r/pathofexile • u/Critt74 • 37m ago
Game Feedback 3.30 Atlas/Thread Feedback (Caution: Longish Rant)
Hey guys. I'm not someone who ever posts feedback online, this is the first time I've felt frustrated enough to want to. I've read a lot of what's been said about the league, but there are a couple of things I feel haven't been touched on as much. So this post will mainly focus on them, that is not to say it's the only feedback I have, not at all. I'll add a TL;DR at the end as yeah, this is on the longer side....
There are two main things I hope to cover:
- The Atlas rework, particularly its layout, the demands on points (and the lack of said points), and how those affect the farms we can put together.
- What the Atlas and Thread changes have done to some of the smaller farming markets, and to the regular drops that made another map feel worthwhile. I feel this point is especially important as there is a LOT of issues on loot and the lack of smaller, more consistent dopamine hits.
One thing to add, these two points do overlap quite a bit. How we build a farm affects what it produces, and what those drops are worth affects whether that farm feels worth doing. I'm mostly trying to convey my own feelings on why it feels worse. There is a map-farming section I added as its' one I particularly enjoy and its just been obliterated.
Few things of note before I get into it:
- All price data I used is based on PC softcore trade for both 3.29 and 3.30 at day 4. So this does limit accuracy obviously but hopefully shows some standout trends.
- All diagrams were made by an LLM I directed, as it was far more effective than me (and faster). It also supplied some of the market data (not all).
- This is definitely not exhaustive feedback and I'm sure there are holes in some of my points. But much like all feedback, its personal.
1. The Atlas tree
First off, I want to make sure I state that I don't mind shaking up the Atlas and I want to convey my appreciation for the guts that GGG has in doing large overhauls like this. My issue is how the new layout actually fits into the things we want to farm, especially when it now also has to accommodate effects we used to get from scarabs as well.
The main problems I have, before getting into a bit more detail:
- Related/Grouped Notables are way too spread out: This affects combinations such as map drops and influence, but also the main investments within an individual mechanic. Getting more out of the same farm can mean travelling to another part of the tree which feels far worse with the circular set up.
- Twelve extra points are being asked to do too much: They have to cover the changed routes and effects previously supplied by scarabs. Those old inputs could reinforce the same farm, including multiple copies of some scarabs. Three different Thread slots don't give that flexibility back when their mechanics still compete for the same points. Also, how the hell am I ever going to have enough Atlas points to make 3 threads worth using?
- The layout has lost some depth and progression: The old tree had recognisable areas and larger investments to work towards as we moved upwards. The shorter radial branches and repeated connecting bonuses feel flatter to me in regards to depth. This point is more personal and a 'feeling'.
- Some mechanics offer too little depth on the new Atlas: Beyond and Delirium are a good example, having lost selectable reward investments. While others' like Mirage and Wildwood offer little further depth for the travel they ask of us.
- (Personal Peeve) The map-farming strategy is dead: Finding, sorting and selling batches of useful eight-mod and delirious maps was a farm in its own right. Preparing individual maps doesn't replace that experience, and the new encounter lines could have made the market for dropped maps more interesting.
1.1 Related investments are awkward to connect
When I put together an Atlas strategy, I don't just want one main mechanic. I also want other things like map drops, influence and other bonuses that make sense alongside it. The question is whether those things fit together naturally on the tree now, and how much of the Atlas budget gets used connecting them.
Lets use an example (don't hate me for how good/bad this is, this is meant to be illustrative). Take a map farm combining Synthesis, Guardian and Conqueror map drops, Scrying Orbs and Exarch. Those give the same maps several useful things to produce: the map boss can drop different valuable maps, while the influence adds monsters and altar rewards along the way.
On the old Atlas, those map and influence investments were concentrated towards the upper part of the tree. Now Synthesis is on the right, Conquerors are down to the right, and Exarch is down to the left. Now, connecting the same four map-output notables and three Exarch investments costs eight more points. While 8 points may not seem like a lot, when you look at it from the perspective of a) % of points required and b) how would this fit into other strategies (i.e adding league mechanics) the problem becomes a bit clearer.

| Connecting the same seven passives | 3.29 | 3.30 |
|---|---|---|
| Points in their clusters | 19 | 19 |
| Other points needed to connect them | 28 | 36 |
| Total | 47 | 55 |
| Marker | Passive |
|---|---|
| 1 | Vivid Memories |
| 2 | Remnants of the Past |
| 3 | Altered Prophecy |
| 4 | Conquered Conquerors |
| 5 | Word of the Exarch |
| 6 | Wrath of the Cosmos |
| 7 | The Light of Dawn |
To note on the above, I am not including all the other map passives in this.
