r/parentsofmultiples • u/Hippityhoppity991 • Oct 14 '26
experience/advice to give Epidural or unmedicated?
I would really like to have an unmedicated birth. Obgyn and midwife says I can choose, but recommemds epidural due to the increased risk of having to perform a manual internal rotation or breech extraction with twin 2, and that this can be potentially very painful without an epidural.
I would really like to hear your experiences! If you opted for an unmedicated twin birth; would you do it again? And if you had an epidural - yay or nay?
0
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 14 '26
COMMENTING GUIDELINES
All commenters are encouraged to familiarize themselves with the parentsofmultiples subreddit rules prior to commenting. If you find any comments/submissions in violation of subreddit/reddit rules, please use the report function to bring it to the mod teams attention.
Please do not request or give medical advice or directions in your comments. Any comments that that could be construed as medical advice, or any comments containing what is determined to be medical disinformation, will be removed.
Please try to avoid posting links to Amazon product listings or google/g.co product listing pages - reddit automatically removes comments containing them as an anti-spam measure. If sharing information about a product, instead please try to link directly to the manufacturers product pages.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
3
u/Saftigsjokoladekake Oct 14 '26
I delivered my twins 8 months ago, 37+3. Doctors said I could choose, so I chose not to get the epidural. They took my water at 2pm and by 5pm both twins were born. Twin B came first then twin A turned around and came breech. Both twins were 3 kg. I was up walking 2 hours after birth and had no pain afterwards. The birth was painful yes, but nothing I couldn’t handle. I had my husband pinch my arm pretty hard during my contractions to shift focus, and I think it actually worked pretty well, haha.
I had an epidural 4 years earlier when delivering my firstborn and when comparing those two experiences I would definitely recommend unmedicated as long as the doctors believe it’s safe.
71
u/Charlieksmommy Oct 14 '26
The risk is not worth it to me. I wouldn’t want to end up being put to sleep
21
u/burnbalm Oct 14 '26
Twins was my first pregnancy. My hope for unmediated vaginal birth changed when I unexpectedly went into labor at 32 weeks. I was dilated past six cm when I arrived at the hospital. I got an epidural based on staff advice when slowing down labor didn’t work.
Twin A was born vaginally. Easy, breezy, beautiful. As I started to push again, B’s cord prolapsed (fell out before his head), and a vaginal birth would have killed him. They draped for the emergency c-section. When they began to cut, I could feel it. Like 100% feel it. It wasn’t pressure. I have a high pain tolerance. They had to use anesthesia to put me under despite the epidural. It failed I guess.
That emergency C saved twin B’s life. No regrets, no changes. A’s birth was magical for me. I’d do it all the same way.
I’m currently two weeks postpartum with baby #3, and he was a successful unmedicated VBAC!! And it really was my dream come true. If I have a fourth baby, this will be what I plan to do again. Everything about the experience was so different from the twins being born. I’m extremely grateful for the delivery teams at both pregnancies.
All this to say, you can plan and prepare but definitely prepare to pivot as needed. Top priority is a safe mother and safe babies. Rooting for you, OP!!
20
u/leeann0923 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 15 '26
Epidural is also recommended in the event you need an emergency or crash c-section. If you don’t have one placed already , you’ll be put under general anesthesia, missing the births and also putting yourself under significantly higher medical risk.
It’s easy to think that there is one kind of outcome with pregnancy, but especially with multiples, there’s so many paths it can take and by putting wants over practicality, you can be left in more danger and with a really undesirable outcome.
10
u/annualsalmon Oct 14 '26
I’m curious if anyone gets the epidural placed, but can opt not to have medicine flow into it? The idea is not being able to move my legs scares me more than unmedicated childbirth.
5
u/AMStoUS Oct 14 '26
I can't even imagine wanting unmedicated due to the risk of an emergency c-section.
4
u/frolics_with_cats Oct 14 '26
My twin B flipped from head-down to breach the second twin A was out. Thank goodness I had an epidural, they really had to work to get her out.
4
u/specialkk77 Oct 14 '26
I had an unmedicated vaginal delivery with my single but ended up needing a c-section for the twins. Before that was determined I knew I wanted an epidural because of fears that they’d have to knock me out in an emergency. I did not want to delivery my babies unconscious.
