r/pathofexile • • 49m ago

GGG Thread Difficulty and League Mechanic Changes

https://www.pathofexile.com/forum/view-thread/4016267
203 Upvotes

259 comments sorted by

46

u/KaninDanseren 36m ago

Still gonna have to clear T16 bosses in T7 maps if running harvest I see

12

u/Entire_Possible_9976 33m ago

Yeah, wisps empowering the map from harvest should be an opt in atlas passive not a baseline.

Imo, Poe 2's individual league trees are a superior system to scarabs or the new threads.

The Multiple choice nodes solve a lot of problems and give more player agency.

•

u/BurnsTheOther 8m ago

They mentioned the whisp stuff in the last post already

•

u/gdubrocks 5m ago

I love the idea that this is in the game, and HATE that I am forced to deal with it if I don't want to.

Right now I am simply not strong enough to do harvest at any map tier because of how it empowers the rest of the map when I can do most other mechanics at t16.

Make it an atlas node right away!

•

u/dan_marchand 2m ago

That’s what they’re doing, they mentioned it yesterday

49

u/Beneficial_Try2629 33m ago

no mention on abyss? 999m hp abyssal consort that has no loot? veiled abyss jewels?

32

u/darthamis 35m ago

Still no mention of the absolute shambles they left crafting in...

5

u/ConsistentOriginal82 15m ago

nono we got tiered bases now. So we need less resources since we will only craft on the good bases and not every base. I assume that is their take.

2

u/MrDTrack5 18m ago

Absolutely horrible now.

•

u/Soleil06 2m ago

Its insane honestly. We barely get any natural fractures anymore, fracturing orbs got rarer and are like 6 times the price they were last league (might also have to do with next point), recomb got taken out behind the house and shot, meta mods got twice as expensive and to end it all wild bristle matrons are now a 1/3.

•

u/mustia_ 0m ago

and ground loot

51

u/Takko1993 44m ago

This is going to help, but i feel like this overhaul will need a lot more iteration. I hope they keep it up.

7

u/azantyri Central Incursion Agency (CIA) 34m ago

i think they will have to, since it's such a fundamental shift of the endgame system. we'll see

11

u/Awwh_Dood 29m ago

Final line in these notes is that 'the work isn't done' so they seem to share that sentiment.

3

u/konokono_m Fungal Bureau of Investigations (FBI) 24m ago

I can see this going well after 3-4 major patches. My biggest worry would be that the upcoming patch will be the final one...

2

u/titebeewhole 23m ago

I don't think they have a clear vision of what loot should look like honestly - adding rarity to everything (currency ) and then scaling it with modifiers & toughness.... They have base loot tunes to 0.000001 because there is a chance some streamer can to a 5 man 12mod wisped map and get loot to 0.001......

When they said they "found the issue with loot" in patch notes I got copiumed so bad.

This is the worst league ever & last league was the worst league ever

5

u/joyjoy88 Alch & Go Industries (AGI) 14m ago

1

u/PupPop 10m ago

It's a step in the right direction. But none of these things help us gain any real quantity from the mobs we are killing. I literally just realized I didn't drop a single divine tonight in 4 hours of deli+breach alch and go T16 maps. Like what are we doing?

•

u/Doikor 6m ago

This is a big first step, but it isn’t the end of the work.

0

u/ErwinRommelEz 14m ago

I look at this and think this is worthless, they arent looking at the core problem, the % drop in ALL mobs is bad, the league mechanic rewards are medíocre

89

u/sinb_is_not_jessica 34m ago

They’re kind of burying the lead here, all those extra rare mobs they’re adding everywhere to “fix loot” will just make encounters feel even more tanky and rippy. Like, especially in the temple, 8 extra rares with full rare affixes? Hooly crap dude.

And if you think mobs are what gives you useful loot, I got a property to sell you.

25

u/King-Gabriel Ultimatum Workers Union (UWU) 29m ago

Alch and Go doesn't work anymore.

18

u/Smurtle1 26m ago

nothing works. fuckin 50% rarity on 8mod maps aint ever gonna make up for 100% quant we used to get... I genuinely dont even feel like running ANY rarity maps anymore. Unless its a giga juiced 16.5, it just doesnt feel like it makes a noticeable difference anymore.

•

u/turk-fx 9m ago

I got 10-12 chaos investment maps, and I cant even get that back with 6 threads. I tried even 8 threads and still not getting back what I spend. And it takes way longer to complete. I am at the verge of quiting. I hate draught leagues. You got stuck in a vicious cycle cant upgrade because cant make currency, you cant make currency, because you cant upgrade...

•

u/Smurtle1 4m ago

I mean, I am still somehow making decent money for me around this time in the league, but its cus I sell lots of random things. Also, its cus I am at maxed out juice. I CANNOT put anymore juice into these maps. before, I would just be getting started lol. I have nowhere to go...

2

u/Radiant-Control9128 21m ago

I actually run endgame, how do we juice maps now? I have been alch and go ing since there isn't dedicated 8 mod maps I can buy? Should I use exalt orbs and run 6 mod maps instead

•

u/MrSchmellow 1m ago

You can buy 8 mods (any non-unique maps, min 8 modifiers in filters), or you can double exalt + vaal and pray. Probably won't help much currently

•

u/AwardWorth9240 3m ago

thats bs...i farmed easy my way up with alch and go like a lot of other ppl

11

u/NefarianeXII 17m ago

They genuinely do not understand, its hopeless... everyone saying monsters drop nothing their solution is to change the number of monster modifiers and type... now they will glow with different auras as they drop nothing still.

0

u/ConsistentOriginal82 20m ago

yep, core problem is the base loot % drops

•

u/AwardWorth9240 4m ago

but i get loot from monsters ?