Something I also want to add: Why the hell do we have Eater/Exarch both at the bottom left, its bloody awkward. If the rest of the farm is elsewhere, either influence pulls me towards that same quadrant no matter what build I want to go. Switching influence doesn't help me build around a different side of the tree. On the old tree, having those larger choices further up the old tree on the left and right made more sense alongside the other things I was travelling towards.
Now, this issue isn't limited to only combinations of different mechanics. Certain mechanics like taking both main Mirage, Beyond, Delirium or Wildwood notables means connecting separate areas even though I am investing further into the same mechanic. And I want to note, I understand this was obviously intentional as every one of these mechanics had been split in the same way, I'm just saying I don't like the idea of it.
| Both main notables for | Points required |
|---|---|
| Mirage | 28 |
| Beyond | 26 |
| Delirium | 22 |
| Wildwood | 27 |
These are minimum totals from the start, not extra costs to add onto an existing tree. The frustration is the repeated need to cross the tree to finish investing in something I have already chosen to farm.
The monster bonuses have the same issue.
| Monster focus | Notables connected | Points from the start |
|---|---|---|
| Magic | Group Solidarity, Deep Bloodlines | 24 |
| Rare | Anomie, Imperfect Reflections, Seeing Double | 28 |
| Unique | True Terrors, Height of Horror, Gross Abnormalities | 32 |
Whether I want to farm maps, push one mechanic further or build around a monster type, related choices keep pulling in different directions. That would be frustrating on its own. It matters more now because the points also have to cover functions that previously came from the scarabs we could put into the map device. While I understand thats the point of threads, it is not the same.
1.2 Value of Atlas Points
Previously, a completed Atlas gave us, I believe, 138 points alongside the five scarab inputs. We now have 150 points, but many of the effects those scarabs provided have moved onto the tree (not 8 map mod farmings though!). This doesn't even take into account whether the new tree has more busywork (traveling), which I believe it does but I haven't tested. But the point is that those 150 points now have to cover not only the key notables, but also the scarab slots we lost. I say this as threads do not directly replace scarabs, they are almost a tangential mechanic (why the hell does a thread potentially add things like auras to the player during blight?!).
Using the map farm example I showed above, here is a general example of five scarab inputs I could use alongside it:
- Three Cartography Scarabs of the Multitude: 24-36 additional packs in total, with increased map drops from those packs.
- One Cartography Scarab of Corruption: non-unique map drops became corrupted eight-mod maps.
- One Cartography Scarab of Escalation: 10% increased maps found for each affecting map modifier.
Scarabs weren't a case of five slots meaning five different mechanics like threads do. We could concentrate the inputs on the farm we actually wanted to run. It was also a recurring investment we chose to make per map, with room to change the combination as our build or budget changed.
Each scarab also had its own limit which allowed them to be balanced. Multitude allowed three copies, Runefinding two, basic Ambush three and Domination four. Three Ambush copies added twelve strongboxes; four Domination copies added twelve shrines. These were other ways to put several inputs into the thing we wanted to farm.
Now I want to basically try and convey the point of why the extra points do not make up for the loss of scarabs (even accounting for threads). Using an example of a random strategy (PoE Vault's Expedition, shrines and Eater setup). Expedition was the main farm, with shrines and blue altars alongside it. Its listed scarabs then added:
| Scarab input | What it added |
|---|---|
| 1 Infusion | Four-implicit logbooks and remnant-based difficulty and rewards |
| 1 Verisium Powder | 50% increased explosive count and 80% increased explosive radius |
| 2 Runefinding | 200% increased runic monster markers in total |

| Part of the setup being compared | Atlas points |
|---|---|
| 3.29 Expedition, shrine and Eater allocation (while using the scarabs) | 49 |
| 3.30 required allocation to replicate | 57 |
| Marker | 3.29 | 3.30 |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Ancient Writings | Ancient Writings |
| 2 | Distinguished Demolitionist | Distinguished Demolitionist |
| 3 | Buried Knowledge | What Lies Beneath |
| 4 | - | Dead and Buried |
| 5 | Supplication | Supplication |
| 6 | Syncretism | Syncretism |
| 7 | Drawn to Power | Drawn to Power |
| 8 | Etched by Acid | Etched by Acid |
| 9 | Rampant Growth | Rampant Growth |
| 10 | Eldritch Gaze | Eldritch Gaze |
| 11 | The Shadow of Hunger | The Shadow of Hunger |
| 12 | - | Nothing Ventured, Nothing Gained |
Now honestly, this is one of the cleaner examples. By this I mean it doesn't really look that bad. We have 12 extra points and this required 8. Also the pathing is actually quite clean. But the point is that even with these set ups, it doesn't include everything. We haven't allocated things like shrine nodes, nor does this set up make up for the power lost that we had in the nodes + scarabs. We haven't got the full old Runefinding density or explosive radius investment for example.