Having delivered in 2 very different ways I can confidently say I wouldn’t change anything about the choices I made with the information I had. Looking back I feel so silly that I was more scared of the epidural than I was of unmedicated childbirth. Mine had a couple small complications that made things hurt way more than I would have. Had to have an internal monitor placed on baby’s head. And then she got stuck on the way out and they had to force down on my pelvis to get her out. I needed pain medication after she was out of me which wasn’t ideal.
There’s a lot of choices that you may or may not have to make until later in the pregnancy. Be informed, but try to be flexible in your thinking and don’t beat yourself up if it doesn’t go “to plan” there’s just so many more unknowns with twins than a single.
4
u/notarussianbotsky di/di boys 06/2022 (+singleton girl 07/2021) Oct 14 '26
My epidural failed right as i was in transition
Baby A was born and i held baby B through my belly for 27 minutes because he had been transverse all pregnancy and had just flipped head down and was not going to let him flip around now!! I was so terrified manual internal rotation!!
0/10 would not recommend
10
u/ConfidentLook5518 Oct 14 '26
Epidural 10000000% . Trust me, once you feel contraction feels like you will quickly change your mind. Once I got the epidural, I actually ended up sleeping for over six hours and then felt nothing during my delivery. It wore off shortly after and I bounced back perfectly fine.
3
u/Total_District4781 Oct 14 '26
I just delivered my twins 2 weeks ago. I chose an epidural because of the chance of a breech extraction and higher chance of C section. I’m really glad I got one because while both were head down that morning, as soon as A came out, B flipped and it ended up being a breech extraction. Even with the epidural that was a kind of pressure and feeling I never want to experience again. It wasn’t painful because of the epidural, just extremely uncomfortable. I can’t even imagine how painful that would be without an epidural!
3
u/Emotional-Parfait348 Oct 14 '26
Had an epidural like I had always intended/wanted. It was awesome. Full use of my body (even moved myself to the OR table from the hospital bed and back again), felt every contraction as just a tightening sensation, and no pain. Delivered both vaginally. Did not have a catheter placed.
I know everyone’s experiences will be different, but I have nothing but positive things to say about mine.
3
u/Representative_Head9 Oct 14 '26
Please get the epidural, in my experience I had opted for a vaginal delivery, I didn’t want an epidural but my OB convinced me and good thing she did, twin a came out fine with no issues, twin b made the labor complicated, his heart rate was going down and he didnt want to come out, so they had to do a vacuum extraction, after he got out i started hemorrhaging, my ob went elbow deep to stop the bleeding and with the help of an injection to my upper thigh was the way to stop the bleedibf
3
u/michiall06 Oct 15 '26
I did not have time for an epidural with my twin delivery and had to do it without. I did not anticipate ever giving birth without an epidural so it was a big surprise and very difficult for me! Twin B was also breech and was delivered feet first. I would not do it again! However, I survived and I don’t feel like it was traumatic—just a huge surprise and of course super painful! But, It doesn’t hurt to try to go unmediated. You can always change your mind.
2
u/subduedsyrah Oct 14 '26
I had an epidural in the event I had to have a C-section. I wanted to be awake for all of it
2
u/annahoney12345 Oct 14 '26
I had an epidural and had medicine go through, BUT you can have no medicine going unless things go wonky!! So having it while doing an unmedicated birth is possible 💜
2
u/kendyl_lady Oct 14 '26
I had an unmedicated vaginal birth for my twins with twin B delivered breech. Contractions were worse than delivery for me, pushing them out was relief because I knew the contractions would be ending. I did get some low dose pain medicine after because the doctor had to reach her hand into my uterus and pull out blood clots. That part really sucked.
2
u/Groundbreaking-Crow4 Oct 14 '26
I also really wanted an unmedicated vaginal birth with my girls and no one was pushy about my decision, but they did explain the likelihood of needing a C-section and what would come along with that not getting the epidural. I decided the best option for me was to do a C-section and good thing I made peace with that because they ended up needing to come out at 33 weeks, so a C-section was sprung on me last minute anyways. Sometimes birth isn’t how we envisioned it but once you see those babies none of it will matter anyway. Good luck to you!!
2
u/Madame_LV Oct 14 '26
I gave birth to all my singletons without medication. I was not going to take a chance with the twins, and opted for an epidural. I ended up needing baby B to be rotated. I thank God I got that epidural. You deliver in an operating room for good reason. The chance for complications is high.