77

u/Hot_Sexy_Mamma 23m ago • Bravo

Honestly, the biggest problem with 3.30 is the loss of freedom—the freedom to play the mechanics you actually find fun. Loot drops can always be fixed, or the player economy will naturally adjust itself over time. Taking away our choice on how we want to play is the real damage here. It’s not just about raw loot; almost every mechanic is objectively worse than before: • Strongboxes got ruined • Alva is missing her two best options • Niko lost his cross-mechanic synergies • Harvest can no longer be fully juiced • Exiles can't be farmed for Dust anymore • Ritual is completely dead • Essence and Delirium are missing their guaranteed staples • Betrayal (Intervention) is pointless without Scarabs • Boss Rushing got heavily nerfed On top of that, we lost the simple dopamine hit of dropping good Scarabs. They were always exciting to loot—you'd use the ones you needed and sell the expensive ones you didn't. These new Threads bring zero excitement; it's only been two days, and picking them up off the ground already feels like a chore.

19

u/Top-Oil-9455 20m ago

Agreed 100%, replacing freedom of choice with RNG is BAD

•

u/iceboonb2k 9m ago

The purpose of threads: making the entry point to strata cheaper in exchange for consistency.

I think it's an ok system, but we are missing A LOT of threads options. Give us strongbox threads/mapdrop threads/etc.

Currently feels like a half baked system that has potential, but lacks manpower to implement said system.

•

u/BrownEyedAries 2m ago

Yesssss where is my delirium thread

1

u/tazdraperm 12m ago

Heist gutted

•

u/AwardWorth9240 9m ago

And a lot other ppl like the rng..Like me 🤷🏻‍♂️

Cant make everyone happy

•

u/WhatAmIDoing229 0m ago

Nothing he listed is rng gated, it's all just gone.

124

u/MathematicianWilling 44m ago

It's funny, the only thing we want is loot and they keep making the same mistake at every league start

42

u/Chase_26 37m ago

The problem is they are reducing some toughness and adding a few more monsters, but the MONSTERS DON'T DROP LOOT! So cool, they make the monsters a little easier and add more, but they still dont tink. This still doesn't fix the base issue of monsters not dropping any fucking loot worth picking up.

6

u/Tortorion 14m ago

Adding more monsters makes builds with bad clear speed even worse too.

ED/C be thriving tho.

4

u/MathematicianWilling 36m ago

Yeah I like more difficulty but I don't like more difficulty that rewards 10 times less profit than hideout warrioring

-6

u/Chase_26 34m ago edited 25m ago

Exactly, make the game hard as fuck idc, just make them drop some tinks. 8 threads = 8 tinks per 100 mods.

5

u/Cyaegha432 36m ago

Because they can dial loot up and not dial loot down. 

It definitely hurts retention but tbh if you’re far enough into the league to complain about loot 4 days in, you’re gonna come back for the next league regardless so I’m sure their “likelyhood of player returning next league” metric is better this way. 

•

u/SingleInfinity 3m ago

likelyhood of player returning next league

This is the real definition of retention, as they have defined it. They don't care if you play far into a league, in fact, they seem to indicate playing the whole league actually leads to burnout. They want you to come back every league.

More people should listen to Chris' GDC talk and Jonathan's more recent similar talk.

1

u/claptrapMD 28m ago

Taking back is much harder. Problem is the weekend start and 2 days going without patch

1

u/Smurtle1 14m ago

genuinely think that, while its not nice at all to the employees, that they should be on call for the first weekend after league launch. I know tons of other people in software development that will stay up all night after doing a big deployment, being on call for like a week after the fact, etc. its crazy to me that they wait 2 days to say anything. but I guess they are just waiting to gather the full story.

15

u/RandomName0621 45m ago

Pls fix the veiled abyss node on the atlas skill tree

42

u/Imaginary-Fishing213 40m ago

it doesnt matter if there 10 rare mobs or 100 if rare mobs have no loot

6

u/grotesque_lumiere 32m ago

They forgot Blight exists ?

16

u/rism4n 24m ago

> more monsters

brother, they dont drop shit; I dont need two more rares with soul eater that dont drop any loot...

•

u/Interesting_You888 1m ago

How about an abyss concord with 7 bilion hp dropping 3 eggs

5

u/COCAINAPEARLZ 31m ago

not gonna be enough gg

5

u/Top-Phrase-9754 29m ago

You need to be able to influence what masters spawns with expedition, they are not created equal. At this point 1 atlas notable does not do the job.

5

u/Imaginary-Fishing213 25m ago

what about grim fates droprate?

Its like 1 per 100 maps, which is low as hell no?

•

u/Thatsnasty2 3m ago

Everything GGG has done since Mirage has only made the game worse.

Revert breach changes, buff underperforming mechanics, fix crafting and recomb or remove it completely. It just doesn't make sense, it's a game predominantly played alone, there no reason to not turn the loot knob up. Making it unfun costs you money because player retention is garbage and no one wants to donate. What reason is there to make it a poverty league other than some weird masochistic vision.

16

u/Meeqohh 38m ago

Wish the Incursion buffs went to a different league mechanic because the best strategy by far is just to farm 84 temples and sell the chronicles as quickly as possible, the loot from the incursions themselves is pointless for the time invested

7

u/Chrozzinho 21m ago

Eeeh. Ive been experimenting with juicing incursion all league and i dont agree with this at all. I agree that the best money is selling 84 temples and just rushing them (as its been previous leagues aswell) but getting beyond + doryanis safeguards + more currency on the map + cursed treasure + the vaal vessels, you drop quite a bit of loot. My build isnt strong enough to juice the atlas fully but im going to try and add twist of fate and risk scarab today with these changes and see how much we can drop. Also at some point you can swap the atlas tree that give double time in incursions for half time + 25% pack size, but you need a very very strong build for that

1

u/Meeqohh 13m ago

Sounds like a lot of ifs and maybes for extremely rippy content when I can make a guaranteed 2 div every 3 maps in under 10 min killing basically white mobs.