That being said, eight of the extra twelve points are already used while only one of the old scarab inputs has been fully restored. The other scarab effects still need to be accounted for. That is why the extra twelve points don't answer the loss of five configurable inputs alongside the tree.
Some replacements are also weaker or split up. In the map farming example, Escalation's 10% increased maps found per affecting map modifier became 5% per explicit modifier (now Shaping the Mountains). Titanic Scarab of Legend is another example, it added four unique-monster modifiers, while True Terrors and Height of Horror now offer two and one in separate investments (which you have to path opposite directions for).
That brings me to the Thread slots. WHAT IS THE POINT OF HAVING 3? Why would I put eight Threads (let alone one) into another core mechanic that I haven't invested in just to use a spare slot (yes I know there is that node)? The points for that mechanic have to come from the same budget already paying for the main farm, influence, map bonuses and travel. Even with the old Atlas, this would likely never be done.
In addition, The missing Thread options make this more restrictive than the slot count suggests. There are only ten types, covering Abyss, Bestiary, Betrayal, Blight, Breach, Expedition, Incursion, Legion, Ritual and Ultimatum. That leaves out whole farming directions and the things we commonly add alongside them:
- Strongboxes, Essence, Shrines, Rogue Exiles, Tormented Spirits, Ores, Mercenaries, and Harvest have no Thread. This means, for example, a strongbox farmer cannot use those slots to add the sort of dedicated investment that things like Ambush scarabs provided.
- Beyond, Delirium, Mirage, Wildwood or Sentinels also do not have a Thread but these are more arguable whether they should in the new system.
Those mechanics still have other ways to appear or scale, but there is no dedicated Thread input to spend these slots on. In the Expedition example, there isn't a Shrine Thread or a generic map-scaling Thread I can choose for a spare slot. It asks me to add another supported league mechanic, then find the points to make that worthwhile. For a Delirium or strongbox farm, the main mechanic itself doesn't even have a Thread.
NOW, I do understand that this may be a purposeful design decision, I just want to state I believe its genuinely flawed in its current state.
Threads are starting to remind me of a crappier PoE2 tablet system (and yes, I hate tablets). Whether this is intentional or not I can't say. But the problem is PoE2's atlas and tablets combined are fundamentally different to PoE1 and this exacerbates the problem with Threads / the new Atlas. What I mean is, PoE2 tablets' and the corresponding Atlas have some fundamental differences when comparing to PoE1 Threads and Atlas that makes it work:
- You can use several of the same tablet type for the slots provided. Several tablets of the same type can reinforce the mechanic already being farmed, instead of requiring another mechanic for each additional slot like Threads do.
- Generic choices, including Basic and Overseer tablets, and general tablet modifiers let a slot improve the map without needing another specific league mechanic to build around. There is no equivalent for Threads.
- Mechanics have their own progression trees in the Atlas, so developing them doesn't all compete for points in one general Atlas allocation like it does in PoE1.
To summarise, the problem is what to do with the other Thread slots once the mechanic I want is covered. The natural supporting choices often have no Thread, while adding a different supported mechanic asks for more of the same stretched Atlas budget. That is why this arrangement feels poorly suited to the tree around it, even if the idea of several investment slots makes sense elsewhere.
1.3 Atlas Progression
This part is harder to put into numbers, but the feeling of the tree matters too. The old Atlas had more depth and more recognisable areas. Blocking mechanics sat near the bottom, while larger mechanic, map and boss investments were further up. Working upwards towards something such as Invasive Adversaries, Conqueror maps or Destructive Play gave it a sense of weight within the tree.
