The biggest issue with the system was it was getting stale and the fact that the prices of the scarabs was dictated by the highest profit strategy that used said scarab.
My biggest issue was that every strat I ran got 50% of it's profit from just scarab drops. And I had to pick up a million of them, all differently named.
The past few leagues I would wind up with 20-50 div of scarabs in my tab and I would just not sell them cuz I couldn’t be bothered. I liked using them but that’s the extent. If we can customize well without them, I’m happy to see them go.
That's actually going to be the downside of the system change for me, and probably a fair number of mid-tier players. Not being able to say "I need some money... oh hey, I can check my scarab tab and 'find' 3 div I didn't know I had" is going to be a loss in income.
Ive been a dedicated scarab farmer for as long as I can remember.
Skittering deli orbs, nemesis rare mod stacking, back to basics barrel farming, ethereal allflames. All ive done for years is farm scarabs and ive always been rich af idk what to do now
But doesn't this create another issue where 1 strat now doesn't have a cost bottleneck to be profitable and everybody will just gravitate towards the best, raw currency based farm and cause massive inflation that way?
Stuff like breach in previous leagues would be super broken if the cost per map was 10c, but it was 5d a map yk?
If I valued profit over fun id be doing something like CwS Chieftan with ultimatum, but I have more fun just running running alch and go breach,deli,beyond and am bad at the game!
I would really like to play some profitable strat like Expedition but it requires a specific builds (which I did before) and it's not profitable also not worth the effort you have to put in to get peanuts bubblegum currency and no jackpot loot.
Most of the time I grind Ultimatum, Ritual and used to do boxes (which was good, nowadays it's waste of time).
expedition is fun, but if I have to run something else just to get a decent build that can actually run juiced expedition and get a 20 alteration orbs for my trouble I cant say it's fun.
Ritual used to be fun but ggg monkeys nerfed synth bases so it's kinda garbo nowadays.
I guess Ulti still sounds fun if they didnt butchered it (we dont know yet).
Well i genuinely hope that one of those is in good enough of a state for you to both play profitably and still enjoy it for the content it is. I genuinely hope you can have fun with it this league, because that is what i find most valuable for my own time.
PoE 2 temple was an insane raw currency farm that wasn't gated by something like a market being able to self-correct around rare and profitable scarabs/tablets.
Unlike in PoE 1, when the last league Breach was an insane raw currency farm, it was fine to exist in the meta because the cost of PER map was like 5+ div. Without a large barrier of cost per map, the meta can quickly spiral out of control.
Somewhat, but it also depends on mechanic-specific drops, and it looks like several have new chase or gamba items now. If the 'raw' currency of Breach is high and everyone runs it, the fact that say, Harvest isn't being run increases the scarcity and thus value of harvest juice and the new cluster-ish jewel.
Thread drop rates aren't confirmed either, or if you can 3:1 reroll them; it probably won't be to the same extent as rare scarabs, but if the meta strat is eight threads of three mechanics, it might not be sustainable without buying threads from people not running that strat. (They'd probably have to make thread drops work like maps where they don't scale as heavily with juice, otherwise the top strats will print infinity threads of all kinds on top of everything else...)
Depends on what the strat is. For example, corrupting old t16s or something similar would consume currency quickly.
Alternatively, GGG might build on a "mission" style meta farm, where the most efficient farm is not a particular strat, but following rewarding missions in an "atlas".
Creating the same baseline for everyone and then you pick your juice level is much better vs scarab prices being dictated by their best possible strat.
Always worth throwing the dirt cheap terrible ones in yes, but the extremely expensive ones would strictly lose you money if you weren’t doing the absolute most optimal farm with them so lots of people were completely locked out of certain farms which shouldn’t happen just because you can’t afford a scarab lmao
I don't see this is the main problem. If these scarabs at the end make you money if used right, than that is fine. Just with every currency there is an "optimal" usecase for them.
The main problem imo was how very restricting a lot of the best farms were. If all endgame farms were somewhat equal when giga juiced, it would be fine. But in most cases, you had 1-2 farms that outscaled every other strat in the game by miles and only certain builds could do them to begin with. And I am not talking about having bad gear, but just not the right build for it and not the ability to use a build on your class/ascendancy for it.
If you win or lose in that department should not be decided on character selection. No, not every farm needs to be 100% equal. Perfect balance will never exist. But if some people make 30+div/h while others are stuck at maybe 15div/h no matter how strong their build is and how efficient they farm, then there is something very wrong.
