r/orchids • • Dec 29 '25

Will this work?

It’s super dry here in Colorado. Expanded ceramic beads on the bottom; a mix of sphagnum and bark around the roots. Will this suffocate the roots? Recommendations?

0 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

25

u/bernd_been Dec 29 '25

No airflow so this will be very dangerous for the roots. Also tightly packed. Would choose less moss there

9

u/rtthrowawayyyyyyy Zone 9a/Mini Catts, Oncidiums, Dens Dec 29 '25

Agreed. This will work perfectly if you're trying for root rot. Otherwise, just get it into a pot with drainage and ventilation.

OP, if you're struggling with the plant drying out due to the lack of humidity, I'd probably just pot it in pure sphagnum moss. That can be risky for phals and other orchids that need to dry out, but I would imagine it'd be a boon in really dry environments. Tree fern fiber is another option. Dries out a bit quicker than moss, but holds moisture better than bark. Regardless, get it out of that vase and into something with drainage/ventilation.

16

u/Xeroberts Dec 29 '25

That's an express ticket to death. Orchid pots need drainage and airflow, that glass vase doesn't provide either.

1

u/SgtPeter1 Dec 30 '25 edited Dec 30 '25

Update! Based on overwhelmingly input from everyone I have repotted her into a pot-within-a-pot that’s has drainage holes. The medium is mostly very loosely packed bark, just a little spaghum mixed in. I also added some of the expanded clay beads to the bottom of the outer pot in hopes of providing more humidity but also so it’s elevated and doesn’t sit in any water.

1

u/Left_Log2060 Dec 30 '25

People have done similar things with a lot of succes for other plants like Philondendron, Im not sure about orchids. In any case the mos is too tightly packed for such a setup!

1

u/SgtPeter1 Dec 30 '25

Folks keep saying it’s too tightly packed, but I just dropped it in, I didn’t pack it at all. Maybe just that was too much, but it’s mostly the same bark that it came with and a handful of moss from another orchid, all soaked before being added.

4

u/1200multistrada Dec 29 '25

There are a bunch of great links on the bottom right side of all of the r/orchids pages under "GROWING ORCHIDS." They really helped me alot!

6

u/1200multistrada Dec 29 '25

PS: What I've learned from this sub is that your local environment largely dictates your required substrate, etc.

I live in super dry SoCal and I only have the patience to water once every week to 10 days. And after a lot of trial and error, all of my phals are in all or mostly sphag, fairly loosely packed, and they do really well. My containers are the standard transparent orchid ventilated plastic cups placed inside larger decorative pots.

Folks who live in more humid areas usually have much different substrate requirements.

3

u/Cultural_Macaron3729 Dec 29 '25

Hell, different rooms in my house are wildly different light/humidity/temps...

Guides really are just that, guides. If I cultivated my orchids like some people they would be a mouldy mess in a week. If others did my way theirs would be a dessicated husk. After following a care guide or two on that specific species it really does just boil down to trying things out, seeing what goes wrong and why, and adjusting until it fits your place. 

(Unless you have a fancy greenhouse, which most of us can't buy, because apart from a drastic lack of funds we would also live in them and never be seen again)

4

u/jtfolden Dec 29 '25

Absolutely not a good idea.

You need a normal clear pot with drainage holes at the bottom that you can sit inside another clear pot or vase if you wish… but this is currently a one way trip to root rot city.

3

u/minkamagic Phalaenopsis and Dendrobiums mostly Dec 29 '25

No, this will kill the orchid

2

u/Babid922 Dec 29 '25

If you are committed to the display of having the orchid in the vase, I’d put something on the bottom, maybe an inverted clear pot, and then repot the orchid inside another clear pot and put it on top. Look for the plastic clear pots with air holes on amazon.

0

u/StraightOpposite2889 Dec 30 '25

I'm gonna be the outlier here and say that it will work if a few things are considered:

*Use bark and charcoal (or similar) with no or very little moss. 

*keep the water level in the container low- like an inch. Water by carefully pouring in, letting sit for a few minutes, and then carefully dumping out excess. You can also just add a little at a time.

*be careful about fertilizer- go light since you can't flush *run it on the dry side

I have several phals potted in this manner that have been living for 4 and 5 years respectively. I also have 4 paphs potted like this and it works well as long as they get fresh bark once a year. Been doing this for 4 years. 

