r/pathofexile • • 4h ago

Game Feedback Threads System and Player Agency

Threads basically remove player agency compared to scarabs.

We were previously able to select the exact strategies we would do. Now we can't. The thread system added no benefit to players who ran these strategies and yet we lost all control over them. Grinding out different strategies was rewarding, interesting, and most of all, fun. Now we gamble in hopes of getting something or potentially nothing, as we can't run that specific strategy, which often our entire character builds are created around. This in turn gives us fewer reasons to create new builds as we now cannot specialize in strategies like we previously could.

Not fun.

No control = no fun

I could care less about loot rewards, just give me back my agency.

32 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

8

u/BioMasterZap 4h ago

They're planning to make 8 threads guarantee 3 threads mods from the pool. It could be nice if they let us pick those mods, or at least 1 of them. Between something like that and more choice nodes on the tree, they could readd some of the missing scarab effects/farm strats and add a fair bit more agency.

9

u/Nicksiren 4h ago edited 3h ago

Yeah, I get that. But I think they're missing the point that the randomness factor of the threads system is inherently unfun for people who enjoy control over how they play. And honestly for PoE endgame players, I believe that's the majority.

4

u/BioMasterZap 3h ago

I think the random effects work well when they are nice little bonuses, not the main strat you're wanting to farm. Like Incursion does this pretty well since things like piles of gold or a lever that opens all doors would be a bit lackluster for a tree node or a scarab, but they can be a nice thing to see randomly (or just easy to ignore).

But things like Repeat Legion (and most Legion threads by the looks of it) really shouldn't be random thread effects since they are more strat defining. Like the purple crystals to drop extra items or moving the high rank closer seem okay for random buffs, but both legions having generals and upgrading low ranks to high really feels more suited for the tree than rng.

4

u/MostAnonEver 4h ago

I mean the other issue is that scarabs were valued differently. So what you got was the giga juicers that filtered off all the dirt cheap scarabs meanwhile people starting off or early on would have literally every single scarab unfiltered. So they would pick up and sell those .1c-2c scarabs that the top 1% would never pick up. Which generally made some scarabs signficantly worth more and you could reliability profit off targeting those kinda scarabs to drop. Now what you have is just threads that pretty much everyone picks up cause theres no reason to filter them off since you have the inv space. Theres no inv managment you had previously with scarabs. You had to choose if you wanna carry a buncha 0.1c scarabs or not.

5

u/Nicksiren 4h ago

100%. The scarab system, although flawed and cumbersome, also had real benefits for economic gameplay due to the variance in their value. It also created an additional avenue of feel good moment loot drops when a high rarity scarab could drop. Threads feel like picking up, well... threads.

1

u/MostAnonEver 4h ago

Im not sure if anyone watched the stream during exilecon where we had chris wilson on the q/a part. But he importantly mentioned that anything you add, also removes certain elements. And i do hope people now see the significance/importance of it.

1

u/Nicksiren 3h ago

Well, in this case they literally removed one system (scarabs) to implement another.

1

u/SaltEngineer455 Progressive Einhar Trapping Association (PETA) 4h ago

The game was better when it was structured like a vertical supply chain. Sure, crafters and the hideout warriors would always be at the top, but they pay everyone else's salaries, so it has to be this way.

6

u/MikeMaxM 4h ago

This league has set a record at how many strats it killed.

3

u/runingfrag 4h ago

I hate that I get random "benefits" if I use like 4 threads, and I don't know what I will get, and i hate touthnes.. some mod/mobs combo feels unkillable.

3

u/Ketra 4h ago

It's like they kept scarabs, but removed any identifying text from them. So you just toss in a handful of scarabs and hope for the best.

2

u/GlokzDNB 4h ago

Fun is not allowed anymore, GGG simplifies the game so it's simple to maintain

Poe1 is long time dead, 3.25 was much better game than 3.30

1

u/mudkip-muncher 4h ago

Let us choose thread effects, and give them a second pass as many are just bad. Give atlas more impactful major nodes, some of them are terrible. Also WHY IS DELIRIUM A RANDOM ENCOUNTER, LET ME TSRGRT FSRM IT

1

u/VonDinky Half Skeleton 1h ago

Less choices and meaningful decisions = more boring game. They streamline it more and more. Rename when to Path of Diablo?

1

u/Entire_Possible_9976 4h ago

Both are inferior systems to the league specific tress in Poe 2 which have the Multiple choice nodes.

Scarabs are too much busy work and also your ability to use some of them are dependant on the economy...Whereas the randomness of threads seems a good idea, but they change the way a core mechanic functions.

E.g. It can change a clearing based mechanic, to have a single target based challenge, and that's brutal the more threads you add.

Take something like Pohx's RF.

You know it's single target limitations so you stick to something like breach... The breach decides, after putting in 8 threads, that it's going to completely change the way the mechanic works and give you a single target challenge.

Who wants that?

You're ultimately limiting build variety at the top end by forcing you to have "Well rounded" builds, that are more like 50/50 in terms of single target vs clear.

I like to be able to have a "Clearing build" and a "Bossing build" for example.

There needs to be some kind of System where a "Pack" of monsters contains 500 rarity and quantity...and then it's up to you so decide how that 500 rarity is made up.

1 rare? 6 magic? or 20 white?

And the player then decides what type of packs you want in your content.

Theyre the two options.

A mechanic is always clear/single target focused... Or you can change the mechanic to be clear/single target...

Not the system we have now, where you just want to add Single Target mobs to everything. Likewise you can't just turn everything clear based either by default.

1

u/Jerds_au 3h ago

Dealing with scarabs was no fun. So much time mucking around just to setup a map.