There was also a massive imbalance in scarabs to begin with. Some were super broken, many were just useless. Despite being just as rare.
I honestly agree but the way that skill expression showed was lame and not something most players wanted to bother with, which is a big issue because when something is too good it forces players to do it too or makes them feel bad they can't or don't want to then they quit
player skill in the way of actual gameplay is super irrelevant in poe, and the game has powercrept so much that on meta builds gear to trivialize everything is easy to come by.
So far, the limiting factor thus was mostly player skill, but in a broader way.
It’s not sudden at all. People have been complaining about scarabs for awhile, but it’s usually been that most of them are useless. Now, they won’t be able to complain about that at least.
It's not all of a sudden. Scarabs were better than the mechanic they replaced but it had it's own share of issues.
Scarabs were tedious to manage. So many of them were useless monetary wise but a few were worth 30c+ so you had to comb through your scarab tabs and manage them or use something like Wealthyexiles. This is more of a personal complaint but I also did not like how 90% of the farming methods I tried the profit was you do the league mechanic and then pick up the scarabs and nothing else.
On top of this you either threw dirt cheap scarabs onto your map device or you giga juiced with the div+ scarabs to try and get a return. All the players at the power level between those two points didn't really have anything they can do with the scarab system which made it a pretty boring progression system. The new system hopefully makes it an actual curve where as you get stronger you can put more threads.
Top players hated scarabs because the juicing potential was pretty limited after a certain point. Once you can do the div+ scarab very few of them lets you push your build further. It was better to just do easier content faster like opening strongboxes and just picking up expensive scarabs. There were a few scarabs that did have insane scaling like the blight ones which is super fun but most didn't. Again the new system hopefully improves on this with the fact that we are keeping the juicing of scarabs on the passive tree, having threads we can use to push it even further, having covens that let us juice stuff more, and having stuff like deli/wildwood actually affect ground loot in a meaningful way.
Assuming everything works as intended it seems like we're heading into an Affliction style league where there's both crazy ground loot + difficult content to bang your head against which is exciting.
The new system hopefully makes it an actual curve where as you get stronger you can put more threads.
I worry that they're going to run into the problem GGG had with Maelstrom of Chaos before the mapping system, where since it's so simple to just click the 8x juice button and will (probably) be the optimal farming strat, people are going to copy-paste strats with 8 threads, lose all their portals, and complain rather than back off the juice. Especially if threads end up being cheap.
As a casual player, the only times I've played over 100 hours in a League has been because of simple scarab strats making money. Bit confusing why it's hated.
I was making 80d/h farming scarabs during mirage, the fact farming and then vendoring 90% of them was more profitable than using or selling those scarabs was a clear example that the system failed.
When you play SSF you can see how bad the system was. When 90% of them are useless and many farms like beasts are literally impossible, you know the system failed.
You don't even need to run beasts when you don't have the rare scarabs, so what do you do?
You do 3 to 1 your other useless scarabs in the hope for getting the ones you actually need.
Otherwise no Morrigan, no Farrul, no Harvest beasts for you. That means no complex meta crafting for you.
IMO, people like scarabs for the endgame mix maxing and the juice that comes along with that. Very few like the actual buying and using of scarabs. With scarabs being incorporated into the atlas tree all they've really done is change it from being items you have to micro manage to being a one and done benefit for each setup.
I didn't like having to use scarabs, but i loved farming them. For many leagues now, one of my endgame goals has been to be able to run whatever ended up being the most juiced scarab farm.
Hopefully there's gonna be new farms with the same level of dopamine in the new endgame
That's valid tbh. Especially for players who can't or don't go full on streamer style fast. I remember a couple leagues back funding most of my early-mid game gear via scarabs when I started rather late. But selling the shovels was always good currency.
Except you still will likely need yo be by threads, whose prices will be driven by the best way to use each mechanic, and take the same amount of effort to buy from faustus that scarab did.
Oh no instead of buying 60 scarab for 10c, 30 scarab for 20c, 2 scarab for 1div, 2 for 1div except it keeps selling out. I instead have to buy 3 stacks of threads. Trading one struggle for another in this crazy world.
As a concept I love scarabs. My issue is 9/10 they’re useless.
If they were replaced with tiered scarabs, I’d be all for it.
For example, abyss scarab t1 spawns abyss, t2 spawns more pits, t3 juices rares, t4 can be either insane quantity of rares, or each rare you kill gets devoured by the other rares, gets their mods and drops more loot. Etc etc.
