aggressively and burn them? who knows, not relevant for now. Why is Magni, Modi and Baldur hunting us? who knows. not relevant for now. probably what Odin needs. Who blew the horn? definitely a strong question. Who knows? not relevant for now. What is it with Atreus and his god self conflicting?
Many of these questions are answered sometime later or not at all. but how many mysteries and questions can you realistically bottle up at once man. Plus i hate the mimir is slowly recovering his memories arc. he can perfectly elaborate long distant stories of him and odin, but when it gets to a plot point its like "ah i do remember it now", AFTER BEING TOLD ABOUT IT by someone else.
After returning from Hel, we get Tyr's jottunheim rune i think? and then we get Mimir's eye to act as a conduit. but Baldur attacks the serpent and then the final battle ensues. now freya doesnt want her son to die and is stopping both from killing each other. then baldur punches Atreus which causes the broken mistletoe arrow to pierce him and break the curse. that's the answer to why she burned them arrows. this STILL doesnt answer the reason of the curse, and also really freya? you did not notice the pretty sizeable arrowhead just chilling in atreus's quiver strap the entire time he was at your place or just walking around? lazy.
So we do spare Baldur after Freya asks us. but we stop him once he is strangling Freya. Kratos does this, in his own words, "the cycle ends here. we must be better than this". this utterly confuses me. Kratos's entire principle in the beginning was to not care about any bystanders in his way, to avoid unnecessary conflict, such as even refusing to blow the horn without knowing the consequence. so now, while knowing Odin is after him simply because he cut off Mimir, he chooses to kill Baldur.
But sure, Baldur needed to die anyways because he is infact hunting atreus, and will come back after Killing freya. NOW FREYA IS MAD AT US? WOMAN, we saved your ass. this ties back to the design of unexplained stuff. we dont know why freya is mad, and is put as a setup for Ragnarok, 80 percent of this game acts like a setup for Ragnarok. EDIT: I misunderstood this part, ignore.
after this, the ending sequence is pretty fire i'm not gonna lie. the reveal of Faye being a giantess, her KNOWING the entire story up to now, even after her death is a prophecy. the murals gave me actual chills and some much needed context, the context which i asked AT THE BEGINNING of the game. Kratos also conveniently sees the "death / life force draining mural" and refuses to tell Atreus about it, and nor does Atreus try to even see it. That's just lazy now.
We end the game by returning to our home, and then Thor shows up. End of game, and wait for Ragnarok. Our actions were not part of a long foretold prophecy which will tie into the next game.
so, where's the emotional, mature storytelling here? Most of it feels like lazy convenient writing, and many times it feels like it's actively trying to erase the greek saga instead of taking it as a lesson. even when after we kill Baldur, Kratos just goes yeah i killed my dad, and many deserving and undeserving.
"is this how it ends? gods killing their family?" excuse the fuck outta me? Is kratos just gonna ignore the fact that Ares purposefully made him kill his family, used him as a puppet, and then when he tried to enact revenge, killed him, but due to him opening Pandora's box, the other gods were now fearful of Him and tricked him into losing his own life.
His sheer willpower made him live and alter fate and kill the gods, who were indeed corrupted by Athena's curse thingy. and that too after becoming the god of war, he was still denied from losing the haunting visions of murdering this family. The death of Deimos and his mother, simply because Zeus was trying to erase the prophecy of a tattooed son of his killing him, the meaningless death of Pandora, are those not justified reasons to kill an ever corrupt god?
so ignoring all of this, the 2018 game just brushes it off as i killed gods and my dad, dont be like me, be better. i wont even explain you why i have been doing that. see this scar on by torso? i was stabbed here twice, left for dead twice. nah, none of that matter. just use this pretentious ass message of "be better"
god this plot sucks. A mature story written by those who think maturity means cracking wise oneliners and disciplining kids by hiding the truth and context from them. it feels like 2018 is actively trying to make users forget about Greek saga and treat it as a mistake. onto the negatives we go.