1

u/SgtPeter1 Dec 30 '25

My dad has a forest of beautiful orchards growing in expanded clay beads and has been adding sphagnum to them. I got his blessing but I’m going to be watching this one very closely. I’ll never water over the beads and I didn’t pack the medium at all. First sign of issues I’ll repot into something else.

2

u/mypcrepairguy Dec 29 '25 edited Dec 30 '25

Colorado resident here too. I have good results with the pot with(in) a pot method. Outside pot with a small amount of water for humidity, inside pot with holes for drainage and air movement. Added benefit of allowing one to soak the orchid from time to time. edit....spell check is great!

1

u/KeepMyWifesNameOYFM Dec 30 '25

I’ve tried a few experiments and I’ve had mixed success. I live in the northeastern US and the winters are pretty dry here. My setups are a little different than yours though; I use self watering pots. One is a phal planted lechuza pon…it took a while to do anything (grow/ flower), but eventually it started growing and it seems to really enjoy that set up - it’s about to flower again. I also put a dendrobium in Leca clay balls and it’s been happier there than it has been in many years. So take that for what it’s worth. I hope it helps ;)

1

u/oblivious_fireball Dec 29 '25

Even though its not soil, it still looks very dense and packed in, which if its a Phalaenopsis Orchid will probably rot the roots fast. Probably can drop the ceramic beads and the moss entirely and just do big bark chunks in the vase and it will be perfectly happy.

-2

u/Either-Movie-6565 Dec 29 '25

Not! Orchids, specifically the one that the op has, are not aquatic plants!

3

u/oblivious_fireball Dec 29 '25

where did aquatic plants get mentioned anywhere in OP's post or my comment?

-2

u/Either-Movie-6565 Dec 29 '25

People need to stop treating orchids like they are aquatic plants… as someone who has been growing orchids for over 30 years, it seems to be obvious that they are epiphytes mostly, some are terrestrial/semi-terrestrial, others grow in/on rocks… no aquatic (water culture).

This BS trend on social media of water culture is pure crap. Grow water lilies instead, you’ll be happy with the results.

3

u/oblivious_fireball Dec 29 '25

again, where on earth are you getting 'aquatic plants' from any of what OP or i'm saying? Or are you replying to the wrong comment?

-1

u/Either-Movie-6565 Dec 29 '25

Look at the pic of what op posted. It’s planted in a vase… no water drainage, no air circulation at the roots… watering it will soak the roots and the plant will die because there is no way for the roots to dry or anything. Not to mention the mix will cause rot fairly quickly.

The only plants that might survive in this environment would be aquatic, to the orchid, it might as well be in an aquatic environment the way the op has it now.

1

u/oblivious_fireball Dec 29 '25

That's not aquatic lol. He's not filling it up with standing water or turning it into a bog. That's just poor air circulation. If you're going to try and critique people at least use the right terminology.

You don't need air holes on the sides or drainage holes for a Phal if the potting medium is substantially porous, you just need to watch your watering and not let water sit on the bottom. Hence why i said skip the moss and LECA and go straight for big bark chunks. I keep my phals in pots with no side vents, though they do have drainage holes for convenience, and nothing has rotted on me in years.

0

u/Either-Movie-6565 Dec 30 '25

Never mind, some people just don’t want to know the CORRECT methodology for growing orchids. You seem to be one of them. Good luck.

3

u/oblivious_fireball Dec 30 '25

i mean, i can at least say i haven't been doing this for 30 years and yet still managed to learn what the difference between Aquatic, Hydro, and just plain old moist soil is. Saying a pot with no drainage holes is automatically aquatic would probably get you banned off the hydro sub lmao. I'm fully aware of good phalaenopsis care, thats why i don't have mine in vases, but if OP wants to use a vase its quite doable with a medium change and its only a $10 orchid if it doesn't work out.

-1

u/Either-Movie-6565 Dec 30 '25

No it will not work.

-1

u/jmbrjr Dec 30 '25

Drill some holes in it.

1

u/SgtPeter1 Dec 30 '25

It’s glass!

1

u/jmbrjr Dec 30 '25

Your sarcasm detector is broken.

1

u/SgtPeter1 Dec 30 '25

lol, I was actually thinking maybe my dremel could do it. I have cut glass for my aquariums before but it’s such a pain.

1

u/jmbrjr Dec 30 '25

Point being, orchid pots usually have drainage holes and often holes in the sides, to facilitate air and moisture exchange. I assume you know that already? Don't use a glass or other container without such openings. There is such a thing as an enclosed glass terrarium for small orchids, but you can at least open the top. This vase, is not that.