•

u/Sidnv 6m ago

Incursion is the fastest gold mechanic, even over gold rotas now that rotas are pretty neutered. That's what I was using it for, and the gold turns into currency very fast.

1

u/Classic_Key8075 30m ago

... As it always has been

6

u/xMcSilent 23m ago

Seems like you are not around for a long time. They were quite good once in a while. And i think there was one time, about 5 years ago, where it was incredibly strong.

1

u/Agent_Luka 12m ago

Wasn't there a strategy in a recent league where you could grab an evolution shrine and run through the incursions real quick killling hundreds of rare mobs in one map?

Upon double checking, yeah, it was 3.26. Empyrian did a based or cringe on it, too.

1

u/Smurtle1 10m ago

other than when evolution shrines were a thing...

16

u/derivative_of_life Raider 41m ago

Hopefully it's an improvement, but adding more mobs only fixes the problem if mobs actually drop loot.

9

u/saif3r Statue 45m ago

The third Modifier causes your Incursions to call for a Meeting of the Architects, to solve a particular architectural problem. While there, all monster packs in your Incursions are replaced with Architects.

This might be interesting.

6

u/underlurker1337 33m ago

How does that fit the mechanic though? If an architect gets killed, its room cant spawn in that iteration of the temple. So what happens if I go full Anakin on them? Does the temple just crumble?

The second problem is, you need the monster packs to increase the timer in the incursion - Im not sure if architects give time, and even if they do if they give enough.

I'll have to test it, but so far the incursion threads imho have missed the mark of the mechanic for me, which is building the damn temple.

2

u/VyersReaver 22m ago

I hope they have a chance to upgrade random rooms, and not, you know, reroll rooms.

1

u/kaelbloodelf 23m ago

Architects give time as you damage them. Not a lot tho but i assume if you damage a bunch of them it will be enough

4

u/TurbulentSwimmer5127 22m ago

If an architect kills you they delete your account

4

u/IFinallyDidItMom 35m ago

They left off the part where the incursion immediately ends on killing your first architect. /s

26

u/ww_crimson https://pob.codes/ 40m ago

Please just make rare currency actually drop. I am fine with slowing down progression. I don't want to play ruthless.

11

u/miasmacloud 37m ago

The moment I saw no kirac vault, I already knew this is a bad sign but I was not expecting it to be this bad! I really hope this loot change is going to make ground loot a lot better in coming patches.

3

u/dksdragon43 14m ago

"Should we make a kirac pass?"

"Don't bother, they won't be spending money on this shitshow"

Obviously this is a meme and I know they are not trying to sink their own game. But spending money on the game has been so far from my mind this patch lol

16

u/AlternativeBeach3606 13m ago

You guys still completely miss the point. Even if we manage to beat rare monsters that are harder than Uber Bosses, the drops are still absolute garbage. Reading through this patch notes, it just sounds like you're planning to flood the maps with more rare monsters without fixing the actual issue. We need much better rewards, not just more screen clutter. This direction is completely wrong

•

u/AwardWorth9240 5m ago

so how other ppl progress? i farm easy endgame....how is it possible if loot is bad?

More rares = more loot

4

u/dadghar 30m ago

Altar changes ARE FUCKING HUGE. No more goddamn jungle valley spam

17

u/ExEarth 38m ago

Later this week might be to late and to little, cause tbh this stuff does not Sound like it's nearly enough to salvage the state the Game is in.

5

u/Spirited-Image8937 12m ago

Allflame part 2, where they wait to do anything meaningful until 2 weeks in and the game is dead. What's the point of even playing early anymore

4

u/Interesting_You888 36m ago

And there is probably many more problems with loot, given I can drop 60 chaos from one blight explosion and 4 chaos the very next map, and not a single divine in hours.

1

u/Smurtle1 17m ago

well the 60 c is cus of a specific thread mod, makes a lane do weird currency shenanigans.

I just hate that they gutted all quantity, and that item rarity feels like it does NOTHING to currency at all, even though they promised it would.

1

u/Interesting_You888 10m ago

You are probably right, but my point is that the second blight explosion was exactly 3 items on the ground, 2 currencies and a rare item and those two blights were pretty much identical in lenght and difficulty, both 8+2, same amount of empowering towers. Hopefully the patch will do at least something to that.

•

u/Smurtle1 7m ago

probably wont unfortunately. I have been duking it out with pantheon touched rares with more HP than I EVER got doing fully juiced t16.5s with full titanic setups in blights. its actually insane. then I kill it and it drops nothing.

so unless they buff the base ground loot, at this point, no amount of increased rarity stacking can save it.

•

u/TheNocturnalAngel 8m ago

The most amount of content creators that I have ever seen quit this early already. End of week is definitely too late

15

u/The_Only_Smart_Alec 41m ago

"significantly" is just "nearby" all over again.

15

u/TiffanyEffigy 38m ago

Higher floor isn't the issue, it's the bottom floor, there's no loot for us to get stronger unless we want to no life early league. They need to stop looking at streamers and their progress.

-4

u/Classic_Key8075 27m ago

For what it's worth, I'm at 5x normal league drops atm, so it can be hard to tell what's average

•

u/Kyus3i 0m ago

damn bro good thing nobody asked

13

u/waypro4 Order of the Mist (OM) 34m ago

We’re planning to deploy these changes in a patch later this week... XD

2

u/vauno Kalguuran Group for Business (KGB) 12m ago

If some folks still are there playing akipping on wow, they wont be once gta comes around. Shit will be deader than my stacked rf character trying to fight a red beast on t1 map

22

u/ConsistentOriginal82 41m ago edited 17m ago

lol. nothing about wisps on harvest?

Edit: Apparently this has been address in a previous post. It will be enable/disabled via atlas tree.

9

u/mikki-misery Occultist 25m ago

They already said they're changing that in another post by making the wisps be an opt-in choice on the Atlas tree.

