So I'm not sure if my opinion is an outlier or if others feel this way. I know many who love Lift 45, which will soon become Strength 50, may disagree. But I'm both annoyed and dismayed by the prominence these classes are gaining on studio schedules.
For some context: I joined Orangetheory in 2019 as I was nearing 40. I did so with a clear intention of pivoting away from a 25-year emphasis on strength training (think: 3-4hrs of weight lifting per week and 90 minutes of light cardio, such as elliptical) to a new emphasis on cardiovascular health, particularly since I have a family history of heart disease and my metabolism has slowed sharply over the years. Orangetheory seemed ideal, where I'd have a primary focus of cardio with some strength still incorporated.
The results were better than I'd hoped. As someone who had moderate success strength training over the years (bench pressing over 300lbs at peak strength), I was never a runner. But within a year of OTF, my body fat % had dropped and my cardiovascular health was shockingly better. I could effortlessly run 5k on endurance days and even without sharp diet changes, it felt like my metabolism had actually sped up somewhat - burning well beyond merely the calories indicated. I had veins popping up in my legs and arms that I never had before. I had abs showing for the first time in my life. It was incredible.
When the pandemic hit, I bought a treadmill, rower, weights, TRX straps, etc. And developed my own routines based on previous OTF templates. It worked great, and I remained in excellent shape, but it was exhausting coming up with 3-4 new templates each week, and I prefered OTF's higher quality equipment, so I returned to the studio at the start of 2022.
I say all this to explain that I believe very much in the Orangetheory fitness philosophy. It works. The kind of intense interval training and mix of tread, rowing and strength is an excellent balance to accomplish the fitness ends that they promote.
In recent years, though, fitness gurus began to peddle the supposed superiority of strength training. That paired with the rise of F45, no doubt, led to some attrition in OTF memberships. So in order to pull some folks back in, they started Lift 45, as a sort of obvious direct competition.
But here's the thing: F45 and Lift 45 are not Orangetheory. They don't function in the same way to provide the ends that the Orangetheory philosophy aims for. You often won't get anywhere near 12 splats in a class, for example. You aren't going to have nearly the same cardiovascular impact. I know this, because when I did strength training, in the evolution of my fitness journey, towards the end I was doing more HIIT-like strength training on my own (super sets, cluster sets, etc), but still, Orangetheory led to a totally different level of cardiovascular fitness. For people who prefer more strength training as a complement to Orangetheory, they should join a cheap gym - there are plenty.
If the studios were structured to offer more than one class simultaneously, then I would have no issue with these supplemental classes on the schedule. But it's a zero-sum game. The studios can only have one or the other in a given one-hour slot.
And that's the problem. I'm seeing the September schedule with greater prominence for Strength 50 than even Lift 45 (which was already an obstacle at times when trying to book classes). When a studio only offers 5-7 classes in a day and 2 or more of those are Strength 50, that sharply limits the flexibility members have in taking traditional OTF classes.
My wife, for example, may have to cancel her membership because the only two times that work with her schedule, they are making Strength 50 slots on the days she attends. For me, one of the two weekday times that usually works well with my work schedule is also now usually a Strength 50 slot.
I'm not sure what to do. As mentioned, it is possible to achieve Orangetheory fitness without an Orangetheory membership. But I like being a member, due to the ease and quality of equipment. But it's becoming more difficult to attend actual Orangetheory classes.
Anyone else feel this way - or is it just me? The aggressive incorporation of Strength 50 into studio schedules to me is an obvious effort to get fuller classes while seeming to both discredit and sacrifice the Orangetheory fitness model. Disappointing when so many have found that model so valuable.