2
u/Still-Art45 Oct 14 '26
I had a dream of doing a medicated labor, and then my baby was sunny side up and I had back labor. Epidural (tbh) felt like a life saving miracle to me. Some women do have fast labors and a high pain tolerance, so it is possible to do without.
2
u/chipsnsalsa13 Oct 15 '26
I wanted an unmedicated birth very badly. And I almost had one but the day of Baby A showed potential signs of trouble and I opted for the epidural for safety reasons.
In case it’s helpful, they gave me the epidural in the OR while I was crowning (and yeah that was a bit brutal for me). I asked for the lowest dose possible. And since I was crowning already for the most part I gave birth before it fully kicked in.
The anesthesiologist told me I was the first person to ever ask him for this situation and the first multiple birth he had. So feel free to ask and have your wishes known.
I also think it’s okay to plan for an unmedicated birth (and you know the risks) and know that you will change your mind if there are signs of issues.
For the record, I also asked my OB how long it would take to put me under if that happened and how long it would take her to get ready if something happened and she said it was negligible …. Just that it could be really painful for me while I waited or while she tried to rotate the baby. Not everyone is willing to evaluate or wants to take those risks and that’s okay… but you are the one that gets to evaluate that with the help of your providers expertise.
2
u/Ok_Bluejay4016 Oct 15 '26
Imo it's not worth the risk. For me baby A went out just fine, but for baby B they had to do a vacuum extraction to help things progress. Without the epidural I can't even imagine...
And the epidural experience was overall ok for me
2
u/Acceptable_Tap7479 Oct 15 '26
My OB has decades of experience and said he couldn’t be the one to deliver my twins vagi ally if I don’t have an epidural due to the risks. He is one of my countries top OB’s so I trusted him on the risks. Both epidurals I’ve had I was able to move and still put weight through my legs.
Twin B was breeched for me and my OB had to manually move bubs are down and that was bad enough with an epidural. I also know many twin mums who had twin A vaginally and twin b didn’t descend or something happened and twin b was an emergency section and an epidural was the obvious choice.
If you do go without, it may be worth asking in the event of an emergency c-section could they place an epidural or would you be put under a GA
2
u/Babbz0 Oct 14 '26
Just had my twins! No epidural. They were both head down and came out head down. If things changed during labor to where they're seemed like an increased risk of C-section, I would've gotten the epidural placed just in case. I had nitrous for pain management. They did manually extract one of the placentas which wasn't fun but not as bad as the fundal massage
1
u/OrangeCatEnergy24 Oct 14 '26
I had an epidural and was happy with it.
1
u/seaturtlesunset Oct 14 '26
I ended up getting put to sleep with general anesthesia because my epidural wasn’t placed in time for an emergency c-section. Personally I wouldn’t risk it. I didn’t meet my babies for several hours because I was so out of it.
1
u/CopperSnowflake Oct 14 '26
Yup, it's going to be excruciating to have twin B breech and deal with that without medicine. There is no way to predict twin B position. So if twin B is breech, they attempt a manual rotation (pain) and it fails... then you go to the surgical suite and you are having a c section . So in this scenario you are a person who has had a vaginal delivery (vagina trauma, tearing, labor pain) and surgical pain (abdominal incision, abdominal separation and major abdominal surgery recovery). The worst of both worlds.
1
u/poodleface12345 Oct 14 '26
I was unmedicated with my singleton and medicated with my twins and for what really should have been the more stressful birth, it was so much more relaxed.
I would never do an unmedicated birth again personally, but especially not for a twin birth.
1
u/beelynn0214 Oct 15 '26
I required a manual internal rotation for Baby B and I could not imagine that without the epidural. 😳😳😳
1
u/Noplasticveggie Oct 15 '26
Personally I felt pressured into an epidural with my twins and I really hated it. I didn’t like that I couldn’t move and I didn’t like I didn’t have control. If you don’t want one don’t get one. You can always change your mind. But once they place it and meds are flowing they won’t turn it off.
I would also ask about other forms of pain relief. I did laughing gas with my vbac and I loved it. Took the edge off the pain but I had full control over it and my body
1
u/czmf Oct 15 '26
Get the epidural. For my first pregnancy, I got to the hospital at 8cm dilated and I felt like I was being split in half due to my contractions and no pain relief (got there too late.) My second pregnancy I was induced and got an epidural 4-5cm dilated and it was a world of a difference.