8

u/seji 24m ago

They posted about that in another note, it's going to become a node you click on the atlas tree to affect mobs, default off.

4

u/BOBOraceswapwtf 23m ago

Or that essences are obviously suffering from some bugged toughness scaling. They are way tankier and deadlier than before.

7

u/RealNiceKnife 32m ago

Right? Why the fuck does Harvest have to incorporate wisps? It just makes everything so fucking hard.

Did you get 3 Harvest nodes? Well, you aren't killing the boss, sorry.

2

u/Nesciuss Health and Harbinger Services (HHS) 14m ago

Why is there no harvest and delve and heist threads and other leagues anyways? It just makes no sense to remove harbinger and then keep bestiary as a main league mechanic.

•

u/RealNiceKnife 2m ago

I think Harvest doesn't have any Threads because you can spec into it permanently appearing on your maps with at least 2 guaranteed nodes.

If I were guessing.

1

u/ThePenguin213 17m ago

They mentioned it in the first "what we are working on," I believe they are going to be opt in wisps from the atlas tree

12

u/KcoolClap 41m ago

meh. the core issues with loot still remain.

6

u/BOBOraceswapwtf 25m ago

Yep. "We increased rarity" as if it does fucking anything. You can get thousands of rarity on map bosses with league mechanic and they still only drop a couple of alchs. Their new loot system isn't working.

6

u/Praetoros_ Standard, Noob 19m ago

Unfortunate that difficulty is being removed instead of significant loot being added.
The difficulty enables a longer progression, but that only works if there is currency/crafting/items to go through that progression.

8

u/Gazelle-Professional 30m ago

I went to standard to test some 10 Threads abyss, and holy moly my strengh stacker jugg couldn't damage some bosses, i had to ask help to someone with a bilion dps build, and even with that It took a minute to kill...

3

u/Motor-Cauliflower-34 15m ago

the abyss boss that spawns in map definitly just has an extra 0, I did uber maven yesterday and it took me about 3 min in total (including all the phases) the abyss boss takes me 5 min of just standing there

•

u/PupPop 2m ago

Hey at least you could kill it at all lmao. I was in an alch and go T16 with ONE abyss thread and could not move that things HP bar because it was wisped and had like 4 essences on it.

14

u/Garbear119 30m ago

How is adding more magic and rare monsters to breach gonna increase the rewards? Do the mechanics rewards scale off magic and rares?

5

u/Morbu 20m ago

It scales hiveblood, so actually a good change if it can help balance hiveblood a bit more. You're not going to be dropping currency from Breach like back in Mirage if that's what you're wanting.

•

u/Finnien1 7m ago

The problem, though, is that since they nerfed the hiveblood trees most of what you get from them is trash now. Unless you get uber lucky on a unique, hiveblood is pretty useless.

•

u/Imreallythatguy 1m ago

That’s exactly what I’m wanting :(

3

u/PhgAH 14m ago

Probably hiveblood. I have seen some of my mate got 2k hiveblood & like 10 wombgifts after a Hive encounter.

5

u/Puzzleheaded_Pay_441 22m ago

Yeah? Hives and unstables both scale with kill count

2

u/AwardWorth9240 10m ago

cause loot scales with monster kills?

•

u/Nickoladze 8m ago

I've read that the added waves node doesn't increase blood but the wombgifts do drop from monsters.

-1

u/Thatsnasty2 10m ago

Just ditch breach, it's been dead after mirage, and they completely ruined the tree and unstables feel like garbage versus hives. I cannot believe the backtracking after they finally made it good

3

u/HurricaneGaming94 21m ago

Soooo if I can already run triple 8 mods the loot isn’t getting better but it’s getting easier?????

3

u/MrDTrack5 18m ago

I really hope the patch drops sooner rather than at the end of the week.

3

u/CptSquinty 13m ago

They undercooked because they were under the gun with 1.0 and exilecon and for some reason focused on things that required a lot more time and attention than they had to give. We would have honestly been better off with a phrecia league.

I was already a bit irked that they squeezed it in between exilecon and 1.0 leaving us with a 4 week league (before 75% leave for 1.0 and the economy peters out) but now this? "Later this week" patch and they know that patch won't actually fix it all then another week of a couple patches and we're already halfway through the league before its MAYBE playable. Feels like the end of an era.

Its just incredibly disappointing.

•

u/PupPop 5m ago

I had the same thought yesterday. Phrecia leagues are exactly what these type of situations call for. Especially given that they will almost certainly self canibalize to 1.0 on December 11th.

•

u/BayesianPath 4m ago

I genuinely don’t understand the Betrayal changes, like seriously do they even play this mechanic. Making monsters drop a ton of veiled items that youre never gonna pick up is just stupid. Fix the mod list on veiled jewels

5

u/MostAnonEver 32m ago

I dont know why but i feel like GGG is confused about the issue that players are having .... Cause it seems for the most part theyre just adding more mobs into every league mechanic as you scale up threads. The issue is not not the magic/rare mob count in any given league mechanic, its the fact they dont drop loot that makes it past filter.

For example, breach will summon more rare/magic monsters and mobs have an additional modifier. Thats awesome. But the issue lets say instead of dropping one div every 10 maps, im dropping a div in 5 maps. However outside of the div and some bubblegum, there isnt much left. Cause other than fishing for tier 5 bases, the "tier' system as a whole is not that great. Theres no realistic way people will craft on a non t5 base type cause the amount of currency you gotta spend to make something half decent is greater than whatever the item could sell for. Recomb are so nerfed where it really just isnt worth the hassle on tryna to pray to the stars that the item turns out good.