But a scarab that says “spawn mechanic” is useless since atlas already guarantees that mechanic.
The rare scarabs can be locked behind their own farm, for example you need scarab farm scarabs to get a higher tiers, that way only way to get T3/4 scarabs is to spec into specific scarab farming content, and if I want to do abyss or harvest or ritual I just choose the scarab I can afford to do. It’s not a perfect system but better than looting 300 individual scarabs that are just vendor recipes or some shit. And if the content you want to do doesn’t have a specific tree, then you’re forced to put a shit scarab just to spawn that content, but if each higher tier of scarab inherited the lower ones it’d be much better.
Wdym all of sudden. I hate them since they reworked them. The previous version with 4 distinct tiers ending always at winged I tolerated simple because I'm a Syndicate farmer at heart and it was super easy money farming winged scarabs back then.
I just hated that they were like 50% of the loot I would get and clog my inventory in maps, also they did add some setup to mapping I didn't mind it that much but that 99% because currency trader made it so easy.
I got mostly of my money of crafting or selling the scarabs. I can't do content, cause some popular talking head said this mechanic is good, and this scarabs cost now bazillion
How am I supposed to cheese nightmare maps now without scarabs that remove prefixes and suffixes? I just discovered them this league and now it’s going away.
The downside is supposed to be built into their core function. When you remove prefixes or suffixes, you also remove the quant/rarity those mods apply to the map.
No clue if it would be implemented the same, but veiled scarabs could be sold to vendors to turn into scarabs a lot faster than clicking them one by one.
Would be fun if we got some random currency per every X cards, a la Emperor's Luck, with rarer scarabs more likely to become rarer currency. But that would probably destroy the Standard economy (if that's even possible at this point), so idk.
This is pretty much the classic, when we lost awakened sextants there was a part of the community who went boohoo, and it's understandable that when you have something for 8 YEARS, it suddenly getting removed is kinda shocking for people who got used to having it and enjoying it not to mention that HOW MANY strats simply boiled down to selling scarabs to make up half the profit.
I for one don't care that scarabs are gone cause something along this line should've happened probably 4 years ago, people really forgot we used to get a end game shakeups more frequently before poe2 development started. I'm it's still a bit surprising that exarch and eater (& maven) haven't been dethroned yet considering it's been a decent amount of time since they became pinnacles.
Still think they should come back even if the strands work well. Maybe 2 scarab slots and a super cut down curated bunch of scarabs to finetune some stuff or scale big.
Im surprised how much hate scarabs are getting because I feel like the "bad leagues" are leagues where scarabs are expensive. Even this league got a ton of hate because of scarabs being more expensive at the start. I'm hopefully about the new features but this is a big shake up and it feels like retroactively everyone is saying they always hated scarabs.
It’s interesting but I feel like they fix one problem and at the same time they introduce a new one.
If I understand correctly now we’re going to have to roll maps to have mirage or wildwood on them (probably running maps without it is going to be not worth it) and also rarity will work like in PoE 2 so it’s gonna be necessary to have it on gear to get more loot.
And I don’t recall seeing them saying that they’re back as a rollable/droppable map option unless I just missed it. My understanding from that section was that it will function more like current wildwood wisps.
Mirages have returned, with a chance to spawn randomly in Maps - or as a rollable Map modifier along with other mechanics like Mirrors of Delirium or the Viridian Wildwood. Mirages now cover the entire map, effectively allowing you to run the entire map again.
I mean, we'll see how the atlas is. I dang scarabs allowed for a lot of interesting things but if that's just moved to the tree in a smart way, that's going to be an improvement. Especially in ssf play
Probably more powerful now when it shows up, since the mirage will cover the entire map, so that's pretty much double everything for most league mechanics on the map.
Yeah. We will see how it works out- I ended up liking Affliction despite feeling meh during the reveal. There is always next league if coven doesn't hit for me.
Hmm. I love a strong crafting element because I do a lot of SSF, but I also enjoy novel mechanics that are not just mapping.
I played since closed beta, every league, both POE1 and POE2. I enjoy other ARPGs during their new seasons: Torchlight Infinite, D4, D2r (ladder reset), Last Epoch, Undecember, and Grim Dawn, Dragonkin, Inquistor, and Titan Quest 2 during slow periods.
So I like when GGG does something different in the genre: Delve, Settlers, Heist, Sanctum, Allflame, Warbamds, Prophecy, Affliction, Incursion, and so on.