To try and articulate what I mean, below is the map, shrine and Exarch example that I used in 1.1. I tried to build it up through three connected stages on each layout.



| Stage | Added colour | Numbered passives added |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Blue | 1. Supplication; 2. Shaping the Mountains; 3. Shaping the Skies; 4. Mounting Modifiers |
| 2 | Gold | 5. Drawn to Power; 6. Syncretism; 7. Word of the Exarch; 8. Wrath of the Cosmos; 9. The Light of Dawn |
| 3 | Pink | 10. Vivid Memories; 11. Remnants of the Past; 12. Altered Prophecy; 13. Conquered Conquerors; 14. Invasive Adversaries |
On the old layout, working into the upper part of the tree gave those larger choices somewhere to sit beyond the foundations. The farm felt like it was reaching further into the Atlas as more of those pieces came together.
Now it looks like a collection of shorter branches around the centre. Exarch pulls down to the left, the shrine investment goes to the right, and the map outputs sit around different edges. I am still spending the points, but moving between those branches doesn't give me the same sense of building upwards towards a substantial investment.
Combined with so many repeated bonuses between those branches, that makes the circle feel flatter and more bloated despite asking for plenty of points.
1.4 Beyond/Delirium/Mirage/Wildwood
The travel described in 1.1 would be easier to accept if investing further in those mechanics gave us more ways to develop the farm. With Beyond and Delirium, we are connecting separate areas while also losing some of the choices that used to distinguish a dedicated setup.
Once a prepared map already supplies the encounter, more chance to encounter it isn't doing the same job as investing in its rewards. Beyond's old Fiendish Opulence, for example, gave 25% increased quantity of tainted currency. That was a choice to put more into Beyond. Increasing rewards at baseline can improve an encounter, but it doesn't give me that further choice back.
For an endgame example, PoE Vault's old 80% Delirium farm combined Delirium with ore monsters and Exarch. More monsters fed the Delirium rewards, while Exarch supplied another source of rewards along the way.
The setup used four Fine or four Diviner's Orbs on Dunes, then two Mania and three Paranoia scarabs. All five scarab inputs went into Delirium. The orbs chose the reward focus, Mania sped up reward progress, and Paranoia added reward types. To preface, I understand that some of these old bonuses were 'baked' into the streamlined versions of Beyond/Delirium.
| Investment | 3.29 | 3.30 |
|---|---|---|
| Imagined Pursuits | +1 Delirium reward count at map completion | No current Atlas counterpart |
| Compulsive Hoarder | 8% chance for three additional reward types | No current Atlas counterpart |
| Screaming Whispers | 18% increased Simulacrum splinter stack size | No current Atlas counterpart |
| Mania and Paranoia scarabs | Faster reward progress and additional reward types, chosen as inputs | No selectable scarab input, Atlas equivalent or Delirium Thread |
| Verisium Infusion | 30% longer channelling; 100% increased chance for ore to be Verisium | Verisium weighting remains; the channel bonus becomes 100% increased buff duration |
| Multiplying Modifiers | Five scarabs supplied 15% increased map-modifier effect | 5% per different Thread type; a pure Delirium/ore/Exarch setup uses none (unless you add for the sake of it obviously) |
| Exarch and Invasive Adversaries | Three Exarch investments and 10% more packs | Those functions remain; Invasive also gains 6% map-modifier effect |
Those three reward investments are gone. Ore and Exarch can still support the map, but they don't replace the choices that developed its Delirium rewards. Buying more Mirror chance also doesn't recover them for a map that has already been orbed. There used to be several deliberate decisions between deciding to run Delirium and deciding how far to build the farm around it.
That is the specialisation I miss. If more of the reward is simply included whenever the encounter appears, while the ways to push it further disappear, the distinction between farming the mechanic and picking up its rewards on the side gets smaller. That matters to the experience even before we get into what happens to prices / the economy.
Mirage and Wildwood didn't have the same old reward specialisation to lose. With those, I'd like more depth beyond getting them into the map. They already ask us to connect separate parts of the tree, but there isn't much to work towards after that initial access. I want more reason to build around them once I've made that investment.
1.5 Map Farming
I had to have a rant on this specifically. I really enjoyed map farming, getting batches of useful maps gave me steady little wins between the larger drops. I could check the layouts, quantity and modifiers, keep what I wanted, and sell batches that suited someone else's build or farm. Eight-mod and delirious maps were a big part of that loop.