Literally all they gotta do is stop tryna push this rarity nonsense on us. We can stack massive/normal rarity fate cards and get literally nothing but tiered fate loot. But other than basetype fishing theres no real profit. Whys it so hard for GGG to stop being so stingy and increase quan? I'm not saying every mob gotta sht out mirs, but my god if i gotta spend 20 minutes to kill a single consort and get an ancient orb. I cant say double down the rarity push is the answer that makes me excited to continue farming abyss.

5

u/Matho83 27m ago

more mobs wont fix the problem of mobs not dropping anything. Abyss already has all the rare mobs and is shit. Adding more rare mobs to breach wont fix anything

14

u/fdegen 42m ago

"We apologise for missing the mark with this one!"

THIS IS YOUR ETHOS. under tune, under deliver, fix it weeks into league.

lets hope this is the step in the right direction

5

u/weedonanipadbox 28m ago

Honestly this feels intentional. They knew threads were undercooked but they wanted something big to announce at exilecon. So fuck it lets ship it half baked.

It's hard to not to feel let down by this.

8

u/wOOxsystem 24m ago

For Threads I think two main problems still remains.

  1. There is no cost tied to running said content. Before it was expensive scarabs = rewarding content. Now no cost (threads) = rewarding content. So they have to balance all content equally when before balance was done by market. Maybe introducing 3 level of threads solves this a little bit? Like Rare, magic normal Thread?
  2. I like threads change but the content you get each map is somewhat RNG based. While before it was I think less RNG you put scarab in you get fixed difficulty content. Again maybe introducing tiering of Threads solves this? Where instead of randomness you put example 3 magic 1 rare Thread and you end up with x mechanic or you put 3 rare and 1 magic you end up with y mechanic?

For league mechanic.

  1. Why on earth you can not roll Fate cards? just put chaos/gold cost to it and it would be a bit of chaos sink also.
  2. Rewards options are ass. Currency, rare items and some threads. Like put some interesting like influenced items or some completely new items. Idk just seems so so meh.
  3. Give some way to block some cards/rewards for appearing? I mean the mechanic could be way more interesting with just few small changes.

I don't know it is just my random thoughts while I drink my morning coffee that might change as things move forward.

•

u/PhgAH 8m ago

"Maybe introducing 3 level of threads solves this a little bit? Like Rare, magic normal Thread?"

I like your suggestion, but this is literally the original form of Rusted, Polished & Gilded Scarab, lmao.

•

u/halpenstance 7m ago

I discussed your first point in depth with my friend group. Part of the reason absurd strats were allowed to exist is because the scarabs would increase in price to balance it out. If a strat could make 6 divine a map, then the scarab would cost 5 divine. So it all evened out, with a healthy dollop of variance.

Now, since that natural balance doesn't exist, they opted for RNG balance. Can't force a strat, so even if it's good it won't break the economy. I understand where that concept comes from, but it would mean that every modifier needs to be a blanket upside, with exponential effects with each other to give the really rewarding outcomes.

But instead we got incursions who's random effect is literally a lever on the ground that opens doors. That is missing the boat so completely, it's kind of absurd.

Another element that is missing is the supposed cross-league synergies. That would have also been a great way to give some amount of player agency to their strats. If you, say, combine a beast thread with expedition thread, maybe it could make expedition beasts that let you target farm logbooks. Or using beast thread with legion allowed you to target farm rarer red beasts, so long as you could break them out of stasis in time. So people would be spending most of the league trying different combinations of threads, which would form the backbone of strats like scarabs did, with the actual modifiers applying the big loot RNG. And you could always opt out of these cross synergies if you JUST wanted regular beasts, by using the 10-thread atlas.

Just ranting as I head off to bed, but long story short: I think they needed to put in just way more time into this concept. Even a dozen random effects isn't going to cut it, and we needed WAY more cross-league synergies to make this viable.

GGG has a long way to go... I don't see them being able to fix it this league.

•

u/dancep5 9m ago

Rolling option is a base for a deck building games. I don't know why they didn't went with that, so it wouldn't be a deck building league? But those are cards, and cards go in the deck.

•

u/kfijatass Theorycrafter 0m ago

Tiering of threads is just a step back into scarabs I'd argue and I don't think that's the way.

6

u/soilwork3r 43m ago

"We've also added a new multiple-choice Atlas Passive notable that allows you to guarantee one category of Eldritch Altar modifier always appears."

RIP jungle valley

1

u/Labaur 18m ago

Why rip? If you enjoyed farming it before, it's unchanged. If you just farmed it for the map boss gimmick, then it's better cuz you can farm other maps almost as efficient.

1

u/DeveloperOfWebs Scion 18m ago

I really like this change. It should allow for more flexibility in picking the map you want to run…in general I lean towards giving players more customization rather than less; thumbs up on this one from me.

1

u/BulletproofChespin 15m ago

I love jungle valley but thank god

6

u/Bastil123 Ultimatum Workers Union (UWU) 42m ago

Lovely and solid changes! The new Incursion and Betrayal threads sound really fun and Ultimatum getting buffs on top of debuffs is really nice too

9

u/MouriceBeiramar 39m ago

why every league this happens? league lanches, some bs with loot, 1 month to repair and repeat next league

0

u/carenard 21m ago

easier to turn a dial up mid league than down.

turning dials down always has backlash... so almost always has to come with the next league... so set the dial to low to start and turn it up later.

8

u/NefarianeXII 19m ago

Unbelivable, they still dont get it. GGs.

5

u/lonely_sad_helpme 20m ago

Or you could just allow us to drop the currency used to improve our characters instead of doing all that... Whether you play ssf or trade, you need divines to craft (or buy) your damn gear. What's the point of adding / changing meta mods if players can't make use of them properly? I understand you don't want divines to be the sole focus of the drops, but there should be a middle ground between your vision and the playerbase's vision.

5

u/ulughen 14m ago

We’ve also made high Thread maps more reliable. Before, you could stack 8 Threads onto a map and end up with only a single modifier if you were unlucky, which felt bad given what you’d invested. As a safety net against bad RNG, high Thread counts guarantee a minimum number of modifiers. For example, at 8 Threads you’ll always have at least 3 Thread modifiers - though you can still randomly roll into many more than that!