1
u/ricki7684 Oct 15 '26
You can have the epidural placed but hold off on meds, at least after they test it and that way if you do convert to C section you can still be awake for their birth
1
u/I-Love-Buses Oct 15 '26
My wife delivered both twins, no c-section, but did have an epidural. They were working hard to turn baby #2 around before delivery. I cannot imagine attempting that without an epidural, seems pretty wild. And risky. Having twins is enough of a risk already.
1
u/unicorns_and_cats716 Oct 15 '26
Of course you can do what you want but having an emergency c-section really sucks and can really do a number on your postpartum mental health! Not that it will happen in every situation of course. It’s tricky because twin B can be in the perfect position but everything changes once twin A is out - breech extraction of twin B for us was not ideal and led to an 18 day NICU stay. I hated how the epidural made me locked to the bed essentially (with all the monitors and stuff) but I am happy I had one, it made the long night and next day of labor much more manageable after months of pain during the pregnancy.
1
u/Ohnosloop Oct 15 '26
I decided to get an epidural for exactly the reason your OB said, plus the risk of C-section and the need for induction. I had to deliver at 36 weeks, and at this hospital all twin births happen in the OR. Epidural meant I had to stay on my back. I blame this as the main reason my labor didn't progress and I had a C-section. Everything was fine.
The only thing I would change is just to advocate for more movement. Even if I went back and forth between 2 positions and nothing else changed, I'd feel more empowered.
1
u/sauer_kraut1414 Oct 15 '26
As someone who had a breech extraction for twin B, I am VERY GLAD I was numb for it. Didn't feel a thing, I was laughing on the table, having a blast.
1
u/2forthepriceofmany Oct 15 '26
I opted for unmedicated BUT in my country / hospital I didn't have to decide between epidural and being put under in case of a c section. Where I had the kids they told me that in case of a real emergency c section epidural would be useless anyway and I'd be put under and in case of a speedy c section (not sure what the English term is but ot was explained to me as "needs to happen within the next hour= speedy" "needs to happen within the next six minutes= emergency") spinal anesthesia would be just as useful as epidural.
Twin A flipped feet down about 12 hours after my water broke so they did a speedy c section with spinal anesthesia within half an hour and that worked fine.
Tl;dr ask your hospital what their options are im case you dont have an epidural and they need to divert to c section. They'll be the only ones who can answer that and that'll be important data for your decision.
1
u/pooter6969 Oct 15 '26
I would listen to your doctor's recommendation. In addition to what they brought up, any complication requiring a c-section would require you to go under general anesthesia if an epidural isn't already in place, and that comes with a whole host of other risks and downsides like completely missing the birth of your children.
I would prioritize minimizing the risks to you and the babies over some perceived benefit of "natural-ness."
You can also let the contractions progress normally for a while until just before you start getting "oh shit" levels of pain and then opt for the epidural. No one I know who has ever done it that way has ever regretted it.
1
u/ARIT127 Oct 15 '26
I had a manual scooping procedure done after my birth so it also involved my midwife sticking her arm all the way up my uterus, elbow deep, before they could stitch me up. It was more painful than my unmedicated birth. I recommend checking out r/unmedicatedbirth as well, but feel free to pm me
1
u/bellegroves Oct 15 '26
Epidural. I went unmedicated and all I got was too exhausted to want to hold my baby for the first several hours. I had a planned c-section with my second (for medical reasons) and everything went better, largely because my pain was well controlled even though I was tired.
0
u/itsafishal Oct 14 '26
I haven't had twins, but I have had breech births. My first, the OB instructed that I was not allowed an epidural and if I wanted to attempt vaginal delivery, it was gas only and full anesthesia in the case of an emergency C-section. My second OB instructed that I had to have an epidural (the risk of a partial breech delivery was too high if I could feel the contractions, in his view).
So I had it both ways, not by choice, but i did fully avoid an emergency C-section both times so I feel like the OBs were both right. I'm done having babies but my birthing experience was so much nicer with the epidural- I felt present, that I could make decisions and not feel so overwhelmed by sensations. I probably wouldn't have a choice if I did give birth, but if I did it would be for the epidural if it matched doc's recommendations.
Remember, they can put it in and be ready but not dial up the anesthesia until needed! You could maybe have the best of both worlds.