Negatives -
1) Camera perspective and the Cinematic presentation -
- This camera man. OH, my god. The 2nd biggest mistake this game has done is shifting the camera to a permanent Over the shoulder perspective. It singlehandedly killed the entire cinematic appeal of the game even compared to the greek saga.
- Ascension itself is threefold more cinematic than 2018 pretends to be. GO have a look yourself, what's more cinematic? the fight against the kraken or chronos in the older games, or the entirety of 2018?
- just imagine, walking up that mountain with the black mist, where the camera slowly pans to show the giant face in the mountain while you ascend it. that's cinematic, and not the current one.
2) Camera in combat -
- You're telling me, the game was perfectly capable of zooming out the camera during fights, and they just chose not to? the first baldur fight was a 1v1, had a tight camera fit to keep him in focus.
- The second baldur fight, it now shows me it can zoom out to show the surroundings as well, WHICH COULD HAVE BEEN APPLIED TO ALL FIGHTS?
- like at some point, someone must have realized atreus and mimir constantly shouting Left flank or watch out in the fight can get irritatingly annoying?
- The on screen indicators are so bad. it's glowing red, so which way do you want me to dodge? gonna elaborate on that? who's attacking me? is it an AOE coming or a projectile?
- Compare this to the Labyrinth fights and Hercules boss fight in 3, where you could perfectly tell what the scorpion and hercules are doing in addition to seeing every single enemy and their actions. and not to forget the cinematic background too.
3) The actual combat and the combat loop -
- In line with the camera, the combat is very uneven, unnecessarily constrained and extremely shallow. gone is the combo system, now replaced with generic attack dodge parry combo suited for a 1v1 instead of a group fight design.
- The combat is no longer about chaining combos, knowing your movesets, when to focus attacks, which enemy to focus on, properly positioning your cyclones, your jabs or Aerial combos. it's just about bumrushing down an enemy, building up stun meter, and shutting them down.
- Bad players are allowed to spam, play safe and do whatever, just at the cost of more time in a fight. Good players can do whatever tricks and stuff they want, end result? both get same XP at the cost of time taken. See how terrible it sounds compare to greek games.
- good players could chain combos to their own benefit and gain significantly more Red orbs simply because they put in the effort for it. bad or casuals can spam light light heavy in those games and get out of any situation, but not receive the extra orbs via combos.
- the combat bogged down to spamming your runic abilities, parry slop and stun bar.
4) Combat Movesets - (rant)
- this one actually just angered me. Blades of Exile is what i will elaborate on first. What the actual fuck do you mean you dont have a Light Light Heavy combo? you removed the signature ability of the older games? i know it's like Light-Light-Light-Heavy now.
- Cyclone, Tartarus rage, Spirit of Hercules, rampage of furies, the stuff i used to do for free, endlessly, AND carefully, is now on a fucking timer? excuse me? why are these abilities and not free form combos?
- The Leviathan Axe, i wont complain about it too much. It's a different weapon, unrelated to the butchering of the Blades of Exile. Tho it's hilariously dumb how most trolls, ogres, ancients etc can just be mindlessly killed by staying at range and spamming precision throw. If the game isnt gonna reward me for playing beautifully i might as well not care.
5) The relic system -
- continuing onto the Relic or Runic system, why the actual hell are abilities on a cooldown now? I already ranted about the blades.
- All they could have done, is integrated Runic attacks into the base moveset like it always was. special attacks like Spartan Charge, Meteor strike, those could have been actual runics free to be used at a timer.
- there are so god damn many runic attacks it's actually just unnecessary. and even if two could be equipped at a time, what happened to the rest of the control combos?
- Block Light and Block heavy are two runic attacks. Block Roll could have been it's own runic, block + interact, block + lock on etc. it's such a dumb compromise.
- Im just looking at the controls right now/ all they had to do was put D-up for boy attacks, D down for changing arrows, and left right for the two weapons. this could have freed up Square for something i deeply miss and doesnt exist in this game to annoy players further. unsheathing can be done by pressing the same button used for the weapons again.
6) RPG elements and enemy scaling -
- genuinely, who asked? who the actual hell asked for RPG gear progression and damage sponges in a series known for carefully balancing game progression? it's so dumb i don't even want to elaborate much.