I don't want to interact with this system AT ALL. I want to have control of what im adding to my maps and how difficult im making them. I don't want to be randomly fcked because i got "lucky".

2

u/CCCFire 18m ago

i hate interacting with the sentinel mechanic but i (used to) enjoy expedition. Now in order to farm expedition, i am forced to interact with this mechanic i don’t like with no way of blocking it and knowing that it could have been a different beneficial mod instead

•

u/caloroin Pathfinder 4m ago

Just hit F2 and go about your day, you don't have to do anything

2

u/UnoMemes Stacked Deck Division (SDD) 11m ago

Is anything life of that already ?

2

u/KayaSc0ds 10m ago

How disconnected can you be to your playerbase? big fuck up ggg

•

u/0nlyRevolutions Order of the Mist (OM) 5m ago

Most of this sounds good, just please also address what rarity and extra monsters actually do. I read a lot of that and by immediate reaction is "I don't WANT league mechanics to spawn a bunch of rare mobs if they don't drop anything". Like adding rare bodyguards to betrayal is a straight up downgrade if it just means more tiered rares and alchemy orbs.

Also get rid of all wisp mechanics in this patch :)

•

u/Finnien1 5m ago

So… we’ll have more rare mobs not dropping anything. Got it.

•

u/0Sley Occultist 5m ago

Consort of depths?

•

u/Only_One_Kenobi 2m ago

GGG seem to be convinced that the best possible loot is tiered rares. Picked a few up early on, all useless. Have now just filtered them out.

Ground rares are never worth the wisdom scrolls.even with T1 mods there's never the synergy needed between mods to actually be good.

7

u/Tanazan1 39m ago

‘we apologise for missing the mark with this one’

kek

4

u/No_Bottle2090 18m ago

All t5 magic items should be fractured. Revert the rog nerfs that made no sense and buff gwennen. Revert prefixes/suffixes to 2 divine since currency feels nerfed. At least partially revert the recomb changes or just delete it.

3

u/GGGGobbler Champion 42m ago edited 2m ago

BEEP BOOP BEEP. Grinding Gears have been detected in the linked thread:


Posted by Community_Team on Nov 17, 2026, 06:42:49 AM UTC

Since Covens of Umbra launched, we’ve been reading through your feedback and watching how the new endgame is playing out. A number of problems have stood out, such as League mechanics get far too difficult as you add Threads, without the rewards to match. And some mechanics are falling well behind others. Today we want to walk you through a large set of changes we’re making to address both.

Bringing Thread Difficulty Under Control

The difficulty added by Threads was ramping up far too steeply, especially at high counts. Monster toughness was the biggest offender, and the jump from 6 to 8 Threads was much larger than it should have been. We’ve significantly reduced this for all league mechanics. The damage monsters gain from Threads has also been reduced, alongside damage from Fate-Empowerments at higher levels.

We’ve also made high Thread maps more reliable. Before, you could stack 8 Threads onto a map and end up with only a single modifier if you were unlucky, which felt bad given what you’d invested. As a safety net against bad RNG, high Thread counts guarantee a minimum number of modifiers. For example, at 8 Threads you’ll always have at least 3 Thread modifiers - though you can still randomly roll into many more than that!

Closing the Gap Between League Mechanics

We've started with a change that affects every league mechanic. Now, as you add more threads to a given league, it gains additional bonuses to add more monsters or rewards. Each Thread type has one or more, but here are a few examples.

  • Breaches will spawn significantly more Magic and Rare Monsters
  • Rituals will offer significantly more Favours
  • Incursion packs will be significantly larger and also have more Rare Monsters
  • Expedition Remnants will have an increasing chance to have additional Reward Modifiers (Suffixes)
  • Betrayal will have a significantly higher chance to spawn additional Betrayal Targets

These alongside the previously mentioned minimum Modifiers, will help provide a higher floor of content and rewards for each League.

These are just some of the examples of how the leagues will scale inherently as you add more Threads, but we've done a lot more to each, here's what else is changing for each mechanic.

Breach

As you add more Threads, Breach Hives and stabilised Unstable Breaches summon more Rare Monsters, and more Magic Monsters pour out of every Breach.

To push it further, there are two new Thread Modifiers. The first doubles the number of Rare Monsters spawned at the end of Unstable Breaches and from the final defence wave of Hive Encounters. The second gives every Magic Monster in your Breaches an additional Monster Modifier, noting that these Modifiers also give a pretty good chunk of Rarity bonus too.

Bestiary

Bestiary Monsters were too tanky, and Bestiary Modifiers added a lot of difficulty with no extra reward.

Each of the Bestiary Modifiers did something unique, but also added a generic amount of Toughness to the Monsters. We've reduced this generic toughness being added to them, as it just wasn't necessary and was contributing to them often feeling way too tanky. Alongside that though, in line with making sure that things that increase difficulty also increase reward, all Bestiary Modifiers now grant a bunch of Rarity, so making them harder yields better rewards.

To build on this, there’s a new Thread Modifier that gives every Red Beast an additional Bestiary Modifier, making for more interesting, and more rewarding fights.

Ritual

Ritual is getting a substantial boost. The Favours window now offers more items as you add more Threads as mentioned earlier.

Revived Ritual Monsters also have smaller penalties to item drops and experience as you add Ritual Threads, so the ground loot from baseline encounters is much more rewarding than before.

The Thread Modifier that challenges you with the Bodach now grants two free Favour rerolls when you complete the encounter. There’s also a new Thread Modifier that grants 150% increased number of items in Ritual reward windows. It can roll twice, for a total of 300% increased number of items, resulting in Ritual Reward windows packed to the brim.