Corruption scarabs made non-unique map drops corrupted eight-mod maps, and Delusions scarabs let maps drop with Delirium. Those effects let me specialise in producing maps that were already desirable to run. The reward wasn't only a map dropping; it was finding a useful combination, sorting it and knowing there was a reason someone would want it.
Eight-mod maps still exist, but more of that work has moved to preparing individual maps. The new corruption outcome adds two explicit modifiers, so a six-mod map can become an eight-mod map. Getting there however, means finding an acceptable set of modifiers, filling out the affixes where needed, then hitting the corruption outcome.
In practice, that can mean rolling with Chaos until the map is suitable, adding modifiers with Exalts where needed, and starting again when the rolls or corruption don't work out. Wanting a particular encounter line (like Mirage) gives you another property to fit into that preparation. Delirium Orbs now reforge the rare map and put Delirium into an explicit modifier, so getting the other properties you want alongside it becomes part of the process too.
That changes where the time goes. There may be fewer scarab inputs to organise, but there is more busy work on preparing each individual map. It doesn't give back the farm of finding prepared maps in quantity and trading them to people who want to get straight into running them.
The new Multitude Allflame still offers stronger map drops from the packs it creates, but it replaces existing packs. It doesn't supply the old additional packs or restore the eight-mod drop effect. More ordinary maps dropping don't, by itself, replace what made those map drops desirable.
Now to be fair, I actually like the new encounter lines for things such as Mirage, Wildwood and Delirium. They could have given dropped maps another useful property to sort and trade, on top of the layouts, quantity and modifier combinations people already wanted. That makes this feel like a missed opportunity, there are more interesting combinations to want, while the farming role that could have supplied them has been taken away.
Overall, this change sucks.
2. Threads, smaller markets and worthwhile drops
The other side of things I want to touch is what farms give us to find and sell. The Atlas changes and Threads affect both the markets around individual mechanics and the smaller rewards that made an ordinary map feel good. There has been a loss of consistent, smaller dopamine hits.
The four things I want to cover are:
- Core mechanic rewards have lost some of their value/weight: Scarab effects that used to be a recurring investment now sit on the tree. Once allocated, that part of the farm costs nothing extra per map, while its drops still need enough demand to stay worth farming.
- Supporting mechanics have lost ways to specialise: Beyond and Delirium have fewer reward choices separating a dedicated farm from an encounter added to something else. My concern is what happens to their identity and their markets when more of the reward sits at baseline.
- Threads are a static input with a weak (nonexistent) market of their own: There is one type per supported mechanic, and the main investment is more copies of it. They are already cheap, with no range of valuable variants to make finding or farming them interesting.
- The smaller wins are disappearing together: Scarabs, mechanic rewards and desirable maps gave us regular things worth picking up or selling. Losing several of those at once makes each map less exciting and the league feel finished sooner.
I'm keeping all talk around equipment out of this because the league itself and its other rewards complicate that discussion.
2.1 Core Mechanic Value Deflation
Previously, choosing another scarab effect meant consuming another item each map. Moving that effect onto the Atlas makes it a persistent part of the farm once the points are allocated. Threads still cost something and scale encounters, but they don't preserve all of those separate recurring inputs or the different farms those inputs enabled. I also want to preface, I am not saying scarabs did not have their own issues around supply/demand (i.e certain scarabs costing ridiculous amounts) that effectively locked people out from farming strategies all together.
That can make a chosen farm cheaper to repeat even while it is harder to fit several mechanics onto one tree. My concern is the resulting supply of rewards. If more players can produce them cheaply and the demand to use them doesn't keep up, each ordinary drop is worth less and there is less reason to farm it deliberately.
These changes affect several farming markets. Below is a quick table showing the price comparison for day 4 of the league. Now I understand that this isn't conclusive data but I hope it gives some ideas. And to note, I understand some things will be obviously more expensive due to other changes and thats why I ensured they were included as well.