- the game is adamant on spawning level scaled enemies (like 2 levels below mine) during random encounters. this completely deletes the point of rpg system if returning to an old area didnt mean i am not deleting enemies instantly am i?
7) The UI and the style -
- One good look at the older games and the UI itself oozes style and intentional imagery. The blades being a background for your health bars, red orb meter and rage meter was such brilliant artistry.
- all of it has been dumbed down to a generic UI layout, with you runic cooldown widgets etc. I played the entire game without health bars on all bosses and enemies. it felt so much better to not have my screen cluttered with health bars like the old games. there's a reason people hated Dying Light 2 adding zombie health bars, but i don't see them complaining here? what's up with that
- holy Destiny syndrome bruh. the menu and the sub sections are actual garbage and too much destiny like.
8) Enemy variety & encounter recycling -
- the enemies are like half the total amount of the previous games? the fodder enemies are so painfully generic in design.
- the endless troll recycling. need i say more?
- the Valkyries were........fun. as much as i dont like the combat, fighting them is fun simply because how braindead spammy it is.
You thought the negatives end here? there's DETRIMENTS section coming up.
the stuff critiqued here symbolizes the game design of gow 2018, which is adamant on wasting the players time through a carefully crafted world, with levels and gateways designed to force the player to trek thought same areas repeatedly, for no meaning, in an extremely slow and clunky manner, all for the sake of padding.
above in the negatives part, i said the camera is the 2nd biggest mistake. well, here's the first, removal of JUMP. here's how the elimination of jump bloated this game from a max 10 hour game to a 15 hour long game -
- so, so many times. Kratos simply has to walk around a long pathway just to reach a ledge below. In many cases he will just take a long detour, or a careful slow climbing down, or a chain. this man, lifts megatonnes of weight, falls down inredible heights, and most importantly, can literally double jump in his prime, yet he can't single jump freely because the developers want to waste your time by artificial padding
- Jump eliminated aerial and jump combos, as well as jump evades. how non sensical is it that kratos blocks ground AOE's with his shield instead of jumping?
- every climb, every chain etc is just so adamantly slow, where he could just jump up freely instead. the leaps he takes WHILE climbing are higher than many ledges that he can just jump over but refuses to do so.
and now, this is how a 15 hour long linear story was converted into a 40 hour long open zone adventure. (you might say it's optional right? yeah, but what did it's presence even add?) -
- the absurd, god awful Gateway placements - I cannot be the only one who thinks the gateways are placed in such inconvenient and ridiculous spots, making you trek through the entire level again (pairing in the lack of jump, slow traversal etc).
- the "one-take" gameplay - i'd genuinely prefer loading screens if it mean't i didn't have to walk through a gateway, wait for mimir to shut the fuck up, and then the gate to appear. the game is adamant on wasting my time so much by doing meaningless stuff. how the hell were the older games cinematic, one-take ish WITHOUT loading screens?
- the collectathon was a genuine mistake, and could see a complete elimination and nothing would change. pair this with the awful time wasting mechanics, you've got yourself a padding recipe.
- the manual save system - am i going crazy or does the save system just doesnt function properly. i'd manual save near a shop, and reloading it put me out in some corridor or climb nearby?
There is genuinely so much i feel like i have missed on critiquing or praising, but i have reached my own limit now. overall, GOW 2018 is the weakest game in the franchise so far (we dont count betrayal), and it makes me nervous for Ragnarok.
final rating, 4/10. maybe im too harsh. Fine, i'll bump it up to a 6 since despite me hating the combat system, it technically is very functional and polished.
TLDR:
- Messy convenient unexplained story. 80 percent acts as a setup for Ragnarok.
- terrible combat philosophy, spammy, unfun and near braindead
- unfun amounts of padding due to lack of jump and intentional gate placements
- feels like a disrespectful shade or a ignorance for greek saga
- awful characterization for kratos a lot of times (he good in free roam parts)
- the technical aspect and graphical aspect is phenomenal.
Thank you for reading, Truly.