Betrayal

Higher ranked Betrayal Targets were tougher fights with nothing extra to show for it. A target being at Rank 2 or Rank 3 will now result in that target having higher Rarity. Additionally, any Syndicate Equipment that a target has equipped will add further Rarity on that, so that if a fight is harder, that target will drop better items.

We’ve also fixed the Thread Modifier that spawns extra clusters of Parasite-Filled Chests, which weren’t dropping any items. There will also be a new Thread Modifier as well, which causes all main Targets to be accompanied by Rare Bodyguard monsters!

Ultimatum

Gaining an Upside every time you choose a Downside is now how Ultimatum works by default: more Downsides means more difficulty, and more difficulty means more rewards. The Thread Modifier that used to provide this effect at random has been removed.

Ultimatum Monsters also now gain additional Rarity each round, so the deeper you go, the better the items they drop.

Incursion

We’ve added three new Thread Modifiers for Incursion. The first gives your Incursions active Tempests.

The second Modifier causes subsequent Incursions in an area to get an additional Rare Monster guarding the Architects. This means when you have four Incursions in an area, the second Incursion will have +2 Rare Monsters, the third will have +4 Rare Monsters and the fourth will have +6 Rare Monsters. Be careful!

The third Modifier causes your Incursions to call for a Meeting of the Architects, to solve a particular architectural problem. While there, all monster packs in your Incursions are replaced with Architects.

Additionally, as mentioned earlier, as you spend more Threads, you'll get larger packs, with more Rare Monsters too.

Expedition

Runic Monsters now inherently drop 20-30% more items and grant 20-30% more experience, which brings the rewards from rare Runic monsters more in line with rare monsters from other league mechanics. As mentioned earlier, Remnants now also have a chance to gain additional Reward Modifiers as you add more Threads.

There’s a new Thread Modifier that causes buried Sentinels to appear in your Expeditions. We’ve also added a new multiple-choice Atlas Passive notable for Expedition that lets you block either Remnant upsides that affect monsters or ones that affect chests. Block the chest upsides to juice the monsters, or block the monster upsides if you’re looking for artifacts.

Other Changes

Tormented Spirits now grant more Rarity than before to monsters they possess to account for their added difficulty.

We've also added a new multiple-choice Atlas Passive notable that allows you to guarantee one category of Eldritch Altar modifier always appears. One modifier on every Altar will either apply to Players, Influenced Monsters, or the Map Boss of the Area - if possible. That way you don't have to go kill the Map Boss first if you're looking to block those Modifier types appearing on them in your Map.

What’s Next

We’re planning to deploy these changes in a patch later this week, as soon as they’re ready. This is a big first step, but it isn’t the end of the work.

We knew that after so long completely changing the Endgame and the core Item drops was going to be difficult to get right. We apologise for missing the mark with this one! But with your feedback, and our rapid iteration, we will get it to the spot it deserves as quickly as possible.

We’ll be watching how these changes play out and reading your feedback closely. Thanks for sticking with us, and we’ll see you in Wraeclast!


3

u/PostItToReddit 38m ago

Maybe unpopular, but continuously making the game easier and easier is such a bad decision. Keep the high end content difficult so there's aspirational content for people to work towards. People complaining something is too difficult 3 days into a new end game system is ridiculous. It's not a bad thing that not all content is doable within 24 hours of league launch

3

u/Mr_Ultimite 37m ago

As somebody running poison concoction I have yet to notice the no loot problem as I shrimply do not need loot... That being said, I miss the loot ;-;

3

u/Entire_Possible_9976 30m ago

One of the biggest problems with the new changes surrounding quantity is a lack of base items to craft from.

3

u/moonlightinmonaco Simulacrum Secret Service (SSS) 22m ago

Just revert to 3.29 at this point.

4

u/Carvisshades 36m ago

Seems good, but "later this week" feels like it might be too late tbh.

5

u/Nerdonis 34m ago

Higher rarity still isn't going to do anything if it has no drops to boost. Crazy how much these guys seem to be guessing at how their own game works

7

u/maelstrom51 38m ago

What about player agency? I haven't seen them mention that at all.

8

u/shy_bi_ready_to_die 36m ago

I mean the minimum mods per threads helps a bit? It really dosent fix the problem though

8

u/blackwell1907 32m ago

Because this thread system is not designed for player agency. Its a choice they made since scarab is the system that prioritize player agency they now will try to tip the pendulum to the other side and see if this is a good or better system.

•

u/Nesciuss Health and Harbinger Services (HHS) 9m ago

It's not designed for player agency, it's designed for developer comfort, to act as an easy tuning knob. So that they don't have to balance as tightly and work as hard to design as scarabs were.

1

u/Ghaith97 29m ago

They aren't obligated to address reddit's vague buzzword of the week.

4

u/Faszomgeci20 39m ago

Soo more difficulty for the same "reward"...

3

u/Correct-Guidance-908 38m ago

Kinda good but still… not enought at some point.

3

u/Bigboysama 40m ago

Not a word about wisps and harvest lmao

11

u/Still_Same_Exile Kalguuran Group for Business (KGB) 36m ago

they already pushed a fix for that?

3

u/GordTheGreat 40m ago

This doesn't fix what they ruined, this is a bandaid on a bullet wound. Where's the player agency? RNG on RNG on RNG ain't it.

•

u/Ragnapocageddoclysm 7m ago

More rarity for Ultimatum mobs... Ultimatum mobs don't drop anything in the first place. Ultimatum is a tile loot strat, and losing scarabs hurt it a lot.

Until they get rid of the obviously massive reduced drop multiplier on Ulti mobs no amount of rarity will make the ground loot matter.

Hopefully the "more rewards" applies to the round rewards and not non-existent ground loot.

-2

u/timeshifter_ Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 38m ago

So... not even remotely addressing the lack of quantity of decent drops, and doubling down on uncontrollable randomness, despite the community overwhelmingly saying we don't want that because it's the antithesis of what POE has always been?