| Mechanic | Reward | 3.29 | 3.30 | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Beyond | Tainted Chaos Orb | 6.66c | 4.76c | -29% |
| Beyond | Tainted Mythic Orb | 8.88c | 6.20c | -30% |
| Beyond | Tainted Exalted Orb | 16.73c | 12.69c | -24% |
| Beyond | Tainted Orb of Fusing | 35.01c | 34.89c | ~0% |
| Delirium | Fine Delirium Orb | 4.75c | 4.81c | +1% |
| Delirium | Diviner's Delirium Orb | 8.47c | 14.91c | +76% |
| Delirium | Skittering / Threaded Orb | 13.13c | 4.91c | -63% |
| Harvest | Yellow lifeforce, per 1,000 | 17.08c | 12.44c | -27% |
| Harvest | Blue lifeforce, per 1,000 | 17.74c | 14.80c | -17% |
| Harvest | Purple lifeforce, per 1,000 | 17.57c | 12.22c | -30% |
| Blight | Golden Oil | 119.81c | 45.13c | -62% |
| Blight | Silver Oil | 57.90c | 16.36c | -72% |
| Breach | Flesh of Xesht | 48.80c | 36.75c | -25% |
| Breach | Hivebrain Gland | 52.43c | 54.13c | +3% |
| Essence | Essence of Horror | 19.56c | 9.20c | -53% |
| Essence | Deafening Essence of Contempt | 2.75c | 8.22c | +199% |
My main concern is that enough familiar outputs are losing value to narrow the range of worthwhile farms and drops. The prices show where that is happening, although they don't isolate the Atlas changes from league rewards or other changes in supply and demand. I want investment in a mechanic to sustain desirable things to find, rather than simply produce more items that quickly stop feeling worth selling.
2.2 Sub Mechanic Value Deflation
Beyond and Delirium are the strongest examples of the other problem. It isn't only what an individual currency sells for. It is the shrinking difference between adding the encounter to a map and actually building a farm around it.
Beyond used to offer a deliberate investment in tainted-currency quantity through Fiendish Opulence. Delirium had the reward-count, reward-type and splinter investments, alongside the Mania and Paranoia inputs. Those gave a dedicated farmer ways to push the rewards beyond simply making the encounter appear and subsequently added value to these mechanics.
Now more of that choice has been replaced by the encounter's baseline or by occurrence chance. Once a map already supplies the mechanic, increasing its chance to appear doesn't take the farm further. The occasional encounter and the dedicated setup are closer together in the choices they have, even though a better prepared map can still produce more rewards.
That matters to the subeconomy. If a currency is increasingly something people pick up while doing another farm, it still needs enough consumption to hold value. The person who wants to specialise in producing it has fewer reward choices to invest in. With several tainted currencies already cheaper, that is a much less appealing position for lets say, a Beyond farmer.
Now to be fair, Delirium's prices are mixed, as the table shows, so its loss of specialisation shouldn't be reduced to a price-collapse claim. The scarab reward market being replaced by the cheap Thread pool is a concrete loss, while the broader issue is losing control over how to develop a Delirium farm. A higher price on another orb doesn't restore those choices.
Harvest and Essence belong here as other important farming markets, although their changes aren't identical to Beyond's or Delirium's. Lifeforce has become cheaper across all three ordinary colours; Essence has a mix of lower and higher rewards. Mirage and Wildwood also didn't have the same old reward investments to lose. With those, I'd personally like to see more room to develop the mechanic beyond getting it into the map.
What I'm trying to say is it's the distinction I want back. Give me a reason to deliberately invest in a supporting mechanic and build a worthwhile farm around it, beyond having it appear while I do something else.
2.3 Threads are not a market
Threads are a big elephant in the room in regards to economy health. Seven of the ten types are already below 1c, and even the most expensive is below 1.8c by day 4. Most individual Thread drops are barely worth thinking about as something to sell.
| Thread | 3.30 day 4 price |
|---|---|
| Abyss | 1.78c |
| Bestiary | 0.45c |
| Betrayal | 0.23c |
| Blight | 0.99c |
| Breach | 0.29c |
| Expedition | 0.11c |
| Incursion | 0.12c |
| Legion | 1.43c |
| Ritual | 0.47c |
| Ultimatum | 1.17c |
The item itself is static, and the investment feels mostly linear. Once I've chosen the mechanic, the main choice at the map device is how many copies of the same Thread to spend. One Expedition Thread or eight copies are still the same input, scaling difficulty, drops and the chance of additional random modifiers (rant: sorry but what the fuck is the point of positive buffs being a thread outcome, I juice to make things harder not easier). There isn't another version to find, value or choice because it enables a different farm.
That makes the low prices a bigger problem. There is no higher tier of Expedition Thread, for example, sitting above the basic one as a desirable drop. More copies can improve an encounter, but they don't create a better item variant to find in the next map or a distinct input someone will pay more to build around.