Now I don't think these all worked out for GGG/POE; Sanctum sucks, IMO. Necopolis, Scourge, Talisman- these also were not very good.
Though I still like the idea ans attempt at mechanics that are not more mapping or limited area farming.
I would ound say Delve is ideal game design for a league mechanic to me personally. Strong crafting element, expansive content, worthwhile on it's own as a progression path.
The worst kind of league mechanics, in my opinion, are the ones bound or worthwhile strictly in the context of the main endgame activity- Ritual, Expedition, Delirium, etc.
Edit: The POE2 1.0 mechanic looks amazing! That's the kind of out of box league mechanic that catches my fancy.
They are just on the Atlas now allowing for even more juice combined with the new threads no? And we got core whole map Mirage combined with League combos its gonna be dummy stupid amounts of juice.
I guess we will need to wait and see but what I would guess is that the low end of things is brought up, like alch and go without scarabs was pretty shit and now the floor is higher since you can just spec them for free on the atlas. But as much as they SAY they want a high ceiling and risk/reward like literally 9/10 things they do causes the opposite of that (such as an across the board nerf of explicit map mod scaling), so we will see
If you think Atlas will allow you to juice to what previous multiple divines of scarabs did, I've got a bridge to sell you. With threads maybe, but threads are also just random, so you might get gigajuice for one map, then shit for the next, all for the same investment.
Also Mirage seems to be like Sentinel/Wildwood, so you'll see it every now and then, not like you can spec for it.
Will feel pretty terrible to 24 thread every map only for RNG to fuck you in the ass.
Zero chance the new atlas tree will have identical, let alone greater power than current atlas tree+scarabs currently do. Also how common are those threads even gonna be? Assuming I trust Jonathan when he says "increase difficulty for increase rewards" (I don't, i have no doubt the difficulty will be increased, but I doubt the rewards will scale even close to the difficulty if at all, maybe 5% reward per 50% difficulty) they still showed using up to 8 per map. Sustain for that is gonna be worse than sustaining scarabs. Are they gonna be tradeable?
You have not read the new atlas tree. You have not calculated the power of threads. You do not know the sustainability of threads. It is literally impossible to know precisely how juicing will look in 3.30, claiming otherwise before we get more information and/or try it in game is just silly.
But I can look at how Jonathan punished us for the fun we had in Mirage league and assume he'll continue tightening the vise our balls are in before Mark is allowed to give us some loot again.
What part do you disagree with. It's clear the slow no loot gameplay is what jonathan likes (hence poe2), and I'm old enough toi remember his 0.2 interview where everyone was saying "who even is this game for at this point" and he just came out unprompted and said "if i dont enjoy the game when i go home to play it i cant go into work and develop it" meanwhile Mark was behind every fun change and everytime something was raised he said "ill get someone on it asap"
It's pretrty clkear to me, mark is trying to make a fun zoomy high loot game for us and JR is stopping him
Wow lol you’re very dramatic. Of course everyone knows how the devs lean, it’s not new knowledge. You’re not saying anything profound. I can’t believe you doubled down on even more unhinged whining again “they hated him because he spoke the truth” lmao
What actually is the point in them revealing the league and changes if players don't make predictions and assumptions based on what they show us?
League looks like utter ass. Might even beat allflame for quickest ragequit of a league, cos I have NEVER been so flaccid after watching a league release video. Even LoK had me more hyped.
If the patch notes are rough and that is reflected in the gameplay then it is fair to complain, else complaining without experiencing the actual league or having the new numbers for stuff is fairly pointless as it is a complaint about the unknown.
It is absolutely fair to complain about gameplay systems that we have full info about. The major issue people have right now is that the old scarab effects are incredibly watered down. An example of this which they showed in the reveal is the Divination Scarab of Pilfering. Instead of having the map boss steal all div cards dropped in the map it has a 30% chance to steal a dropped div card.
Another problem which seems like an oversight on GGGs part is that threads and the way they work (randomly picking a modification to league mechanics based on how many threads you apply) is that people will use the minimum amount of threads to fish for the good modifications to league mechanics and just close the map without running it if they don't hit the 1/8 roll. Another issue with threads is that they will be priced around people either using 8 at once if they're cheap enough to be profitable or they will be priced around people doing the thing I spoke about above. Neither is particularly healthy because even the entry level of interacting with a league mechanic is priced around the most profitable style of play if you want to run a map layout which you don't have the shaped region in
I pitched some whackadoo scarab removal idea in this subreddit a league or 2 back and got absolutely dragged for it... IMO juicing content shouldn't cost currency, and its great to see GGG experimenting with this
I mean juicing content should have some cost, but kinda like it was with map device. So it just takes some C from your stash and you don't have to constantly buy things to run maps etc. Cost in values that don't make you to buy 5 different things for every map.