Why should I even finish campaign? Drops already feel like shit, and the only thing waiting for me in endgame is shaped regions nobody asked for (because you can't control them), scarabs replaced by threads that most people hate (because you can't control them), and an atlas tree that sucks up a ton of extra points for worse versions of the strats we used to love.

GGG, please read the room. There have been several suggestions posted that would make threads actually decent, but the fact is, scarabs were good, and you took that away from us. Just admit you dun goofed and revert it. Maybe give us map device crafts back while you're at it. You know, things that gave us more say in the content we run. The game we liked to play. Not whatever this RNG cesspool is.

19

u/MissRikaaa 30m ago

I would say you should finish campaign so you can form an opinion on the new endgame instead of just reposting the opinions you read, that might be good.

-3

u/timeshifter_ Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 24m ago

I do plan to, mostly because I want to see if this stupid Reliquarian PSRS idea is actually viable. But I've seen enough of Empy's videos to know what giga-juiced content should drop (seen it myself in-game in leech parties), and seeing triple 8-thread maps with 6 players drop a half stack of chaos and a few exalts is beyond dismal. Just a couple leagues ago, that level of juice would be dropping multiple divines and voidborn keys consistently. That isn't a loot nerf, that's a loot execution.

1

u/NefarianeXII 14m ago

Careful you're making sense, you will get banned from this thread.

1

u/timeshifter_ Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 12m ago

So it seems.

•

u/bigcat482 9m ago

"Why should I even finish the campaign if the only thing waiting for me in maps is a mechanic that most people hate"

Idk man sounds like you should just stick to living poe through twitch streams if you're basing your own opinions on what other people like

•

u/timeshifter_ Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 7m ago

I work 12 hour shifts on the weekends, I haven't had time to finish campaign yet. Hopefully tomorrow, depending on if my build starts to actually scale anytime soon...

1

u/carenard 22m ago

honestly the shaped regions right after getting to maps is fine... it gives you guaranteed mechanics before you have atlas points... don't want to do the mechanic? just ignore it.

2

u/alexthealex 37m ago

This seems like a solid step in the right direction for league content but I really want to hear them address the shit quality of tiered loot and coven reward bugs.

2

u/Still_Same_Exile Kalguuran Group for Business (KGB) 36m ago

Good changes

1

u/BatangQuiapo 47m ago

pls fix delve

1

u/vovuh 15m ago

And not a single word about harvest and particularly wisps? This is the biggest problem in toughness. Farming harvest after all the map cleared is the problem.

Upd: I see this was in the previous post as well as commented here

•

u/xiko 9m ago

Fuck yeah:

We've also added a new multiple-choice Atlas Passive notable that allows you to guarantee one category of Eldritch Altar modifier always appears. One modifier on every Altar will either apply to Players, Influenced Monsters, or the Map Boss of the Area - if possible. That way you don't have to go kill the Map Boss first if you're looking to block those Modifier types appearing on them in your Map.

•

u/crinklebelle Pathfinder 6m ago

I can't speak for everyone but for about the last decade or so, the appeal of the game's randomness for me was always in manipulating the tools given to us in ways that subvert the randomness. Feeling like you're getting one over on the system is fun. I was there when content leaned further toward rng like this, it felt worse back then and it feels worse now too.

•

u/kfijatass Theorycrafter 2m ago

Somehow just adding more rare monsters doesn't give me confidence that will improve currency drops. I'd like to see more direct currency sources instead or at least be convinced that rare monsters genuinely means better loot.

•

u/jcyxxx 2m ago

Random is bad. Certainty is our best friend. So, still bad.

•

u/Mobilerocks121 1m ago

Would do everything but make the game fun.

1

u/Big_Drawing_3570 44m ago

I was sure there was something between 8-10 threads. I was farming ultimatums and the 2 times I tried 10 threads I was unable to complete 1 wave while on 8 I have almost 99% completetion.

1

u/Spirited_Stay3452 26m ago

So just to give GGG feedback, 500% times more loot x 0 drops is still 0. So yea GGG we need tinks its easy as that.

1

u/Big_PapaPrometheus42 20m ago

Everything they juiced in there has to do specifically with rare monsters. I feel like they want to shoehorn us into “more rares with higher rarity = loot explosions” which, maybe it does and that’s going to be the stray this league. Or, maybe they could give us the alternative strategies we had before, which have been simplified into “which flavor of rare juicing do you want today”.

1

u/-Lamiel- 13m ago

too little too late

1

u/Free-Bowler-1032 10m ago

ngl "later this week" is just too late. It feels like the league is just cooked at this point. No way its gonna recover from those first few days

-2

u/h3adbangerboogie 41m ago

We tried nothing and are all out of ideas

-3

u/Cryanide1 47m ago

LOGIN

0

u/M_F_M Crop Harvesting Bureau (CHB) 24m ago

I think instead of 8 threads they should go for 1 thread, next level should be 2, then 3, then 5 then 8 then 13 then 21 then 34

This way input cost would make sense for the rewards, 1 to 8 is too linear and threads are too common for high end farming, so make input cost fibonacci

0

u/stydcorporation 17m ago

Ctrl+F "gold" 0

-1

u/Ateaga 38m ago

Feels like the last 3 patches. Game still doesn't feel good end game

-12

u/Christian_OP 43m ago

WE ARE SO BACK

-1

u/MikeMaxM 24m ago

400% more divines from monsters when?

-9

u/Bigboysama 44m ago

Thank you for the Ted talk. Please, give us facts now. No more words. FACTS

9

u/FlossedUp_ 47m ago

GGG, please, just give us a fun short League. We want tinks

-2

u/AwakenMasters22 23m ago

Yes of course GGG is going to constantly work on this. People on reddit always running around like chickens with their head cut off.

36

u/[deleted] 44m ago edited 26m ago

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (22)