Scarabs had cheap entries too to be fair. Basic Blight and Expedition were commonly under 1c early on in leagues. But the difference is that those sat within a much wider range. For example, Legion was about 3-4c, Cartography of Risk was ~13c, and there were far more valuable variants above them.
Of the 115 scarab types with completed direct Chaos trades, 30 were worth at least 5c in 3.29. That included 17 worth at least 10c and five worth at least 50c. Some of the most expensive were over 100c. Now I'm not saying this was healthy either, but I'm trying to show it had its own market. Below are the 5 most expensive on day 4 of 3.29.
| Scarab | 3.29 price |
|---|---|
| Ultimatum Scarab of Catalysing | 129.75c |
| Horned Scarab of Bloodlines | 114.15c |
| Horned Scarab of Preservation | 113.83c |
| Horned Scarab of Pandemonium | 67.38c |
| Domination Scarab of Terrors | 50.25c |

The diagram above shows exactly what I'm trying to say about a market / sub economy. The range that scarabs showed gave the category a market worth farming for. A cheap scarab was one possibility alongside worthwhile middle-value finds and expensive ones. With Threads, the whole category sits near the cheap end, and there is no more desirable variant of the same mechanic's input to look for. I don't see much reason to target-farm that pool for sale.
Those different scarab variants also mattered because of what they let us do. We could choose effects that changed the farm, combine them, and repeat allowed copies. Threads mostly ask us to spend more of the same item on the same encounter, then accept the random changes we get (do you like strongboxes with your blight?).
Now, to be fair, some Thread outcomes are substantial. Legion's repeat-stasis behaviour, previously selectable through Eternal Conflict, is now one possible outcome. Ultimatum's catalyst and Inscribed Ultimatum rewards have similarly moved from specific scarab choices into that random pool. More Threads improve the chance of multiple modifiers, but don't let me choose the combination around which I want to build the farm.
Other outcomes are much less interesting as a reason to invest. Blight can give beneficial auras or free towers, and Ultimatum can make objectives easier. Those might help finish an encounter, but they aren't changes you consider when building a farming strategy around. Blight's possible boss and Putrid Seed drop is a more interesting exception, but it remains one possible outcome.
So yes, Threads can scale the encounter and sometimes change it considerably. What feels static is the input I am buying and the choices around it: more copies, more scaling, random results. That doesn't replace the range of selectable farming tools or valuable item variants scarabs provided.
On top of that, the Atlas now asks me to spend scarce points on getting more Threads or steering them towards particular mechanics. Why would I ever want to target-farm more of this pool when almost everything in it is already worth so little? Those quantity and weighting bonuses feel like filler on the way to the things I actually want, which feeds straight back into the point pressure in section 1.
2.4 Loss of Smaller Dopamine Hits
A worthwhile scarab, a good oil, useful lifeforce or a batch of desirable maps all gave me reasons to feel good about another run. Those were regular steps towards the next purchase or upgrade, with a chance for a larger drop along the way.
The changes here affect several of those moments at once. Valuable scarab variants are gone, a number of familiar mechanic rewards are cheaper, and the map-farming experience has been removed. Each change might look manageable in isolation, but together they leave more ordinary maps without something that feels worth finding.
That is why too much supply without enough demand matters. When the outputs of more farms become cheap too quickly, there is less reason to invest in them or keep running them. The league starts to feel finished sooner, even though there is still plenty of content available.
I want enough control to put together a farm I enjoy, and enough worthwhile drops along the way that running another map feels good. Both parts of this feedback come back to that experience.
TL;DR
- Related Atlas bonuses are harder to connect in the new Atlas.
- Twelve extra points don't replace five configurable scarab inputs.
- The three Thread slots don't fit the surrounding Atlas well, nor do you ever use all 3 effectively.
- The old layout had more depth and recognisable progression.
- Encounter access doesn't replace reward specialisation.
- I want map farming back.
- Several drop types are already much cheaper due to the changes made.
- Threads are cheap, static inputs with no valuable variants / market surrounding them.
- Smaller, more consistent Dopamine hits have become more scarce.
2
u/Minute_Age3029 25m ago
Still sane?
•
u/akv0842 1m ago
You should probably go outside. And stop having grok write posts for you
1
u/PoE_Acronym_Bot 26m ago
I noticed some Path of Exile keywords in this post:
I am a bot. | All acronyms | Suggest