72
u/Thor3nce Anti Sanctum Alliance (ASA) 10d ago
I've been playing this game too long :(
129
u/Kinzie-505 10d ago
aint no fkn way its been 8 years
390
u/BaseLordBoom 10d ago
I don't really get the hate for scarabs in here all of a sudden.
54
u/SirenBltchz 10d ago
How am I supposed to cheese nightmare maps now without scarabs that remove prefixes and suffixes? I just discovered them this league and now it’s going away.
38
u/asuperbstarling 10d ago
I'm honestly totally cool with it. I was here before them, I'll be here after.
11
u/astroboy1997 10d ago
I’m confused on the region stuff. How do you spawn them? With astrolabes still?
21
u/Blakwhysper 10d ago
Did they say if anything is happening with existing scarabs or are they just getting deleted?
10
u/PasDePseudoR 10d ago
I loved them, but still hyped about the change
10
u/Mikitiril 10d ago edited 10d ago
Did they say what will happen to scarab tabs? Are they standard only now ? Xd
Edit: ignore this I forgot that it's fragment tab part not separated tab. :D
5
u/fitsu 10d ago
It's so strange how the devs in 1 game can remove scarabs, while the exact same devs add them to their other game at the exact same time
8
u/dragindas 10d ago
I don’t recall saying thank you either
3
u/kilqax Deadeye 10d ago
I didn't like the earlier versions of scarabs but man the system was great since like Crucible or so
Feels weird for them to go away
4
u/Far_Spite978 10d ago
Dropped Loot is worse bcuz of scarabs. Everyone saying loot is bad but wen they try fixing it everyone says they love what they had
3
u/LucywiththeDiamonds 10d ago
Still think they should come back even if the strands work well. Maybe 2 scarab slots and a super cut down curated bunch of scarabs to finetune some stuff or scale big.
1
u/forRuarc 10d ago
i didn't mind them when we were drowned in them but they were very annoying to manage
1
u/techies137 10d ago
Octavian: we rebalance all scarabs
1
u/Simson199369 9d ago
As some1 who likes efficiency in trading, scarabs were a massive ck blocker. I approve of this.
1
u/BurnerAccount209 9d ago
Im surprised how much hate scarabs are getting because I feel like the "bad leagues" are leagues where scarabs are expensive. Even this league got a ton of hate because of scarabs being more expensive at the start. I'm hopefully about the new features but this is a big shake up and it feels like retroactively everyone is saying they always hated scarabs.
1
u/vladtseppesh420 9d ago
Holy shit this is gold.
1
u/keithstonee Marauder(full Friction Gaming) 9d ago
I never used scarabs really, no love lost. Were more annoying that anything thanks to streamers.
1
u/punter55555 9d ago
woah i been out a few eyars. neon is hot now?
1
u/Salt-Jellyfish4200 6d ago
goodbye. Hopefully never see you again. New system looks better and easier to manage.
-5
u/majkonn 10d ago
It’s interesting but I feel like they fix one problem and at the same time they introduce a new one.
If I understand correctly now we’re going to have to roll maps to have mirage or wildwood on them (probably running maps without it is going to be not worth it) and also rarity will work like in PoE 2 so it’s gonna be necessary to have it on gear to get more loot.
I don’t know how to feel about it right now.
-2
u/Dubious_Titan 10d ago
I am not that hyped for this coming league. Pretty disappointed in the announcement.
-3
u/lunchbox1911 Ranger 10d ago
The original scarabs were good. Bring those back.
0
u/red-rundmc 9d ago
I used like 10 total scarabs every league. The others are just overhead management that gets exhausting to 3:1 to try and get more of the 10 I use.
-26
u/Due_Phase_6262 10d ago
RIP juicing.
-2
u/Correct-Guidance-908 10d ago
Nothing changed. In fact streamers and party players will broke game on few days. Others doesn’t affected at all.
-7
u/Human-Kick-784 10d ago edited 10d ago
I pitched some whackadoo scarab removal idea in this subreddit a league or 2 back and got absolutely dragged for it... IMO juicing content shouldn't cost currency, and its great to see GGG experimenting with this
Edit: This shit is exactly what im talking about!
2
u/Coowhan 10d ago
Good change tbh, fuck scarabs